by Mason Lee
“I’m going to cum!” Jacob yelled before cumming in his ass. Dylan squeezed his hole tight around the cock, squeezing all of the cum into his ass that he could. The bedroom door opened as they finished and a woman screamed at the sight that she saw.
“Jakey, are you fucking someone?” Lucy squealed. She threw herself onto the bed as if she owned it. She felt around to see if she could catch the other man in her friends bed. “If the lights were on, I would see you naked anyways. Who are you?”
“Your boyfriend.” Dylan answered. The room spun around him, he knew that something was going to happen. Lucy’s breath was short, he couldn’t tell if she was mad or if she was turned on. “I came over because you went out with Gail. One thing lead to another and we ended up having sex.”
“I bet it did. Isn’t that how it always happens with you? The first time you had sex with a man, you were watching sports and then the man just happened to ask you to his room and then shoved his cock in your face.” Lucy was pacing around the room, her silhouette cast on the wall. “Then the guy at the porn theatre that just happened to want your cock and it slipped out of your pants and into his mouth. I always just accepted it and thought hey if it makes him happy. The truth is that it doesn’t bother me that you want to have sex with men. You have always told me about it, what bothers me is that tonight you were too sick to fuck me but you can have sex with my friend, my best friend.”
“Listen I really don’t want to be a part of this drama. I have no part in it, other than fucking your boyfriend, which was really hot by the way.” Jacob tried to get up but Lucy stood in his way and pushed him back onto the bed. “What is your problem? You are the one who wanted me to fuck him so bad, you asked for all of this to happen. If you didn’t need to press him to find out if he was gay, you would still have him all to yourself.”
“I had to know. And you certainly didn’t complain the night that you got to have both of us in bed. You were bragging about it to everyone, how you nailed yet another straight man. I mean my God, did you ever think about telling them how you’re cock was in me too? No, you just kept saying that you fucked my boyfriend. Like you thought you were going to steal him away from me! Well you can have him, I am done with him. I am done with all of the secrets and lies.”
“Lucy, I don’t want to break up. I want to stay with you but I don’t always want to have to tell you about my conquests, I need to hook up with guys and not always have to tell you. We just need to work things out,” Dylan reached out to touch her but she pulled away, he knew that she was about to lower the boom or something. “We have always been able to work out our problems, we can do it again. Compromise is always the key, remember?”
“You crossed a line this time, you both did! If you guys wanted to hook up or whatever it is that you are doing then all you had to do was say something. I wouldn’t have cared much. I thought you both loved me and would never do anything to hurt me but I was wrong, clearly I was wrong. If you want to be together so badly, why don’t you just be together. You can just move in together because as of now, I am kicking Dylan out of my house.”
“Lucy, think rationally. You can’t kick me out of the house, seeing as I own it. That is my house and I am not moving out, if you want to break up or anything then you can move out.” Dylan felt the anger inside of him boiling over. “You’ve been screwing around with half the town, men, women, whoever and I haven’t said anything. In fact I haven’t asked for any of the details of what you are doing and yet you are so pissed at me for needing to take a nap before telling you about anything that happened.”
“You know what you’re right. I have been out getting laid whenever and wherever I can because you haven’t been home to take care of me. If you aren’t trolling the bars or random parks for men, work is sending off to another part of the country. And what do you do on these trips? Find men and fuck them. I’ve been tested so many times in the last few months that the next time I go in, it’s free.” Lucy stormed out of the room, leaving the men alone. Neither moved, neither said anything.
“So that was interesting.” Jacob finally broke the silence. Dylan chuckled slightly and wondered what he would be walking into when he went home. "You know that she'll get over this in no time right? She's just upset right now with everything going on."
"I know, but a break up might not be such a bad thing. I mean maybe we do need some time apart to figure out if we really want to be together. I mean think about it, neither of us are being faithful to one another and there is no jealousy on either side. There is something wrong with that, if there was love or anything there, one of us would be jealous.” Dylan stood up and walked the length of the room. He covered his face with his hand, and wondered where the words were coming from. “Have you ever been in a situation like this before? Where everything seemed to be out of your control, and frankly a break up wasn’t such a bad idea?”
“Of course I have. All I can tell you about that is, distance and time apart do not help the relationship. If you want it to work out, if you want it to last, then you need to make it happen now. Don’t wait until it’s too late, do something now to fix the relationship. Of course if you want it to end, then she just gave you the perfect out. No one will question you or blame you about what happened.” Jacob stood up and grabbed him by the shoulders. The moonlight hit the room in a way that lit everything . It reflected in Jacob’s eyes, turning Dylan’s anger into lust.
