The Ghost of Galileo

Home > Other > The Ghost of Galileo > Page 47
The Ghost of Galileo Page 47

by J. L. Heilbron


  103. Martin, Catalogus (1639).

  104. A. Huguetan, editorial comment, in Galileo, Systema (1641), fo. *3.

  105. Grove, Apollo, 123 (May 1986), 304.

  106. Evelyn, Sculptura (1662), 111–12; Williamson, Miniatures (1898), 35; Watson, Burlington Magazine, 85 (1944), 226–7.

  107. e.g., Rubens, Sara Breyll and Rogier Clarisse, and Van Dyck, A Lady (all at the Palace of the Legion of Honor, San Francisco), and Van Dyck, Agostino Pallavicini (Getty Center, Los Angeles).

  108. Alberti, On Painting (1966), 77; Lomazzo, Tracte (1598), 2.2, 2.5–2.7, 2.9, trans. Haydock, 10, 12–20, 21 (quote), 25; Blunt, Artistic Theory (1940), 140–59.

  109. Haydock, editorial comment, in Lomazzo, Tracte (1598), ¶iiiv.

  110. Junius, Painting (1638), 172–3, 341, 353.

  111. Wotton, Elements (1624), 61, 84–7.

  112. Piles, Art (1706), 31.

  113. Lievens, Prince Charles Louis of the Palatinate with his Tutor Wolrad von Plessen (Getty Center).

  114. Dou’s portrait, Prince Rupert of the Palatinate and his Tutor in Historical Dress (c.1631), is also at the Getty Center.

  115. Quoted by Pace, SC 2 (1987), 179 (Junius’ Painting, 1638), and Word and Image, 2/1 (1986), 4 (Cowley’s The Mistress, 1647).

  Chapter 9

  1. Foster, Register (1889), 192–3; Cowper, Prospect (1985), 24, 30; Headlam, Inns (1909), 153–7; Hill, Bench (1988), 101. Francis Bacon and his brothers offer a parallel case of early admission and retention of the father’s rooms at the Inn; Jardine and Stewart, Hostage (1999), 69–71.

  2. “Mr John Bankes’s observations on his travels,” Kingston Lacy, Dorset.

  3. Howell, Instructions (1869), 41–2; Raymond, Itinerary (1648), A11v–A12; Moshenska, Stain (2016), 62.

  4. Raymond, Itinerary (1648), fo. A9r, and Howell, Instructions (1869), 42, 63–5, resp.; Bacon, “Of Travel,” in “Essays,” in Philosophical Works (1905), 756–7 (n.d.), 74; Duppa (to whom Bankes applied in quest of Isham) to Isham, 20 January 1652, in Isham, Correspondence (1955), 52. “Affectation … is a general fault amongst English Travellers, which is both displeasing and ridiculous.” Earl of Essex to his cousin, 4 January 1596, in Fisher, Instructions (1633), 48–9, 55 (quote), 59–60.

  5. Thomson, Tapestry (1973), 294–7; Hefford, in Murdoch (ed.), Boughton House (1992), 101, 104; Wyld, in Moore, Paston Treasure (2018), 386–7.

  6. Richard Symmonds recorded the content of Cleyn’s studio in 1652; Baker, Lely (1912), ii. 183; Millar, Inventories (1972), p. xx, and Doort’s catalogue (1960), 171.

  7. Walpole, Works (1798), iii. 252; Long, Miniaturists (1929), 72–3; Brown, Catalogue (1982), 61–2, figs 107–13.

  8. The items, unfortunately not identified, survive in the founding collection of Oxford’s Ashmolean Museum; Tradescant, Musaeum (1656), fos N2–N4, and p. 40 (quote).

  9. Venner, Via (1638), 13; Aikin, Biographical Memoirs (1780), 281.

  10. Venner, Via (1638), 10–11, 23–5.

  11. Aubrey, Lives (2018), i. 210–11 (story from Hobbes); Jardine and Stewart, Hostage (1999), 502–4.

  12. Jardine and Stewart, Hostage (1999), 505–11.

  13. BL, Sloane MS 113, 110v, 114v, 117.

  14. BL, Sloane MS 113, fos 120, 121r.

  15. Venner, Via (1638), 32–3, 93, 132–4.

  16. Virgil describes the technique in the Fourth Georgic; cf. Wallace, Renaissance Quarterly, 56 (2003), 377–82; Ovid, Metamorphoses, trans. Sandys (1632), 676. Sampson managed the same trick with a lion, with disastrous consequences; Judges 14:5–9.

