Defining Neighbors

Home > Other > Defining Neighbors > Page 41
Defining Neighbors Page 41

by Gribetz, Jonathan Marc


  apologetics: and N. Malul, 10, 222; and Moyal, 10, 199, 203–5, 209, 212, 220, 221

  al-Aqsa Intifada, 246

  al-Aqsa Library, 136

  al-Aqsa Mosque, 43, 52, 53, 166, 168–69, 239–40

  Arab conquest, 40

  Arab Episcopalians, 33

  Arab Hebrews, 111–12. See also Arab Jews

  Arabic: and Islamic religious terminology, 211; knowledge of among Jews, 36–38, 50, 103, 187–90, 200; literacy in, 49, 193; and N. Malul, 233; as mark of identity vs. Hebrew, 236; and military conscription, 107, 108; and Sephardic Zionists, 9; and Sephardim vs. Ashkenazim, 127; Zionist literacy in, 187–90; and Zionists, 233

  Arabic journals, 9, 12, 26–28. See also al-Hilāl (The Crescent); al-Manār (The Beacon); al-Muqtaṭaf (The Digest)

  Arabic press, 187, 232; as anti-Zionist, 9, 106, 127–28, 129, 187, 190, 192, 231–32; Christian-edited, 6n11; letters to editors by Zionists in, 194; and N. Malul, 231–32; and Nassar, 231, 232; and Ottoman ethnic and religious communities, 196; Zionist attempts to influence, 9, 10, 11, 186–87, 191–95

  Arabic readers/speakers, 12, 188; and Arabic journals, 135; Christian, 35, 210; Greek Orthodox, 33; Jewish, 36–38, 50, 103, 187–90, 200; Karaites as, 112, 113; and M. R. al-Khalidi, 7, 49–50; and Moyal, 77, 200, 210; Muslim, 32, 35, 210–15; mustaʿribūn, 36; Sephardic, 9, 188–89, 192; Zionist attempts to influence, 10, 197

  Arab Jews, 36–38. See also Arab Hebrews

  Arab Office, 244–45

  Arab Revolt, 240

  Arabs, 75, 92; benefit of Jewish immigration for, 128; and Ben-Zvi, 123–25; borders of identity of, 111–12; conquest by, 15, 40, 124; and fear of Jews, 184; and fellahin, 124–25; in ha-Ḥerut, 102, 103; and historically good relations with Jews, 149–50; inexpensive labor of, 76; and intellectual interchange with Jews, 46; Ishmael as ancestor of, 145; Jews as living among, 144; Jews as proof of potential of, 146–49; Jews in land of before Islam, 149, 150; and Jews of Yathrib, 231; Jews tolerated by, 158; Jews under rule of, 149–50, 158; and M. R. al-Khalidi, 40; and Kremer, 105; and language and translation, 185, 186; loyalty of, 35; and N. Malul, 222; and Mandate for Palestine, 244; medieval, 143; and Middle Eastern-born Jews, 114; and nationalism, 3; nationalist nonsectarian notion of identity of, 239; Palestinian identity among, 3, 7, 18, 35, 75, 235–37; population of, 32; and race, 13, 140, 141; as racially linked with Jews, 6, 133, 143–50, 240; and Radler-Feldmann, 93; Sephardic vs. Ashkenazic attitudes toward, 126–30; tolerance as quality of, 158, 159; views of Zionism of (see under Zionism); as workers, 122; in ha-Ẓevi/ha-Or, 102–3. See also Christian Arabs; Muslim Arabs; Palestinians (Palestinian Arabs)

  Arafat, Yasser, 50n40

  Argentina, 90, 91–92, 143

  al-Arish, 90

  Armenia, 242

  Armenian Orthodox, 33

  Armenians, 20

  Arslan, Muhammad, 109n62

  Aryans, 141

  Ashkenazim, 34, 36, 37, 103; and Arabic literacy, 188; attitude toward Arabs, 126–30; and Christian intolerance, 120; and creation of Arabic newspaper, 197–98; First Aliyah, 95, 96, 100; and ha-Ḥerut, 97–98, 105; and literacy in Arabic, 193; Second Aliyah, 96; and Sephardim, 100, 105, 195; and Zionists’ self-conceptions, 94. See also Jews

