Teaching Cayden (The Sutter Family Book 4)

by Heather D'Agostino

  “What?” His voice was gruff as his lips left where they were currently plying my neck with soft kisses.

  “Nothing. I’m just happy right now.” I sighed, but it quickly turned into a moan as he gripped my thigh and pressed his erection against me. He swiveled his hips, and his cock rubbed right where I needed him. I was strung so tight that I probably could have come just from that motion if he would have kept it up.

  “I like that sound better,” he murmured as his lips traveled higher, making their way back toward my mouth. “Let’s see if I can do it again.” His mouth descended on mine as his hands went for the bottom of my shirt. He pushed it up, and then used one hand to yank the cup to my bra down, freeing my right breast in the process. As his tongue plunged deeper, his finger tweaked my nipple, causing it to harden.

  “Yes!” I panted as I pulled my mouth from his. “Don’t stop!”

  “I don’t plan to.” He chuckled as he abandoned what he was doing. “This is kinda in the way though.” He grabbed my shirt and pulled it over my head before yanking his own and tossing it somewhere behind him. “So much better.” He grinned before freeing my other breast. “You are so hot, Miss Porter,” he mumbled before leaning down and sucking a nipple into his mouth.

  My back bowed off the bed as my head bent back. “Let’s not call me that, k?” I half squealed, half groaned. I didn’t want to think about being a teacher right now. All I wanted to be was a woman who was finally getting what she wanted from the man she was attracted to. “Don’t want to teach right now.” I sighed as I began to come back down from the high he was sending me on.

  Cayden stood from where he’d been hovering over me and reached for my shorts. He worked them down my legs before shoving his to his ankles. “Holy shit!” His eyes flared as he took me in. “You are more beautiful than I ever could have imagined.”

  “You’re not too bad yourself.” I grinned as I propped myself up on my elbows and took in his sculpted body. Every muscle was defined, included his cock, which was currently waving at me. “You know how to use that thing?” I eyed it as a cocksure smile spread across his face.

  “Guess you’re about to find out.” He playfully chuckled as he dug a condom out of his pocket. After slipping it on, he leaned forward, and climbed over me. “How about I be the teacher now?”

  “I don’t think there’s anything that I haven’t learned yet, Freshman.” I laughed as his eyes darkened.

  “I’m not so sure about that.” He leaned in and pressed his lips to mine as a hand drifted between my thighs. His fingers danced higher and higher until one lone digit slipped through my wetness. “I think I can do better.” He groaned as he began spread the wetness around. One finger became two, and two became three as he worked me over.

  I was quickly falling apart and he hadn’t even moved onto that thing between his legs. “I’m gonna come,” I yelped as he curled a digit inside of me, hitting that magic spot.

  “That’s the idea.” He chuckled before offering some sort of twist and pumping harder. My eyes rolled back as every part of me started to shake. “Stop fighting it,” he growled as he shifted his weight, allowing me to feel his erection against my thigh. My body began convulsing as Cayden pumped harder, not allowing me to hold it off.

  My orgasm rushed to the surface faster than it ever had in the past causing me to fly, not fall over the edge. My legs tightened as my insides quivered, and every other muscle pulsed. “Holy shit,” I gasped as I felt the bed shift again.

  “I’m not done yet. We’re just getting started,” Cayden groaned, and I opened my eyes just in time to see him licking his fingers. “This right here,” he waved his hand at me, “is so worth the pain I just went through.”

  “Huh?” My cloudy brain wasn’t processing what a dirty mind my little freshman had.

  “You’re sweet. All of you.” He leaned forward and nuzzled his face right between my legs, placing a kiss where his hand had just been. “As much as I’d like to make you come with my mouth, I need to be inside you right now.” His jaw clenched before he climbed higher on the bed, and positioned himself between my thighs.

  “Then what are you waiting for?” I bit my lower lip as I grinned at him.

