The Commissioner took the list, hoping to find in it an opening for a renewed protest. Instead, he found himself gaping at a neat time-table, and particularly at its last phrase:
9 a.m. Comstock at breakfast.
11-35 a.m. (say). C. interviews Archbishop.
11.50 or 55 a.m. Fairweather arrives.
By 12 noon. Littleton also there.
H.-Fairweather in waiting-room.
At noon. Mills in Office.
Littleton in waiting-room.
Comstock and Archbishop in argument.
12.22 p.m. Mills returns to work in the Office, all the visitors having departed.
1.5 p.m. Butler calls Mills from Office.
1.7 p.m. Police informed.
1.15 p.m. Easton arrives.
1.30 p.m. C.I.D. informed by Chief Constable.
2.30 p.m. Home Secretary takes personal charge.
“But—do you mean, Sir Philip, that you personally …?”
“What?—Oh, that’s not the list. Those are my notes. This will come up in the House, you know. Here’s the list I meant. If I add to it, I’ll tell Anderson to let you know. That is perfectly clear, I hope?” He recovered the time-table.
The Commissioner bowed. Further argument, he knew, was useless. He shepherded Shawford and Churchill from the room, and returned to Scotland Yard. taking with him the pistol which had been found by Superintendent Easton.
Littleton had not yet returned from Winborough, but the Commissioner found a lengthy medical report awaiting him. He read it through, and made a note of the principal points contained in it.
The examining surgeon reported that, from the appearance and temperature of the body, Comstock must have been dead for certainly more than one and probably two hours when examined at 2.15 p.m. Death, therefore, must have taken place before 1.15 p.m. (” helpful,” snorted the Commissioner) and probably before 12.15 p.m.
From the nature of the wound, death must have been practically instantaneous. The cause of death was penetration of the brain by a bullet, which had entered the head by the left temple. No traces of burning or of powder blackening could be found in the neighbourhood of the wound.
The course of the bullet had been slightly upward. That is to say, it had been found at a spot slightly higher in the head than the point of entry. It had been extracted, and was of very small calibre, 15 inch, as far as could be judged. Owing to slight flattening, however, it was impossible to measure the calibre exactly. The marks of the rifling, however, could still be detected near the base.
The bullet itself, wrapped up in tissue paper and enclosed in a pill-box, accompanied the report. The Commissioner unfolded it and looked at it closely. It was certainly flattened at the head, but the base appeared to have retained its original dimensions.
He took the pistol from his pocket and inserted the base of the bullet into the muzzle. It fitted exactly.
INTRODUCTION TO PART II
“DEAR JOHN RHODE,
“You do indeed know how to take a hint! This is a superb Problem, with all the recognised ingredients—save only our old friend the “blunt instrument,” of which I should have reminded you.
“Yet I am not much farther forward, for I cannot imagine what the solution of your problem can be. However, there is, as you have shown, a friendly readiness amongst the members of the Detection Club to help the weaker brethren, so I have written to one or two of our friends to ask them to tell me what, in the opinion of their Sleuths, the solution is.
“By the way, my earlier letter to you rather suggested that I had thought of the title ‘Ask a Policeman.’ Actually, Arthur Barker suggested it to me, but an author is naturally reluctant to give any credit to a publisher.
“Yours ever,
“MILWARD KENNEDY.”
“P.S.—I find that I have made an awkward blunder. By a clerical error I have mixed up the sleuths. I have asked Dorothy L. Sayers for Mr. Sheringham’s views, Anthony Berkeley for Lord Peter’s; I have applied to Helen Simpson for Mrs. Bradley’s aid, and to Gladys Mitchell for Sir John’s. Never mind; let us see what happens.”