  17. Dee, Preface (1570), fos iiir–iiiiv.

  18. Nardi, Lactis physica analysis (1634); De Vesme, Della Bella: Text (1971), 141, and Plates, 191; Ciancio, Galilaeana, 15 (2018), 85–7.

  19. Corbett and Lightbrown, Frontispiece (1979), 6–9, 45.

  20. How much of the posthumous Eikon, Charles wrote is disputed. Several versions of the frontispiece exist; Madan, New Bibliography (1950), 126–33, 175–87; Knachel, in Charles I, Eikon (1966), pp. xxi-xxxii. The Latin tags read: “I look at the blessed and eternal [things] of heaven,” “I kick the showy and heavy [things] of the world,” “I practice the hard and light [way] of Christ,” “unmoved victorious,” “valor increases when opposed.”

  21. “Aspice vultus, ecce meos;” Quarles, Fons lachrymarum (1648).

  22. Burnett, Title Page (1998), 8, 20–3; Daniel 12:4.

  23. Bacon, Advancement, ed. Wats (1640); Rosenthal, JWCI 34 (1971), 206–15.

  24. Wither, Collection [1635], “A Proposition to this Frontispiece.”

  25. For the pictures Cleyn is about to describe, see Royal Academy of Arts, In the Age of Giorgione (2016), 27–8, 110–13.

  26. Williams thus anticipated Meller, in Palluchini (ed.), Giorgione (1981), i. 228, 241–6, Wischnitzer-Bernstein, Gazette des beaux arts, 27 (1945), 198, 205–7, 210, and Cohen, Gazette des beaux arts, 126 (1995), 54–61.

  27. Philipp Lansbergen, Tabulae motuum coelestium (1632); for other examples John Bankes may have known, Metze, Entwicklung (2004), 97–108; Gattei, in Albrecht et al. (eds), Tintenfass (2014), 341–2, 350; Remmert, Widmung (2005), 156–78.

  28. SL ii. 486.

  29. Tonini, in Pin (ed.), Ripensando (2006), 715–20; Kainulainen, Sarpi (2014), 18; Gattei, in Beretta et al. (eds), Relics (2016), 68–9, 79–84, 89–90.

  30. Milton, Areopagitica (1644), in Major Works (2003), 258–9; cf. Shea, Galilaeana, 13 (2016), 7, 11, 15–16, 20–2.

  31. Culverwell, Discourse (1652), pt 1, “Introduction,” and pp. 155, 157, 159–60 (quote). Cf. Giudice, in Bucciantini et al. (eds), Caso (2011), 285.

  32. Culverwell, “Spiritual Optics,” in Culverwell, Discourse (1652), pt 2, p. 195; Duppa to Isham, 10 September 1650, in Isham, Correspondence (1955), 17–18: “If I have not answered your expectations [for advice about behavior] in this return, condemn me not for it, for without Galilaeo’s glasses I cannot see spots on the moon.”

  33. Duppa to Isham, 22 July 1651, in Conway, Letters (1992), 34: “for the Earth a heavy dull grosse body to move and the heaven and Starres who are light to stand still is as if a Prince should upon a festivall day appoint all the old and fat men and women to dance and all the younger men and women of sixteen and twenty to sit still.”

  34. John had the quote down pat; Wilkins, Discourse (1640), fo. aa6r; Wilkins says much the same in his opening to New World (1640), 1–2.

  35. Barclay, Mirrour (1631), i. 117–18.

  36. Sharpe, Image Wars (2010), 193, quoting Van der Doort.

  37. Cleyn may have remembered this from Charles I, Eikon [1649], ed. Knachel (1966), 27.

  38. Quarles, Fons lachrymarum (1648), 10–11.

  39. Cf. Battistini, Annali d’italianistica, 10 (1992), 117–18, 125–6, 129–30.

  40. Wotton to Earl of Salisbury, 13 March 1610, in SL i. 486–7: “the strangest piece of news … ever yet received from any part of the world.”