  “I have no idea,” he muttered as one hand grabbed my thigh and lifted my hips just a little. He leaned forward, lining us up in the process, and then slowly pressed forward. It was in that moment that I knew all the rumors about the Sutter men were true. They had a reputation on campus as being some sort of dynamos between the sheets. I’ve never put much stock in it because Cayden didn’t seem like the type, but as his hips rocked into me, I knew that tonight would be one to go down in the history books.

  I moaned as he began to slide in and out, taking me back toward the peak I’d just been on. “You ok?” he whispered beside my ear as his hips swiveled.

  “I’m better than ok,” I half begged. “Don’t stop on my account.”

  He snickered as he bent my leg toward my shoulder, and twisted his hips again. His hand slipped between us, and began rubbing small circles on my clit. My eyes rolled back as I started shaking again. “There we go.” He chuckled. “That’s two.”

  “You’re rather proud of yourself, aren’t you?” I tried to scowl at him but the tingling feeling he’d evoked was still running through me, and I wasn’t ready for it to go away.

  “I’d like to think that I know how to please a lady,” he grunted before releasing my leg and pulling out.

  “What are you doing?” I yelped.

  “Getting a better view of this ass.” He began to flip me onto my stomach. “Every time I see you, you’re prancing around in something that shows off this.” He slapped my ass cheeks. “I want an up close and personal viewing now.” He grabbed my thighs and lifted, causing me to stick my ass up in the air. “Much better.” He nodded as I looked over my shoulder at him.

  He looked so hot kneeling there in the middle of my bed. His hair was in total disarray, and his skin was glowing a beautiful tan in the muted light. He leaned forward and winked at me before he opened his mouth, and playfully bit my ass cheek. “Hey!” I jerked out of his reach.

  “Did that hurt?” he teased. “I’ll make it better.” Before I could say anything, he crawled closer, and in one fluid motion he filled me. “Fuck!” he hissed as his hands grabbed my hips. I could feel him freeze, so I wiggled my hips. “Do not move,” he commanded as he took a few deep breaths.

  “Too much for you?” I giggled as I glanced back.

  “I think you would be too much for anyone.” He started to move his hips again, but kept an iron grip on my hips. I would probably have marks there in the morning, but it would be worth it. “You are a little temptress, but tonight you’re mine,” he growled as he plunged forward, causing my knees to slide up the bed slightly.

  I wiggled my hips again as he reared back, slamming forward, harder this time. “More,” I begged.

  “I don’t wanna hurt you.” He gritted his teeth as I rocked back onto him.

  “You won’t hurt me. More!” I braced myself on my elbows, preparing for his assault.

  “Addison,” he warned as he slammed forward again, causing me to slightly lose my balance.

  “I want you to fuck me hard, Freshman!” I demanded. That was all it took. I heard him snap as a string of curses flew from his mouth. His hips pounded into me, causing me to slip on the sheets. Skin slapping and panting breaths were all that was heard before Cayden shouted, “Fuuuucccckk!” and then slumped over me, causing me to fall down on the bed. When his hands released my hips, I felt the aftermath of the bruise that would be there come morning, but I didn’t care. This single experience was one of the best I’ve had in my short sexual history.

  “That was…” he panted as he rolled off of me.

  “Yeah.” I nodded as I rolled to my back, and stared at the ceiling. “You wanna stay over?” I didn’t want to sound needy, and I wasn’t sure what we were doing yet, but I wasn’t ready for him to leave eith
er.

  “Are you asking me to sleep here?” His head lolled to the side and our eyes connected.

  Swallowing my fears, I nodded. “I guess I am. There are things we still can’t do, but I liked this.” I grinned as I motioned between us. “And I might want to do it again real soon… like in the morning.”

  “I think that could be arranged.” He chuckled as he rocked up off the bed and headed for the bathroom. “I’ll be right back.”

  I watched as he disappeared for a few moments to dispose of the condom before coming back to slip into bed with me. I forewent my normal sleep shirt and instead curled up to a very naked Cayden.

  “Hey, Adds?” His arms wrapped around me.

  “Yeah?” I pressed myself closer.

  “I kinda like this kinda tutoring. You think you could tutor me in all my classes?” His lips turned up in a smile when I glanced up at him.

