Published in 2017 by the Feminist Press
at the City University of New York
The Graduate Center
365 Fifth Avenue, Suite 5406
New York, NY 10016
feministpress.org
First Feminist Press edition 2017
Copyright © 2017 by Felicia C. Sullivan
All rights reserved.
This book was made possible thanks to a grant from New York State Council on the Arts with the support of Governor Andrew Cuomo and the New York State Legislature.
This book is supported in part by an award from the National Endowment for the Arts.
No part of this book may be reproduced, used, or stored in any information retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without prior written permission from the Feminist Press at the City University of New York, except in the case of brief quotations embodied in critical articles and reviews.
First printing March 2017
Cover design by Drew Stevens
Text design by Suki Boynton
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Names: Sullivan, Felicia C., author.
Title: Follow me into the dark / Felicia C. Sullivan.
Description: New York City: Feminist Press, [2017]
Identifiers: LCCN 2016034355 | ISBN 9781558614109 (ebook)
Subjects: LCSH: Stepsisters--Fiction. | Brothers and sisters--Fiction. | Psychological fiction. | BISAC: FICTION / Suspense. | FICTION / Contemporary Women. | FICTION / Psychological. | GSAFD: Suspense fiction.
Classification: LCC PS3619.U425 F65 2017 | DDC 813/.6--dc23
LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2016034355
“I could hear my heart beating. I could hear everyone’s heart. I could hear the human noise we sat there making, not one of us moving, not even when the room went dark.” —RAYMOND CARVER
CONTENTS
TITLE PAGE
COPYRIGHT
MAMMOTH 2013
THE WOMAN ON THE HOTEL BED 2013, 1985–1989
CITY OF GIRLS 1990–1991
WOMEN, DON’T BREAK 2013, 2003–2005
EVERYTHING WAS BEAUTIFUL AND NOTHING HURT 2003–2005
THE MUSIC OUR TEETH MAKE 1985, 2013
SOME ASSEMBLY REQUIRED 1968
FOLLOW ME INTO THE DARK 1958–1968
FLAMMABLE WOMEN 1968–1974
IN CASE OF AN EARTHQUAKE, REMAIN CALM 1977
LEAVING NEVADA 1977
CONSTANT LAND MOVEMENT 1977
HOW TO GRIEVE THE TERMINALLY ILL 2013
THE DAY ELLIE DIED 2013
WE PASS IN PARTS 1985
COLD COMES THE NIGHT 2013
WHERE THE CHILDREN SLEEP 1989, 2003–2005
THE BUSINESS OF LEAVING 2013
ANIMAL KINGDOM 2013
TELL ME ABOUT THE JOY 2014–2015
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
ALSO BY FEMINIST PRESS
ABOUT FEMINIST PRESS
MAMMOTH
2013
“THERE IS A woman on a hotel bed, and her hair is on fire,” I shout into a pay phone. The operator asks me whether I saw actual flames, was there actual fire? Maybe I saw a woman smoking a cigarette, because this is California and that’s what people are prone to do. “No, you don’t understand, I’m talking a fire here. I’m talking about a burning, a smell.”
Come to think of it, the woman, Gillian, was smoking or, rather, swallowing a lit cigarette that burned down her throat. I know this because I put the cigarette in her mouth, struck a match, and said, “All you have to do is breathe. I’ll take care of the rest.” I bound her wrists and ankles with rope, dialed up the thermostat to ninety (because why not?), and drew the curtains. The woman writhed and thrashed; her face was a river—a flood of tears and black kohl.
I waited for the heat.
You should know that I’d come for the hair. The hair that is a constellation of stars, a map of red curls tumbling down the woman’s back. The hair I saw James, my stepfather, run his fingers through. The hair he tucked behind a pierced ear. The hair he took in his mouth. The hair that replaced the clumps that fell out of my mother’s head.
“Tell me why you did it. Why you came into our home and broke things,” I had said to Gillian. “Actually, forget it. I don’t want to know.”