  asqāmah, 60–64, 66, 69, 70, 91

  Assembly of Notables, 62

  assimilationism, 195–96, 197

  Auerbach, Elias, 139n26

  Austria, 29, 183

  Austro-Hungarian Empire, 242–43

  Ayalon, Ami, 135

  Babylonia, 82

  Babylonian exile, 164, 225

  Balfour Declaration, 45, 66, 179, 236, 241, 244

  Balkan wars, 120n101

  Banton, Michael, 5n7

  Bar Giora, 123

  Bar Kokhba, 53, 70, 219, 220

  Barzilay, Isaac, 56n63

  Bashkin, Orit, 37n80

  Batnitzky, Leora, 56

  bedel-i askeri, 23

  Bedouin, 31, 123, 124

  Beer Sheba, 88

  Beirut, 17, 26–29, 43, 202

  Beisan Valley, 88

  Belgium, 29, 183

  Ben-Attar, Hayyim, 129n129

  Ben-Bassat, Yuval, 19n13

  Benedict XV, 237n8

  Ben-Gurion, David, 96, 123; and Ben-Zvi, 123; “Clarifying Our Political Situation,” 120–22; Erets yisroel in fargangenheit un gegenvart, 123, 124, 126

  Ben-Yehuda, Eliezer (Perelman), 24, 118; anniversary celebration of, 129; and Arabic literacy, 188; Arabs in newspapers of, 102, 103; attitude toward Arabs, 127; background of, 1; and borders of identity, 112; and Christians as non-Arabs, 107–8; and de Boton, 100; and distinctions between groups, 111; and Europe, 29; and haskamah, 67–68; and Hebrew, 99, 100; and M. R. al-Khalidi, 1, 10, 15, 19, 39; library of, 46n26; and Mendelssohn, 61n83; and Muslims as enemies of Christians, 109; and Nahḍa, 29; and nationalism, 35n74; and religion in newspapers, 99, 100; as representative of Jewish community, 4; and ha-Ẓevi, 96

  Ben-Yehuda, Hemda, 108n53

  Ben-Yehuda, Itamar Ben-Avi, 108n53

  Ben-Zvi, Rachel Yanaʾit, 96, 123

  Ben-Zvi, Yitzhak, 96, 123–26, 237; Erets yisroel in fargangenheit un gegenvart, 123, 124, 126; ha-Tenuʿah ha-ʿarvit (The Arab Movement), 123

  Berakhot, 203

  Bernasconi, Robert, 27

  Bezalel, Yitzhak, 97, 98

  Bibas, Rahamim, 112, 113

  Bible, Christian: and M. R. al-Khalidi, 235; and Moyal, 206–8, 209; and Septuagint, 212

  Bible, Christian, books of: Gospel of John, 206; New Testament (al-injīl), 71, 73, 75, 88n167, 205, 206–8, 209, 235; Romans, 206n79

  Bible, Hebrew, 18; and Amalekites, 144; and archaeology, 169–72; basis of Zionism in, 76; European criticism of, 164; European research on, 172; European scholarship on, 161, 162; in al-Hilāl, 169, 170, 171; historicity of, 169–72; and M. R. al-Khalidi, 43, 46, 51–52, 71, 75, 76n129, 77–80, 84; Makaryus on, 173; and N. Malul, 226; and Moyal, 201, 202, 212; in al-Muqtaṭaf, 169–72; Muslims on corruption of, 212; origins and historicity of, 133; and prophecy, 77–80; prophets of, 70; and racial link between Arabs and Jews, 144–45; and Rida, 152; Septuagint, 210, 211–12; and E. Zaydan, 132, 180; and Zionism, 132. See also Torah

  Bible, Hebrew, books of: Daniel, 71; Deuteronomy 6:4, 116; Ezekiel, 51, 52; Isaiah, 76, 84, 217; Lamentations, 51; Psalms, 51

  Bilu movement, 35n74

  Bliss, Daniel, 30n58

  B’nai Brith, 46n26

  Brenner, Yosef Hayim, 93n1

  bribery, 87

  British Palestine Society, 179

  Brugman, J., 42n10

  Brunswick Conference (1844), 62n88

  Bulgaria, 242, 243

  Bulgarians, 21

  Byzantines, 40, 124

  Cairo, 26–29, 112, 131

  Capitulations, 21–22, 31; as term, 22n23

  Carmilly-Weinberger, Moshe, 68n108

  Casanova, José, Public Religions in the Modern World, 57

  Catholics, 21, 33, 158, 159, 166. See also Christians

  Christendom vs. Islamic countries, 120, 133, 150, 157, 159, 165

  Christian Arabic press, 6n11, 106, 120, 122

  Christian Arabic-speakers, 35, 210

  Christian Arabs, 6n11, 8, 9; and Balfour Declaration vs. Mandate for Palestine, 241; in ha-Ḥerut, 106–7, 108; and Jewish ritual murder, 201, 202; and M. R. al-Khalidi, 50; and Moyal, 205; as not authentic Arabs, 107–8; tolerance as quality of, 158; and toleration vs. persecution of Jews, 159; in ha-Ẓevi, 108–9. See also Greek Catholics

