The Naughty Virgin (Sorority Sins XXX Book 2)

by Sadie May

  “It’s just that I have something I need to tell you.” I bit my lip as I stepped out from between them, so I could face them both. “I didn’t really date in high school. And I know you’re both older than me--”

  “Not that much older,” Eric smiled.

  “We’re only twenty-four,” Kyle added.

  “Right, but you mentioned other girls, competing, sharing and I…” I trailed off taking a breath. Then summoning my courage, I blurted it out. “I’ve never been with anyone.”

  They both just stared at me. Neither spoke. Eric’s already dark eyes were now unreadable and Kyle’s narrowed in a way that was almost dangerous. “You’re… you’re a virgin?”

  I nodded, biting my lip. They just kept looking at me and I tried not get upset but I could feel rejection coming again. Of course they didn’t want a freshman virgin.

  Whirling around, I blinked away the tears as I made my way to the door. But I hadn’t made it a step before I was in the middle of the man sandwich once again. Eric in front and Kyle behind.

  “If you think you’re leaving now, you’re crazy,” Kyle whispered.

  “But you were just staring and I…”

  “Oh honey, we were speechless.” Eric kissed her long and hard. “You are gorgeous and sweet, sexy as hell, and willing to be with us both. The fact that you are also a virgin makes you irresistible.”

  “Maybe it’s because we share with each other, we don’t like sharing our woman with anyone else, past, present or future.” Kyle’s hand slid under her sweater again, trailing along her skin.

  “We’ll take it slow. There are other things we can do,” Eric murmured between kisses.

  They wanted me? Even though I was a virgin? With both of them offering to take it slow, how could I resist?

  Eric kept kissing me, soft and slow while Kyle nipped at my neck. His hands on my waist, I broke the kiss with Eric long enough for Kyle to send my sweater sailing over my head. He spun me toward him and ravaged my mouth as Eric undid my bra.

  It fell off and dropped to the floor as Eric’s hands reached around to knead my tits, his fingers rubbing and tweaking my nipples.

  I broke the kiss for a second to moan, and Kyle yanked off his shirt too. Then he pulled me into his arms and my bare chest came into contact with his. I almost orgasmed. His skin against mine felt more amazing than I ever could have imagined until Eric peeled his shirt off too and pressed against my back.

  Oh God, my panties were so wet. Taking me to the couch, they sat me between them where they took turns kissing me, each playing with one of my breasts.

  It lasted for so long I was writhing under their touch, ready to beg them to do more, when Kyle’s hand slipped into my jeans. He could barely get his fingers in there but even the small touch against my clit had me jerking and moaning.

  Eric grinned and slid his mouth down to my nipple and Kyle knelt on the floor to strip me of my jeans.

  He left my panties on and began to massage my mound over the fabric. It only enhanced my pleasure, making my clit a little less sensitive. Then he dropped his mouth and started to suck me through my panties.

  I cried out, my hips bucking against him.

  Eric pulled away from my tits to strip off his pants and underwear. His cock sprung out at me and I blinked. It was more massive than I ever could have imagined. Nothing like my friends had described or what I had seen on the few pornos I had watched. “Are they… are they always so big?”

  Both men laughed, Kyle looking up at me from between my legs.

  He stood and stripped down too. His just as large. “No, sweetheart. But don’t worry. You’re made for this.”

  Kneeling back down, he hooked his fingers into my panties and pulled them down over my hips. Eric stood before me, his cock pointing right at me. I reached out my hand and grabbed it, the soft velvety flesh, smooth to the touch.

  He hissed, adjusting my fingers and helping me stroke him. “Just like that, baby.”

  Kyle dropped his mouth to my pussy and licked from the bottom to top. I cried out and spasmed, sure I would come in a few seconds.

  My movements were jerky on Eric’s cock and he moved closer, I’m sure to help me. But he was so close now, I wanted more or him. Without prompting, I licked up his shaft the way Kyle had just licked me and he threw his head back groaning.

  I could see that Kyle was watching us, even as he worked his tongue in circles on my clit. One of his fingers circled around my tight pussy before he inserted it, making me shake with need. His other hand was pumping his own cock.