The operator makes inquiries about the location and coordinates, room numbers and facial descriptions. “To be honest,” the operator confesses, “I’m finding this hard to believe. Who goes and sets their hair on fire? You swallow pills. Or turn on the gas. It’s easier that way. Quick.” Nobody wants a problem suicide, a complicated death by one’s own hand.
From the pay phone I’ve a terrific view of the room I booked and paid for with a credit card that belonged to James. While the flames devour the curtains, I clutch a lock of Gillian’s hair, tight. Later I’ll place it in a small box, next to my mother’s ashes.
The hotel manager arrives in a pickup, surveys the fire, and calls the police. “Murray, you’re never going to believe this, but my goddamn place is on fire. Again.” By then I’m in the car. Gone.
I imagine my mother’s suffocation: her love strangled in her body in life, and her regret, rage, and hurt contained in a small box carrying her to the afterlife.
CALIFORNIA ISN’T HOME. It’s not Nevada. Death in California comes without warning; the land never stills.
Quit it with the story no one wants to hear, says everyone, always, whenever I complain about Gillian, the home-wrecking whore who’s stealing the breath right out of my mother’s mouth by prying my stepfather’s warm body out of bed. All my friends want me on mute because they’ve heard this story before, and the story is never new. Wife becomes a somnambulant. She’s expired, beyond her best-by date. Husband lifts the sheets and checks for signs of life but there is no movement, only the warmth of the sheets. Wife removes her ring and places it on one of her toes, and then kicks it off the bed. Husband raises the sheet over her head as if she’s already one of the departed. Wife still breathes but no one bothers to check for a pulse. See the chalk outline of her body. Feel the sheets cool. Husband drives down to the beach to collect his head and meets a girl listening to Tosca. Her name is Gillian, and she’s a photocopy of me, which sickens and comforts him all at once. I think about the bed and the beach as crime scenes, and I tell my friends this but everyone stops caring. Hurt becomes a constant state.
It’s an affair, Kate. They’ll likely divorce, Kate, they say. Until my mother becomes terminal, is delivered a death sentence in an oncologist’s office, and then they don’t say anything at all.
The day my mother is diagnosed with advanced lung cancer, James drives us home, lets the motor run until we’re inside the house, and then hits the gas. Hours later, I find him and the whore in a hotel room and I watch my stepfather wrap a scarf around Gillian’s neck. She nearly blacks out; her eyes roll to white. Coughing out sentences in starts and stops, the whore speaks in staccato. It gets to the point in the game where it seems like she can’t breathe. James makes out the word love, and he pauses and says, “Let’s get something straight. That’s not a hand I’m playing.”
Gillian says, “Okay, fine,” her mouth all dry and scabbing. Her pain registers—the physicality of her face coming undone, as if it were an abandoned house with rotting stairs, a flood rising up through the floorboards, and a Closed for Renovations sign swinging like a pendulum (although this is the kind of house no one will take on, gut, clean, and repair)—and I can tell that this makes my stepfather want her more.
After six minutes of the old in-and-out in a room they’ve rented, after
their bodies come together and untangle like live wires, they eat ceviche with their hands and talk about Cubans—cigars, not people. On the television a man shifts uncomfortably in his seat as he regales a now-infamous story about a former employee who didn’t quite work out. A perfectly normal individual, he says. Two barrels of a shotgun, he says. Stacked neatly in one of the hotel rooms, he says. From my secret vantage point, I watch them nod, their bodies covered in fuck, letting the scene play out.
Lately I’ve been thinking about the old, deaf artist who painted savagery on his walls. He felt a need to correct the serene and sublime, to undo the harm done by portraits of refined gentry, and the artist was something of a fakir drawing out the barbaric. A still-beating heart held in one hand and a scissor in the other. He made a mural of the macabre, replete with Viejas conjuring, a Sabbath, and a mad Greek devouring the limbs of his newborn. The child was rendered in a chilling white, but all I can remember is the cavern that was the father’s mouth.