PART II
CHAPTER I
MRS. BRADLEY’S DILEMMA
BY HELEN SIMPSON
(I)
MRS. BRADLEY was the perfect guest. Even relatives in-law, those touchy, difficult, and chary hosts, continually requested her to stay, were disappointed when she refused, and frolicked about her like puppies unleashed when she spared them a week in the summer. This similitude might hardly apply to the stately gambols of Lady Selina Lestrange, who weighed fifteen stone, and seldom moved far save under haulage;but the moral effect of Mrs. Bradley’s visits may be thus, not inadequately, represented. The lure on the present occasion had been horticultural and psychological.
“Really, Adela dear, I want to consult you about Sally. She seems to be growing quite morbid, won’t go about, meets a most impossible person secretly, and has been getting, I find, all sorts of dreadful medical books from the London Library. I wrote to them and stopped it, of course. She is behaving very badly to that nice Dick Paradine, you knew his father, and of course I have no influence, but I believe the child really respects your opinion. Our borders are exquisite, it seems hard to realize that with all this taxation we may have to cut down the outdoors staff, and next year it will be a wilderness. So do come—”
Thus Lady Selina, at her none too extensive wits’ end; to which Mrs. Bradley crisply replied:
“I should like to see your garden, and will come, if I may, next Monday. Sally, I imagine, needs something to do rather than someone to marry.”
The result of this interchange was Mrs. Bradley’s arrival in time to drink tea under an immemorial elm on the Lestrange’s lawn, and, with a bright, black eye alert for wasps, to listen to her sister-in-law’s moan.
“—and she won’t be civil, except to this awful young man and she huddles herself up all day in her room. It’s morbid, and if there’s anything I dread—it’s bad enough having Ferdinand always in the papers.”
“To say nothing of me,” supplemented Mrs. Bradley with a gleam.
“Darling, I know you never actually seek notoriety. But I mean, all this obsession with crime! I do think Ferdinand might sometimes find someone respectable to defend.”
That famous criminal lawyer’s mother gave a loud cackle of laughter that set off Lady Selina’s parrot, who had been brought out for an airing in the June sun.
“Ha, ha, ha,” observed the parrot shrilly. “Give us a kiss, give us a drop o’ beer. Smack!”
To this Mrs. Bradley’s cackle played second, and the duet brought a figure to one of the second floor windows of the distant house. Mrs. Bradley’s sharp eyes noted it at once; noted, too, an odd appearance about the mouth, as of a thin dark moustache. “Pencil,” proclaimed her thoughts, while her remarkable voice responded in the negative to her hostess’s question concerning more tea.
“Delicious, but no more. Your garden’s divine. I simply ‘must walk about.”
“Shall I come with you?” Lady Selina’s fond gaze was on the strawberries, of which she had already consumed two platefuls.
“Stay where you are,” commanded Mrs. Bradley. “Goodness, I’ve known you more than seven years.”
“I thought that was poking fires.”
“Gardens too,” responded Mrs. Bradley firmly, who detested a personally-conducted tour as intensely as she favoured a solitary stroll. Her objection was sustained by the parrot, who exclaimed with hospitable heartiness:
“Give ’er air, give us a drop o’ beer, hullo, hullo, she’s my sweetie I”
Mrs. Bradley thus encouraged set off on her tour, keeping well within the field of vision of the second floor window, slowly ranging, surveying flowers with almost professional deliberation. She had worked round to that side of the garden where rhododendrons, past their prime but still heavy with bloom, made an impermeable screen, when she heard the expected voice.
“What are
you doing, Aunt Adela, snooping about?”
“I am snooping, Sally, if that nondescript word means exploring, your mother’s garden.” She eyed swiftly, piercingly, the slim young figure before her. “And what about you?”
“Mummy’s asked you to talk to me, hasn’t she?” asked Sally with no preliminary sparring.
“She did,” admitted Mrs. Bradley, unconcerned, “but I shan’t need to.”
“Oh!” Sally was momentarily dashed.
“When,” pursued Mrs. Bradley, “I hear of a girl who shuts herself up in her room, and gets in medical books, and snubs her admirer, I don’t jump to the conclusion that she’s going to murder him. I assume at once that she is writing a detective novel.”
Sarah stared a moment, and gave vent to an expletive which wrinkled Mrs. Bradley’s eyes with distaste.
