by Rye Hart
Gabe shuddered against me, as if my words alone touched parts of him no hand ever could. Gabe's hands moved beneath the water and found my bikini bottom. His eyes boring into mine, he answered me without his words, instead, he pulled my bottoms to the side and rubbed my clit with his fingers. I moaned softly as I guided his cock closer. He took it into his hand, pushing it against my opening.
Feeling the tip of him against me sent a surge of power through my body that I hadn't felt in so long. A bolt of electricity shot from my clit, sensation exploding within me that stretched from my toes to the top of my head.
There was some resistance and friction as he slipped into me, thanks to the water washing away most of my natural lubrication. But, I ignored it and lowered myself down on him, taking him all the way inside of me inch by inch. He was long and hard, and stretched me open as he plunged himself into me.
Gabe was fully sheathed within me. He filled me up completely, and I swear, it felt just like old times. His hands guided my body as I ground myself down onto him. Both of us straining to be quiet and keep the water from sloshing too much, as we fucked in the hot tub, not even ten feet from where his brothers stood.
He glanced over my shoulder, even though from where they were standing, it could look innocent enough. We were kissing. Making out. Nothing more, right?
Then, they weren't stupid either. I was sure that if they happened to look over, they'd figure out what was going on pretty quick.
I squeezed my muscles around Gabe's cock and watched as his eyes fluttered. A smile stretched across his face and he groaned softly, his head falling into my chest as I used my muscles to squeeze and release his thick, stiff cock. I was doing my best to avoid moving my body too much, which would make what we were doing more than obvious.
“Jesus, Hadley,” he muttered, lifting his head up to look into my eyes again. “When did you learn to do that? Or do I even want to know.”
I shot him a salacious grin. “You don't want to know.”
Slowly, I started rocking back and forth on top of him, our mouths connected, silencing the moans trying desperately to escape from within. Gabe's hands moved up my sides, slipping smoothly underneath my bikini top. His fingers pinched at my nipples, and a spasm of pleasure rolled through my body, threatening to draw a long, loud moan from me. I bit down on his lip, my toes curling as I felt myself climbing higher and higher up the peak, heading for a powerful crescendo.
Gabe was meeting my movements now, our bodies working in unison in an erotic choreography that was driving me wild. We were going slow, trying not to draw the attention of his brother's attention, but at some point, our passions took charge, and we forgot about all that.
I moved up and down on his cock, the water of the hot tub splashing onto the concrete all around us. Nothing else mattered in that moment but him and me and the pleasure mounting inside the both of us.
“Yes, yes,” I whimpered against his lips. “Come inside me, Gabe. Please.”
I'd wanted another baby for so long, that the idea of feeling Gabe's seed filling me up and possibly getting pregnant right that second was what sent me over the top. Gabe's hands slipped from my breasts, all the way down to my hips as he held me down against him. He thrust himself upward, plunging himself as deep and filling me up as fully as he could as we locked lips.
I groaned and shuddered against him, muttering his name over and over again, trying to be quiet. Gabe pulled me down had again, one last deep thrust filling me with his seed as we came together. As hard as we tried to be quiet, I knew it was futile.
My body shuddering, my breathing ragged, I collapsed, my head falling to his shoulder. I nestled against him, breathing in his scent as the waves of pleasure continued rolling over me. Closing my eyes, I relaxed against Gabe as he held me close. It was suddenly way too hot to be in the hot tub and sweat covered both of us. Still, I made no movement to get up, relishing the sweet glow that enveloped us both.
The sound of splashing from behind me made me whip my head around quick, and I saw that it was Jared getting back into the hot tub with us. There was a salacious little smirk on his face as he winked at me.
“So am I next?” he asked, his tone teasing.
My cheeks burning with embarrassment I laughed as I slipped off Gabe's lap, even as he tried to hold me tighter against him. His eyes told me he didn't want to let me go, and I really didn't want him to let me go either. We'd been caught though, and if were being honest, even though I was cool with both Jared and Evan, the aftermath of them seeing us fuck made my cheeks burn red.