Gillian sits naked in a chair, crossing and uncrossing her legs. “You know what I like about us, James? We’re just two tools that fit well together,” she says, James’s tie a tourniquet on her wrist. Her lips barely move when she says, “Just a hammer and a nail. What keeps this interesting is that we’re never in the same role; sometimes I’m beaten and other times I’m beating.”
“Ellie’s dying,” he says, referring to my mother. The woman he once loved, who’s now nothing more than a mess of patchy blond hair, bleached skin, and bone. “She’s got no more than a few months left and I’m fucking you. Don’t be a lesser version of her. Ellie mastered the game of not caring, of crawling through the dark and coming up empty. Improvise for me, at least. Give me a new play on an old trick. Don’t just sit there and pass off all her best plays as your own.”
“I’m not a fucking dog. I don’t heel on cue.”
“Is that right?” he says slyly.
“And besides, Ellie’s been dying.”
“I don’t know why I fuck you,” James says.
I watch him reach for the watch my mother gave him. I watch him clasp it around his wrist. I watch him register the time. I watch him glance at Gillian and then at the door with a longing that resembles love. He wants out, I can feel it, but why bother? The damage is done. On the upside, he’ll squeeze in a few last lays before he has to play the role of mourning the departed.
“You fuck me because it feels good,” Gillian says.
James buries his head in his knees, like what you do in the event of a plane crash. Four-color brochures depict the serenity of the leaving: the dramatic gasps for oxygen and bodies folded in half. Perhaps we’re instructed to do this, not because we have a desire to breathe (what’s the point, really?), but because we’ve an innate need to return to what we believe to be the beginning. To close our eyes and humbly crawl back to the warm and familiar dark, because although this is the one thing we don’t remember (that one head pushing out, those eyes that opened wide to the first light, and the mouth that screamed so valiantly, the terror of being born), it brings us an unexplainable comfort. James once asked Ellie, why him? Of all the men, why did she choose him? She paused, leaned over, and smoothed his hair out of his eyes—no one had done that, gotten so close, touched the skin above his brow—and said that she liked men who had been through war and would spend the rest of their days dressing their wounds. Who could predict then that the wounds would stay open, never heal? This is how James feels when he’s with Gillian—a walking wound.
“You gonna bake me a cake, James? Like the old days? Buttercream frosting with a cherry on top?” Gillian says. “You know of my affection for ovens.”
“These aren’t the old days,” he says, weary.
“You used to have some fight in you. Stop acting like you have cancer.”
“We’re not talking about my wife. We’re not permitted to have that conversation. You want me to draw you a fucking map of where you can and cannot go?”
“Maybe I was wrong,” Gillian says. “Maybe there’s some fight in you left.”
I watch her eat fish. Is there no end to how much this woman will devour? The chewing, the picking out of flesh from her teeth, the swallowing—it makes me dizzy, but I have to keep it together. I need to see. I’ve got to gather the evidence, do the math, and make the case. All of them will invariably beg for a reason, and I will hand over that whore of a woman’s hair and say, Do you understand I had no choice?
Things had to be done. This woman had to be burned.
THE DAY MY mother dies, but before she does, I make her toast. Palming a hot cup of coffee, I feel the steam rise and warm my hand. “We can talk about it, if you want. Or not, if that’s what you want, too,” I say.
“Men are always ready to trade you for a younger version of you. It’s still you, but with lighter hair and a tighter face. A passport with no stamps,” my mother says, slathering cold butter onto toast. She doesn’t seem to notice the bread tearing, the crumbs scattering the counter.
“You’re breaking the toast,” I say.
“That’s what concerns you,” my mother says, “a mess in the kitchen.” Sometimes when Ellie speaks she sounds like me, or me like her. I can’t tell which.
“Mother, of course not.” But I don’t register. I might as well have not been in the room.
