by Alison Weir
Certainly the miniature dates from the mid-1520s. The Toronto version is inscribed ANNO XXV, showing that the sitter was in her twenty-fifth year; and it is possible that Mary could have been born in 1500, making her twenty-four in 1524/5, which would coincide with Horenbout’s first year in England. The brooch is possibly symbolic—a kneeling woman represented deference, humility, and subordination, and was often a ritual image suggesting the marriage bond, so this sitter is almost certainly a married woman. It could also represent a mythological or allegorical figure.
At that time, however, the portrait miniature had only just been introduced into England, and was an expensive novelty, sought after by a king and nobles eager to be at the forefront of artistic fashion. With Horenbout, the chief master of the form, being a court painter, most early English miniatures are therefore of royalty, with only a few exceptions. The sitter in this pair of miniatures, however, does not resemble any royal lady of the mid-1520s. The age of the sitter excludes Katherine of Aragon and Mary Tudor, Duchess of Suffolk. It is of course possible that if Sir Thomas Boleyn was responsible for bringing Horenbout to England, he then commissioned a work or works to demonstrate the limner’s craft in order to win his protégé commissions; it follows too that he might have chosen one of his daughters as a sitter. If this is Mary—and that is a big “if”—the portrait could have been painted to mark the birth of her daughter; and if that daughter had been fathered by Henry VIII, there was all the more reason to commission a likeness.
Normally, the existence of duplicated portraits suggests that there was some demand for the image of an important or royal personage, but it is credible in this case that a second miniature may have been painted for William Carey. Furthermore, the suggested Boleyn link to Horenbout is strengthened by the fact that the latter was appointed King’s Painter in 1531 when Anne Boleyn was riding high in the King’s favor; this grant of office was confirmed three years later, on the day before George Boleyn was made Lord Warden of the Cinque Ports.20 All this is speculation, though, and without any more evidence to go on, the identity of the sitter in these miniatures must remain in question.
Select Bibliography
PRIMARY SOURCES
Ambassades en Angleterre de Jean du Bellay, 1527–29 (ed. V. L. Bourilly and P. de Vassière, Paris, 1905).
An English Garner (8 vols., ed. Edward Arber, London, 1877–92).
Anselme, Père (Father Anselm of the Virgin Mary): Histoire généalogique de la maison royale de France, et des grands officiers de la couronne (2 vols., 1674).
The Antiquarian Repertory: A Miscellany, intended to Preserve and Illustrate Several Valuable remains of Old Times (4 vols., ed. F. Grose and T. Astle, London, 1775–84, 1808).
Bellay, Martin and Guillaume: Mèmoires (4 vols., ed. V. L. Bourrilly and F. Vindry, Paris, 1908–19).
Bibliothèque Nationale, Paris MS. fr.7853, f.305b.
Blackwood, Adam: Martyre de la Reyne d’Éscosse (Edinburgh, 1587; Antwerp, 1588).
Bourbon, Nicolas: Nicolae Borbonii Vandoperani Lingonensis, Nugarum libri octo (Lyons, 1538; Basel, 1540).
Brantômè, Pierre de Bourdeille, Seigneur de: Ouvres Completes (12 vols., ed. Ludovic Lalanne, Librairie de la Société de l’Histoire de France, Paris, 1864–96).
Brodeau, Jean: La vie de Maistre Charles Dumoulin, advocate au parlement de Paris (Paris, 1654).
Calendar of the Close Rolls preserved in the Public Record Office: Henry VII (2 vols., London, 1955–63).
Calendar of Inquisitions Post Mortem: Henry VII (2 vols., London, 1915).
Calendar of Letters, Despatches and State Papers relating to Negotiations between England and Spain, preserved in the Archives at Simancas and Elsewhere (17 vols., ed. G. A. Bergenroth, P. de Goyangos, Garrett Mattingley, R. Tyler, et al., H.M.S.O., London, 1862–1965).
Calendar of Letters and State Papers relating to English Affairs, preserved principally in the Archives of Simancas, Vols.1–4, Elizabeth I, 1558–1603 (Vaduz, 1971).
