Theirs To Protect: a Reverse Harem Romance

by Stasia Black

  More likely, they were dead. And it was the second party this month not to come home.

  He should be out there. He’d never stayed in the township this long. Things were supposed to be stabilizing under President Goddard’s government, but in Nix’s experience, disappearing resources—as they became more centralized and regulated—just made marginalized people more desperate.

  Nix’s jaw hardened as he walked into the kitchen. He should be out there with his men. Instead he was stuck with the precious little princess who thought she had it so tough here in town with food and shelter and plenty of water to drink.

  Nix looked around. Where the hell was everybody anyway?

  Were they out back at the cookstove trying to make something her highness would deign to eat? Or were they upstairs trying to coax her out of her weeklong tantrum?

  A quick glance out the back kitchen door showed no one was out there.

  Nix shook his head and went back to the living room to trot up the stairs to the second story.

  Which was when he heard them.

  And realized exactly what was going on.

  He ground his teeth together even as his cock hardened in his jeans. He pushed the door open and saw Audrey riding Graham like he was a goddamned bucking bronco.

  With Clark’s hand buried up her ass.

  Nix got there just in time, too, because she howled as she came. Graham’s eyes rolled back in his head like he was gonna fuckin’ pass out, Audrey’s pussy was so magical.

  But it wasn’t magical.

  It was just a pussy like any other. The fact that it was the only one they had access to had driven them all stupid for a while.

  Even him. He’d admit it. He’d gone soft in the head. Thinking all sorts of stupid shit on their wedding night. Forgetting that everybody was only out for themselves. But her running away had shown her true colors and brought him back to his senses.

  He was back in his right mind and he saw her for what she was. A user. A smart, manipulative user. After she realized escape wasn’t going to work, she’d done everything possible to get them eating out of her hand again. Starting with that sucker, Mateo.

  It looked like she’d finally decided it was time to pull the rest of them back in to her little web.

  Well, she could try, but he saw through her.

  “Clark,” Nix snapped as he stomped over to the bed, unbuckling his belt as he went. “Help me lift her up.”

  Audrey’s head swung his direction, her bright blue eyes going wide. That’s right, little girl. It’s time to pay the piper.

  Clark stood and, taking Audrey’s arms, helped her off the bed. She was naked. Fuck. Nix’d forgotten how perfect her body was. Those full, rounded breasts, her tapered little waist flaring out into that wide, fuckable ass. She followed Clark’s lead and got off the bed, eyes on Nix the whole time.

  She wasn’t the only one.

  Mateo climbed off the bed and hurried around, getting right in Nix’s face. “Don’t you dare give her a hard time.”

  Nix tried to shove him out of the way but Mateo just kept stubbornly just stepping back in between him and Audrey.

  Until she put a hand on Mateo’s shoulder. “It’s okay, Mateo,” she said, her voice soft. Mateo looked over his shoulder and they seemed to communicate something in the gaze.

  Nix shook his head in disgust. Fucking wrapped around her little finger.

  “You upset her and you’ll have me to deal with,” Mateo said.

  Nix rolled his eyes but then Danny piped up. “Me too.”

  Graham struggled to a sitting position. “And me.”

  Nix held his hands up. “As terrifying as three naked men are with their dicks swinging in the wind, I think me and our wife can manage a civil conversation.”

  “Just a conversation?” Audrey asked, a challenge in her eyes. She glanced down his body to his unbuckled belt. “Seems to me like you came in here with more than talking on your mind.”

  “Depends.” He curled one edge of his mouth up in a smirk as he met her gaze. “You callin’ it quits on your dramatics?”

  Her eyes flared with fury and Nix’s smirk turned to an all-out grin.

  “Depends,” she said, her voice full of challenge while she cocked her head to one side. “You gonna stop being an asshole?”

  Nix’s grin dropped off his face. He reached out and slid one hand around the back of her neck. Then he drew her sharply forward and whispered in her ear. “I think you like it when I’m an asshole.”

  He didn’t miss the way her breath hitched at the action. Or the fact that his camouflage security shirt was rubbing against her bared nipples, making them harden.

