China and Japan

Home > Other > China and Japan > Page 30
China and Japan Page 30

by Ezra F. Vogel

to fight the Japa nese. By the time the fleet reached Indonesia, Japa nese ships

  were observing its movements very carefully. After the Japa nese discovered

  that the Rus sians would pass through the narrow strait near Tsushima,

  Japa nese ships were deployed to lie in wait. When the Rus sians, who had

  not taken great care in following Japa nese troop movements, passed through

  the Tsushima Strait, the Japa nese caught them in another surprise attack.

  After a two- day battle, the Japa nese had destroyed two- thirds of the Rus-

  sian fleet and incurred very few losses themselves. By the end of the battle,

  Rus sia, preoccupied by the 1905 revolution at home, had lost the will to con-

  tinue the war. In fact the Japa nese were also exhausted by the end of the

  Russo- Japanese War, and had Rus sia continued the fight, it is doubtful Japan

  would have won. Once Rus sia sought an end to the war, Minister of For-

  . 186 .

  The Colonization of Taiwan and Manchuria, 1895–1945

  eign Affairs Komura Jutaro went to his classmate from Harvard Law School,

  Theodore Roo se velt, to seek his cooperation in concluding a peace treaty.

  Peace discussions, mediated by President Theodore Roo se velt, who was

  awarded the Nobel Peace Prize for his role, were held in Portsmouth, New

  Hampshire, in August 1905 and an agreement was signed on September 5.

  In the treaty, the Rus sians acknowledged that Japan had paramount interests

  in Korea and agreed that they would not interfere with Japan’s activities

  there. Japan gained full sovereignty over the southern half of the island of

  Sakhalin. Rus sia also transferred its Port Arthur lease and nearby territorial

  waters to Japan. Rus sia did retain control of the railway from Harbin to

  Changchun and thus could continue to dominate northern Manchuria, but

  it transferred to Japan the lease, then good for twenty- five more years, to a

  420- mile portion of the southern spur of the China Eastern Railway, from

  Changchun to Dalian, and other branches of the southern spur, such as the

  link from the city of Jilin to Changchun, a total of approximately 700 miles

  of railway. The Japa nese renamed the railways that they received the South

  Manchurian Railway Com pany. Japan was also given rights to the land adja-

  cent to the railway, extending out for ten kilo meters on each side, and rights

  to the coal mines that supported the railway. In 1915, impressed by the ninety-

  nine- year lease Great Britain had received for Hong Kong in 1898, Japan

  pressured China to grant it an additional ninety- nine- year lease.

  Rule by the South Manchurian Railway and the Kwantung

  Army, 1905–1931

  After the Russo- Japanese War, Japa nese po liti cal leaders remained anxious

  that Rus sia might launch a war of revenge. They were frightened by the

  growing number of Rus sian settlers in Siberia and by Rus sia’s increasing

  ability to send troops and goods from Moscow to Vladivostok as a result

  of its double- tracking of the Trans- Siberian Railway and its completion of

  a new railway around Lake Baikal in 1905 that enabled the Rus sians to go

  by rail directly to East Asia without stopping to transfer goods to and from

  a boat to cross the lake. Japa nese po liti cal leaders began planning for how

  to respond to Rus sian attacks if Rus sia were to launch such a war of re-

  venge. But Rus sia was facing domestic turmoil, especially after the Rus sian

  Revolution of 1917, and though relations between Japan and Rus sia remained

  . 187 .

  china and japan

  tense and Rus sians dominated the area north of Changchun where the

  railway remained in their hands, in the end Rus sia did not interfere with

  Japa nese interests south of Changchun.

  At the time, Japa nese leaders realized that the United States and the Eu-

  ro pean powers would not tolerate Japan’s turning Manchuria into a Japa-

  nese colony, and after the Russo- Japanese War, China retained po liti cal sov-

  ereignty over Manchuria. But Japa nese organ ization along the railway was

  far better than the regional organ ization of Manchurian warlord Zhang

  Zuolin, and Japan began to extend its influence beyond the leased territory.

  Although not part of Japan’s formal empire, Manchuria in effect became part

  of its informal empire. Western businesses kept operating in Manchuria,

  but after 1905 Japa nese businesses began to dominate the economy.

  Japa nese interests in other parts of China, especially in Shanghai and

  Fujian, continued to grow, but after 1905 its investments centered around

  the South Manchurian Railway Com pany (Minami Manshu Tetsudo

  Kabushiki Gaisha; abbreviated as Mantetsu in Japa nese, Mantie in Chinese),

  and Japanese- owned companies in Manchuria grew faster than Japa nese

  companies elsewhere in China. By 1914 an estimated 69 percent of Japa-

  nese direct investments in China were in Manchuria, and most Japa nese

  activity in China remained in Manchuria until the Second Sino- Japanese

  War broke out in 1937. Manchuria remained an agricultural area, where soy-

  beans and soybean products (including soy sauce and soybean pulp for

  fertilizer) were the major export items (to Japan, Eu rope, and to China

  proper, south of Manchuria). Since land in Manchuria was basically dry,

  little rice could be produced there, and sorghum ( gaoliang) was the main

  grain. New Japa nese investments were mainly focused on the railway and

  the construction proj ects near the rail lines.

