Finally, he thrust his hips upwards and penetrated me. I dug my nails into his shoulders and screamed out, feeling him stuff every inch of me. He was big. Bigger than I remembered. His smooth cock slid inside of me until his balls cradled my ass. I arched my back and held my breath before I started to ride him slowly, letting my ass bounce every time. His eyes were locked on my body as my tits bounced up and down with my every movement. Our bodies rocked together in perfect sync as our moans got louder and louder. My fingernails dug into his skin before he flipped us over and fucked me for all he was worth. Our hips slammed together as the bed shook, nearly collapsing with our lust. It wouldn’t stop creaking as he went harder and harder, his hands on my shoulders, pinning me down as he rammed into me faster and faster.
My toes curled and my eyes rolled into the back of my head. “Fuck! Leo!” I screamed out his name, my vision blurring before I finally climbed over the edge.
Chapter 6
I don’t even remember how I left the house after that. Had Leo fallen asleep? Had I tip-toed down the stairs in a walk of shame? Did I face his parents with that same embarrassed look I used to give them when I was in high school? I honestly don’t know. I just blocked it all out. Deleted it all from my memory the moment I rolled out of his bed.
All I do know is that once I got to the car, the guilt hit me like a wrecking ball. I felt dirty. Had I really just cheated on Jaimie – a man I loved? I sat there, my forehead on the steering wheel. I should have driven away right then and there, but I couldn’t. I felt like I was going to throw up. My stomach bubbled with bile and I had to do everything I could to hold back being sick. My fingers tightened on the steering wheel so hard that my knuckles turned white.
Eventually, I managed to start the car and drive away. Leo was just coming out of the house as I drove down the street, my vision blurry from the tears that threatened to escape. Why had I cheated on Jaimie? Why did I have to go and ruin a good thing? Especially with Leo? The man who left me without even saying goodbye. But as much as I wanted to hate him – I couldn’t. Deep down, I knew I loved him, just like I loved Jaimie. “Fuck me.” I slammed my hand down on the dashboard and the radio started.
It was another stupid love song. I tried to turn it off, but the radio wouldn’t obey. I growled. “What’s the point? I’m just going to break both their hearts…” I whispered to myself. “I fucked everything up… Dammit. Dammit. Dammit.”
***
I couldn’t bring myself to tell Jaimie for a couple of days. I avoided him as best I could. I went to the mall more often. I spent more time with Marsha. I did everything I could to avoid him until I knew I couldn’t postpone any longer.
I got back at the apartment after a day of idly walking through the mall. I took as long as possible to get up the stairs. I knew Jaimie was home. I could hear his voice from the open window, talking to Buster, asking him to sit and roll over. Jaimie always opened the windows when I wasn’t home. That’s why it was always so cold in the apartment. That and the broken thermostat.
I pulled my scarf tight around me like it could turn me invisible or something. Finally, I trudged up the stairs and opened the door. “Babe, is that you?”
I didn’t answer. I just shuffled into the kitchen, feeling like a zombie. I shrugged off my coat and placed it on the back of a chair. Lingering by the sink, I wonder if I wasn’t going to vomit my lunch after all.
“Babe?” He peeked his head into the kitchen. Still, I didn’t answer him. He came up behind me and wrapped his arms around my waist, pulling me close and nuzzling my neck affectionately. “Is something wrong?” He asked, feeling how tense my body was.
Slowly, I turned around. I refused to look him in the eye. If I did, I would never be able to tell him the truth. I played with his shirt, twisting the black material between my fingers. “I have to tell you something… but I don’t want to hurt you…” I could feel my voice crackling and if I didn’t tell him soon, my throat would close and I would never admit my mistake.
“What is it?” He asked, tilting my chin up so I would look at him. I focused on his sharp nose. His kissable lips. Anything but his eyes.
I gulped. “I…”
“Babe… just tell me.” He encouraged, squeezing my shoulders.