“Blast! And I didn’t want Mummy to know!”
“So you shut yourself up, and don’t go out, and won’t be civil, and generally behave in a way calculated to drive her to frenzy.”
“Don’t go out! Where is there to go? You don’t know how dull it is here.”
“Dull, with his lordship of Common-Stock at your back door?”
“He’s an old toad. He’s vile to everybody. Teddy Mills told me—”
She halted. “Oh, well, I don’t suppose it matters. Teddy’s leaving the old brute, anyway. But he said sometimes he feels like strangling him. He uses money like a bludgeon, and publicity like poison-gas.”
“A quotation from your book, I presume,” said Mrs. Bradley, “or from Mr. Edward Mills?”
“As a matter of fact,” Sally answered, with an innocent air, “I thought it would be rather fun to make my murderer someone like Lord Comstock.”
“Never embark on a jargon you don’t know. Landed gentry are more in your line, and journalese is one of the more difficult languages.”
“Oh, Teddy helps with that.”
“H’m!” Mrs. Bradley cleared her throat with emphasis, and lifted one yellowish claw covered with admirable but equally yellowish diamonds. “Edward is forbidden fruit; Edward takes your fancy. Edward’s employer is unsympathetic. Your mother also is unsympathetic. Don’t interrupt me. Comstock keeps Edward’s nose to the grindstone and makes his life a burden generally. It is difficult for you to meet Edward often; whose fault? The employer’s, naturally. You therefore start a novel, in which you avenge yourself on the employer by proxy, and with impunity. The name for this process is wish-fulfilment. Two centuries back people stuck pins into wax figures with the same idea.”
Sally, who had begun by looking angry, now had subsided to something like reluctant awe. “I say, Aunt Adela, that’s most awfully good. Grand sleuthing—”
“Is it correct?”
“Pretty well. I mean, Teddy’s fearfully good-looking, and good at things, and that old animal won’t ever let him off the chain. And then Mummy’s always ramming Dickie Paradine down my throat.”
“Do you want me to speak to your mother about it?”
“Oh no, please,” said the girl in a great hurry. “You see, there wouldn’t be much money, and of course he’s frightfully young and so am I really, if you come to think of it.”
Mrs. Bradley came to think of Sally’s seventeen years, and found them surprising in combination with this very reasonable attitude.
“The question of marriage hasn’t arisen, then?”
“No. Why should it? Why should one start off being all stuffy? Marriage is like cold cocoa, nourishing but nauseous.”
Mrs. Bradley surrounded this last remark with quotation marks, labelled it “Edward Mills, Esq.,” and passed on.
“I think I shall have to meet this young man.”
“Mummy won’t have him here. Mummy’s maddeningly county, sometimes. I mean, Teddy’s meeting Cabinet Ministers and people like that all day. He’s bound to get on.”
“I see. Ambitious?”
“Oh yes, fearfully.”
“Yet he is leaving this employment where he meets such daily stepping-stones to ambition?”
The girl flushed.
“Teddys awfully sensitive. Why should he stay and be treated like a pickpocket? Aunt Adela, swear you won’t say a word to Mummy about all this?”
“I’m your mother’s friend, you know,” Mrs. Bradley reminded her.
“Yes, but you didn’t play fair. I mean, you got it out of me-I mean, it’s Teddy’s secret as well as mine. And after all “—a touch, could it be of relief?—” he’ll be going away soon.”
“We’ll see,” said Mrs. Bradley. Then, briskly, “Let me help you with the book, at any rate. How far have you got?”
“Only the first two chapters.”
“Body on the floor, I suppose, in the study?”
“Yes. Shot. Lots of blood,” Sally responded with relish.
“Off with his head! So much for Comstock,” pro-claimed Mrs. Bradley grandly, her amazing voice lighting up even so uninspired, so very blank a verse, into poetry. Another voice, an excited and bubbling voice, but one that knew its place, said at her shoulder:
“For you, madam. A note. Gentleman’s waiting.”