  Christian-edited newspapers, 196

  Christianity: and antisemitism, 88n167, 228; divisions within, 227–28; and essential sameness of all religions, 222, 224; Hellenistic Jewish roots of, 209–10; and inauthentic form of Judaism, 210; and Islam, 50, 73–75, 151; Islam’s close relationship to, 227; Jewish conversion to, 53; and Jewish philosophy, 150; Jewish sermons in support of, 118; Jews as unequal under, 53; and Judaism, 50, 75, 205–10, 215–16, 221; Judaism’s close relationship t
o, 206, 226, 227; and Judaism vs. Islam, 235–36; and M. R. al-Khalidi, 50; and N. Malul, 222, 224, 226, 227; and Moyal, 199, 205–10, 215–16; and religion vs. nationality, 138–39; and Zionists, 8. See also Greek Orthodox faith; Jesus

  Christian missionaries, 18, 29–30, 99–100, 116–18, 171n126

  Christian Muslims, 112

  Christians, 8, 21, 166, 235; and British Mandate period, 239; as category of interpretation, 3; compared to Muslims, 136–37; as enemies of Muslims, 109–11; European protection of, 22; and fellahin, 124; in ha-Ḥerut, 100; and Jewish ritual murder, 201; Jews as evicting, 167, 169; Jews as excluding from workforce, 167; Jews as persecuted by, 8, 119–20, 121, 150, 154, 156, 157, 158, 159, 165, 230–31; and M. R. al-Khalidi, 43; as less tolerant of Jews, 165, 236; and messiah, 163; and monotheism, 116n90, 222, 224, 225, 226, 227; and Moyal, 221; and Muslims, 94; Muslims as persecuted by, 230–31; Muslims in shared religious-communal existence with, 236; as non-Arabs, 107–8; and Ottoman military draft, 22–23, 98, 107–8; population of, 32, 33; preaching to Jews by, 116–18; pro- vs. anti-Jewish views of, 136–37; and racial hatred for Jews, 106–7, 114; and redemption in Islam, 151–53; and religious hatred for Jews, 83–84, 106–7, 114–20, 121; and Septuagint, 212; socioeconomic status of, 115; and Tanzimat, 20; and toleration, 8, 119–20, 121, 157, 158, 159, 165; in ha-Ẓevi (ha-Or; Hashkafah), 99–100; Zionist category of, 95; Zionist views of, 94

  Christians, Palestinian: characteristics shared with Jews, 98; in ha-Ḥerut, 98–99; and Muslim-Christian Association, 235–37

  Christian Syrians, 26

  Church Fathers, 209

  Churchill, Winston, 241–42n23

  circumcision, 74

  Clarke, Adam, 164

  Cohen, Julia Phillips, 119n99

  Cohen, Mark R., 53n54, 150–51n67

  Cohen, Mendel, 199

  commerce, 81–82, 83n154, 84, 87, 146, 230

  Committee of Union and Progress (CUP), 25

  Conference of Rabbis, Frankfurt-am-Main, 62

  Copts, 21, 33

  Corneilhan, Georges, Juifs et opportunistes, 222, 228

  Crusaders, 124, 231

  Cyrus, 217, 218–19

  Czecho-Slovak state, 243

  Damascus, 16n5, 26, 53

  Damascus Affair, 201, 202

  Darwin, Charles: The Descent of Man, 27; On the Origin of Species, 27

  Darwinism, 26–28, 139

  David, 49, 168, 172

  David ha-Nagid (David ben Abraham Maimun), 200, 207, 208

  de Boton, David, 100

  Deganiah, 33

  Derenbourg, Hartwig, 44

  Dhu Nuwas, 144

  Disraeli, Benjamin, 148

  Dome of the Rock, 41, 52–53

  Drews, Arthur, 115–16

  Dreyfus Affair, 92, 147

  Drumont, Edouard, La France Juive, 228

  Druze, 21, 32, 176n141

  East Africa, 90, 91

  East Central Africa, 143

  Eastern Orthodox church, 33

  Efron, John, 31, 139n26

  Egypt, 88; British conquest and occupation of, 28; Fatimid state in, 156; and al-Ḥizb al-waṭanī (National Party), 220; and intellectual and cultural orbit of, 26; Israelite emigration to from Judea, 208–9; Jewish migration from Palestine to, 131–32, 138, 179; Jews in, 156, 177; and race, 28, 29; and Sudan, 28