“I… I slept with Leo.” I spat it out as quick as I could, feeling like a monster the moment I said it. My fists were clutched around his shirt, keeping him close to me. I didn’t want him to leave, even though I knew I had just broken his heart. I closed my eyes, expecting him to explode, but all I heard was the silence settling around us. I didn’t open my eyes until I heard the soft padding of Buster’s footsteps in the kitchen, followed by him lapping some water from his bowl. Cautiously, I opened one eye and peeked at him. “Aren’t you going to say something? Aren’t you going to yell at me?” I asked, half-wanting him to. After all, I deserved it.
Jaimie sighed, running his fingers through his thick hair. “Leo already told me.” My eyes grew wide and I feared the worst. My heart started to pound in my chest so hard. What had Leo said? What was Jaimie going to say? Why did he look so calm in a situation like this? “He told me everything and I think we should all sit down and have a talk.”
“What do you mean?” I asked, confused.
“This is never going to work out unless all three of us sit down and talk to each other like civilized human beings.” He said, sounding mature. “I don’t want to do it. Trust me, I don’t.” He chuckled softly. “A part of me wishes that Leo was still overseas and I didn’t have to fight with him over my girlfriend. But he’s back and now we all have to face the facts.” I stared at him. I couldn’t believe what he was saying. Jaimie sounded like he had put so much thought into this like he had contemplated it even before Leo called. Almost as if he had expected it. And maybe he had.
Chapter 7
Waiting for Leo to arrive at our apartment was the longest fifteen minutes of my life. I sat in the living room, my knees pressed tightly together. There was a cup of tea balanced on my right knee that I hadn’t even touched. It had certainly over-steeped by now. I put it down on the coffee table, my fingers shaking. Jaimie was sitting down on the loveseat, Buster on his lap, watching TV. It irritated me that he was so calm about the whole thing, while I was nothing more than a ball of nerves.
Was he not angry about the fact that his girlfriend cheated on him? I looked up at the football game and gritted my teeth. I never liked the game, even though I had been to every single one of Leo’s games in high school and I had even gone to some professional ones with the guys once or twice. It was just sixty minutes that were dragged out for way too long.
I leaned back into the couch, wishing I could disappear, that the cushions would devour me. I looked up at the ceiling and listened carefully for the sounds outside. I was dreading the moment Leo finally showed up. There was bound to be a fight. I imagined fists flying and furniture being shattered to pieces.
Suddenly, however, I heard the sound of a car parking on the street. I peeked out the window and saw Leo approaching the building. My heart hammered quickly and my fingers balled into fists. I couldn’t even hear myself think with the ferocious beating of my heart.
There was a soft knock on the door. I was about to get it when Jaimie beat me to it. The two brothers looked at each other over the threshold. I braced myself, nearly wincing, but they were surprisingly calm. “Come in.” Jaimie waved his arm in the direction of the living room.
Leo was once again wearing his army-style pants and white tank top. It didn’t look like he had brought a jacket with him. Slowly, he crossed the area rug and sat down beside me. Jaimie sat down on the coffee table in front of us, his hands on his knees. With the football game playing in the background, this almost felt like a huddle. My nerves only got worse as my stomach tangled into a horrendous knot.
“First off, let me just say this was my idea –”
“And what was your idea, exactly?” I interrupted him. I couldn’t understand why w
e were here when I was sure this meeting could only end in hostility.
“I think what my brother is trying to say is that he and I talked about what happened between us.” Leo looked at me and I avoided his gaze, but not before noticing his black eye. I winced, knowing the two brothers probably had a fight over me. I felt horrible.
“Well, we mostly fought it out.” Jaimie chuckled lightly. “And short of killing each other, we found out that both of us are way too stubborn to ever give you up.”
“We also decided that it wouldn’t be fair to make you choose.” Leo took my hand, squeezing it gently. “And we aren’t going to make you.” I swallowed hard, thinking this was the end. They were both going to leave me. “Instead…” Leo paused and I waited for them to kick me out. “You can have us both.”
