Deep Waters

by Martin Edwards

  Or, rather, former friends. For now they were divided by abysses of hatred, crime, and a sudden welling up of unbelievable possibilities from their hidden hearts.

  And then suddenly Hopkins burst out laughing. A hard, dry, cold laugh so that at first they thought he had gone mad. Both the listeners felt their flesh creep.

  ‘For God’s sake, what is it, Hopkins?’ cried Leathart.

  ‘What fools we’ve been! What utter fools!’ And now they saw that he was waving the crumpled chemist’s bill.

  ‘Look at the date on that! See? July 13!

  ‘All July 13 we three were at Aintree races, 200 miles from this shop. The poor fool! He left this vital clue! Didn’t notice it, I expect, when he tore off the brown paper wrapping.’

  ‘But what do you mean?’

  ‘Pickering killed himself!’ shouted Hopkins joyously. ‘He was hoist with his own petard, with a vengeance! He tried to poison Leathart out of jealousy, and he had everything prepared to throw the blame on Garrett, so as to cover his tracks.

  ‘After doping the brandy, he dropped the bottle in the drawer and locked it with a private key—for, as owner, he would have second keys of all lockers. Meanwhile, he had Garrett’s letter, which he would produce at the right moment to prove that Garrett owed Leathart money, and so supply a motive.

  ‘He must have been hatching the scheme months before. Perhaps as soon as he got Garrett’s letter he saw how it could be used. He must have invited us to go on this trip for that very purpose—you remember we were all a bit surprised by the invitation.

  ‘And he must have been waiting for the first meal that would give him an opportunity for his diabolical scheme; but, thanks to the weather, it wasn’t until we beat into Vigo Harbour this afternoon that we sat down together.

  ‘Then he dropped the poison in Leathart’s glass; and our dear old Glutton, with his immortal idiocy, swapped the glasses and made the devil drink his own medicine.’

  Hopkins’ words died away. Leathart gave a strangled groan of relief. Then there was silence for a few moments.

  When the wake of another passing ship rocked the yacht, when once again the shaft of sunlight came groping in, it lit the contented faces of three friends and glittered on their upraised glasses, toasting a friendship that had struck dirty weather and come near being cast away, but, at the last moment, had managed to claw off the rocks and make harbour.

  The Turn of the Tide

  C. S. Forester

  Few authors are as closely associated with sea stories as Cecil Scott Forester (1899–1966), creator of Horatio Hornblower, an officer in the Royal Navy during the Napoleonic era. The success of the Hornblower series has meant that it is sometimes forgotten that Forester, whose real name was Cecil Louis Troughton Smith, also wrote three notable crime novels. Payment Deferred (1926) anticipates the ironic tone and plotting of Malice Aforethought, a more famous novel by Francis Iles which was published five years later. Plain Murder (1930), about advertising men who turn to crime, has a similar flavour. Astonishingly, The Pursued, a fascinating novel written in 1935, was lost and forgotten, as Forester concentrated on Hornblower. The manuscript resurfaced in the twenty-first century, and the book was finally published in 2011.

  Forester’s occasional ventures into the crime short story are well worth reading. A good example is ‘The Letters in Evidence’, also known as ‘The Editor Regrets’, first published in 1937. ‘The Turn of the Tide’ originally appeared in The Story-Teller in April 1936. For all Hornblower’s popularity, it is a matter for regret that this talented writer did not contribute more to the crime genre.

  ‘What always beats them in the end,’ said Dr Matthews, ‘is how to dispose of the body. But, of course, you know that as well as I do.’

  ‘Yes,’ said Slade. He had, in fact, been devoting far more thought to what Dr Matthews believed to be this accidental subject of conversation than Dr Matthews could ever guess.

  ‘As a matter of fact,’ went on Dr Matthews, warming to the subject to which Slade had so tactfully led him, ‘it’s a terribly knotty problem. It’s so difficult, in fact, that I always wonder why anyone is fool enough to commit murder.’

  All very well for you, thought Slade, but he did not allow his thoughts to alter his expression. You smug, self-satisfied old ass! You don’t know the sort of difficulties a man can be up against.