Calendar of Patent Rolls: Henry VII: 1485–1509 (2 vols., London, 1914–16).
Calendar of Patent Rolls for the Reign of Henry VIII, 1509–1547 (incorporated in Letters and Papers, Foreign and Domestic, of the Reign of Henry VIII (21 vols. in 33 parts, ed. J. S. Brewer, James Gairdner, R. Brodie, et al., 1862–1932).
Calendar of the Patent Rolls preserved in the Public Record Office, Mary and Philip and Mary (4 vols., ed. A. E. Stamp, London, 1937–39).
Calendar of State Papers, Domestic Series, for the Reigns of Edward VI, Mary, Elizabeth I, 1547–1625 (12 vols., ed. Robert Lemon and Mary Anne Everett Green, London, 1856–72).
Calendar of State Papers, Foreign Series, of the Reign of Elizabeth (23 vols., ed. Joseph Stevenson and A. J. Crosby, et al., London, 1863–1950).
Calendar of State Papers: Ireland: Elizabeth I, 1588–92 (ed. Hans Claude Hamilton, London, 1974).
Calendar of State Papers and Manuscripts existing in the Archives and Collections of Milan, Vol. 1, 1385–1618 (ed. Allen B. Hinds, London, 1912).
Calendar of State Papers and Manuscripts relating to English Affairs preserved in the Archives of Venice and in the other Libraries of Northern Italy (7 vols., ed. L. Rawdon-Brown, Cavendish Bentinck, et al., H.M.S.O., London, 1864–1947).
Calendar of State Papers relating to Scotland and Mary, Queen of Scots, 1547–1603 (12 vols., ed. Joseph Bain, W. K. Boyd, and M. S. Giuseppi, Edinburgh, 1898–1969).
Camden, William: Annales rerum Anglicarum et Hibernicarum regnante Elizabetha (London, 1615).
Camden, William: Reges, Reginae, Nobilis et alii, in Ecclesia Collegiata B. Petri Westmonasterii sepulti (London, 1600).
Carey, Sir Robert: Memoirs of the Life of Robert Carey, Baron of Leppington and Earl of Monmouth, written by himself (written before 1627; ed. John Boyle, Earl of Cork and Orrery, London, 1759; ed. F. H. Mares, Oxford, 1972).
Carles, Lancelot de: Letter containing the criminal trial brought against the Queen Anne Boleyn of England (Mss. Fr. 1742 and 2370, Bibliothèque Nationale, Paris, written 1536, published Lyons, 1545, of which a copy is in the British Library; published as “Épistre contenant le procès criminel faict a l’encontre de la royne Anne Boullant d’Angleterre” (in La Grande Bretagne devant l’Opinion Française by Georges Ascoli, Paris, 1927).
Cavendish, George: The Life and Death of Cardinal Wolsey (London, 1557; ed. R. Sylvester, Early English Texts Society, 1959; ed. Roger Lockyer, The Folio Society, 1962).
Cavendish, George: Metrical Visions (published in vol. 2 of S. W. Singer’s edition of George Cavendish’s The Life of Cardinal Wolsey, London, 1825).
The Chronicle of Calais in the Reigns of Henry VII and Henry VIII, to the year 1540 (attributed to Richard Turpin; ed. J. G. Nichols, Camden Society, 25, 1846).
The Chronicle of King Henry VIII of England (Crónica del Rey Enrico Otavo de Inglaterra, sometimes attributed to Antonio de Guaras; also known as “The Spanish Chronicle”; ed. M. A. S. Hume, 1889).
Clifford, Henry: Life of Jane Dormer, Duchess of Feria (1643; ed. E. E. Estcourt and J. Stevenson, 1887).
Correspondence de l’Empereur Maximilien Ier et de Marguerite d’Autriche sa Fille, Gouvernante de Pays Bas (ed. Le Glay, André Joseph, Paris, 1839).
Cotton mss., British Library.