Evan joined us in the tub, sitting next to Jared, but didn't meet my eyes. He also seemed a little embarrassed by it all, and that made me feel bad. Had I really agreed to sleep with all of them? As much as I loved the fantasy of it, the reality now somehow seemed too outlandish to contemplate seriously. Even for us. Maybe it would be better to just stick with Gabe. After all, we had a past together, and there could be something there between us still. Obviously.
Evan lifted his head and met my gaze, our eyes locking, and a feeling like a pulse of electricity ran through my body. His eyes moved up and down my body as he drank me in. He looked at me in a way I'd never seen from him before – as if I was the most beautiful woman on Earth.
We stared at one another for a long time, and even though I'd just had sex with Gabe, there was a tightness low within me. A craving for Evan, and as I looked over at his brother, I felt that craving for Jared too. What was going through my head? My hormones were out of control. Yet, I kind of liked it.
I loved all of them. To choose one would be impossible. Their plan, however, was to share me. At least until a baby was conceived. That I could live with. I wouldn't have to pick just one of them, no one would know who the father was. It wouldn't have to tear them apart, and I would never have to lose any of them again. I thought it was a win all the way around.
I waded through the hot tub until I got to Evan. Lifting his chin up, I stared into those eyes up close. His face was softer than Gabe's, gentler. His eyes were larger and more innocent, less intense. There was a softness, perhaps even a kindness in his face that neither of his brothers had. Even without his glasses, which he didn't wear in the pool or hot tub, he was still very much Evan. The brothers might look a lot alike, but there were differences amongst them.
Differences that made them each sexy, in their own unique way.
“Do you want me?” I asked Evan, lowering my voice so only he could hear me.
“Yes.”
Just one word, but there was so much need, so much desire and longing in his voice. I leaned down, pressing my lips to his, and kissed him for the very first time.
CHAPTER TEN
EVAN
When Hadley's lips touched mine, electrical currents ran through my body so strong, I was half-afraid I was going to keel over on the spot. For years, I'd dreamt of that moment. Of her discovering my feelings for her and returning them with a kiss. As I was living that dream, my heart raced, and I wasn't sure if it was real. It all felt like a dream to me still. A fantasy that, in the middle of the night when nobody else was around, I'd have jacked off to as a younger man, perhaps.
She was real though, and the kiss was real. I couldn't help but open my eyes and stare past her, my eyes focused on Gabe. My pulse raced at the look on his face. There was a darkness in his face. A hard-set edge that made me nervous. His brow was deep set, his eyes narrow slits, and his fists were balled up at his sides like he was ready to beat the shit out of me. I pulled away from the kiss.
“Actually, I don't know if we should – ”
Hadley stroked my cheek, and I leaned into her hand. “If you want it, we should. I belong to no one now,” she said softly.
No one. She didn't belong to Gabe. Chris was gone. She was a free woman making her own choices, and in that moment, her choice was me.
Gabe climbed out the side of the hot tub, and he stomped off without a word. Clearly, he wasn't pleased with how this situa
tion was all playing out. Hadley didn't see him, nor could she hear him walking away. He went inside the house, leaving the rest of us outside. I looked over at Jared who was grinning back at me like the Cheshire Cat.
“Go for it, man,” Jared said. “Forget about Rebecca and – ”
“I wasn't even thinking about Rebecca,” I said, feeling sheepish. No, my ex hadn't even crossed my mind, ironically enough. “It's Gabe.”
“He'll be fine,” Hadley said, running her hands down my chest. “We're not dating. I love him, but I'm not going to make the mistake of losing the rest of you again. We're all in this together. Bonded.”
Jared came up beside us, and Hadley put her hand on his cheek. She leaned over and kissed him too, and Jared seemed to have an easier time going with the flow. Of course, knowing my brother like I did, I doubted this was his first time sharing a woman. I watched as their tongues danced in each other's mouths, and Jared's hands moved over her breasts, touching her in places I'd only dreamt of touching her for so damn long.
Hadley pulled away from Jared and kissed me again, nibbling my lower lip as her hands continued moving lower on my body. Suddenly, the water in the hot tub was getting unbearable, and I shifted my body, growing a little uncomfortable.