  I sucked Eric’s fat head into my mouth and felt it pulse, his body trembling. He liked it. I used my mouth as he had used my hand, working in and out until I could see his muscles tightening and straining.

  Kyle swirled faster, his finger pumping in and out. I could barely see, it felt so good and an orgasm was building out of control.

  I sucked more of Eric’s cock in my mouth, suddenly wishing I could fit them both at the same time. It was impossible of course, I was straining over Eric’s. But I wanted to taste Kyle too.

  Then I couldn’t think another thought because my body spasmed and I screamed around the fat cock in my mouth.

  My orgasm set both of them off, because a stream of cum shot down my throat and I greedily swallowed it. “Fuck, yeah,” Eric moaned.

  Kyle’s mouth lost all rhythm as I heard Kyle moan into my pussy, his body wracked with tremors.

  This time, I wasn’t going to fall asleep as Kyle rested his head on my belly and Eric slumped on the couch.

  I slid to the floor, pushing Kyle onto his back. He gave me a questioning glance as I slid my hand over his abdomen. I was on all fours above him. “I want to taste you.”

  His eyes darkened as his cock hardened. His hand tangled in my hair as I knelt my head down to lick the cum, already on the head of his cock, off. “Holy shit, sweetheart,” he gasped as I started licking down his shaft.

  “She’s a natural,” Eric replied behind us. His hands skimming down my back and holding my hips.

  Taking Kyle’s rock hard cock into my mouth, I sucked on the mushroom head before opening my mouth to let it slide down my throat. I heard him groan, his hand pulling tighter on my hair in a way that was so hot.

  Eric’s hand was now rubbing along my slit as he spread my natural juices from my pussy to the crack of my ass.

  I tensed, popping off Kyle’s cock, and looking back at Eric. But he gave me a gentle smile. “No penetration… yet.”

  Relaxing, I sucked on Kyle’s cock again, as Eric laid his cock in my ass crack. Squeezing my cheeks together he rubbed along it until his balls slapped my clit.

  Sensation zinged from my extremely sensitive clit as I jolted from the pleasure.

  He felt it and then he moved the head of his cock down to rub against my lips, teasing my flesh. I shivered and moaned. Having him back there, so close to my opening, my fear was gone. Instead, I wanted to thrust back and take Eric inside of me.

  I was leaning back as he teased me, pushing closer and closer. I think I might have begged him to take me if my mouth wasn’t so full of cock.

  Kyle was tightening as I slurped up and down him, his hips lifting off the floor to thrust further into my mouth.

  My insides were tightening again, another orgasm about to rip through me. Eric rubbed faster his hand pumping his own cock making it work my clit back and forth till I was ready to scream with pleasure.

  “Fuck,” Kyle cried out. Cum was streaming down my throat as I came.

  Eric grunted behind me, then moaned, and just as my body quieted, his head jerked away and I felt his cum shoot across my back.

  I collapsed on top of Kyle and then Eric on top of me, our bodies pressed together.

  I was sleepy again and I sighed in contentment.

  Eric stroked my hair. “Need a nap, sweetheart?”

  I groaned. That sounded heavenly. “I can’t. I have to move my stuff over to the sorority.”

  Kyle sque
ezed my waist. “Lucky for you, I know two guys who could totally help with that.”

  I picked my head up, giving him a sleepy grin. “Really? In that case, maybe I will have time for that nap.” It was so nice to have their help. It made it feel like something real. But a little niggle of doubt worked in the back of my mind. I still hadn’t told them about the video. What if someone mentioned it?

  “Good idea,” Eric kissed the spot just under my ear. “You rest, then we’ll get some lunch and then off to move you into the sorority.”

  I took a deep breath. I’d have to tell them soon.

  Eight hours later, I looked around my new room in amazement. Bed was made, pictures were hung, desk was set up. They’d even ordered pizza.

  “Thank you both, so much.” I blushed because I must have thanked them a hundred times.

  They both winked.

  “So,” Kyle gave me a delicious grin. “What should we do now?”

  My blush deepened.

  “Movie?” Eric suggested. His own grin matching Kyles.

  “Party?” Kyle caught the joke.

