“Don’t move!” a cop shouted.
“You got the wrong man!” I yelled back.
“You’re under arrest!”
My heart sank as the cold metal cuffs closed around my wrists.
32
MALLORY WAS ALONE IN THE BACKSEAT OF A TAXI, PEERING THROUGH the window as she drank from her go cup—a double vodka tonic she’d mixed before leaving her apartment. It wasn’t even dinnertime, but she would have liked nothing better than to crawl into bed and sleep till morning.
“You’re quite the piece of work,” she said quietly to her reflection in the glass.
Storefront after storefront raced by her, the driver catching every green light as they sped south on Fifth Avenue. She downed the rest of her drink, laid her head back on the headrest, and stared at the taxi’s tattered felt ceiling.
Today’s court hearing had gone exactly as planned. Her reaction to it was nothing like she’d expected. Accusing Michael of conspiring with a secret lover to hide assets left her with the uneasy feeling that “what goes around comes around,” and Mallory knew she wasn’t exactly standing on solid ground.
She’d met Nathaniel three months ago at the fitness studio. Mallory was serious about her workouts and didn’t make small talk with guys who grabbed an eyeful of her body. But one day her Pilates instructor had failed to show up, and Nathaniel was kind enough to share his and turn a private lesson into a semi-private. Nathaniel was good—pairing with him was almost like having two instructors. So she kept up the semi-privates for a couple of weeks, and by week three they were going for coffee afterward. By week four they were sleeping together. The man was fun in bed, but it wasn’t just that. He filled a need.
You don’t love me, Michael. You like me, but you don’t love me.
The cab stopped between Eighth and Ninth avenues, and Mallory stepped out. It was their usual meeting spot, one of the few places where she felt comfortable meeting her lover in public.
Therapy was a spacious lounge with killer decor, a friendly atmosphere, and cozy sitting areas. The food was good enough to get it a spot on Hell’s Kitchen, and its tasty drinks bore memorable names like Freudian Sip. Most important—and in keeping with Mallory’s low profile—Therapy was one of the best gay bars in the city. Of course, meeting in a gay bar didn’t take all the risk out of a heterosexual affair. While Therapy wasn’t known as one of those places where investment bankers went looking for boy toys, it drew its share of Wall Street types, and Mallory was all too aware that one of them might have some connection to Saxton Silvers. Her little joke was that at least she would hear them coming. They’d be the ones humming Fagin’s refrain from the Broadway hit Oliver: In this life one thing counts, in the bank large amounts—or something like that.
Mallory found Nathaniel waiting upstairs, where the lighting was low and the tables were arranged cabaret style. Stage shows here ranged from the whacky to the sublime, but the night was too young for live entertainment, so the booths in the back gave them relative privacy. Nathaniel had insisted on seeing her tonight, his text message saying, Urgent. She tried to smile as she approached, but her mind was busy searching for a way to tell him that she was in no mood for sex.
He rose and gave her a hug. No kiss. His smile was awkward. Right away, Mallory knew something was up.
“Are you okay?” she asked as she slid into the booth.
“Yeah, fine,” he said.
He cast his gaze downward at his hands.
“Are you sure?” she asked.
Now he was looking toward the bar. “Yeah. I’m good.”
Mallory’s throat tightened. This was starting to feel like a page out of her first marriage. All of the bad signs were there.
“Look at me,” she said.
Slowly his gaze drifted back toward her. Their eyes met, and Mallory’s heart sank.
“Something’s wrong,” she said.
He grimaced, as if in pain. “I can’t do this.”
“Can’t do what?”
“Us,” he said. “It’s over.”
Mallory had to catch her breath. “You’re the one who gave me the strength to divorce Michael.”
“Don’t put that on me.”
She reached across the table and took his hand. “No, I’m not blaming you. Michael and I were headed for divorce, I’m sure of it. You gave me the strength to accept it.”
He withdrew his hand and wrapped it around his beer bottle.
“I’m grateful to you,” she said, trying to smile. “Let’s face it: If it had been any other man but you, I would have been caught cheating long ago.”
“What the hell are you talking about?”
“I don’t have what it takes to pull off something like this. You knew all the tricks to keep Michael from suspecting.” She squeezed his hand, but he pulled back.
“This isn’t going to work anymore, Mallory. Get it? I’m outta here.”
Her body stiffened. She’d never heard this tone from him before, and she was beginning to wonder if she had ever seen the real Nathaniel. After a day like today, it was making her downright angry, and she suddenly found a new kind of courage.
“An interesting thing happened in court today. Michael’s lawyer informed the judge that there was spyware attached to that ‘happy birthday’ e-mail we sent to Michael.” Her eyes narrowed, and she said, “Do you know anything about that?”
He shot her a look that cut to the bone. “This is exactly the kind of shit I’m talking about. I have no interest in getting caught in the cross fire of nasty accusations flying back between you and Michael.”
“I just asked a simple question.”
“Go to hell, Mallory. If you want to ask questions, go ask your husband why he flipped his lid and shot Chuck Bell in the head.”
“You don’t know that.”
“It’s what everybody is saying. Do you think I want my picture on the front page of the Post when this shit unravels?”