“Maybe we should go inside,” I said. “To a bed?”
“That sounds great,” Jared said.
The guest house had a bed, but it was just a queen sized. Hadley spoke up, without missing a beat.
“My bed is huge,” she said. “My mom and Grayson are asleep, but we'll have to be quiet. Let's move this over to my room, shall we?”
I couldn't bring myself to argue. Hadley looked around for Gabe, as if she'd only just now noticed he'd left. Her smile fell a bit, but Jared kissed her again, wrapping his arms around her and she was lost to their embrace. The three of us climbed out of the hot tub and walked toward Hadley's house, my mind spinning with the fulfillment of a lifelong dream so close at hand.
***
“Shhh,” Hadley said, giggling as we walked upstairs to her bedroom.
To be fair, we were all still a bit tipsy and chuckling. If Hadley was upset about Gabe's disappearance still, it didn't show. She seemed to have already forgotten he was gone again. Either that, or maybe she did notice and had just pushed it to the back of her mind to give the both of us her undivided attention. I much preferred that idea, personally speaking.
She pushed open her bedroom door, and the three of us spilled inside, doing our best to be quiet – though, I wasn't sure we were entirely that successful. Her bedroom looked much the same as I remember it had, all those years ago. Not that I'd been in her room that many times growing up, but I'd been in it a few times.
As soon as she kicked the door closed behind us, Hadley put her arms around my neck and kissed me long and hard. Her tongue pushed past my lips, and we made out as if we were two lovers who'd been kept apart by some unnatural forces and were only now reuniting after so many years. She pressed her firm body against me, her hand groping me.
I kissed along her jaw and down her neck, and she muttered, “Evan, yes, Evan...” in case I had any doubt that she wanted me.
She unzipped my pants while backing up toward the bed. Jared was already laying on it, watching us, his eyes alight with desire.
My erection was pressing against the inside of my pants, but as soon as I saw my brother on the bed, it started to deflate a bit, the desire in me suddenly dimmed. I had to admit, it was really fucking awkward with Jared there. Hadley was pressed up against me, and she must have felt it.
“No, no,” she said. “We can't have that now.”
She pulled my pants down and dropped to her knees as I watched in half-horror, half-dreamlike state. I looked at Jared and had a moment of panic sweep through me, but then her mouth was wrapped around my cock and I forgot about all of that awkwardness. Closing my eyes, I leaned my head back and blocked Jared out completely, focusing all of my attention only on the way her lips surrounded my shaft, and how her tongue circled the tip just perfectly. Focusing all of my attention only how goddamn amazing it felt to have my dick in her mouth – finally. After wanting it more than I wanted anything for so long.
“Fuck,” I groaned.
I ran my fingers through her hair and opened my eyes, looking down at her. She was the only person in the room in that moment, and her lips looked amazing wrapped around my shaft. Her big, blue eyes stared up at me as she flicked her tongue around the head of my cock, licking the precum from the tip.
“Much better,” she said.
She grabbed me by the cock and stroked me a few times before standing up. She slipped the straps of her bikini top down off her shoulders, all the while holding me fast with her gaze, giving me the best “Come hither” look I'd ever seen in my life.
My dream girl, begging me with her eyes to come take her. How could I resist? How did I get so lucky?
She slipped the straps down further and her breasts spilled out of the top. My eyes nearly popped out of my head as I gazed upon the perfectly round mounds of pale flesh. I'd never seen her topless before, only very close to it, and her breasts had never been that large before.
She pulled the top off and threw it to the ground, leaving her standing there with only her bikini bottoms on. As her hands moved down, she slipped her fingers under the band of the bottoms and slowly pushed them down. I could only stand there and stare, wide-eyed, as she slipped them down low on her hips, finally revealing the beautiful mound between her legs. Only a thin strip of reddish hair covered the flesh of her opening. She looked so incredibly tight and inviting that I was nearly overwhelmed by the urge to rush over and take her right then and there. After stepping out of the bottoms, she kicked them aside and crooked her finger, motioning for me to come closer to her.
