by Syd Parker
She left them and found Rick cuffing Meghan roughly. It was finally over. She met Jordan’s eyes and silently asked if she were okay. Jordan nodded slightly and winked. The cut was a small price to pay. They had finally caught the Cradle Killer. Jordan stepped closer to Rebecca, feeling her warmth. Rick’s voice wandered in and out of her head.
“…will be used against you in a court of law.”
Chapter 26
Rebecca set her case file down and settled into the chair across from Meghan. She was handling the interrogation alone. It was the general consensus that she was the least threatening. Jordan was too close to the case, and Rick would be seen as a threat. Rebecca flicked her eyes across the table, meeting Meghan’s gaze. “I just want to remind you that you do have a right to have an attorney present.”
Meghan shrugged, her face cryptically nonchalant. Not the reaction that Rebecca expected from a woman who was certain to go to prison for multiple homicides.
Okay, Rebecca thought. That’s how you want to play this. “Meghan, why don’t you tell us why you killed all these women?”
Rebecca set pictures of all the victims in front of Meghan. She waited for her to react. Nothing. She didn’t even blink. Rebecca narrowed her eyes. Time to play hardball. “What about Christine? Why did you want to kill her?”
Finally, a twitch. Meghan shifted in her chair. “If, and I do emphasize if, I wanted to kill her, she deserved it.”
“Why did she deserve it?” Rebecca looped her hands together.
“That bitch left me.” There was the twitch again. Christine was the only thing that seemed to faze Meghan. “Married for twelve years and she leaves me for a man. I gave her everything.”
“Why did she leave?”
Meghan’s eyes glazed over, and Rebecca knew that she was talking to the killer now. Her voice dropped to menacing low and Rebecca could see where she could have been confused for a man. “We wanted children. We tried the non-conventional methods, but nothing took. With my job, I could have done it, but she didn’t want to mix our home life with my work.”
Rebecca flicked her eyes to the two-way mirror where she knew the interrogation was being watched. This was the story they were looking for, and it was her job to stretch it into a confession. “That must have frustrated you. Especially knowing that you had the power to get your wife pregnant.”
Meghan’s eyes shifted, and Rebecca thought she lost her again, but just as quick the sneer returned. “She knew how good I was. I told her that this wouldn’t fail. It was our only chance. But she wouldn’t listen to me.”
“How did that make you feel?” Rebecca gave the line another tug, just a little bit more, and she had her right where she wanted her.
The muscle in the side of Meghan’s temple started to pulse, a steady but noticeable tempo. “Angry. I was so angry. I begged Christine to let me help. But she wouldn’t. She pushed me away.”
“How did you handle that?”
Silence. Meghan took several deep breaths. “I snapped.”
Yes. Rebecca thought. This is it. Come on, baby. I just need you to confess to one murder. “Snapped how?”
“It consumed me. I had the power to fix everything, and she wouldn’t let me. I went off the deep end trying to convince her. My job suffered. Everything suffered. But she kept refusing. Said that she wasn’t going to allow me to foster my God complex with our child. If she did that, all that child would be in her mind was something grown in a petri dish.”
“That must have hurt. Obviously, she knew you wanted children as badly as she did.”
Meghan slammed her hand on the table, causing Rebecca to jump back. “It killed me. She was being unreasonable. The more I pushed, the more she pulled away. Before she left, she could barely look at me. All those years together meant nothing.”
“And she threw all that away and walked out of your marriage?” Rebecca tugged again. Ever so slightly, just enough to remind Meghan that she wouldn’t get away.
Anger. Fury. Meghan’s eyes flashed darkly. “She left me for a man. Some piece of shit with a dick because she wanted a baby and sleeping with him was less deplorable than just letting me do my fucking job.”
Rebecca smothered a smile. She was so close. “What did you do when she left?”
Meghan calmed down slightly. She was a roller coaster of emotions, reliving the years that drove her to kill. “I tried to get her back for a while. She made it clear that it was over and there was nothing I could do or say that would change that. She eventually filed a restraining order. I turned to the only thing I could to dull the pain.”