Cranmer, Thomas: Miscellaneous Writings and Letters of Thomas Cranmer (ed. J. E. Cox, Parker Society, Cambridge, 1846).
Dugdale, William: Monasticon Anglicanum (6 vols., ed. J. Caley, H. Ellis, and B. Bandine, London, 1817–30).
Egerton mss.(British Library).
English Historical Documents, 5, 1485–1558 (ed. C. H. Williams and D. C. Douglas, London, 1967).
Fénelon, Bertrand de Salignac de la Mothe: Correspondance Diplomatique (Paris, 1838).
Four Years at the Court of Henry VIII: Selections from Despatches written by Sebastian Giustiniano, January 12, 1515 to July 26, 1519 (4 vols., trans. and ed. L. Rawdon Brown, London, 1854).
Foxe, John: History of the Acts and Monuments of
the Church (Foxe’s Book of Martyrs) (1563; ed. G. Townshend and S. R. Cattley, 8 vols., London, 1837–41).
Fuller, Thomas: History of the Worthies of England (London, 1662).
Gardiner, Stephen: The Letters of Stephen Gardiner (ed. James Arthur Muller, Cambridge, 1933).
Hall, Edward: The Triumphant Reign of King Henry the Eighth (London, 1547; 2 vols., ed. C. Whibley and T. C. and E. C. Jack, London, 1904).
Harington, Sir John, et al.: Nugae Antiqua, being a Miscellaneous Collection of Original Papers in Prose and Verse; written during the reigns of Henry VIII, Edward VI, Queen Mary, Elizabeth and King James (ed. Henry Harington, London, 1779, 1804).
Harington, Sir John: A Tract on the Succession to the Crown (1602; ed. Sir Clements Robert Markham, Roxburghe Club, New York, 1970).
Harleian mss., British Library.
Harpsfield, Nicholas: The Life and Death of Thomas More, Knight (London, c.1557; ed. E. V. Hitchcock and R. W. Chambers, Early English Texts Society, London, 1935).
Harpsfield, Nicholas: A Treatise on the Pretended Divorce between King Henry VIII and Katherine of Aragon (ed. N. Pococke, Camden Society, 2nd Series, 21, London, 1878).
Hatfield mss.: The Salisbury (Cecil) Manuscripts and Papers (Hatfield House, Hertfordshire).
Herbert, Edward, Ist Baron Herbert of Cherbury: The Life and Raigne of King Henry the Eighth (London, 1649).
Hostillers’ Books (Durham Cathedral Muniments, Durham University Library).
“Household Expenses of the Princess Elizabeth during her Residence at Hatfield October 1, 1551 to September 30, 1552” (ed. Viscount Strangford, Camden Miscellany, 2, Old Series 55, London, 1853).
Inventories of the Wardrobe, Plate, Chapel Stuff etc. of Henry Fitzroy, Duke of Richmond and Somerset … (ed. John Gough Nichols, Camden Society, Old Series 61, London, 1854).
Lansdowne mss., British Library.
Latymer, William: “Treatise on Anne Boleyn” (Bodleian Library, Oxford, ms. Don. C.42).
Leland, John: The Itinerary of John Leland in or about the years 1535–1543 (5 vols., ed. Lucy Toulin Smith, London, 1906–10).
Leti, Gregorio: Vita di Elisabetta (Amsterdam, 1692).
The Letters of King Henry VIII (ed. Muriel St. Clair Byrne, London, 1936).
Letters of Mary, Queen of Scots (ed. Agnes Strickland, London, 1848).
Letters and Papers, Foreign and Domestic, of the Reign of Henry VIII (21 vols. in 33 parts, ed. J.S. Brewer, James Gairdner, R. Brodie, et al., 1862–1932).
Letters of the Queens of England, 1100–1547 (ed. Anne Crawford, Stroud, 1994).
Letters of Royal and Illustrious Ladies of Great Britain (3 vols., ed. Mary Anne Everett Wood, London, 1846).
The Lisle Letters (6 vols., ed. Muriel St. Clair Byrne, London and Chicago, 1981).
