Winter Tales: An Original Sinners Christmas Anthology

by Tiffany Reisz

  “You think I’m lying?”

  “I’m certain you had ulterior motives.”

  “Such as?”

  “Such as hurting me?” Søren said. “Do you deny that part of you wanted to hurt me and you knew this would do it?”

  “Are you asking me to forgive you or demanding I apologize?”

  “I don’t blame you for wanting to hurt me. I only told you because, were the situation reversed, I would—”

  “But the situation isn’t reversed, is it? It never is. You always hold every card. Every last fucking card while the rest of us stand around with nothing in our hands but our hearts.”

  “You accused me a thousand times of picking her over you,” Søren said. “You chose her over me that time. And now I know how much it hurts. I am sorry, Kingsley.”

  “So am I,” he said. “As always.”

  Kingsley turned and strode into the woods.

  “Where are you going?” Søren called out after him.

  “Anywhere you aren’t.”

  Four

  The Hawk and the Hare

  Kingsley walked away, shocked by the enormity of his own anger. He shook with it, breathed steam like a dragon, almost wanted a wolf to attack him so he could kill it with his bare hands.

  He headed west, in the direction of the cabin, his fury guiding his feet. He didn’t know for certain what he’d do when he got there. Probably get his phone and find the path to the road and take it on foot until someone picked him up and drove him to the nearest town. Of course Søren would bring him to the middle of nowhere to tell him this secret. Had they been home in New Orleans, Kingsley could have simply gotten into his car and driven away.

  If he couldn’t drive, he would walk. If he couldn’t walk, he’d crawl. Whatever it took to get away. He’d walk until he couldn’t walk anymore. He’d walk to Portland if he had to. Fuck it, he’d walk all the way to New York.

  He’d walk...

  “Ah, merde.” Kingsley stopped walking.

  He was lost.

  “Fuck. Fuck. Fuck.”

  He was lost.

  Again.

  He wasn’t scared. Not like he’d been that night long ago. He knew how to survive a night in the woods now. He had warm enough clothes on him to live out here if he had to. All he had to do was find a clearing and see where the moon was in the night sky, and he could get his bearings enough to find west. He could have used the compass on his phone, except he’d left it in his other coat pocket. Didn’t need it since he was with Søren, and it was almost dead.

  Except he would have liked to have it now.

  And his gun—he could always use his gun.

  Kingsley looked up through a break in the trees at the sky and did something he wouldn’t have thought himself capable of doing ten minutes earlier.

  He laughed.

  Ah, well, this is what he got for wishing to feel seventeen again.

  “God, you have a sick sense of humor,” Kingsley said.

  Then he heard a twig snap.

  “Case in point,” Kingsley said to God. Then he turned around. “You again?”

  “Did you think I would let you wander off into the forest?” Søren asked, stepping out of the woods.

  “That was the idea.”

  “Should I leave?” Søren asked. “You can take my compass. I know the way back without it. I’ll even lend you the lantern.”

  To prove he meant it, Søren set the lantern on the snow between them and placed the compass on top.

  “That way,” Søren said, pointing. “Road. Take it northwest and you’ll make it to a small town call St. Mary’s in three miles. Take it southeast, and you’ll be back at the cabin in thirty minutes.”

  Then he turned around and started to walk away.

  “Stop,” Kingsley said.

  Søren stopped, but didn’t turn.

  “This isn’t Simon Says,” Kingsley said. “You can turn around without me telling you.”

  “I’ve never taken orders from you before,” Søren said, turning to face him. “It was a novel experience.”

  “Go fuck yourself,” Kingsley said. “How’s that for an order?”

  “A logistical nightmare, fucking oneself. But I’ve always relished a challenge.”

  “You wanted me back.”

  “Yes.”

  “You wanted me back six years ago.”

  “Yes.”

  “You wanted me back six years ago and you didn’t tell me because I didn’t tell you about Wesley moving in with Nora.”

  “That sums it up nicely.”

  “You’re an asshole.”

  “I’ve never denied that,” Søren said.