Mallory collected herself, then said, “You’re married, aren’t you.”
“No,” he said, scoffing. “I’m too smart for that.”
She took that as a direct shot at her second failed marriage. “What’s that supposed to mean?”
“Nothing,” he said, and then he rose from the booth. “Look, we all have to make our own choices. I choose not to be part of your mess. So let’s agree to do you, me, and your divorce lawyer a big favor: Keep me out of it.”
He left a ten-dollar bill on the table for his beer and walked away. Mallory didn’t watch him go. She stared at the money on the table and half laughed, half cried.
It was the first time Nathaniel had ever paid for anything.
33
I WAS IN JAIL. I COULDN’T BELIEVE IT. I WAS ACTUALLY BEHIND bars.
Before leaving Rockefeller Center, the arresting officers had patted me down, run a background check through their databases, and satisfied themselves that I wasn’t actually carrying a bomb. But that didn’t stop these men of the Midtown North Precinct from hauling me downtown. Technically speaking, it wasn’t jail. I was in a holding pen in the Manhattan Detention Complex, where prisoners were held for relatively short periods of time pending arraignment or some other court appearance. Not that this was a step up from jail. I was locked in the very same cell in which a seventeen-year-old boy had used his shirt to hang himself the summer before.
“Got two more bodies,” the guard announced.
The guards had a habit of calling us “bodies” when talking among themselves. It seemed kind of ghoulish, especially since the Manhattan Detention Complex was known as “the Tombs” to police, lawyers, criminals, judges, and anyone who had ever watched an episode of Law & Order. The nickname fit. Over the past two hours, I had climbed up and down several flights of stairs and in and out of three different holding pens. I had lost track of what floor I was on. I had been shackled, unshackled, and shackled again. The body search had been especially memorable, not so much for what actually had happened, but for fear
of what might. On a sign on the wall, some joker had scribbled in the word “anal” between “Male” and “Search.” Fingerprinting took another hour. The state-of-the-art machine kept delivering error messages: rolling too fast, too slow, not a clear image, multiple fingers detected (odd, since my other fingers weren’t even on the screen), partial finger detected. At that point, I was willing to forgive the inaccuracy of one of my all-time favorite films, American Gangster, in which Denzel Washington’s character is shown leaving the Tombs—a temporary holding facility—after a fifteen-year stay.
This could actually take fifteen years.
The mug shot was the final indignity—a real beaut that I was sure would end up all over the Internet, if not in the tabloids. Finally, the guards brought me back to my cell and gave me dinner, though I passed on the soggy bologna-and-cheese sandwich. It smelled so awful that I was going to flush it down the toilet, which was in open view in the corner of the cell. Instead, my cell mate tore the sandwich into pieces, rolled them into balls, and one by one pitched them into the toilet from various positions behind the imaginary three-point line.
Around seven o’clock, the guard returned.
“It’s your lucky day, partner. You can go.”
He opened the cell door and led me down the hall. We passed a window that was open just a crack, and I was certain that I could smell spring rolls. We were that close to Chinatown—and I was that hungry.
At the end of the corridor the guard pushed a button, a buzzer sounded, and the iron door slid open. Kevin was on the other side of the chute waiting for me, a look of complete disbelief all over his face.
“What the hell is wrong with you, Michael?”
“Good to see you, too,” I said.
“You’re lucky I have friends in the D.A.’s office,” he said. “They’re not charging you.”
“They shouldn’t. I didn’t have a bomb.”
Kevin clearly had much more to say, but the guard was standing just a few feet away. We went downstairs to collect my belongings—including Papa’s old trench coat and Italy golf cap. When he saw what I’d been wearing, Kevin just shook his head and said, “We need to talk.”
The lobby of the station house was far from private. Uniformed police officers coming and going, two prostitutes in a territorial dispute, a drunk with a bloody nose, and a homeless guy with vomit all over his shoes sitting on the end of a long wooden bench. It was like something out of that show Hill Street Blues that Papa used to watch when I was a kid.
Kevin led me down the hall to a small room. I could see the stenciled words ATTORNEY CONFERENCE backward on the glass as he closed the door. It was a stark room with yellow walls of painted cinder block, a small wooden table, and two oak chairs. Kevin asked me to sit, but after two hours on the hard benches of the holding cell, I didn’t want to. We just stood on opposite sides of the table.
“You could have been in a heap of trouble,” he said. “Two witnesses said it was the homeless guy—you—who ran off with a college girl’s camera and started the whole panic by threatening to set off a bomb.”
“That’s not what happened. A woman shouted that I had a bomb. And then it was chaos.”
“Did you steal the camera?”
“No. I was taking a group picture for these girls and then I…I saw something, and I had to run.”
“What did you see?”
“I’m pretty sure I saw Ivy,” I said.
Kevin groaned, and then his expression turned serious. “I’m worried about you.”
“Why?”
He took a breath, as if to calm himself. “I’m worried that it’s more than you—more than anyone—could handle. The divorce, the identity theft, the attack on Saxton Silvers, the pillaging of your financial accounts, the lack of sleep. You aren’t thinking clearly—dressing up like a homeless guy, setting off a panic attack in one of the most popular urban tourist areas in America, all this talk about seeing Ivy.”