  ‘I’ve often thought the same,’ he said.

  ‘Yes,’ went on Dr Matthews, ‘it’s the body that does it, every time. To use poison calls for special facilities, which are good enough to hang you as soon as suspicion is roused. And that suspicion—well, of course, part of my job is to detect poisoning. I don’t think anyone can get away with it, nowadays, even with the most dunderheaded general practitioner.’

  ‘I quite agree with you,’ said Slade. He had no intention of using poison.

  ‘Well,’ went on Dr Matthews, developing his logical argument, ‘if you rule out poison, you rule out the chance of getting the body disposed of under the impression that the victim died a natural death. The only other way, if a man cares to stand the racket of having the body to give evidence against him, is to fake things to look like suicide. But you know, and I know, that it just can’t be done.

  ‘The mere fact of suicide calls for a close examination, and no one has ever been able to fix things so well as to get away with it. You’re a lawyer. You’ve probably read a lot of reports on trials where the murderer has tried it on. And you know what’s happened to them.’

  ‘Yes,’ said Slade.

  He certainly had given a great deal of consideration to the matter. It was only after long thought that he had, finally, put aside the notion of disposing of young Spalding and concealing his guilt by a sham suicide.

  ‘That brings us to where we started, then,’ said Dr Matthews. ‘The only other thing left is to try and conceal the body. And that’s more difficult still.’

  ‘Yes,’ said Slade. But he had a perfect plan for disposing of the body.

  ‘A human body,’ said Dr Matthews, ‘is a most difficult thing to get rid of. That chap Oscar Wilde, in that book of his—Dorian Gray, isn’t it?—gets rid of one by the use of chemicals. Well, I’m a chemist as well as a doctor, and I wouldn’t like the job.’

  ‘No?’ said Slade, politely.

  Dr Matthews was not nearly as clever a man as himself, he thought.

  ‘There’s altogether too much of it,’ said Dr Matthews. ‘It’s heavy, and it’s bulky, and it’s bound to undergo corruption. Think of all those poor devils who’ve tried it. Bodies in trunks, and bodies in coal-cellars, and bodies in chicken-runs. You can’t hide the thing, try as you will.’

  Can’t I? That’s all you know, thought Slade, but aloud he said: ‘You’re quite right. I’ve never thought about it before.’

  ‘Of course, you haven’t,’ agreed Dr Matthews. ‘Sensible people don’t, unless it’s an incident of their profession, as in my case.

  ‘And yet, you know,’ he went on, meditatively, ‘there’s one decided advantage about getting rid of the body altogether. You’re much safer, then. It’s a point which ought to interest you, as a lawyer, more than me. It’s rather an obscure point of law, but I fancy there are very definite rulings on it. You know what I’m referring to?’

  ‘No, I don’t,’ said Slade, genuinely puzzled.

  ‘You can’t have a trial for murder unless you can prove there’s a victim,’ said Dr Matthews. ‘There’s got to be a corpus delicti, as you lawyers say in your horrible dog-Latin. A corpse, in other words, even if it’s only a bit of one, like that which hanged Crippen. No corpse, no trial. I think that’s good law, isn’t it?’

  ‘By jove, you’re right!’ said Slade. ‘I wonder why that hadn’t occurred to me before?’

  No sooner were the words out of his mouth than he regretted having said them. He did his best to make his face i
mmobile again; he was afraid lest his expression might have hinted at his pleasure in discovering another very reassuring factor in this problem of killing young Spalding. But Dr Matthews had noticed nothing.

  ‘Well, as I said, people only think about these things if they’re incidental to their profession,’ he said. ‘And, all the same, it’s only a theoretical piece of law. The entire destruction of a body is practically impossible. But, I suppose, if a man could achieve it, he would be all right. However strong the suspicion was against him, the police couldn’t get him without a corpse. There might be a story in that, Slade, if you or I were writers.’

  ‘Yes,’ assented Slade, and laughed harshly.

  There never would be any story about the killing of young Spalding, the insolent pup.