  The Japa nese assassinated Manchurian warlord Zhang Zuolin in 1928

  (see Chapter 7) and tightened Japan’s control in Manchuria, and in 1931

  Japan turned Manchuria into a Japanese- controlled puppet state. Army

  strategist Ishiwara Kanji began considering how to expand the industrial

  base in Manchuria so as to equip a modern army. In the mid-1930s his ef-

  forts were unsuccessful because he refused to make investments in Man-

  churia attractive to private companies. He wanted such investments to be

  controlled by the state, not by private cap i tal ists. In 1935, a bright young bu-

  reaucrat from the Ministry of Commerce and Industry, Kishi Nobusuke,

  . 188 .

  The Colonization of Taiwan and Manchuria, 1895–1945

  who believed in Soviet- style economic planning, was appointed deputy min-

  ister of Manchurian industrial development. Kishi made enough conces-

  sions to attract Nissan ( Japan Industries), after World War II a car com-

  pany, led by Ayukawa Yoshisuke, who was willing to cooperate with the

  government to develop heavy industry so as to strengthen the military-

  industrial base. Though Manchuria later suffered from U.S. attacks on its

  shipping fleet that made it difficult to transport the necessary machine tools

  from Japan and impossible to achieve its ambitious targets, Manchuria de-

  veloped coal, iron, and copper mines. By 1942, it was producing more than

  three million tons of iron and steel per year.

  Given the shortage of laborers in Manchuria, some of the physical labor

  during Japa nese colonization— clearing the fields and growing the soybeans,

  working in the mines and on construction proj ects— was supplied by mi-

  grants from other Chinese provinces, particularl
y Shandong and Hebei.

  Once the Manchu rulers, concerned about Japa nese and Rus sian pressures,

  had begun allowing non- Manchus to migrate to Manchuria in the late nine-

  teenth century, Chinese mi grants began to move into sparsely populated

  Manchuria from nearby Shandong and Hebei, which were heavi ly popu-

  lated. From the 1890s until the beginning of World War II, approximately

  twenty- five million people migrated to Manchuria from Shandong and

  Hebei, and of them, approximately eight million remained there.1 After 1942

  the number of Chinese mi grants declined as the economy slowed down in

  the chaos of the war.

  About two- thirds of the Chinese mi grants to Manchuria from 1905 to

  1942 were seasonal workers, mostly young men who performed physical

  labor. In the early years, they worked in agriculture and construction, but

  later, as industry developed, they worked in factories and mines. The sea-

  sonal workers came from spring through fall and then they returned to their

  homes during the winter months when much of Manchuria was very cold.

  During the period Manchuria was under Japa nese control, on average more

  than 500,000 mi grants arrived in Manchuria each year. Most of them went

  to Manchuria only once and then returned home with earnings for their

  families. The mi grant workers, unlike the young intellectuals, generally did

  not take part in po liti cal activities.

  From 1905 until 1931 when the Japa nese made Manchuria a puppet state,

  the two major centers of Japa nese authority in Manchuria were the South

  . 189 .

  china and japan

  Manchurian Railway Com pany (Mantetsu) and the Kwantung Army of the

  Imperial Japa nese Army. After 1931, although the highest Japa nese official

  in Manchuria was the governor- general, in fact Mantetsu and its manage-

  ment retained considerable in de pen dence and had a far larger staff than the

  governor- general had.

  Mantetsu (The South Manchurian Railway)

  Beginning in 1905, the South Manchurian Railway Com pany became the

  administrative headquarters for the Japa nese in Manchuria. As a model for

  how to manage Japan’s role in Manchuria, some Japa nese researchers were

  assigned to study how the Dutch East India Com pany conducted its busi-

  ness while representing Dutch broad national interests. As Mantetsu be-

  came a quasi- government institution, Japa nese industrial, financial, and

  agricultural ministries assigned officials to serve under Mantetsu’s leader-

  ship in Manchuria. Within Japan, Manchurian development was consid-

  ered of sufficient importance that not only the ministries but the very

  highest levels of the po liti cal leadership were involved in development plan-

  ning that went far beyond the operation of the railway.

  The importance of Mantetsu’s broader mission was reflected in the

  November 1906 transfer of Goto Shimpei from Taiwan to become the head

  of Mantetsu. Although officially Goto was only administering the railway

  and the land along the railway, in fact he had a mandate to strengthen

  Japan’s overall interests in Manchuria. For this task, he drew on his broad

  experience as head of all civilian work in Taiwan.

  Despite his wide- ranging mandate, Goto realized that Mantetsu was at

  its core a business, responsible for running a railway efficiently and profit-

  ably. Railways were then at the cutting edge of modern infrastructure around

  the world. Mantetsu purchased the world’s best railway cars from the United

  States and quickly developed a reputation for providing high- class ser vice

  for passengers, on- time arrivals, and reliable transport for freight traffic. The

  Japa nese also quickly began double- tracking railways that originally had

  been single track and building wider- gauge tracks. The telephone and tele-

  graph, which the Japa nese were already using during the Russo- Japanese

  War, were linked with the transportation and communications advances

  built up around the railway.