“No one can tell you guys what to do but it might best if you actually talk to one another. Find out what each of you wants and how far you are willing to go to get it. Worst case scenario, you guys do break up and you are free to explore your sexuality guilt and girlfriend free.”
“That’s what I’m afraid of though. What if Lucy is the best thing that ever happened to me and I lose her because of a phase, a small time frame where I enjoy fucking men. Then I will live the rest of my life knowing that I had a great girl but gave it up for a few good orgasms.”
“Trust me, if this was a phase you wouldn’t like getting cock up your ass like you do. Bisexual men always try to convince themselves that enjoying sex with men, being attracted to men, is just a phase that they will grow out of. It’s not. Trust me, gay men tell themselves the same thing, the only difference is that we know the truth and accept it.”
The men looked at one another, the truth hanging between them like the sliver of moonlight that was peaking out from behind the clouds. Dylan took in a deep breath and realized for that he had just been called bisexual and it didn't upset him. In fact the label seemed to give him a place, a purpose, an identity.
As if on cue, the lights came back on. Both men looked at each other and realized for the first time since Lucy had burst into the room that they were still naked. Jacob chuckled at the sight, and gently reached out to Dylan.
“This seems oddly appropriate doesn’t it? Both of us being naked, vulnerable. The truth is, if you and Lucy don’t stay together, I wouldn’t mind giving it a try with you. I wouldn’t mind waking up next to you every day and going to sleep next to you every night. What I’m trying to say is, that I wouldn’t mind being in a relationship with you. I wouldn’t mind being in love with you.”
Dylan found Lucy sitting on the porch, watching the pool. Her hair was wet and she had a towel wrapped around her shoulders, she had just been swimming. He knew that she hadn’t gone far after her outburst. Part of him hoped that she hadn’t heard what Jacob had said to him and part of him hoped that she did. He touched her shoulder gently and she turned around. “What do you want? I’ve said all I have to say to you.”
“Well then just listen to me. I haven’t had a chance to tell you everything that I want to tell you. In fact I wasn’t allowed to say anything to you in there. I still don’t understand why you freaked out about me having sex with Jacob. It’s not like we haven’t done it before, hell I’ve had sex with quite a few men and that’s never bothered you before.” Dylan took a seat next to her.
She scoo
ted away from him. “What is the problem? I wasn’t feeling well when you got home earlier, when I got up and you were gone I figured I would come hang out with Jacob.”
“Doesn’t that sound weird to you? The two of you had never really hung out together, at least not for an extended period of time alone, and then suddenly you want to hang out with him. You knew that when you came over here, you would end up in his bed. Which would have been fine, if only you had told me the truth. if you had only sent me a text that said what you were going to do.”
Lucy stood up and walked away from him. “I don’t have a problem with you exploring sex with men. In fact I was the one who encouraged it but when you start to lie to me, when you start to ignore my needs, then we have a problem. Especially when you exchange numbers with the trick and he texts you right away.”
“What? Did you go through my phone?” Dylan pulled out his cell phone and opened up the messages folder. Third message down was one from Ron about their encounter and how he wanted to get together again. “Who or what gave you the right to go through my phone? I was sleeping and hadn’t had a chance to tell you what happened yet. You never even gave me a chance to explain what was going on or what had happened on this trip. You seen one message and decided that I was going to lie to you, keep a secret from you.”
“You always go to sleep or don’t feel good when you don’t want to tell me something. When you slept with that first guy, you had a headache until you talked to Jake about it. Then we all fucked and you couldn’t wait to tell me. With the football coach, you waited until after you talked to everyone else and told me that your allergies were going crazy. When you wanted head, you told me the full story as I sucked your dick.”
Lucy walked back to the porch and sat on the step. She looked up at him, her eyes full of accusations and hurt. “Maybe I shouldn’t have jumped to conclusions or gone through your phone. But given your track record lately, given the fact that I don’t seem to know anything about you anymore, I had to decide what to do for myself. The fact that you gave this trick your number means that you want to see him again. While the rule was never said, I always assumed that you knew it was one and done. You don’t fuck the same person twice, unless you want something more from them.”
“I do want something more from him. I want to fuck him in the ass. I want to know what it is like to put my dick in a guy’s ass and just fuck him. Maybe it’s wrong, maybe it seems weird to you but it’s something that I want, no it’s something that I need to do.”
For a few minutes they listened to the waves that the pool was making, and the chirps that came from the crickets. The light was still on in Jacob’s bedroom but there was no movement. “If you want to break up, then that is on you. I want to work things out, I want to be with you but I need my space. I need time to figure out what is going on with me. I thought you of all people would understand that.”