  41. Cf. Jaclobeanu, in Neuber and Zittel (eds), Copernicus (2015), 67–70, 79–80.

  42. Hobbes, De cive (1647), fo. *4v; Rothman, Pursuit (2017), 216–21; Virgil, Georgics, 2.490, “happy was he who could know the causes of things.”

  43. Wotton, Elements (1624), 100.

  44. Wotton, Elements (1624), 90, 95.

  45. Hart, Jones (2011), 139–42; Wotton, Elements (1624), 51, 85–6.

  46. Wotton to Wentworth, 8 April 1628, in SL ii. 306–7.

  47. SL ii. 347; Wotton, Elements (1624), 47, 109, 113.

  48. Galileo, Dialogue (1953), 103.

  49. Gadbury, Coelestis legatus (1656), fo. A2r (quote), 12–15, 26, 41 (quote).

  50. Galileo, Sidereus nuncius [1610], trans. van Helden (1989), 29.

  Postscripts

  1. De Vergette, in Bucciantini et al. (eds), Caso (2011), 438–40, 443, 450, 454 (quote).

  2. Daedalus, 197/4 (2018), title page.

  3. Guillaume Libri, Histoire des sciences mathématiques en Italie (1838), quoted in Bucciantini, in Bucciantini
et al. (eds), Caso (2011), 356.

  4. Sergi, Nuova antologia, 35 (1900), 212.

  5. Sergi, Nuova antologia, 35 (1900), 217–20.

  6. Redondi, Nuncius, 9/1 (1994), 96–100, 108–9 (quote), 111–13. The play: François Ponsard, Galilée (1867).

  7. Ferrone, in Bucciantini et al. (eds), Caso (2011), 336; Torrini, Galilaeana, 7 (2010), 63–4, 67–70; Cavagnini, Galilaeana, 13 (2016), 111–12.

  8. Tognoni, “Naturamque” (2013), 41, 53, plate 7.

  9. Tognoni, in Coppini and Tosi (eds), Sapienza (2004), 168.

  10. Tognoni, Galilaeana, 1 (2004), 216, 218, 221–2, 226, quoting mainly the address of the rector; Micheli, in Galluzzi, Micheli, et al., Galileo (1988), 180, on the Te Deum and placards.

  11. Tognoni, in Coppini and Tosi (eds), Sapienza (2004), 171–8.

  12. Cavagnini, Galilaeana, 13 (2016), 115–20, 129–30.

  13. Pisa Today, 8 February 2020, “Cronaca.”

  14. Melloni, in Bucciantini et al. (eds), Caso (2011), 463, 468–72, 476.

  15. Melloni, in Bucciantini et al. (eds), Caso (2011), 475–8, 482.

  16. HG 363–5.

  17. Catholic News Agency, 6 May 2008, TimesOnline News, 3 April 2008, and Scotsman, 29 January 2008.

  18. Comunicato stampa, 186, 28 April 2010, (accessed 30 April 2010).

  19. Quoted by Redondi, Nuncius, 9/1 (1994), 73–4.

  20. Savorelli, Galilaeana, 7 (2010), 32, 37–8.

  21. Remmert, Science in Context, 14 (2001), 343, 346–54.

  22. Schirrmacher, Legends (2001), 8–30, following Custance, Science and Faith (1978), 152–6.

  23. Davis and Chmielowski, Brill’s Series in Church History, 30 (2008), 461–2.

  24. Tognoni, Galileo (2014), 56 (quote), 126, 128, 148–59.

  Works Cited

  This list does not include standard reference sources like the Dictionary of National Biography (DNB), which are cited in the notes only when quoted directly or for other special reason. Also items that exist in many editions, such as the Bible and the plays of Jonson and Shakespeare, are usually not cited to any particular one, but given by chapter and verse, or act and scene. Other items not listed are books mentioned in the text but not cited in the notes; sporadic comments (as opposed to introductions) by editors; and brief descriptions of artworks in catalogues. In the last two cases, the authors of the comments and descriptions are credited in the notes.