“I know what I saw.”
“You didn’t see Ivy.”
“Could have been someone pretending to be Ivy.”
“Why would someone pretend to be Ivy?”
“I can’t think of a reason. That’s why I say it was her.”
He groaned even louder. I was undeterred.
“And I think she was literally running for her life when she took off and ran from that man who was chasing her.”
“Michael, you’re my brother, and I want to help you. But I’ve had just about enough.”
I could see he wasn’t kidding. It was time to change the subject. “Can we get something to eat?”
“Yeah. Good idea.”
I gathered up Papa’s trench coat and hat. Kevin yanked open the heavy entrance door and together we walked outside. We were at the base of the steps, and I was pulling on Papa’s old coat, when two men approached from behind a construction barrier on White Street.
“Mr. Cantella?”
Kevin and I stopped. I recognized one of the men as he flashed his shield.
“Malcolm Spear,” he said, “FBI.”
It was the same agent I’d met in Eric’s office with our general counsel. Spear had another agent with him, not the computer fraud specialist I’d met before. It was Agent Coleman, the one who had come to my building to investigate the elevator fire. I noticed a spot of duck sauce on his jacket, and I could almost smell it. We were still that close to Chinatown, and I was still that hungry.
“Let me guess,” I said, “you found my money.”
Spear showed no reaction. “Heard you had a temporary change of address,” he said. “Wanted to come by and ask you a question.”
Kevin stepped between us. “He’s not talking to the FBI.”
“Who are you?” asked Spear.
“His lawyer.”
“No tricks here,” said Spear. “I just want to ask him about Chuck Bell.”
“Since when does the FBI investigate homicide?” said Kevin.
“We’re talking about a pattern of criminal activity that includes a number of federal offenses. It’s all our business.”
“Sorry, he’s not talking,” Kevin said.
“I simply want to know if your client can tell me where he was between twelve and one A.M. night before last, when Chuck Bell was shot.”
Instinct told me not to answer, but a flash of excitement came over me. “As a matter of fact, I can,” I said, reaching for my wallet.
“Hold it,” said Kevin as he grabbed me by the wrist. “For the last time: He’s not talking to the FBI.”
“But I want to answer,” I said.
“Don’t,” Kevin told me.
He was probably right, but as always, something about his tone made it impossible for me to heed his advice.
I showed Spear the ATM receipt—the one that read “nonsufficient funds”—and said, “I was at an ATM on Third Avenue trying to get money to pay my hotel bill.”
He checked the receipt, stroking his chin. “So, if we went to the bank and reviewed the tape from the security camera, we’d see that it was indeed you who conducted this transaction?”
“You sure would,” I said smugly.
“Interesting,” he said.
“Why is that interesting?”
Kevin was about to explode. “That’s enough,” he said. “You’ve got your answer, Agent Spear.”
“I just want to know why that’s interesting,” I said.
Spear narrowed his eyes. “About a year ago I investigated a racketeering case. Mob guy took great pains to make sure he was on camera at an ATM in Manhattan at the exact moment the trigger was pulled in Jersey. He wanted to be able to prove up an alibi.” He paused for effect. “We nailed him on murder for hire.”
My expression fell.
“May I keep this?” he asked.
“No,” I said, taking the receipt back. I gave it to Kevin. “I think my lawyer will want that.”
“Fine,” said Spear. “We’ll see you around, gentlemen.”
&nbs
p; I watched as the two agents walked away. Then Kevin looked at me, glowering.
“Don’t ever do that to me again.”
There was that tone again. “I have an alibi,” I said.
“Not anymore you don’t. Now he knows the correct charge against you is not murder. It’s a murder-for-hire case. That’s why you never talk to law enforcement.”
My stomach was suddenly in knots. Maybe Kevin was right: This was more than anyone could handle. Too much had happened in too short a time, and if I didn’t get some food and sleep, I was well on my way to becoming my own worst enemy.
“Let’s go eat,” I said.
“No,” he said. “You go.”
“Don’t be like that.”
He took a breath, then paused to measure his words. He spoke in an even tone, but I could hear the anger behind it.
“I’m really trying, Michael. But you’re making this way too hard. So please, get something to eat, and get a good night’s sleep. Because if you’re still talking crazy in the morning, you’re going to need a new lawyer.”
He walked away. I started after him, then stopped.
Better to let him go, but as he rounded the corner, it suddenly occurred to me:
I had no idea where I was going to sleep.
34
FROM THE DETENTION CENTER I WENT TO MY CAR, THEN DROVE TO Long Island, when a thought popped into my mind. I didn’t call first; I knew Olivia would tell me not to come. By the time I pulled into her driveway my thoughts had gelled, and I was so pumped with adrenaline that I nearly flew up the sidewalk to ring the doorbell. It was getting dark, and in the shadows I must have looked like some lunatic on a home invasion. But that wasn’t the reason Olivia left the screen door closed between us.
“I thought I made myself clear earlier,” she said.
James Grippando Page 17