“What was that?”
“I drank. Did coke.” Meghan swiped her finger across her nose subconsciously. “Started skipping work. The only thing I cared about was forgetting Christine. After a while, Dr. Stein had enough. He pulled me aside and pretty much told me if I didn’t straighten up, he would have the board kick me to the curb.”
And there’s the reason you wanted us to focus on him. “Did you clean up after that?”
Meghan shrugged. “Enough to fool him. Stupid fuck. He couldn’t fire me anyway. He needed me. I ran that place while he sat on his ass and used it to pick up women.”
Bring it back to Christine. “Did you ever see Christine again after all that?”
Meghan nodded slightly. “Once. She was shopping downtown.”
Her face dropped. “She was pregnant.” She stated it so matter-of-fact that Rebecca almost believed that she had accepted it with nothing but stoic resignation, but she knew better. “That must have really hurt your feelings.”
“I died that day.”
“Was that when you started killing the other women?”
Meghan jumped. Her eyes cleared up. “Uh-uh, Detective. Did you really think I would fall for that?”
Rebecca leaned forward, her gaze locking in on Meghan’s face. “Just for argument’s sake, let me tell you what I think happened.”
Meghan smirked, but nodded and gave her the go ahead, as if she was just listening to some funny anecdote.
“Here’s what I think.” Meghan pulled out the picture of the first victim. “I think you saw Christine pregnant, and you went ballistic. All these women coming into the clinic looking to you for help to get pregnant, and the one woman you wanted to help most, leaves you. The only way to get back at Christine is to take punishment out on innocent women. So you start picking women from the clinic, follow them, assault them and kill them. Every time you slice a woman’s throat, it’s Christine that dies.”
“Interesting theory, Detective.” Except for the vein in her temple pounding furiously, Meghan looked almost bored.
“But it’s not enough to just kill them. You had to rape them to get back at Christine for fucking you over. But you don’t stop there. You take her baby.”
A ghost of a smile broke out on Meghan’s face, but she said nothing.
“You robbed her of the one thing she wanted more than anything.” Rebecca took the next picture out and slammed it on the table. And another one until she was done. She was angry, and she trembled. “You killed every single one of these women.”
Meghan glanced at the pictures again. Still no reaction.
“Eight women and none of them was Christine.” Rebecca pulled out the last photo and set it on the table silently.
Meghan’s eyes dropped to Julie’s photo. She picked it up wordlessly, her jaw tightening. She studied it a moment longer then flung it on the table.
Rebecca picked up the photo and showed Meghan the back where Julie’s name had been written. “See that? Julie Keppler. Not Christine.” She flipped it around and shoved it in Meghan’s face.
Meghan flinched. No, this wasn’t Julie. This was her Christine. She belonged to her, and she had left. She left and had a baby with someone else. She felt a dull pounding at her temple, and she massaged it with her fingers. You let her get away. Just like that, the voice was back, taunting her for her failure. “Shut up!”
She spo
ke not so much to Rebecca, but to the voice that never went away. Never let her have a moment’s peace. She wanted it gone. “Get out of my head!”
Rebecca tensed. An odd transformation was happening. Meghan was fighting with something or someone. She watched the change and almost flinched at the look of pure hatred that flashed in Meghan’s eyes. Realization slowly dawned on her. This was the Meghan that had committed the murders. “Meghan? Are you still with me?”
Evil glinted in Meghan’s eyes. “Of course I am, you fucking bitch.” She said it with as even a tone as someone talking about the weather, but the look in her eyes sent chills down Rebecca’s spine. “Do you know why you’re here?”
“Of course I do.” A sneer. She picked up Julie’s picture. Meghan rubbed the tip of her finger over Julie’s mouth. “Sweet Christine. This is all your fault. You made me do it.”
“What’s all Christine’s fault?” Rebecca asked quickly. She needed to get her to confess. She could deal with the details of insanity later.
“She left me and she had to die.” Meghan stated angrily.