  Manuscripts

  Bodleian Library, Oxford

  Add. MS A380

  Add. MSS 14923 = MS Rawlinson Letters 41

  Sir John Bankes Papers (cited as BPB)

  British Library, London

  Add. MSS 11309, 46925, 70499–70503 (Cavendish papers)

  Harley MSS 6320 (Joseph Webbe’s translation of Galileo’s Dialogo), 6796

  Sloane MS 70 (Maurice Williams, “A survey of the motion of bodies”)

  Sloane MS 95 (Williams, [Lectures on anatomy])

  Sloane MS 113 (Williams, “Prolongation of life” and “Use…of cold drinke”)

  Sloane MSS 682, 2052, 2681

  Dorset History Centre, Dorchester

  The Bankes Papers (cited as D-BKL)

  Getty Research Center, Los Angeles

  Heinrich Geissler Collection

  Huntington Library, San Marino, California

  Hastings Papers

  Kingston Lacy, Dorset

  John Bankes, Jr, diary and other papers

  Oriel College, Oxford

  Buttery Books

  Statens Museum for Kunst, Copenhagen

  TP 503 (Cleyn material)

  Printed Material

  Abell, E. T. “A Note on Jasper Mayne,” Reports and Transactions of the Devonshire Asssociation, 57 (1925), 257–65.

  Acheson, Catherine, “The Picture of Nature: Seventeenth-Century English Aesop’s Fables,” Journal for Early Modern Cultural Studies, 9/2 (2009), 25–50.

  Adams, Robyn, and Rosanna Cox (eds), Diplomacy and Early Modern Culture (Basingstoke: Palgrave, 2011).

  Adamson, John S. A., “Chivalry and Political Culture in Caroline England,” in Sharpe and Lake (eds), Culture (1993), 161–97.

  Adamson, John S. A., The Noble Revolt: The Overthrow of Charles I (London: Phoenix, 2007).

  Adlington, Hugh, “Gospel, Law, and ars praedicandi at the Inns of Court, c.1570–c.1640,” in Archer (ed.), Worlds (2011), 51–74.

  Aikin, John, Biographical Memoirs of Medicine in Great Britain (London: J. Johnson, 1780).

  Akrigg, G. P. V., Jacobean Pageant: The Court of King James I (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1962).

  Alberti, Leon Battista, On Painting, trans. John R. Spencer (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 1966).

  Albion, Gordon, Charles I and the Court of Rome: A Study in 17th Century Diplomacy (London: Burns, Oates & Washbourne, 1935).

  Albrecht, Andrea, et al. (eds), Tintenfass und Teleskop: Galileo Galilei im Schnittpunkt wissenschaftlicher, litterarischer und visueller Kulturen im 17. Jahrhundert (Berlin: De Gruyter, 2014).

  Alexander, Michael van Cleve, Charles I’s Lord Treasurer, Sir Richard Weston, Earl of Portland (Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press, 1975).

  Allacci, Leone, Apes urbanae (Rome: L. Grignanus, 1633).

  Allan, David, “‘An Ancient Sage Philosopher’: Alexander Ross and the Defense of Philosophy,” SC 16/1 (2001), 68–94.

  Allsopp, Bruce (ed.), Inigo Jones on Palladio, 2 vols (Newcastle on Tyne: Oriel Press, 1970).

  Anderson, Christine Marie, “Art Dealing and Collecting in Venice: The Multifaceted Career of Daniel Nys (1572–1647),” D.Phil. thesis, Oxford, 2010.

  Anderson, Christy, Inigo Jones and the Classical Tradition (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2007).

  Anderson, Christy, “The Learned Art of Architecture: Henry Wotton’s Elements of Architecture,” in Howard and McBurney (eds), Image (2014), 124–35.

  Anderson, John Eustace, A History of the Parish of Mortlake (London: T. Laurie, 1886).

  Anderson, John Eustace, A Short Account of the Tapestry Works, Mortlake (Richmond: R. W. Simpson, 1894).

  Andersson, Daniel C., Lord Henry Howard (1540–1614): An Elizabethan Life (Cambridge: Brewer, 2009).