I stared at him, my jaw hanging open. I was in shock. “What?” I croaked. They couldn’t be serious, could they? Of course, I was hesitant about the whole thing. These two guys were always fighting over me, why would they suddenly come to a truce?
“Listen.” Jaimie took my other hand, patting it gently. “If you love us both, what’s the issue? We both love you. It’ll just have to be our little secret since you know, threesomes are still kind of taboo, especially when it comes to our parents. But I’m sure we can handle it.”
“I…” I stumbled and stuttered over my words. I couldn’t believe they were really suggesting this. I bit my lip and looked from one man to the other. Suddenly, Jaimie leaned forward, kissing my lips. Seconds later, Leo’s strong arms pulled me into a tight embrace. His head burrowed into my neck as he kissed my skin. I shuddered, feeling both men kissing me at once. My head spun and I tried to make sense of what was going on.
“Lola, we just don’t want to lose you,” Leo whispered. “I lost you once and I can’t allow that to happen again.”
“And I never want to lose you, ever,” Jaimie added, his hands on my shoulders, our knees touching.
“I don’t want to lose you two, either…” I whispered softly. “But…” I hesitated, my heart rampaging. “I’ll agree on one condition.”
“What’s that?” Jaimie asked.
“You both take me. Right here. Right now.” My hormones had taken over. I lusted for them so badly. I could feel a fire burning between my thighs, calling out for them. The dream I had about them replayed in my mind, reminding me of how good it felt when they both pleasured me. I wanted that dream to become a reality... I wanted them so bad. I almost ached for their touch in a way I couldn’t really describe. The fact that their bodies were so close to mine was already driving me insane.
They both smirked, nodding their heads. I looked back and forth between them, noticing the bulges in their pants. I imagined their dicks straining for freedom in their jeans as I bit my lip, yearning to reach out and grab them, but my body was frozen in place. I couldn’t think straight. All I could think about was their dicks in my hands, stroking them at the same time. I licked my lips at the thought, my heart racing and my pussy getting eager as juices seeped onto my panties.
Before I knew what was going on, Jaimie had me in his arms, carrying me into the bedroom. “I hope you don’t mind a little change of scenery.” He chuckled, leaning down to kiss me. Our lips smashed together and I could feel his lust flowing through me. His lips were hungry and animalistic as his fingers dug into my ass, squeezing me tight. I giggled and pulled him closer, my fingers tangling in his hair as I pushed my tongue into his mouth. Behind us, I could hear the sound of Leo’s heavy combat boots crashing against the floor.
In the bedroom, Jaimie playfully tossed me on the bed. Before he could pounce, however, Leo had already jumped on top of me, pinning me down, my arms above my head. I wiggled my body in response, pushing my hips into the air. I spread my legs, letting my skirt hike up, giving him a little sneak peek at my panties. His eyes darted between my legs. “So naughty…” He whispered before he bit the side of my neck, leaving behind a profound hickey. “Spreading your legs for me…” He reached down and ran his hand along my panties. “And so wet too.” He chuckled, one finger sliding under my panties before he pushed it inside me without warning. I moaned out, my back arching as he hooked it around, sending me into a frenzy.
I ground my hips into his finger, feeling my lust grow. “Fuck… Jaimie…” I moaned. “You can’t tease me like this.” I pleaded. “You know it drives me insane.”
“But I want to hear you screaming my name.” His breath caressed my ear as he slowly pushed in another finger, his thumb flicking my clit back and forth. I bucked my hips, hoping he would push his fingers deeper, but he just continued to tease me. I bit my lip and sighed in frustration.
“Jaimie… please…”
“You heard the girl.” Leo’s voice suddenly broke us out of our trance. He pulled me away from Jaimie, forcing his fingers to slide out of me. I blushed, feeling the juices soak through my panties. I closed my legs a little, thinking I would drip onto the sheets.