  “I bet you’ve missed me so much you’ve had blue balls for weeks,” she whispered back, hand snaking between their stomachs and into his pants.

  Fuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuck. It took everything Nix had not to grind against her hand when she wrapped her firm little fingers around his shaft. Okay, so maybe he’d underestimated or forgotten just how tempting she could be.

  But that was fine. They could enjoy each other’s bodies. It didn’t mean he trusted her or had to give her any more than that.

  “I bet you’d just love it if I did.” He shoved his pants down his legs and kicked them off. “You love torturing men, don’t you? It’s what gets you off.” Then he took Audrey in his arms and hiked her up. She yelped in surprise but wrapped her legs around his waist.

  “Clark,” Nix said, nodding over Audrey’s shoulder and gesturing him to come closer. A wide grin broke across Clark’s face.

  “Thought you’d never ask,” he said, coming up behind Audrey’s back and helping Nix support her weight.

  “We’re gonna fuck you now,” Nix said, staring straight into Audrey’s eyes as he held her aloft. “Both of us. You get what that means?”

  Audrey gasped and looked behind her at Clark, chest heaving.

  “Shh,” Clark said, pushing a stray curl behind her ear with one hand. “Just like this baby, but it’ll be my cock.”

  Nix had guessed Clark had been fingering her ass just like earlier and his words confirmed it.

  Audrey blinked, eyes wide and eyebrow furrowed. She swallowed hard, then said, “I trust you.”

  Nix barely bit back his scoff. He had to hand it to her. She had the scared, vulnerable act down cold.

  Let’s see how good an actress still is with his and Clark’s cocks destroying her pussy at the same time.

  Nix felt around. She was plenty slick down there, with her own natural wetness combined with Graham’s cum. Nix didn’t know who else she’d fucked before he’d gotten there.

  But he’d be the last and he’d make sure to be the most memorable.

  Flexing his biceps, he hefted her body up in his arms just enough to line up his cock with her entrance. Inch by inch, he lowered her down on his cock.

  Her eyes shot wide. “I forgot how big—” Her choked whisper broke off as her arms squeezed tight around his neck and she buried her head into his chest.

  Nix’s cock flexed as soon as he was balls deep and he squeezed her ass. Shiiiiiit. For a second he had to close his eyes against how good it felt. He’d forgotten. It had only been three weeks but he’d forgotten. Maybe on purpose.

  Because if he’d remembered it felt this fucking good, he would have been joining Mateo on the goddamned floor, begging her to take them back every second of every goddamned day.

  He tried to reject the thought as soon as he had it.

  No. She was a manipulator. She was—

  “I’m gonna come in now too, beautiful.” Clark’s voice was low and raspy.

  Nix lifted Audrey and dropped her, wanting one more moment where she was only his. And then he felt her whole body go tense as Clark stepped closer from behind.

  “Relax,” Nix whispered. “Shh, it’s gonna be okay, honey. Just relax.”

  What the fuck was coming out of his mouth? But he couldn’t stand the thought of her hurting. That was just him being decent.
He was a decent guy, that was all.

  “I promise, baby,” Clark said, dragging his mouth along the back of Audrey’s neck, “if you thought what I did earlier felt good, this will blow your fucking mind. Having both of us take you at once, it’ll be like nothing you’ve ever felt before.”

  Audrey sucked in a deep breath and, looking into Nix’s eyes, repeated, “I trust you.” Then she frowned slightly before her eyes widened and the softest fucking smile lit her face. Like she’d just had some realization. Her eyes glowed with warmth. “You’ll keep me safe. I trust you.”

  Then suddenly Nix was the one who couldn’t breathe, Roxy’s voice ringing in his head: You know why I’m not afraid? Because I’m with you. And you’ll never let anything bad happen to me.

  “You’re so beautiful, baby,” Clark said from behind, dissolving the memory of Roxy’s voice. “That’s right, keep nice and relaxed like that. Shit. Oh fuck, baby, that’s right, let me in. Holy shit. Holy shit, baby, your ass is so tight. Do you have any idea how amazing it feels to fuck this tight little ass?”

  Audrey’s chest heaved against Nix’s and she sounded out of breath when she gasped. “Now you. Move, Nix. Oh God, move so I can feel both of you together.”