  ‘Well,’ said Dr Matthews, ‘we’ve had a pretty gruesome conversation, haven’t we? And I seem to have done all the talking, somehow. That’s the result, I suppose, Slade, of the very excellent dinner you gave me. I’d better push off now. Not that the weather is very inviting.’

  Nor was it. As Slade saw Dr Matthews into his car, the rain was driving down in a real winter storm, and there was a bitter wind blowing.

  ‘Shouldn’t be surprised if this turned to snow before morning,’ were Dr Matthews’s last words before he drove off.

  Slade was glad it was such a tempestuous night. It meant that, more certainly than ever, there would be no one out in the lanes, no one out on the sands when he disposed of young Spalding’s body.

  Back in his drawing-room Slade looked at the clock. There was still an hour to spare; he could spend it making sure that his plans were all correct.

  He looked up the tide tables. Yes, that was right enough. Spring tides. The lowest of low water on the sands. There was not so much luck about that. Young Spalding came back on the midnight train every Wednesday night, and it was not surprising that, sooner or later, the Wednesday night would coincide with a Spring tide. But it was lucky that this particular Wednesday night should be one of tempest; luckier still that low water should be at one-thirty, the best time for him.

  He opened the drawing-room door and listened carefully. He could not hear a sound. Mrs Dumbleton, his housekeeper, must have been in bed some time now. She was as deaf as a post, anyway, and would not hear his departure. Nor his return, when Spalding had been killed and disposed of.

  The hands of the clock seemed to be moving very fast. He must make sure everything was correct. The plough chain and the other iron weights were already in the back seat of the car; he had put them there before old Matthews arrived to dine. He slipped on his overcoat.

  From his desk, Slade took a curious little bit of apparatus; eighteen inches of strong cord, tied at each end to a six-inch length of wood so as to make a ring. He made a last close examination to see that the knots were quite firm, and then he put it in his pocket; as he did so, he ran through in his mind, the words—he knew them by heart—of the passage in the book about the Thugs of India, describing the method of strangulation employed by them.

  He could think quite coldly about all this. Young Spalding was a pestilent busybody. A word from him, now, could bring ruin upon Slade, could send him to prison, could have him struck off the rolls.

  Slade thought of other defaulting solicitors he had heard of, even one or two with whom he had come into contact professionally. He remembered his brother-solicitors’ remarks about them, pitying or contemptuous. He thought of having to beg his bread in the streets on his release from prison, of cold and misery and starvation. The shudder which shook him was succeeded by a hot wave of resentment. Never, never, would he endure it.

  What right had young Spalding, who had barely been qualified two years, to condemn a grey-haired man twenty years his senior to such a fate? If nothing but death would stop him, then he deserved to die. He clenched his hand on the cord in his pocket.

  A glance at the clock told him he had better be moving. He turned out the lights and tiptoed out of the house, shutting the door quietly. The bitter wind flung icy rain into his face, but he did not notice it.

  He pushed the car out of the garage by hand, and, contrary to his wont, he locked the garage doors, as a precaution against the infinitesimal chance that, on a night like this, someone should notice that his car was out.

  He drove cautiously down the road. Of course, there was not a soul about in a quiet place like this. The few street-lamps were already extinguished.

  There were lights in the station as he drove over the bridge; they were awaiting there the arrival of the twelve-thirty train. Spalding would be on that. Every Wednesday he went over to his subsidiary office, sixty miles away. Slade turned into the lane a quarter of a mile beyond the station, and then reversed his car so that it pointed towards the road. He put out the sidelights, and settled himself to wait; his hand fumbled with the cord in his pocket.

  The train was a little late. Slade had been waiting a quarter of an hour when he saw the lights of the train emerge from the cutting and come to a standstill in the station. So wild was the night that he could hear nothing of it. Then the train moved slowly out again. As soon as it was gone, the lights in the station began to go out, one by one; Hobson, the porter, was making ready to go home, his turn of duty completed.

  Next, Slade’s straining ears heard footsteps.

  Young Spalding was striding down the road. With his head bent before the storm, he did not notice the dark mass of the motor car in the lane, and he walked past it.