Leo stared at me, a love in his eyes that I hadn’t seen in a while. He pulled me closer before he ran his fingertips along the side of my face. His thumbs caressed my cheeks affectionately as he smiled, our noses touching. “God… I’ve missed you.” He leaned down and kissed my neck, moving toward my collarbone. I shuddered and wrapped my legs around his waist. Quickly, he tore through my shirt, exposing my large chest. His fingers kneaded my flesh until I was moaning in pleasure. He was rough and yet gentle. He would go from making me scream into the kiss to making me moan in pleasure. I ran my hands up and down his back, holding onto his shirt as he leaned down and took my nipple between his teeth, rolling it back and forth before he finally started to suck on it. I moaned louder than ever as his tongue circled around my hard nub, teasing it until goosebumps covered my tits. I shivered, pulling him closer, feeling like I never wanted him to stop.
“If this is going to work, you’re going to have to share.” Jaimie suddenly pushed him away, pulling me onto his lap. I could feel his hardening cock pressing against my thigh and when I looked down, he was wearing nothing at all. He was a little smaller than Leo and a bit hairy. His light blonde pubic hair was curly and soft. I giggled, taking him into my hand and slowly jerking him off, my hand running up and down his length. I squeezed my fingers around him until he groaned with pleasure. Carefully, I took his tip between my fingers, rolling it around until his eyes rolled into the back of his head. “Mmm, baby.”
“Doesn’t feel so good to be teased, does it?” I asked, my voice seductive as I kissed his neck, letting my lips graze his sweet spot. I knew how much he loved it when I gave him hickeys, but I just teased him with the idea, my teeth nipping at him, but never actually biting down hard enough. “Makes you feel like you’re losing your mind, doesn’t it?” I whispered, squeezing his balls in my hands until he jumped.
Suddenly, from behind, Leo grabbed my hips, pushing me down on all fours. Jaimie shimmied up the bed until his throbbing shaft sprung in front of my face. I licked my lips before I leaned down and wrapped my lips around his throbbing dick. I flicked my tongue over his head, teasing him until he bucked his hips, forcing himself deeper down my throat. I looked up at him from under my eyelashes as my lips ran along his veiny underside. I sucked him harder, creating a vacuum as I bobbed my head up and down, my hair tickling his thighs. My tongue traveled along the length of his cock, moving slowly. As I picked up the pace, he slammed into the back of my throat. Even though I gagged a bit, I continued to suck him off, determined to make him feel good. My eyes sparkled as I heard Jaimie moan in pleasure. Sneakily, my fingers moved along his thighs until they found his balls, giving them a firm squeeze. He groaned loudly as I fondled his balls for a moment while continuing to deep-throat him.
Abruptly, with all my attention focused on the blowjob, Leo smacked my ass. I jumped, arching my back from the impact. He smacked my other cheek for good measure before he hiked up my skirt, exposing my round ass. “Nice choice of panties.” He commented before his fingers tightened
around the waistband of my green thong. He pulled it upwards and I squirmed, feeling the fabric bury itself inside my wet folds. Before I could moan out, however, Jaimie had tangled his hands in my hair and pulled me down onto his cock, silencing my moan before it began.
Gagging, I spread my lips as far as they would go I took him down my throat. I pulled out, gasping for air just as Leo ripped my panties off, letting them flutter to the floor. I moaned softly before diving back down onto Jaimie’s cock, my hips swaying, hoping to tease the sexy ex-soldier behind me.
His large, rough hands moved over my still burning ass before he spread my pussy lips, feeling how wet I really was. I couldn’t help myself. Being with both of these incredibly sexy men at the same time was almost too much for me to handle.
He ran his middle finger along my slit, taking his time to tease me. As I bobbed my head up and down on Jaimie’s cock, I heard the sound of a zipper. My heart skipped a beat as I continued to run my tongue along Jaimie’s length, loving the sound of his moans. Jaimie continued to tug at my thick hair, twirling the natural curls in his fingers as he face-fucked me harder and harder. I could feel a bit of spit running down my face and onto his thighs, but still, I continued. I knew I wouldn’t stop until Jaimie came hard.
Bad, Very Bad Shifters- The Complete Mega Bundle Page 117