The Love Letters of Henry VIII (ed. Henry Savage, London, 1949).
The Love Letters of Henry VIII (ed. Jasper Ridley, 1988).
The Love Letters of Mary, Queen of Scots, to James, Earl of Bothwell (ed. Hugh Campbell, London, 1825).
Mander, Karel van: Schilderbook (1604; trans. Constant van der Wall, New York, 1936).
The Manuscripts of J. Eliot Hodgkin Esq., F.S.A., of Richmond, Surrey (Historical Manuscripts Commission, 15, 2).
Meteren, E. van: Historie der Nederlandsche … oorlogen ende geschiedenissen (Delft, 1599, 1609).
National Archives (Public Record Office): C142: Inquisitions Post Mortem E326: Ancient Deeds SP1: State Papers.
Naunton, Sir Robert: Fragmenta Regalia (London, 1653; ed. Edward Arber, London, 1879, 1896).
Newton, Thomas: An Epitaph upon the Worthy and Honourable Lady, the Lady Knowles (London, 1569).
Original Letters Illustrative of English History (11 vols. in 3 series, ed. Sir Henry Ellis, London, 1824, 1827, and 1846).
“Papers relating to Mary, Queen of Scots, communicated by General Sir William Knollys” (ed. William Knollys, Philobiblon Society Miscellanies, 14–15, 1872–76).
Parker, Matthew: The Correspondence of Matthew Parker, 1535–1575 (ed. J. Bruce and T. Perowne, Parker Society, 1853).
The Paston Letters, 1422–1509 (3 vols., ed. James Gairdner, Edinburgh, 1910).
The Privy Purse Expenses of King Henry the Eighth from November MDXIX to December MDXXXII (ed. Sir Nicholas Harris Nicolas, London, 1827).
Pole, Reginald: Pro ecclesiasticae unitatis defensione (A Defence of the Unity of the Church) (Rome, 1538, based on an open letter sent to Henry VIII in 1536).
Puttenham, George: The Art of English Poesie (London, 1589; ed. G. D. Willcock and Alice Walker, London, 1936).
Rastell, William: “Life of Sir Thomas More” (fragment in the Arundel mss., British Library).
Robinson, C.: “Carey, Barons Hunsdon, etc.” (Herald and Genealogist, 8 vols., London, 1867).
Roper, William: The Life of Sir Thomas More, Knight (c.1556; ed. E. V. Hitchcock, Early English Texts Society, 197, 1935).
The Rutland Papers: Original Documents illustrating the Courts and Times of Henry VII and Henry VIII, selected from the private archives of His Grace the Duke of Rutland (ed. William Jordan, Camden Society, Old Series, 21, London, 1842).
Rymer, Thomas: Foedera, Conventiones, Et … Acta Publica inter Reges Angliae (London, 1704–17).
Sander, Nicholas: Rise and Growth of the Anglican Schism (De Origine ac Progressu Schismatis Anglicani) (Rome, 1585; ed. and trans. David Lewis, London, 1877).
Skelton, John: The Book of the Laurel (ed. Frank Walsh Brownlow, Delaware, 1990).
Sloane mss., British Library.
Smyth, John: The Berkeley Manuscripts: Lives of the Berkeleys (ed. Sir John Maclean, Gloucester, 1883).
State Papers of the Reign of Henry VIII (11 vols., Records Commissioners, 1831–52).
Statutes of the Realm (11 vols., Records Commissioners, London, 1810–28).
Stow, John: A Survey of London (London, 1598; Stroud, 1994).
Testimenta Vetusta (ed. Nicholas Harris Nicholas, London, 1826).
Thomas, William, Clerk of the Council to Edward VI: The Pilgrim: A Dialogue on the Life and Actions of King Henry the Eighth (1546; ed. James Anthony Froude, London, 1861).
Tillet, Jean du: Receuil des Rois de France (Paris, 1580).
Tottel’s Miscellany (ed. H.E. Rollins, Cambridge, Mass., 1965).