  I laughed then tossed in a joke of my own. “You two go ahead. I’m totally beat. I think I’ll call it an early night.”

  Both sets of eyes turned to me then. Their smiles gone.

  “You’re kicking us out?” Kyle’s eyebrows drew together, one hand slung on is hip.

  Eric’s dark arms crossed his chest.

  “Guys,” I rolled my eyes. “I was kidding.”

  Both men relaxed into smiles, then gave a chuckle. “Oh,” Eric rubbed his hand along the back of his neck.

  “I thought it was the running joke.” I stepped closer to them. “You know, all the things we might do besides stay here together and…” I let the words trail off.

  It was Kyle who reached my side first. “Sorry about that, sweetheart. We normally have a good sense of humor but we seem to get rather serious about you.”

  Eric came to my other side. “But since we’re talking about it, I want to hear you say what we would stay here to do.”

  I gulped, my face flaming. It was one thing to do all these dirty delicious acts but so much more embarrassing to say it out loud. I’d stopped feeling insecure but suddenly my newbie status had me blushing again. “I mean, we could, that is to say…” I faltered.

  “We love that you are so sweet and fresh,” Kyle whispered.

  “But you can be as dirty as you want with us,” Eric finished. “But just us.”

  Giving a nod, I summoned my courage. “I want you to fuck me.” I didn’t say it loud but they both heard me and suddenly, their hands were everywhere.

  Kyle’s lips captured mine in a fierce kiss as one of his hands squeezed my tit, the other cupping my ass.

  Eric had the other tit in his hand but he slid his other hand down to cup my mound outside of my jeans.

  My pussy was so wet, I was hot for them already. But that didn’t speed them up. If anything, they slowed down.

  Their hands light as they massaged various parts of my body. They were so in tune with each other, like they were meant to work as one. I pulled away from Kyle’s lips. “How can you both touch me the same way? Like you’ve discussed it.”

  Kyle gave me a grin and then both of them spun me so that I was facing Eric. His lips began teasing mine. “We told you, we’ve been friends for a long time. We work better together.”

  I gave a nod. Eric’s hand slipped up my shirt and began massaging my breast over my bra. A groan of frustration built in my throat. I wanted to be naked, I wanted their mouths on me.

  “Newbie,” someone called and knocked on the door. It was Missy.

  Eric’s hand was still up my shirt and Kyle was running his fingers along the seam of my jeans. Then he moved to the button and popped it open, sliding down the zipper. He pushed his hand inside, running his finger along my lips. No way was I stopping now. I decided to ignore her. I’d find out what she wanted later.

  But a second later, she just opened the door and strolled in.

  I ripped my mouth away from Eric’s and looked at her, my mouth hanging open. Neither Eric or Kyle took their hands off me, but they stilled. “What are you doing?”

  “Don’t stop on my account. It’s even hotter than the other night.” She gave a cat like grin. “There’s a party downstairs in the basement if you want to join. All three of you.”

  “Missy, we’re busy.” I gave an exaggerated sigh. But I knew what she meant now. They were having a sex party. I got wetter just thinking about it.

  “Oh you can keep doing what you’re doing. It’s just a little less private.” She winked and then she was gone.

  Kyle’s fingers were still in my pants and he slipped one of his fingers inside me. “You’re so wet.”

  Eric’s eyes held a question, his hand in my shirt. But he must have decided not to ask it because in the next second, he was pulling my shirt over my head.

  “Take down her jeans too,” Kyle rasped in my ear. His finger was working in and out of me as his palm pressed to my clit. I leaned against him, as Eric stripped off the rest of my clothes. It felt so good, an orgasm was already building. I blinked, taking a few deep breaths to try and slow myself down. But then Eric’s mouth clamped on one of my nipples.

  “Fuck,” I cried out as I started cumming. I hadn’t been naked for more than thirty seconds and I was already having an orgasm.

  But they didn’t stop, Eric started kissing down my body, his lips nipping, teeth biting playfully. “I want to taste you,” he groaned.

  Kyle slid his hand out of the way as Eric reached his tongue out to circle my clit. I bucked and cried out as intense pleasure zinged through me. My legs nearly buckled, but Kyle held me up.