“I’m all for you figuring out what you like and what you don’t like. I don’t care if you sleep with a hundred men, we can have an open relationship. What I do care about is you respecting me, respecting the guidelines that we both agreed to. When you can’t do that; that tells me that you don’t care about our relationship. That you don’t care about me.”
Lucy grabbed the towel that had fallen onto porch and wrapped it around her again. “I don’t know what it is you want from me anymore. It’s like I’m the cum dump that you fuck when you can’t find a guy to do it. The problems we were having before we went to the porn theatre are resurfacing but in a different way this time.”
“You always try to control me, everything. It’s about time you stopped that. Yes I agreed to the rules that you set forth but what choice did I have? You made it seem as if there would be no further discussion. It was as if I didn’t have a say in my own life.”
He tried to sit next to her but she moved away from him. “I have no problem sharing my experiences with you but sometimes i don’t want to talk about them. Sometimes I just want to think about them, contemplate them and not talk about them with you. Or turn them into one of your sexual games, where you feel the need to one up the man I was with.”
“Well there is no way for me to one up Jacob is there? If you want to stay with me, if you want this relationship to work out, you can’t have se with Jacob ever again. Tonight was the last time you guys get to enjoy each other’s bodies.”
“I don’t agree to that. I think it’s silly for you to be this jealous over him.” Lucy threw the towel to the ground and stood up. She walked away without glancing back at him until he yelled after her. “Where are you going?”
“I don’t know. I don’t care.”
“What does this mean for our relationship?”
“I don’t know. “She opened her car door, slammed it shut and sped away.
Dylan slumped against the patio table and wondered to himself where everything had gone so wrong. In less than an hour he had gone from being on top of the world to being in the depths of hell. The thought of losing Lucy was more than his heart could bear, but the thought of never being able to be with Jacob again was just as bad.
“You ok?” Jacob asked as he sat down next to him. “I heard her car peel away but wasn’t sure if you were with her or not.”
“No, I wasn’t. She left angry.”
“About what?”
“You. I refused to say that I would never have sex with you again. I couldn’t bring myself to agree to that rule and she got mad.”
Jacob leaned over and kissed him. Dylan allowed him to push his tongue into his mouth. He felt his cock stiffening and reached over to Jacobs and found that he was still naked. Soon his shorts were taken off of his body and tossed to the side. Jacob kissed his nipples, using an ample amount of tongue of them, causing Dylan’s body to warm with desire.
He wrapped his legs around Jacob who teased the hole with the head of his cock. Dylan whimpered every time that Jacob moved his cock away from his hole, until he finally pushed it into his tightness. Jacob moved slowly, allowing his stroke of his cock to push Dylan closer and closer to orgasm. Slow and steady, in and out, Dylan never wanted Jacob to cum, he wanted to keep his cock inside of him.
With both nipples erect, Jacob kept his mouth busy on one or the other. his tongue moved around them as if they were mazes and it needed to escape. After a few short minutes, Jacob released another orgasm. He kept pumping inside of Dylan until he did too.
After the finished, they took a shower together and Jacob washed his lover's body. Dylan luxuriated in having someone take care of him but there was a thought that kept nagging him. What would his life be like without Lucy in it?
After their shared shower, the men climbed into bed together. Jacob brought Dylan close to him, wrapping his arms securely around him. As the darkness of the room lulled him into sleep, Dylan wondered again how different things would be if he and Lucy were broken up. Would he end up in a relationship with Jacob?
He had known Jacob for just a few short years but in that time had never seen him in a relationship. There had been plenty of flings, but no man had ever last more than a few weeks with him. Jacob seemed to sense that he was thinking about him “What are you thinking about? Lucy?”
“Lucy. You. Relationships and why they can’t be easy.”
“You always want what you can’t have.” Jacob kissed the top of his head and snuggled closer.
Even though Dylan didn’t think that his bed partner was talking about him, he let the words sink in. They were so true, especially for him. He did want what he couldn’t have, another romp with The Man. he had wanted to find a room and fuck Ron. He wanted to have both Lucy and Jacob.
After a few minutes sleep took over and he found bliss in his dreams. Reality would wait.
To be continued…
Other Books by Mason Lee
Bi Guy: Vol. 1
Male Seeking Male (A Gay Erotica Short)
Tall Cup of Joe
My Gay First Time (An Erotika Short)
&n
bsp; A Secret Night (My Crossdressing Gay Surprise)
A BDSM Collection: Vol. 1
Holiday Delight (A Romance Short)