  Aw fuck, she was killing him. Nix was completely back in the moment. Did she have any fucking idea how hot she was? How amazing she was, taking both their cocks and asking for more?

  Nix pulled his hips back and then pushed back in again. And holy mother of Christ but he could feel the fullness provided by Clark’s cock. It made it feel like she was squeezing around Nix’s shaft twice as hard.

  “Oh fuck. Aud, you’re so—” Nix broke off, not even knowing how to finish the sentence.

  Audrey pulled back, her arms still around his neck. And for several long moments, they just fucked, slow and deep, gazes locked.

  And he couldn’t keep more than two thoughts together in his head.

  There were things about her that he… He wasn’t supposed to… She was—

  Beautiful.

  Perfect.

  All that mattered.

  He leaned in and kissed her hard. She kissed him back just as hungrily, groaning into his mouth and digging her nails into his shoulders when Clark started fucking her so vigorously her body was thrust repetitively into Nix’s.

  And it was clear by the way she dropped her head back the next moment that she loved it.

  Goddamn she was perfect.

  She reached one arm out back toward the bed the next second. Her eyes were still squeezed shut in pleasure as she called out, “Danny. Mateo. Graham. I need all of you.”

  Then put her arm back around Nix’s neck, thrusting her pelvis against his as she sought her pleasure.

  Within seconds, the other men were surrounding them where they stood in the middle of the room. Mateo reached in to pinch at Audrey’s nipples. Graham dropped to a crouch, looking upwards from underneath, no doubt to watch Nix’s and Clark’s cocks disappearing into Audrey’s two holes. Danny pulled Audrey’s face slightly to the side so he could kiss her.

  In between kisses, she gasped, “Touch yourselves. All of you.”

  Goddammit, Nix was gonna blow.

  The thought of all of them, fucking as one… Plus Audrey’s tight pussy and the pressure of Clark’s cock—

  Just like that, Nix was over the edge.

  “Come with me,” he shouted to Audrey.

  But it was like she’d felt him coming, because her face was already scrunched, her mouth dropped open. Then her entire body spasmed around his cock. Her pussy milked Nix so good, so fucking good he’d thought he’d pass the fuck out.

  But he didn’t. He stayed on his feet and between him and Clark, who seemed to have come simultaneously with him and Audrey, they kept Audrey in their arms.

  “Spread her legs,” Nix growled to Clark.

  Nix didn’t know if Clark knew what he had in mind, but he followed Nix’s instruction.

  Together, they spun Audrey so that her back was to their chests and, Nix taking one half and Clark the other, they held her up so that her legs were wide open, knees out. Exposing her pussy that was dripping with Nix’s cum. And maybe Clark’s too, dripping down from her ass.

  “Shoot your cum on our wife’s sweet pussy,” he ordered the other three men. “Mark her as ours.”

  The words were barely out of his mouth before Danny’s cock was right at the lips of Audrey’s pussy. He was artless but enthusiastic as he jerked his cock roughly, quickly shooting ropes of thick cum messily all over her pussy.

  “Fuck,” Clark muttered. “I’m gonna get hard again and be ready for round two if this keeps up.”

  Graham was up next. He pushed his glasses up his nose with his eyebrows scrunched in concentration, gaze locked on Audrey’s dripping cunt.

  He was jerking lazily at his cock like it was almost an afterthought but the closer Nix looked, he realized he was muttering numbers to himself. He rubbed his cock up and down Audrey’s slit like a metronome and soon had her shuddering with need.

  Graham’s concentration seemed to focus even more and he centered his attentions with the head of his cock on her clit, rubbing circles around and then back and forth. It was only when she came with a breathy moan that Graham shot his load on her, soaking her curls with pearly, creamy cum that dripped down to combine with everyone else’s.

  Feeling her shudder in their arms had Nix completely hard again. His arms were starting to get tired, but he’d hold her for a week if it was possible so they could all just keep fucking and fucking and fucking her.

  Mateo stepped up last.

  Audrey’s head had been dropped back onto Nix’s chest after her last orgasm, but she lifted it when Mateo approached.