  “You know, I might not have taken you back,” Kingsley said. “You skipped off to Syria to play Father Flanagan and my life went on just fine without you. I had Juliette. I had Nora. I had the clubs. Did you really expect me to jump back in bed with you the second you returned?”

  “Yes.”

  Kingsley laughed. He didn’t want to laugh, but he had to. But only because it was true. “You’re right,” he said. “I would have. But I would have hated myself after.”

  Søren said nothing.

  Kingsley sighed, exhaling steam along with his anger. “Are you as heartless as you seem to be sometimes?” he asked.

  “If I were heartless, I wouldn’t have been as devastated as I was to see Wesley moving in with Eleanor. I wouldn’t have been furious to think you two had purposefully kept such a secret from me. Especially since I asked you… No. I begged you to let me know how she was while I was gone. We stood together at the bottom of the stairs at your house and you promised me you would.”

  “I did,” Kingsley said.

  “But you didn’t keep your promise.”

  “No,” Kingsley said. “And I was wrong to break it. But you made certain to punish me, didn’t you?”

  “Yes,” Søren said. “Though I punished myself as well. I could have had you back, but through my own fault I lost you again. From where I stand, my loss was far greater than yours. You lost me. I lost you. And you’re worth much more than a billion dollars to me.”

  Kingsley swallowed hard. He didn’t realize until Søren had said all that how much he’d needed to hear it.

  He inhaled deeply and caught a scent in his nose. The scent of winter.

  “I love that smell,” Kingsley said.

  Søren closed his eyes and inhaled.

  “Snow,” Søren said. “Clean snow. Someone’s fireplace in the distance, probably ours. Pine needles. Moonlight. Starlight.”

  “You,” Kingsley said. “Smells just like you. Even when we’re making love and the room is hot as a sauna and I can’t tell your sweat from mine...your skin smells just like this.”

  Kingsley inhaled again. “I love the scent of winter,” he said. “I love the scent of winter enough to suffer the cold for it.”

  Søren exhaled heavily and steam rose like smoke from his lips and up, up into the sky. “Kingsley…”

  Kingsley waited for him to continue, but it seemed to be all Søren could say.

  “It’s not normal for a man to smell like snow,” Kingsley went on. Might as well, if they were being honest tonight. “I think sometimes you’re not quite human. Like you said, the night in the forest, our first time together, you weren’t chasing me like children chase each other, or lovers who play at running from each other only to run back. You were hunting me. Hunting me like a wolf. I never hated my dogs when they nipped at me. You keep Rottweilers as pets and you’ll get teeth marks in you from time to time. It’s simply in their nature and I loved them for that little bit of wild wolf in their blood. And you. Whatever you are. Why would I think I could fall in love with a wolf and never get bitten?”

  Kingsley paused, smiled. “That being said,” he continued, “I do love it when you bite me.”

  “Even when I break the skin?”

  “Especially then,” Kingsley said. “Answer this question, though. When you retur
ned from Syria, you came to see me first, you said. Not her. Why? Was it because I was closer?”

  “I didn’t fly into New York. I flew into Bradley. Claire has a house in Old Saybrook and I was planning on staying there with her a few days. Bradley, as you know, is in Connecticut. I was closer to Eleanor’s house than yours by an hour’s drive.”

  “Then why did you come to me first?”

  “Because she knew I loved her. You didn’t. And I felt I would die if I couldn’t tell you as soon as possible.”

  “Have you told her any of this?”

  “No.”

  “Will you?”

  “Eventually.”

  “She’ll forgive you in a heartbeat,” Kingsley said. “Forgive you without question, won’t she?”

  “I have no doubt that’s true,” Søren said.

  “She’s self-aware. A gift. She knows the pain she’s caused others. She’s quick to forgive because she wants to be forgiven.”

  “Something about that in the Bible,” Søren said. “If I had my collar on, I’d tell you the exact verse, but I’m off-duty tonight.”

  Kingsley smiled. “But when you tell her…will you tell her you came to me first?”