Mrs. Bradley was too much of her generation to give any outward sign of irritation or dismay. She did say, however, plaintively:
“Now, who can have found me here? “as she opened the envelope. The note was long; it covered two sheets, and when she had read it she paused a moment, weighing it in her hand with pursed lips, thinking. At last she asked of the waiting butler an unexpected question.
“What’s the time?”
It was six; five o’clock by what the agricultural neighbourhood called God’s time, and completely light. Her next question was to Sarah.
“Dear child, do you think your mother’s ban on young men would extend to an Assistant Commissioner of Police?”
And she handed the note, which Sarah conned.
“Heard in the village you’d just arrived. Look here, may I see you? Sorry, but it’s something really urgent, and I’ve got to get back to London at once. Please. A. L.”
“Now what,” pondered Mrs. Bradley, “can Alan Littleton’s really urgent trouble be?”
It was a rhetorical question, one, that is, which anticipates no answer; but answered it was, and from an unexpected source.
“Pardon me, madam,” said the voice of the salver-bearer, tremulous with that sweetest, supremest human joy, the joy of being first with the news. “Can the gentleman be referring to the murder of Lord Comstock?” And, while they gaped: “Found in his study, miss. Shot through the ’ead. (Just ’ad the news from the grocer’s boy, madam.) Shot right through the ’ead; blood “—the gleam in the salver-bearer’s eye betrayed him an amateur of crime—” blood everywhere.”
(II)
The situation was more than usually unfair to Lady Selina. Seated in a pleasant torpor, comfortably involved in a patent garden chair from which no unaided exit was possible, her contented gaze resting upon an empty cream-jug, she was suddenly assailed by her daughter, breaking the news that an Assistant Commissioner of Police was on the premises, and that her neighbour, whom she ignored while detesting, had been murdered during the day. At first her reaction to the double news was slow; the effect of the latter part, not unpleasant, being cancelled out by the former statement, which seemed to have more than a savour of the dreaded morbidity. But that savour, like a clove of garlic artfully used in cookery, rose gradually to appal and permeate her whole mind. That the neighbour should meet a thoroughly deserved end was nothing much; that her roof should harbour policemen was serious and unsettling, and a matter that must at once be dealt with in person.
Her first recorded utterance was: “Bother Adela!”
Her second:” Well, I suppose-but I cannot and will not have him to sleep!”
Her daughter, wrought to politeness and tact by this new excitement, reassured her.
“He only wants to talk with Aunt Adela. And he says he’s probably not a policeman any more.”
“Then why does he come here?”
“Aunt Adela, Mummy, I told you. He’s come about the murder. It’s frightfully important. ‘Oh, Mummy, don’t go all Cadogan!”
Thus Sally who, with tact, but at a great expenditure of self-restraint, kept apart herself, and fended off her indignant mother from the concentrated talk which was proceeding in the breakfast-room, and whose progress, through the windows, she could witness; an impressive sight. Aunt Adela, shockingly and expensively dressed in her orange satin coat and skirt, sat bolt upright like a Buddha, only her quick black eyes moving. A dark lean man with a moustache gesticulated, standing. As she watched she saw him sketch a gesture, a very characteristic gesture, a sudden tugging at the lobe of the left ear by the right hand. He laughed as he did it. Sally did not laugh. For that was the way Teddy pulled his ear, and the very thought of Teddy, so sensitive, involved in this mess, turned her for a moment still as stone. When Alan Littleton came out to his car she was waiting by it.
“I meant to ask you-do you think I could have a word with Mr. Mills?”
Littleton looked at her.
“He’s at Winborough.”
“Winborough? Why?”
“He’s been—” he softened it—” asked to make a statement, I believe. But I can’t give you any exact information. I’m here as a private individual, you know. Must be off up to London again at once.”
“But what can Teddy know about it?”
“The police have to question everyone. It doesn’t mean they think he’s done it. I’m sorry, I must be off now.”
Ask a Policeman Page 7