  Andrewes, Lancelot, XCVI. Sermons…Published by His Majesties Special Command, ed. John Buckeridge and William Laud (London: R. Badger, 1631).

  Andrewes, Lancelot, The Morall Law Expounded (London: A. Cooke for M. Sparke et al., 1642).

  Andrewes, Lancelot, Selected Sermons and Lectures, ed. Peter E. McCullough (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005).

  Andrews, Thomas, His Majesties Resolution Concerning the Setting up of his Standard…Also Sir John Bankes his Perswasion, for His Majesties Return to London, His Majesties Consent at the First, but Afterwards His Refusal (London: I. Thompson and A. Coe, 1642).

  Anon., The King of Denmarkes Welcome: Containing his Arivall, Abode, and Entertainement, both in the Citie and Other Places (London: E. Allde, 1606).

  Anon., Justa funebria Ptolemaei oxoniensis Thomas Bodleii equitis aurati celebrata…1613 (Oxford: J. Barnes, 1613).

  Anon., The Mountebank’s Mask ([1618]; Cambridge: Chadwyck-Healy, 1994).

  Anon., Learned: Tico Brahae his Astronomical Conjecture, of the New and Much Admired [Star] which Appered in the Year 1572 (London: B. Alsop, etc., 1632).

  Anon., The Entertainment of the High and Mighty Charles King of Great Britaine, France, and Ireland, into his Auncient and Royall City of Edinburgh (Edinburgh: J. Wreittoun, 1633).

  Anon., The Popes Nuntioes or, The Negotiation of Seignior Panzani, Seignior Con, &c. Resident here in England with the Queen (London: R. Bostock, 1643).

  Anon., A Brief Declaration of the Reason that Moved King James…to Erect a College of Divines, and Other Learned Men at Chelsea (London: E. P. for N. Bourne, 1645).

  Anon., A Refutation of a False and Impious Aspersion Cast on the Late Lord Cottingham by the Writer of the Popish Currant (London: s.n., 1681).r />
  Anon., “Some Althams of Mark Hall in the Seventeenth Century,” Essex Review, 17 (1908), 74–87.

  Anon., “The Magical Speculum of Dr Dee (British Museum),” Burlington Magazine, 110/778 (January 1968), 42–3.

  Anon., “Propositions extraites des Dialogues de Galilei entre quelques autres, où il se trouve quelques difficultés” [n.d.], in Mersenne, Correspondance (1945–88), v. 603–14.

  Anthony, Francis, Medicinae chymicae, et veri potabilis auri assertio (Cambridge: C. Legge, 1610).

  Appleby, John H., “Arthur Dee and Johannes Bánfi Hunyades,” Ambix, 24 (1977), 96–109.

  Appleby, John H., “Some of Arthur Dee’s Associations before Visiting Russia Clarified, Including Two Letters from Sir Theodore Mayerne,” Ambix, 26 (1979), 1–15.

  Appleby, John H., “Dr Arthur Dee, Merchant and Litigant,” Slavonic and East European Review, 57 (1979), 32–55.

  Archer, Elizabeth Jane (ed.), The Intellectual and Cultural Worlds of the Early Modern Inns of Court (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 2011).

  Aristotle, Complete Works, 2 vols (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1984).

  Arrowood, Charles Flinn, The Powers of the Crown in Scotland. Being a Translation…of George Buchanan’s “De jure regni apud scotos,” (Austin: University of Texas Press, 1949).

  Ash, Eric H., The Draining of the Fens (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 2017).

  Ashton, Robert, The City and the Court 1603–1643 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1979).

  Aston, Margaret, “Gods, Saints and Reformers: Portraiture and Protestant England,” in Gent (ed.), Classicism (1995), 181–220.

  Aubrey, John, Brief Lives, Chiefly of Contemporaries, ed. Andrew Clark, 2 vols (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1898).

  Aubrey, John, Brief Lives, with an Apparatus for the Lives of our English Mathematical Writers, ed. Kate Bennett, 2 vols (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2018).

  Avery, Charles (ed.), Studies in European Sculpture (London: Christie’s, 1981).

  Aylmer, G. E., The King’s Servants: The Civil Service of Charles I, 1625–1642 (New York: Columbia University Press, 1961).

 

‹ Prev