  “I will if you ask me to. If you need her to know that, I will tell her.”

  “It will hurt her.”

  “Yes, it undoubtedly will,” Søren said. “And I’ve already hurt her deeply this year. But that’s what we do, the three of us. Hurt each other.”

  “Don’t tell her. Let her think you came to her first. I know you love me. I don’t need you to hurt her to prove that to me. I love her, too.”

  “Can you forgive me?” Søren asked. “You don’t have to tonight. But it would mean a great deal to me if you’d consider forgiving me eventually.”

  “I forgive you. Of course I do.” Kingsley paused to inhale another deep beautiful breath of pure winter air. “I thought of telling you so you would know what you were coming home to. But I was afraid that if you knew about him, that he was moving in with her, you might not come back to us at all. You thought I didn’t tell you out of vengeance. The fact is, I didn’t tell you out of cowardice.”

  “She had every right to love him and live with Wesley. You had every right not to tell me about him. And while I had every right to be hurt, I didn’t have the right to take my pain out on you and her like I did.”

  “Would you have come back if you’d known about him?”

  “Yes. For you.”

  “Ah, now you tell me.”

  Søren grinned. “Let me make it up to you,” he said. “Name it.”

  “All I want is for you to take me back to the cabin and beat me and fuck me within an inch of my life.”

  “The French use the metric system,” Søren said.

  “A millimeter then,” Kingsley said.

  “That can be arranged,” Søren said softly, and then kissed him within a millimeter of his life. “This way.”

  Kingsley followed him southwest through the woods until they reached a narrow country road. On one side stood forest. On the other, a snow-covered field edged with white-tipped shrubs and outlined by a barbwire fence.

  They made quick progress on the road. They could go much faster when they didn’t have to watch every step.

  “Can I ask a follow-up question?” Kingsley said. Søren nodded. “Why tell me now? Did you just forget to tell me you were in love with me six years ago? Were you having a blond moment?”

  Søren smiled but didn’t laugh. “Too many secrets, I suppose,” he said. “They’re weighing heavily on me. And Eleanor, too. We had to clear the air recently of a few secrets we’d been keeping from each other. It was harrowing to say the least, but we both felt better once we’d done it.”

  “You said you’d hurt her already this year? What happened?”

  “I kept one secret too many from her. She found something in my Bible I’d never shown her, nor had I planned to show her. Habit, I suppose. All three of us have to keep secrets in our work. I don’t know anything about any of Eleanor’s clients anymore. Or your work at your new club.”

  “That’s for your own good. Plausible deniability.”

  “Unfortunately we three have gotten so good at keeping secrets, we keep them from each other even when we don’t have to. Even when we shouldn’t.” Søren stopped and faced the woods. “We have as many secrets from each other as there are trees in that forest. No wonder we all keep getting lost.”

  “Who’s getting lost, Søren?” Kingsley asked. He knew that look on Søren’s face. He wore it when his mind and his heart were elsewhere, across the ocean, where his son lived. Kingsley knew that look because he’d worn it himself every day since learning about Nico.

  “Fionn,” Søren said at last.

  “Fionn? I don’t think he has any secrets.”

  “He is the secret. That’s the trouble.”

  “You’re a priest. He has to be a secret.”

  “Does he?”

  “I don’t know,” Kingsley said. “You tell me. What are you thinking of?”

  “I’m considering telling my superiors about Fionn,” Søren said.

  Kingsley’s eyes went wide with shock. This was unexpected news.

  “Won’t there be consequences?” Kingsley asked. What he wanted to ask was, Are you out of your fucking mind?

  “Undoubtedly. Jesuits aren’t supposed to go around fathering children. Then again, they aren’t supposed to do a lot of things I do. Best case scenario, I’ll be asked to take a long leave of absence. Worst case—excommunication. But that’s highly unlikely. Whatever happens, it won’t be pleasant.”

  “Why do you think they need to know?” Kingsley asked.

  “Not them. Fionn.”

  “Fionn needs to know?”