  Eric kept working me and I knew I wouldn’t last long. Kyle was moving back until he reached the bed. Sliding down, he held me on top of him as Eric moved with us, keeping up the assault on my clit. I wanted to feel something inside me and I was about to beg him to put use his fingers when something larger pressed at my opening. My nerves crackled with need and I moaned loudly.

  Kyle chuckled behind me. “Needy girl. I love it when you moan like that.” He reached over to the nightstand and pulled out a condom, rolling it down his shaft.

  Eric kept up his assault, my legs shaking from the orgasm building deep within. Kyle moved slowly, pushing inside of me. I was stretching around him, completely full. I felt the pinch, but with Eric’s onslaught, I barely noticed.

  He pushed all the way in and and then he touched something deep inside me. I couldn’t hold it back. Eric’s tongue, Kyle’s cock, I howled an orgasm.

  My entire body clenched, every muscle straining as stars exploded before my eyes.

  I have no idea how long it lasted, but awareness slowly came back. Eric’s head rested on my belly as he grinned at me. Kyle was still buried inside me, not moving.

  “Okay?” Eric asked.

  I gave him a sleepy smile as I nodded, words failing me. Their fingers were skimming across my skin, soothing and tantalizing. “That was amazing,” Kyle whispered in my ear.

  “I agree,” I chuckled as I spoke. Taking a few deep breaths, I tried to shake the sleepiness. It was time to return the favor.

  Eric was kissing up my belly. When he reached my breasts, his tongue circled my nipple. At the same time, Kyle moved inside me.

  I looked down to see his thick cock pushing back in, filling me, stretching me, and the ache started again. “Holy shit,” I moaned.

  Eric switched to the other breast, his hand sliding down to work my clit. “I love watching you cum,” he murmured.

  My hands in his hair, I pulled his mouth to mine. “I appreciate that but I think it’s your turn.” Then I kissed him, my tongue sliding up against his.

  Pushing him up, I kissed a trail down his torso, to his nipples, across his belly, Kyle fucking me all the while. It was so hot, I could feel the pressure building again and it made my movements bold, as I nipped at Eric’s skin. When he r
ose up high enough that I could reach, I sucked as much of his dark cock into my mouth as I could. Opening my throat, I swallowed him down.

  I heard his grunt and felt his body jerk in response. Kyle’s fingers slid to my clit, working it in circles as he pumped in and out of me, making my body tense as another orgasm raced toward me.

  Kyle’s breath hissed in my ear, “Baby girl, you feel so fucking good.”

  Eric moaned above me as I took him as deep as I could, my hands wrapping around his thick cock to pump him as I worked him with my mouth.

  I focused on Eric, keeping up the rhythm but I was slipping, I could feel it, about to fall over the edge of another mind blowing orgasm. Suddenly he shuddered and groaned, his thick cum sliding down my throat. The taste, the feel sent me over the edge and I exploded, my muscles clenching around Kyle’s cock.

  He lost it too, his guttural cries filling the room as he pumped in and out of me.

  It took several minutes before I became aware of anything. But when I did, I was laying between them both, Kyle behind me, Eric in front.

  Their bodies, pressing close to mine, I had never felt safer, more protected. I moved a little, rubbing against them, reveling in feel of their skin against mine.

  Eric kissed me softly. “Tiffani, that was incredible.”

  I gave him a sleepy smile. “I bet you say that to all the girls.”

  Kyle gave a small laugh. “No, we don’t.” He started feathering kisses across her neck. “Get some sleep. You must be exhausted.”

  “Mmm,” I answered closing my eyes. I was exhausted and so comfortable. I wanted to stay just like this with them, forever.

  The next morning I woke to kisses on my chest and back. “Good morning.” I gave a sleepy smile. “I guess it’s never too early for some fun.”

  They both chuckled, but Eric tilted his head up to look at me. “We have an early morning class, we have to go.”

  I nodded, trying not to show my disappointment. I would miss them. Both of them. Was it even possible to be emotionally attached to two men at the same time? It must be, because it felt like I was. Which worried me. I still hadn’t told them about the tape. What if they didn’t want me after they knew?