“I spend my days, my life, reconciling the woman I once was, all my wants and desires, with the woman I became, and the wants become needs, necessities, and there comes a moment when desire extinguishes. So here I am, holding the ashes of my former self, mourning. Marriage made me selfish—don’t do it, Kate. Don’t get married. Become allergic to the thought of it. Because you’ll keep asking yourself if what you have, who you are, is ever enough. And one day you’ll wake and realize this is your life, all of it. Your life has become an inventory of all the things you’ve accumulated over the course of a marriage, and you wonder if it was all worth it. You’re not a wife or a husband—you’re an accountant, a taxpayer, and a divider of property. I made a mistake; I asked for too much, loved too little. I thought I could get away with giving only the minimum. But in the end you’re left with so much less than what you started with, and no one can solve that. Maybe my love should have been a tidal wave—all-consuming, a love that swallows you whole. Or maybe I shouldn’t have bothered to love at all. Look where it got me. Look at you, sweet Kate, aching for what I can’t give you.”
My mother’s wrist shakes. She holds a knife in her hands. Butters toast as if her life depends on it.
“Please. Stop. This isn’t your fault,” I say. “You didn’t make him fuck that woman. Mom, can you stop buttering the fucking toast?”
“I did this to you. I allowed this to happen, and for what? We’re none the happier because of it, in spite of it.”
Ellie balls up the obliterated toast. Stands there, feels the crumbs rain down from the spaces between her fingers. She’s gone, now. Never coming back, now. All the life drained, now. Sessile, now. Finally in love, now. But there’s only room enough in her heart for James; I get the scraps, the never enough, the remains of what James will inevitably abandon.
My mother says, “I did this to you.”
I’m not going to talk about what it was like to find my mother when I came home that evening. Cold cheeks, hair shorn with the scissors in her drawer (no one will understand why she cut her hair to the nape), lips parted from when the contents of the bottle pulled the last vestige of air out. Traces of crumbs in her palm. The toast remnants, buttered now. Cold remains on a plate.
At the wake, I observe the people in black, our friends and family, and think: keep moving. Go on, there’s nothing to see. The motley lot slouches past, with their popcorn and binoculars, their suppositions and theories. Now my friends want to talk to me so they can fill in the blanks. Now my friends are in the business of concern with their thin lips and sympathy symphonies.
The Chinchorro were unique in their dedication to preserving the dead. Embalmers exci
sed the skin and the flesh, replacing it with clay. Precious organs were removed and pickled before they were returned, tissue wrapped, to the body. Only the heart remained, lying still among the pickles and animal hair. I admire this ritual, the Chinchorro’s fastidious connection to the departed, and the nearly two months of care devoted to the remains.
The curtain closes. It’s the end of the show, folks. The coffin glides in.
After everyone leaves, watch me scream.
I READ A book where the author replaced the word die with complete. As if to say, we’re done with that now, let’s move on to something else. Let’s change topics. Let’s move to the next item on the agenda. Let’s muffle the tears of the grieving with a word that is at turns gruesome and elegant. Why don’t we all gather over here and whisper because there’s no need to go out and create a massacre on the street?
Childhood Is the Kingdom Where Nobody Dies, a pro-life billboard reads. What if you were never a child? What if you sprung as an adult out of the womb and spent your life in constant repair? Where does everyone go when they complete?
There is no nobility in a body shuddering its last breath, of a heart slouching forth to its final beat, of a mother’s hand that has grown cold and inert, like unworn cashmere. There is only a full bottle of prescription pills and an empty one. There are knuckles in my mouth in the middle of the night smothering screams; I hear her voice. It’s Christmas morning and she tells me that when she dies she wants to be burned. None of this below-the-ground business with worms in her eyes. Burn me up and spread me out in the water. I am fifteen and I nod, taking note of a time when I’ll have to endure a burning. There are only the sentences My mother is alive and My mother is dead.
Excuse us. Complete. Let’s be careful not to make a disturbance.
After the wake, James sits in a car and cuts the engine. His face is a mess of pain. He wraps his hands around his neck and begins to choke himself, but stops because he can’t handle the pressure. From the window above I shake my head. Fucking amateur. You can’t die that way. I want to tap the window and say, Give me the keys. Let me turn on the engine. Let me let it run.
Follow Me into the Dark Page 1