  . 190 .

  The Colonization of Taiwan and Manchuria, 1895–1945

  After the damage from the Russo- Japanese War, considerable funds

  were required for reconstruction in Manchuria, but the Japa nese govern-

  ment had exhausted its financial reserves during the war. To supplement

  the funding from the Japa nese government, Mantetsu raised money from

  the financial community in London. As a business operation, the railway

  quickly became financially in de pen dent, and within years it was bringing

  in a large profit. During its early years, its major source of income was the

  transport of soybeans and soybean products that were being exported from

  the ports on the Liaodong Peninsula to Japan and Eu rope. In transporting

  soybeans, Mantetsu was competing with Chinese companies that used

  trucks and horse- drawn carts that could transport soybeans at a lower cost

  than Mantetsu.

  Goto Shimpei was well known for his commitment to science and for

  the research he had or ga nized in Taiwan to study local social customs. By

  April 1907, shortly after his arrival, he established Mantetsu’s Research De-

  partment (Chosabu). The Research Department provided information

  and analy sis to guide the operation of the railway and overall Japa nese poli-

  cies for the po liti cal, economic, and social development of Manchuria. It

  also became the center for Japa nese government research on the economy,

  politics, and society of North China. Even the Kwantung Army drew on

  research conducted by Mantetsu’s Research Department, which grew to be

  one of the largest research centers anywhere in the world. At its height in

  the early 1940s, the Research Department had more than 2,300 researchers.

  Its scale and scope reflected the Japa nese belief in the importance of knowl-

  edge and in the role of enlightenment in guiding national policy. At the

  time, no research institution anywhere in China conducted work of such

  breadth and depth. As a result, the Mantetsu Research Department had a

  far deeper knowledge of Manchuria than the Chinese government did.

  Goto was willing to work with the Kwantung Army, but he considered

  establishing rules and laws to be central to the development of an adminis-

  trative infrastructure in China. He selected Okamatsu Santaro, a professor

  of Chinese law at Kyoto Imperial University, as the first head of the Re-

  search Department. Although Goto sent Okamatsu to Eu rope to study the

  role of the Western powers’ colonial research centers, he hoped to surpass

  what those research centers were doing with re spect to their colonies.

  Okamatsu and his staff believed that rules for Manchuria should grow out of

  . 191 .

  china and japan

  existing law. While Americans guiding the development of local laws might

  have used American laws as a framework for teaching local people around

  the world, the Japa nese realized that in some cases Western laws did not fit

  Asian traditions, and therefore they were more willing to create laws that

  accorded with local customs. A central task for Okamatsu after arriving in

  Manchuria was to or ga nize research on Manchurian law and then to adopt

 
appropriate policies that would prove effective.

  Goto recruited young gradu ates from Japan’s best universities to join the

  staff of the Mantetsu Research Department. Since they had been trained

  in Japan in an intellectual atmosphere that focused on how to promote de-

  velopment and modernization, they knew how to conduct research that

  would help the administrators in Manchuria build a modern economy, so-

  ciety, and governance structure. Like the faculty under whom they had

  studied in Japan, many came from modest social backgrounds, had risen

  because of their academic rec ords, and held liberal or even leftist views.

  Just as he had in Taiwan, Goto Shimpei attached a high priority to ed-

  ucation in Manchuria. Teacher-training programs were established, and

  the number of elementary schools rapidly increased. In addition to Japa nese

  language, the subjects taught included basic mathe matics and science. In

  the better schools in towns and cities, where some Chinese students were

  admitted along with the more privileged Japa nese students, the schools had

  some teachers from Japan and some Chinese teachers who had studied in

  Japan. Most of the educated Chinese in Manchuria who were of school age

  between 1931 and 1945 learned Japa nese language.

  In the 1930s nearly three- fourths of the employees of Mantetsu were

  Chinese. Although many did not hold positions as high as those of Japa-

  nese employees of comparable ability and length of ser vice, they did have

  better working conditions and received more stable salaries than most

  people in Manchuria. Other Chinese workers in Manchuria served as

  house hold servants for Japa nese families or operated small retail establish-

  ments that catered to Japa nese customers. Some were upset that they were

  treated poorly by the Japa nese for whom they worked, but others appreci-

  ated the higher wages they received from Japa nese employers. For higher

  positions in Mantetsu and for teachers, the Japa nese drew from the small

  group of Chinese who had studied in Japan and then had returned to Man-

  churia. In addition to working for the South Manchurian Railway and for

  . 192 .

  The Colonization of Taiwan and Manchuria, 1895–1945

  the government, those educated in Japan could also teach Japa nese lan-

  guage in schools.

  Goto left Manchuria in 1908 to become minister of communications and

 

‹ Prev