“Why all of them, Meghan?” Rebecca slid the photos closer, hoping to trigger another burst of anger.
An evil smirk broke out on Meghan’s face. This time she looked at the photos with a sneer of satisfaction. “Every one of them wanted something she couldn’t have. Just like every other woman in the world. All these stupid bitches begged me to play God for them. Every single one of them wanted to be pregnant. I had to look at their faces when they told me how much they wanted a child and how grateful they were that I could give it to them. All of them had what should have been mine.”
“What should have been yours, Meghan?”
“The baby. Every single baby should have been mine. That should have been Christine there, but I wasn’t good enough.”
“Is that why you took the babies?”
“I gave them that life.”
Meghan stated it without ire, and Rebecca wondered if she had lost contact with the crazy Meghan. “So the baby was yours to do with as you pleased?”
“Yes, you stupid cunt.” Meghan sneered.
“So, because Christine couldn’t let you play God, you had to punish all of them?”
“You’re so smart Detective. You’ve got this whole thing worked out, don’t you?”
Rebecca shrugged nonchalantly. “Maybe. Some of the details are a bit foggy.”
Meghan toyed with the edge of Julie’s photo. “Oh, I think you’ve got it all figured out.”
Rebecca held her gaze. “Tell me why you tried to frame Richard Hudson?”
Meghan chuckled evilly. “He was perfect.”
“What do you mean?”
“Surely, you know that Richard’s first wife was murdered, and the case is still unsolved.”
Rebecca’s brow furrowed. “How do you know about that?”
“Detective Foxx.” Meghan said condescendingly. “As I told you before, the clinic offers mandatory counseling for all its clients. Richard’s sessions proved very enlightening. His colored past made it all too easy to frame him.”
“So, you took his loss and punished him for it?”
“Richard Hudson was a bastard. I did the world a favor by taking him out of the picture.”
“And were you doing Elizabeth a favor by killing her and taking her baby?”
Meghan waggled her finger at Rebecca. “Tsk, tsk Detective.” The word Detective dripped with disdain. “What the world didn’t need was his spawn.”
“And that was your choice to make?”
Meghan slammed her fist down. “Of course it was my choice. I’m the only reason she was pregnant in the first place.”
“How did you kill them?”
Meghan studied her for a second, measuring her up. “The case files tell you all of that, I’m sure.”
“Yes, they do.” Rebecca nodded. “But as I said before, we weren’t quite sure of some of the details.”
“It was quite easy actually.” Meghan studied her fingernails. “Women are so trusting these days. They don’t sense danger. It made killing them rather simple.”
“And raping them and leaving DNA at the scene? Kind of hard for a woman?”
“Not really.” Meghan smug smile returned. “You’re a lesbian, Detective. I’m sure you know that there are tools out there. A strap-on and a condom full of semen. It’s not that hard to figure out.”
“And taking the baby? How about that, Meghan? Was that easy too?” Rebecca’s tone bordered on contempt.
Meghan’s eyes softened slightly. The only sign that she cared about life at all. “They were my children. I was saving them, Detective. Can’t you see that?”
“I don’t understand.”
“I couldn’t let them grow up in a world where love and vows mean nothing. I couldn’t let them be in a world where people like Christine could steal everything from them.”
Rebecca’s stomach turned. Meghan honestly believed she had done some magnanimous turn by killing them all. She swallowed as Meghan looked on expectantly. It was almost as though she took joy in what she had done.
Rebecca clasped her hands on the table. “What about Phillip Stein? Why him?”
Meghan looked at her askance. “Detective, everyone knows the perfect murder is the one you commit without being caught.”
“So, you steered us to him?”
“Giving you Phillip was as easy as leading a pig to the slaughter. You had already fucked up and caught the wrong guy once. You needed to break the case. All I needed to do was put the suggestion out there and you would find a way to fit the pieces into the puzzle.” The ghost of a smile formed in the corner of Meghan’s mouth. Her eyes looked almost triumphant.