  “Go to sleep, Freshman,” I swatted his chest before burrowing into his side. I kinda liked this tutoring too, but I couldn’t show all my cards yet. I had to keep something to myself.

  Chapter 8

  Addison

  When my alarm went off this morning, I almost jumped. I’d forgotten that I’d asked Cayden to stay. I never let guys stay over, so when his warm body pressed against my back, I jerked forward, almost falling out of bed. I didn’t have morning classes today, so I wasn’t in a rush, but I wasn’t sure about Cayden, and then there was the problem with my brother. He’d wanted to come over the night before. I’d faked an illness, but now he might show up as a way of either calling my bluff or bringing me soup or something.

  “Are you a breakfast person?” Cayden murmured as his arms tightened around me.

  “Not really.” I shifted to try and loosen his grip. “I usually grab a coffee on campus or something. Why? Are you?”

  “Uh, no. I always choose sleep over breakfast. I just wanted to make sure that I wasn’t going to deprive you something this morning.” His hand began to snake down my stomach, and before I knew it, he was pushing his hips forward and slipping into me.

  “What are you doing?” I tried to push away, but he had an iron grip on me.

  “Giving you a proper wake up.” He chuckled. “Now be quiet and let me finish.” He pressed a kiss right below my ear as his hand slipped down to rub my clit.

  “You need a condom!” I shrieked as I berated myself for letting him stay.

  “Whoa!” he paused. “I already took care of that before you woke up.” He released his grip, slipped free, and sat up. “What kinda guy do you think I am?” He looked hurt, and pissed.

  “I just,” I started but he held up his hand.

  “You think I’d be careless like that? Seriously?” He stood from the bed, and reached for his shorts, giving me a view of his rubber covered cock. “I need to leave.” He yanked them up, pulled his shirt over his head before running his hand through his hair. “I’ll see ya in class, Addison.”

  “Wait!” I scrambled out of bed and rushed after him, grabbing my robe in the process. When I stepped into the living room, Cayden already had his backpack on his shoulders, and was digging for his keys. “You’re leaving? Just like that?”

  “Yes.” He gave a quick nod, and threw open the door, leaving me standing there baffled at why I was the bad guy here. After a few seconds, I ran over to the door and opened it just in time to see him slam his car door shut. He peeled out of his parking space and took off, leaving nothing but hurt feelings in his wake.

  Cayden

  I can’t believe that just happened. I stepped under the hot spray of the shower as I let my head fall forward. I’d gone straight to the bathroom to take care of myself after Addison flipped out on me. The fact that she thought I would do that to her really hurt. My mom always stressed protecting myself, especially after the way my brother treated women. I watched from afar as girl after girl snuck out of his apartment. I heard the fights he’d have with our parents over the way he was turning into my father. I had to admit, there were times I loved it because I could laugh at him but there were other times I hated it. It seemed like every time Aaron screwed up, I got a lecture out of it too. It’s like my mom thought I was him, and that I couldn’t think for myself. I always prided myself in the way I treated girls, but I’ve never really had a challenge before. Addison has been a challenge since the beginning.

  At first, I told myself that she probably wasn’t really worth all this hassle, but after last night I know that I was mistaken. The way she responded to me told me she was in to me as much as I was her. Now I just have to get her to admit it. I have to “woo” her as my dad calls it. My mom has other names like “being romantic”, but Dad was always the crass one in the relationship.

  After this morning though, I’m not sure how to get through her walls. She’s wrapped up so tight I’m beginning to wonder if last night was just sex for her. Take all of this, and add in the teacher thing and the fact that her brother holds my frat life in the palm of his hands for however long I decide to be a part of Tau Alpha, and I’m screwed every which way but up.

  After finishing my shower, I went back to my room to grab my things and go study. I only had three classes today, and unless Addison showed up at the library I wouldn’t see her. I jogged down the steps of my dorm, and began to walk briskly toward the engineering building. I wanted to talk to my heat transfer professor before I had to delve into my next set of homework problems. I’d been doing ok in there, and I got a B on my last project. If things kept going in this direction, I might pass the class after all.