  Egypt, ancient, 71, 82, 171

  Egyptian press. See al-Hilāl (The Crescent); al-Manār (The Beacon); al-Muʾayyad; al-Muqaṭṭam; al-Muqtaṭaf (The Digest)

  Eisenmenger, Johann Andreas, Entdecktes

  Judenthum, 228

  Elijah, 216

  Elmaleh, Avraham, 97, 192

  Ereẓ Yisraʾel, as term, 18

  Essenes, 149

  Europe: as imagined Other, 150; immigration of Spanish Jews to, 53; and Jerusalem, 29–31; Jewish acculturation in, 58; Jewish citizenship in, 31, 55–56; Jews in, 125, 146–47, 179; oppression of Jews in, 150, 151, 153, 156–57, 158, 159; religious intolerance in, 120–21; and representation of non-Muslims in Ottoman lands, 21. See also Capitulations

  European Christian missionary activity, 18

  European Christians: as residents of Palestine, 99–100

  European consuls, 29

  Europeans: and antisemitism, 228; anti-talmudic claims of, 11; biblical criticism of, 164; and Capitulations, 22; and claim of Eastern inferiority, 146, 147; and context of Jerusalem, 7; and Jewish ritual murder, 201; and Jews in Holy Land, 24; and M. R. al-Khalidi, 8, 43; and Moyal, 207; and Nahḍa, 145–46; protection of Christians by, 22; and race, 30, 139, 140, 146; and research on Bible, 172

  Eusebius, 171

  Exodus, biblical, 169–70

  Ezra the Scribe, 78–80, 164, 217

  Faisal Hussein, 240

  Faris, Habib, Ṣurākh al-barīʾ fī būq al-ḥuriyya, 202, 203, 208

  Fatimid state, 156

  Federation of American Zionists, 48

  Feldman, Yehoshua, 191n28

  fellahin, 123, 124–26

  Filasṭīn (Palestine), as term, 50. See also Palestine

  finance, 82, 86, 87, 133, 146, 155, 157. See also money

  First Aliyah, 34, 76, 95, 96, 100

  Fleisher, Rabbi, 118

  Four Holy Cities, 33

  France, 21, 29, 147, 158, 166, 173, 182

  Frankfurter, Felix, 240

  Galilee, 33

  Gamaliel, Rabban, 219

  Gaspo, Shimon, 246n34

  Gaza Strip, 16, 246

  Gelvin, James, 22n26

  gender equality, 245n33

  Geonim, 66

  Germany, 173, 183

  Gershoni, Israel, 220

  Gezer, 170

  Glass, Cyril, 213n101

  Goldziher, Ignaz, 47, 47n31

  Gorni, Yosef, 197n52

  Gospel of Barnabas, 163

  Gottheil, Richard James Horatio: and M. R. al-Khalidi, 11, 40–41, 42, 43, 46–47, 48, 51–52, 53, 62, 71, 76, 77, 86n162, 90, 91, 185; and Makaryus, 11; and Moyal, 185, 186, 190; and Nassar, 90, 91, 106, 185, 190, 231; Zionism, 48n33; “Zionism” (Jewish Encyclopedia), 11, 40–41, 42, 43, 46–47, 48, 51–52, 53, 62, 71, 76, 77, 86n162, 90, 91, 106, 185, 186, 190, 231

  Graetz, Heinrich, 216n119

  Great Britain, 29, 143; conquest of Palestine by, 179; and Egypt, 26; and grand mufti of Palestine (muftī filasṭīn al-akbar), 239; and al-Ḥizb al-waṭanī (National Party), 220; Jews in, 183; and Mandate for Palestine, 12n16, 16, 45, 66, 236, 237–45; and millet system, 238–39; and national home for Jews, 238, 241; and representation of non-Muslims in Ottoman lands, 21; The White Paper (May 17, 1939), 244

  Greater Syria, 26

  Great Revolt of 1936–1939, 240

  Great War, 2, 6, 7, 8, 16, 32, 35, 123, 178, 240; and Jews, 132, 179–80, 183; new political discourse after, 10; and Paris Peace Conference, 242