  “Come in me,” she whispered. “I haven’t felt your cock inside me yet, Mateo. Please.”

  Mateo swallowed hard and when he looked back up at her, Nix thought the dumb fuck was gonna make some excuse.

  Instead, he just repeated Audrey’s earlier words. “I trust you.”

  And then he stepped up to Audrey, his cock standing straight out from his body. Audrey’s arms were wrapped around Nix and Clark’s neck so she couldn’t help put him inside her.

  Mateo had to make the choice to guide his own cock into Audrey’s cum-slick channel. And finally, he did. Almost immediately, his eyes rolled back like Audrey’s pussy was fucking paradise. Not far off, buddy, Nix thought.

  Mateo didn’t make a big affair of it.

  He fucked their wife with deep, slow strokes. He dropped a hand between them so that Audrey came in a minute flat.

  But that wasn’t enough for Mateo. Right after her spasms finished, he was whispering, “That’s right. Now give me another one. I know you’ve got it in you. It’s right there. That next peak. You’re already so close. Give it to me, sweetheart. It’ll feel so good. That’s right, just give into it.”

  And she did. Once. Twice. Three more fucking times.

  Her entire body was shaking—Nix didn’t know if it was another orgasm or if she was just exhausted with all the ways they’d used her flesh the past few hours—when finally, finally, Mateo pulled her mouth to his, kissing her and thrusting deep before stilling.

  When he eventually pulled back, cum poured out of Audrey’s pussy like a waterfall onto the floor.

  Nix and Clark set her back on her feet. She was wobbly and unsteady. Clark held her up and Nix took her other side. But he couldn’t help reaching down and dipping a couple fingers to the lips of her sex, swirling them in all the mixed cum, and then shoving them up inside her pussy.

  “You’re our wife now,” Nix growled, repeating the action, scooping more cum off her leg and pushing it back up into her pussy. “So don’t you go fucking forgetting again.”

  Chapter 33

  AUDREY

  “Shit,” Danny swore, pumping his hips and driving his cock in and out of Audrey. “I’m gonna come.”

  “Jesus, we just started,” Clark shouted in exasperation. “Di
d you even masturbate earlier like I told you to?”

  “Yeah,” Danny said, looking helpless. Well, as helpless as a guy with giant muscles and a fat cock could while he pumped into Audrey like a goddamned champ.

  Audrey thought he was doing a lovely job fucking her with said cock. In fact, if Danny would just lean a little further down, she bet she could get that last little bit of friction she needed so she could—

  “What’s the unsexiest thing you can think about?” Clark asked, butting in on her almost-orgasm. “Quick. Unsexiest thing you’ve ever seen. What’s the first thing that comes to mind?”

  “I don’t know. I can’t think… Jesus, she’s gripping on me so fucking tight.”

  Clark turned and glared at Audrey. “You’re not helping.”

  Audrey threw her hands up. “Oh now you’re dragging me into this?”

  “Trust me, your pussy is half the problem.” Clark shot her another look. “I’ve seen him go a full ten minutes when it’s just his own hand.”

  “We timed him yesterday,” Graham piped up helpfully from the couch by the window, watch held up close to his face.

  “The sanitation buckets at the barracks!” Danny said suddenly, sounding triumphant.

  “Ewwww,” Audrey said, covering her ears. “You do realize that the other half of sex is his partner still finding it sexy too?”

  “All right, all right,” Clark said, waving a hand. “Just keep it to yourself. Picture it in your head, don’t say it out loud.”

  “But now I know he’s thinking about buckets of crap,” Audrey complained. Come on, there had to be a better way than this to—

  “Nope,” Danny said, “Now all I can think about is how fuckable her tits are. And damn, that ass. Have you guys seen her ass when she bends over to pick something up? I just wanna stick my dick— Oh— Oh shit— I’m—”

  Audrey shoved her hand down and rubbed her clit furiously, managing to get herself there right as Danny’s face did that adorable thing where his nose scrunched up like he was about to sneeze.

  Her orgasm stretched throughout her body like one great, extremely satisfying yawn. It left her pussy humming with that satisfying buzz that she was beginning to get very familiar with.