  “Last week, I was at your house,” Søren said. “And Céleste needed help tying her shoes. She came to you and stuck her feet in your face.”

  “She does that. Often.”

  “I watched you tie her shoes and it was such a simple thing. The child who needed help running to her father. Her father helping her without giving it a second thought. It’s how it should be, isn’t it? Since then, I can’t stop thinking, What if Fionn needs my help someday? When he’s ten or eleven or fifteen or sixteen… What if he wants to talk to me but is afraid to because he believes he’s my dirty little secret? I need him to know he can come to me. I need him to know he’s not something that has to stay hidden.

  “You and Eleanor chose to be with me knowing I was a priest. Eleanor knew we could never marry and have children. You knew that I’d have to introduce you as my brother-in-law if you wanted to be part of my life. But Fionn had no choice in this. And someday he may need help, the sort of help only I can give him.”

  Kingsley sighed. For a long moment, the only sound was their boots crunching across the snow.

  “You know,” Kingsley said. “Nico and I are exactly the same height. Same belt size. Same shoe size. Same size hands. Nora even says we—”

  “I hope this isn’t going where I think it is.”

  Kingsley laughed. “She says we stand the same way,” he said. “What I’m saying is he takes after me. It must scare you to think Fionn might take after you in ways you’d prefer he didn’t.”

  “I pray about it every day,” Søren said. “I pray for him.”

  “Does God ever answer?”

  “Not in words. Only in joy. There were four times in my life I felt utterly certain God was real and He was pointing His finger into my life, telling me what path to take. The day I met you. The day I joined the Jesuits. The day I met Eleanor. The night I fathered Fionn. All four of those moments fill me with the deepest peace and the most incredible joy when I think of them. Fionn especially, since I know what joy he’s given Grace and Zachary.”

  “And the joy he’s given me and Nora,” Kingsley said.

  “And me,” Søren said.

  Kingsley smiled, and felt a glowing warmth inside him. “It’s
good to hear you talk about him. You don’t very often.”

  “We’ve been in a magnificent snowy forest for over three hours and you haven’t once said it’s beautiful.”

  Kingsley shrugged. “What can I say? What words would do it justice?”

  Søren nodded. “My point exactly.”

  “There’s really a chance you’ll be kicked out of the order when you tell them about Fionn?” Kingsley asked.

  “Grace is married. It was adultery.”

  “She had her husband’s permission to be with someone else.”

  “Even the most liberal people have trouble understanding the concept of the marital free pass. You’re asking a lot of the Jesuits.”

  “She was a woman desperate to have a baby. I know how she felt. It was nothing more than sperm donation.”

  “We had sex, Kingsley.”

  “So it was sperm donation the old-fashioned way. We’d all been through hell that week. Any angel would have fallen.”

  “I appreciate your defense of my indefensible behavior. But the simple fact is, I knew the rules, I broke them, and now I must accept the consequences.”

  “Do you want me to try to talk you out of telling them?” Kingsley asked.

  “Only if you think I’m doing the wrong thing. If I were expelled from the order or excommunicated, Fionn might blame himself the way children always blame themselves for the sins of their parents. I would never want that. And I would never want anyone in the Church telling Fionn he was conceived in sin. I knew a priest in Rome who left the clergy to marry, and both his wife and his children were treated very cruelly.”

  Søren took a breath, and Kingsley saw his eyes were clouded with concern.

  “He’s a child,” Søren continued. “He should never be the center of a scandal. This is why I’m so torn. You’re a father. What’s your advice?”

  His advice? Søren was asking his advice? It was an awesome responsibility, advising Søren about something with such potentially life-altering consequences. Kingsley was inclined to demur. He considered Søren’s calling to the Church something between him and God alone.

  But tonight he would speak. Kingsley had held Fionn and wept with the joy Søren had spoken of so movingly, the deep joy nothing and no one could touch. So he knew the answer to this question. He knew it as if God were whispering it in his ear and all Kingsley had to do was open his mouth and God’s good true counsel would come out.