Like I was moving through a dream, I did as she commanded, stepping over to her. Hadley slipped her arms around my neck and stood on her tip-toes to kiss me again. Her now naked body was rubbing up against mine, and as our lips met, she pulled me backward onto the bed, forcing me down on top of her.
We adjusted, moving higher on the bed. I was dying to have my mouth all over her, and I moved down her neck to her collarbone. Finally, when I reached her breasts, I took her pink nipple between my lips and sucked. Hadley let out a soft moan as I licked her nipple, gave it a little nip with my teeth, her body arching upward. I stared up at her and she looked down at me. I was so caught up in her, it wasn't until she said, “Jared, come here,” that I even remembered my brother was still with us.
I feared I might lose some of the bulge down below but sucking on Hadley's nipple and feeling her body grinding against mine prevented that. Her skin was still moist from the hot tub, yet she tasted of something sweeter. Her skin was softer than I'd ever imagined.
Jared leaned down and kissed her while I sucked on her nipple. I watched as my brother made out with her, and I expected to feel something – jealousy, perhaps? – but I was surprised, because I felt none of that. While he was kissing her, my mouth was all over her delicious body, and I reveled in that, not threatened in the least by the presence of Jared. I was the one making her moan and whimper, the one naked and on top of her. Her hands were in my hair even though her tongue was in his mouth, and I found that I didn't mind it at all.
When Jared came up for air, she commanded him to undress, her voice breathy and ragged. He stood up beside the bed and started to strip, Hadley watching his every move. I moved lower on her body with my mouth, my hands exploring every inch of her, until my fingers found the flesh between her legs. I rubbed her clit and her eyes flicked back to me as a small groan escaped her. A smile stretched across that beautiful face as she looked into my eyes.
She whimpered as I fingered her, her attention fully back on me. Back where it belonged. With my hand working between her thighs, I continued to lick and suck on her stiff nipples, making her gasp and moan.
“Fuck me, Evan,” she whimpered. “I need to feel you inside of me.�
�
I moved up her body, shuddering at the thought of being inside of her. It was my dream, my fantasy, becoming a reality, and I was on the verge of freaking out about it. I hovered above her, my dick pressing against her opening when she quickly shook her head.
“No,” she said.
With that one simple word, I froze. I didn't dare push myself into her, fearing she'd changed her mind. My heart raced as I saw the chance to fulfill my lifelong fantasy hanging by a thread. I wanted her so fucking bad, but there was no way I would go any further without her consent.
She gave me a wicked grin. “From behind,” she said.
My head was spinning, but I sat up and helped her into position. She was on her hands and knees, facing Jared who stood completely naked just a foot or two away.
Great, I thought to myself. I would have to look at my naked brother while fucking Hadley. Before my cock could react to the thought though, Hadley pressed her tight little ass against me. I looked down at where our bodies met, my dick rubbing up and down on her pussy, slipping between the velvety folds of her lips. She was so wet, I could feel her warmth on the tip of my cock. Could see her juices glistening upon my shaft. No, this close to fulfilling my fantasy, I wasn't about to let my brother's presence stop me from having sex with Hadley. In that moment, nothing in the world could have stopped me – not nuclear war, alien invasion, or zombie apocalypse. Nothing.
Grabbing my cock, I held it in place, pressing it firmly against her opening. Hadley whimpered as she pressed back against me, and I thrust my hips, plunging deep inside of her.
The feeling of being inside of her for the first time was intense and surreal. She was tight and warm and wet and being in her was unlike being inside anybody else I'd ever been with. It was somehow so much better. Her muscles clenched around my cock as I held her in place, my hands on her ass. I stared down at where our bodies were united, still in awe that I was now sheathed inside of her and needing the visual confirmation of that fact.
I focused on Hadley's tight little ass rocking back and forth against me, my cock sliding in and out of her. My hands gripped her ass, but I wanted more. So much more. Leaning down, I kissed along Hadley's spine. She shuddered and fell flat against the bed, her hips and ass raised slightly. I continued fucking her, kissing the back of her neck, pumping away until I felt like my balls were about to burst with the cum that was building up within me.