  Greece, 29, 242

  Greek Catholics, 33

  Greek Orthodox faith, 20, 21, 33

  Greeks, ancient, 209

  Greek-speakers, 36

  Griffith, Sidney H., The Bible in Arabic, 76n129

  Groyser Kundes, Der (The Big Stick), 181, 182–83

  Haddad, Rashid, 232

  hahambaşi, 19, 36

  Haim, Sylvia, 154n75, 161n92

  al-Hajj, Najib, Fī az-zawāyā khabāyā aw kashf asrār al-yahūd, 222–23

  Halevi, Judah, 53

  Halevi, Solomon, 53

  Hallaq, Wael, 63–64

  Hama, 202

  Hamas (Islamic Resistance Movement), 246, 247

  Hammurabi’s Code, 164

  Ḥanafī madhhab, 32

  Hanina, Rabbi, 206–7

  Hanioğlu, M. Şükrü, 21, 23n30

  al-Ḥaqīqa, 223

  al-Ḥaram ash-Sharīf. See Temple Mount

  al-Harizi, Judah ben Solomon, 200n56

  Hasidic Jews, 1

  haskamah/haskamot, 61, 66–68

  Hayes, Carlton, 5n7

  Hebrew, 55, 189, 191; Arabic as mark of identity vs., 236; an
d Ben-Yehuda, 99, 100, 108; learning of, 188; and N. Malul, 233

  Hebrew press, 8–9, 11. See also ha-Aḥdut; ha-Ḥerut; ha-Ẓevi (ha-Or; Hashkafah)

  Hebron, 33, 97

  Herodotus, 171

  ha-Ḥerut, 96, 185; anti-Christian polemics of, 117; and anti-Zionist Arabic press, 190; and Arabic press, 192; Arabs in, 102, 103, 126–30; and Ben-Gurion, 122; Christian Arabs in, 106–7, 108; and Christian religious intolerance, 119–20, 121; Christians in, 100; and Christians’ religious hatred for Jews, 114–20, 121; “A Christian Stabs a Hebrew,” 103; and creation of Arabic newspaper, 195; “The Enemies of Judah,” 114; “The Great Danger,” 106–7; “Heresy or Incitement?,” 116–18; “Jesus of Nazareth Never Existed,” 115–16; and Jews in Christian countries vs. Muslim world, 119–20, 121; and Kremer, 104, 105; “The Libel of our Enemies,” 129; and literacy in Arabic, 193; and N. Malul, 233; mission statement of, 97–98; Moyal’s translations of Arabic press in, 191; Muslims in, 100; and Nassar, 232; as offended by criticism of Zionism, 128–30; religion in, 98–99, 100, 101–2, 103; and Sephardic Zionists, 97–98; and Zakka’s an-Nafīr, 193

  Herzl, Theodor, 35n74, 42n12, 50, 54, 62, 66, 84n157, 172–73; and Hirsch, 91; and Yusuf Diyaʾ al-Khalidi, 89; and Kremer, 104; and Makaryus, 175; and Nassar, 90; and Pius X, 237n8

  Hibbat Zion, 35n74, 50n42, 197n52

  al-Hilāl (The Crescent), 133, 134–35, 158, 184; agent in Jerusalem, 135–36; Bible in, 169, 170, 171; cartoon from, 181, 182–83; Christian vs. Muslim editors, contributors, and audience of, 136n19; defense of Judaism against defamation in, 159, 160–61; “The House of Rothschild,” 154–57; “The Jews and the War,” 131–32, 138–39, 179–84; “The Jews in the Lands of the Arabs,” 143; and N. Malul, 11; and Moyal, 11; and pro- vs. anti-Jewish views, 136–37; and race, 9, 28; on Rothschild family, 174–75; and J. Zaydan, 141, 203

  Hillel, 204–5, 214–15

  al-Hindi, Rahmat Allah, 164

  Hirsch, Maurice de, baron, 91–92

  Histadrut ha-poʿalim ha-ẓeʿirim be-ereẓ yisraʾel (Organization of Young Workers in the Land of Israel), 127

  Hitler, Adolf, 247

  Ḥizb al-umma (People’s Party), 220

  al-Ḥizb al-waṭanī (National Party), 219, 220

  Holland, 29

  Holocaust, 246

  Holy Land. See Palestine

  Hourani, Albert Habib, 83n155, 153n74

  Hourani, George, 65

  Hugo, Victor, 51

  Hungary, 243

  al-Husseini, Hajj Amin, 247

 

‹ Prev