  As I was jogging up the steps to McArthur Hall, Will was coming down them. “Hey, Sutter,” he waved as he approached. I couldn’t help but wonder if he knew anything about what happened between his sister and me the night before.

  “S’up,” I returned the greeting.

  “I’m gonna need your help on planning the Spring Formal this year. You didn’t help with the winter one, so you kinda have to.” He grinned as he stopped in front of me.

  “Fine.” I sighed. “What do I have to do?” I stuffed my hands in my pockets, resigned to the fact that I wasn’t going to make office hours today, and instead plan this party.

  “We join up with our sisters over at Omega Phi for this one. You need to go see who’s on their planning committee. They pick a theme and all that crap, and we help organize where it’s going to be. Last year it was held at the Marriott downtown. They booked a ballroom and all that.” Will shrugged as he lifted his backpack higher on his shoulder. “I gotta go see my sister for a little bit. You think you could tell the guys that I’m cancelling the meeting tonight? I don’t know if I’ll be back in time.”

  “Sure.” I glanced around and shivered as the thought of him going to see Addison sunk in. “Anything I can help with?”

  “Nah. I think she’s full of shit with this being sick crap that she pulled on me last night. If I don’t check on her though, she’ll think I don’t care. I think she just didn’t want to help me hide.” He rolled his eyes as he started to walk away.

  “Maybe you should stop treating girls like they’re disposable.” I laughed as he shook his head.

  “Why would I do that? This is college. That whole sowing your wild oats is a real thing. I only have a few more months until I have to enter the real world and not have a life. You sure you’re really Aaron’s little brother?” He threw his head back laughing and I couldn’t help but scowl. “I mean, do you even get laid monthly?”

  “I get laid plenty, and when is none of your business. I don’t share my conquests,” I growled.

  “Right. That means there aren’t any, and just so you know, Sutter…you sound like a total chick right now. Maybe you should go to the gym instead of class. Work whatever that is out of your system before you turn into a one.” He slapped my shoulder before jogging towards the parking lot. If I wasn’t so irritated at the moment, I probably would have given Addison a heads up, but after this morning I was kinda pissed at her too.

/>   Addison

  I’d just gotten out of the shower when I heard a knock at the door. I wasn’t expecting anyone, but after the way the morning ended I wondered if Cayden had come back to apologize. I smiled to myself as I walked over to the door and quickly flung it open. “Couldn’t stay away, huh?” I laughed and then froze when my eyes met my brother’s.

  “You look real sick, Addy.” He rolled his eyes at me as he pushed inside and looked around.

  “What do you want, Will?” I closed the door, turned in his direction, and crossed my arms over my chest.

  “I came to see if you were ok, and apparently you are so now you can tell me; who are you so eager to see? I mean, I know you love me and all, but that greeting wasn’t meant for me.” He squinted as he stared at me. “You had a guy here last night, didn’t you?”

  “What does it matter to you?” I began walking back to where I was making lunch in the kitchen.

  “It matters a lot when you blow me off. I was dodging Stephanie all day yesterday, and then when she texted that she was coming over I had nowhere to go. You took away my hideout. I hope it was good for you.” He walked over to my couch and flopped down.

  “Make yourself comfortable,” I grumbled as I carried my sandwich over and sat on the floor in front of him.

  “I can’t shake her, Addy. She shows up at the house, calls me all hours of the night. We fucked. That was it. It was a weekend, and now it’s over.” He threw his arm over his eyes as he let his head fall back on the couch.

  “You’re so romantic. Did you tell her you’d go out again? Promise to call? Anything?” I took a bite as I watched him stiffen. “You did, didn’t you? You said something stupid and now she thinks she meant something.”

  “All guys say ‘I’ll call you sometime’,” he mumbled before dropping his arm. “It’s just the way we are.”

  “No, it’s not. It’s the way you are.” I sighed as I set my sandwich down. “We don’t want you to lie to us. We just want to know that it meant something. Trust me when I tell you, it always means something to the girl. We just want to know that you feel the same way we do. When are you actually going to date someone?” I shoved his leg.