Another wave of nausea. “Nine people are dead because of you. Doesn’t that bother you?”
Meghan sneered again. “They all died because of Christine. She still needs to die.” She leaned forward, put her finger on Julie’s picture and slid it in front of Rebecca. Their eyes locked. “She will die too.”
Rebecca felt a cold chill slide down her spine. “No one else will die. I promise you this. You will rot in jail.”
“Ahh, Detective.” Meghan smiled eerily. “As I said before, that’s the thing about the perfect murder…not getting caught. You have nothing on me. No way to tie me to any of them. At the most, you have assault and battery on a federal agent. But as you already know…” She rolled her finger in a circle near her temple. “…I’m crazy. I’ll do a little time in a cozy institution somewhere for a year or so.”
This time it was Rebecca’s turn to smirk. “The funny thing about evidence is you never know where it will pop up.” She looked over her shoulder and nodded.
The smile disappeared from Meghan’s face as the door opened and two officers deposited several bags of evidence on the table containing items that she immediately recognized.
Rebecca picked up a bag containing specimen cups. Meghan’s face blanched. “They’ve already been tested. Richard Hudson and Phillip Stein.”
Meghan swallowed. “Where did you get that?”
Rebecca picked up the next item. “I’m pretty sure that if we test the epithelial cells found on this strap-on with yours, they will be a match.”
“All that proves is I’m into penetration.” Meghan crossed her arms defensively.
Rebecca pulled the case folder out that the officers had just dropped off. She pulled several pictures of perfectly preserved fetuses out and lined them up in front of Meghan, who jerked away quickly. She cocked her head. “How am I doing so far?”
“You’ve got nothing, Detective.” Meghan said stoically, but her disdainful hubris was gone. “None of this ties me to the murders.”
Rebecca leaned back and smiled cryptically. “The funny thing about the perfect murder is there is no perfect murder. You made a mistake. You thought you had committed the perfect murder. That’s the problem with thinking you're smarter than everyone else.”
There was a flas
h of panic in Meghan’s eyes before it was replaced with cold fury. “You’re just trying to trip me up.”
“Not necessary.” Rebecca leaned forward. “You did that on your own.”
Meghan eyed her skeptically. “How so?”
“It’s funny how people will talk, isn’t it?” Rebecca smiled condescendingly. “You thought you had everything sewn up perfectly. Frame the perfect person. Leave behind nothing that really ties you to the case. This was all found at the clinic. It would be easy to fit it to Phillip Stein, just like you wanted. You figured it would be enough to convict someone else.”
“You’re fishing.” Meghan said flatly.
“Am I?” Rebecca countered with barely veiled civility. This was the moment she had been working up to. The coup de grace. The finishing stroke. “What you didn’t figure into the equation was human emotion.”
Meghan stared at her blankly.
“You see when you got Phillip Stein fired, you took away Ruth Dawson’s chance to get pregnant. She was perfectly happy to start talking once we asked the right questions.”
Meghan blanched. She couldn’t have known about that, could she? Stupid cunt!
As if on cue, the door to the interrogation room opened with an ominous creak. This time it was Jordan, who came into the room carrying a manila folder. “Here you go.”
The air in the room crackled around them. Jordan handed the folder to Rebecca, nodded at her and shot Meghan a murderous look.
Meghan saw the smug look of satisfaction of Rebecca’s face, and her breath caught. She knew what the folder contained. She was now the hunted. She was the prey. She balled her hands at her side angrily. “I want my lawyer.”
“Believe me, you’re going to need more than that.” Rebecca shot her a cold smile, the feeling of having finally caught the killer filling her with a sense of pride. To drive the nail further into the coffin, Rebecca pulled a specimen bag out and smiled smugly. “You got too cocky, Meghan. Your last victim fought back. The scratches on your face, we know how you got them, and I’m pretty sure the cells found under the victim’s fingernails are going to point to you.”
Meghan shifted and touched the raw skin subconsciously. She could no longer hide the fear. Her world was unraveling right before her eyes and the stupid bitch in front of her was the reason.