Weever, John: Ancient Funeral Monuments within the United Monarchies of Great Britain, Northern Ireland and the Islands Adjacent (London, 1631).
Worde, Wynkyn de: The Manner of the Triumph at Calais and Boulogne (London, 1532; printed in Tudor Tracts, ed. A. F. Pollard, London, 1903).
Wriothesley, Charles, Windsor Herald: A Chronicle of England in the Reigns of the Tudors from 1485 to 1559 (2 vols., ed. William Douglas Hamilton, Camden Society, 2nd Series, 10 and 20, 1875, 1877).
Wyatt, George: Extracts from the Life of the Virtuous, Christian and Renowned Queen Anne Boleigne (published privately, 1817, and publicly as an appendix to vol. 2 of S. W. Singer’s edition of George Cavendish’s The Life of Cardinal Wolsey, London, 1825).
SECONDARY SOURCES
Aikin, Lucy: Memoirs of the Court of Elizabeth, Queen of England (London, 1818).
Albert, Marvin H.: The Divorce (London, 1966).
Anne Boleyn (ed. Frederic P. Miller, Agnes F. Vandome, and John McBrewster, Mauritius, 2009).
Ashdown, Dulcie M.: Ladies in Waiting (London, 1976).
Asquith, Clare: Shadowplay: The Hidden Beliefs and Coded Politics of William Shakespeare (New York, 2005).
Astor, Gavin, 2nd Baron Astor of Hever: Hever in the 20th Century (no publisher cited, 1973; reprinted 2003).
Aungier, George James: The History and Antiquities of Syon Monastery, the Parish of Isleworth and the Chapelry of Hounslow (London, 1840).
Bagley, J. J.: Henry VIII and His Times (London, 1962).
Baker, John Austin: The Living Splendour of Westminster Abbey (Norwich, 1977).
Ball, W. E.: “Old Heraldic Glass in Brasted Church” (The Antiquary, 42, 1906).
/> Barnes, N., and Newman, L.: Transactions (Rochford Hundred Historical Society, 17, 1973).
Barnwell, Edward Lowry: Perrot Notes: Some Account of the Various Branches of the Perrot Family (London, 1867).
Barrett, C. R. B.: Essex: Highways, Byways and Waterways (London, 1893).
Beauclerk-Dewar, Peter, and Powell, Roger: Right Royal Bastards: The Fruits of Passion (Burke’s Peerage, 2006; republished as Royal Bastards: Illegitimate Children of the British Royal Family, Stroud, 2008).
Beckingsale, B. W.: Elizabeth I (London, 1963).
Bell, Doyne C.: Notices of the Historic Persons Buried in the Chapel of St. Peter ad Vincula in the Tower of London, with an Account of the Discovery of the Supposed Remains of Queen Anne Boleyn (London, 1877).
Benton, P.: The History of the Rochford Hundred (Rochford, 1882).
Bernard, G. W.: Anne Boleyn: Fatal Attractions (Yale, 2010).
Bernard, G. W.: The King’s Reformation: Henry VIII and the Making of the English Church (Yale, 2005).
Bernard, G. W.: “The Rise of Sir William Compton, Tudor Courtier” (English Historical Review, 96, 1981).
Bindoff, S. T.: The House of Commons, 1509–1558 (3 vols., London, 1982).
Birch, Thomas: Memoirs of the Reign of Queen Elizabeth (2 vols., London, 1754).
Black, J. B.: The Reign of Elizabeth, 1558–1603 (Oxford, 1959).
Blomefield, Francis, and Parkin, Charles: An essay towards a topographical description of the county of Norfolk, Vol. 6 (London, 1807).
The Book of Beauty, or Regal Gallery for 1848 (ed. the Countess of Blessington, London, 1848).
Borman, Tracy: Elizabeth’s Women: The Hidden Story of the Virgin Queen (London, 2009).
Bowle, John: Henry VIII: A Biography (London, 1965).
Brewer, J. S.: The Reign of Henry VIII: From His Accession to the Death of Wolsey, Vol. 2 (London, 1884).