  Slade counted up to two hundred, slowly, and then he switched on his lights, started the engine, and drove the car out into the road in pursuit. He saw Spalding in the light of the headlamps and drew up alongside.

  ‘Is that Spalding?’ he said, striving to make the tone of his voice as natural as possible. ‘I’d better give you a lift, old man, hadn’t I?’

  ‘Thanks very much,’ said Spalding. ‘This isn’t the sort of night to walk two miles in.’

  He climbed in and shut the door. No one had seen. No one would know. Slade let his clutch out, drove slowly down the road.

  ‘Bit of luck, seeing you,’ he said. ‘I was just on my way home from bridge at Mrs Clay’s when I saw the train come in and remembered it was Wednesday and you’d be walking home. So I thought I’d turn a bit out of my way to take you along.’

  ‘Very good of you, I’m sure,’ said Spalding.

  ‘As a matter of fact,’ said Slade, speaking slowly and driving slowly, ‘it wasn’t altogether disinterested. I wanted to talk business to you, as it happened.’

  ‘Rather an odd time to talk business,’ said Spalding. ‘Can’t it wait till tomorrow?’

  ‘No, it cannot,’ said Slade. ‘It’s about the Lady Vere trust.’

  ‘Oh, yes. I wrote to remind you last week that you had to make delivery?’

  ‘Yes, you did. And I told you, long before that, that it would be inconvenient, with Hammond abroad.’

  ‘I don’t see that,’ said Spalding. ‘I don’t see that Hammond’s got anything to do with it. Why can’t you just hand over and have done with it? I can’t do anything to straighten things up until you do.’

  ‘As I said, it would be inconvenient.’

  Slade brought the car to a standstill at the side of the road.

  ‘Look here, Spalding,’ he said desperately, ‘I’ve never asked a favour of you before. But now I ask you, as a favour, to forgo delivery for a bit. Just for three months, Spalding.’

  But Slade had small hope that his request would be granted. So little hope, in fact, that he brought his left hand out of his pocket holding the piece of wood, with the loop of cord dangling from its ends. He put his arm round the back of Spalding’s seat.

  ‘No, I can’t, really I can’t,’ said Spalding. ‘I’ve got my duty to my clients to consider. I’m sorry to insist, but you’re quite well aware of what my duty is.’

 
‘Yes,’ said Slade, ‘but I beg of you to wait. I implore you to wait, Spalding. There! Perhaps you can guess why, now.’

  ‘I see,’ said Spalding, after a long pause.

  ‘I only want three months,’ pressed Slade. ‘Just three months. I can get straight again in three months.’

  Spalding had known other men who had had the same belief in their ability to get straight in three months. It was unfortunate for Slade—and for Spalding—that Slade had used those words. Spalding hardened his heart.

  ‘No,’ he said. ‘I can’t promise anything like that. I don’t think it’s any use continuing this discussion. Perhaps I’d better walk home from here.’

  He put his hand to the latch of the door, and as he did so, Slade jerked the loop of cord over his head. A single turn of Slade’s wrist—a thin, bony, old man’s wrist, but as strong as steel in that wild moment—tightened the cord about Spalding’s throat.

  Slade swung round in his seat, getting both hands to the piece of wood, twisting madly. His breath hissed between his teeth with the effort, but Spalding never drew breath at all. He lost consciousness long before he was dead. Only Slade’s grip of the cord round his throat prevented the dead body from falling forward, doubled up.

  Nobody had seen, nobody would know. And what that book had stated about the method of assassination practised by Thugs was perfectly correct.

  Slade had gained, now, the time in which he could get his affairs in order. With all the promise of his current speculations, with all his financial ability, he would be able to recoup himself for his past losses. It only remained to dispose of Spalding’s body, and he had planned to do that very satisfactorily. Just for a moment Slade felt as if all this were only some heated dream, some nightmare, but then he came back to reality and went on with the plan he had in mind.

  He pulled the dead man’s knees forward so that the corpse lay back in the seat, against the side of the car. He put the car in gear, let in his clutch, and drove rapidly down the road—much faster than when he had been arguing with Spalding. Low water was in three-quarters of an hour’s time, and the sands were ten miles away.