Henry Sidgwick- Eye of the Universe
Page 153
Schneewind on reason and, in S, ME, ;
Brink’s critique of S’s, –; Brink
S, ME, and independence of, ; S’s
versus Shaver on S, ME and, ; and S,
controversial construction of, in ME, ;
ME on esotericism, –, ,
ME, methods and, –; S on history
–; S’s social, –; of the closet,
of, , –; S on ME not
, –, –; and S’s psychical
representing his, –; S to Dakyns on
research, ; S’s, and sex, gender, race,
problems of, ME and, ; ME and
; Green’s, –; S, GSM on Green
post-positivist expansion of, ; and
and, –; S and James versus Bradley
Schneewind’s Rawlsian interpretation of
on, –; and Kantian conception of
ME, –; and esotericism, –,
self, –; and cosmic consciousness,
–; Symonds on ME, science and,
Symonds on, –; and feminist
; and S, ending in practical problems,
critique of S, EMS, ; S, EP on
; Symonds versus S on, –;
consensus test, –; and S’s appeal to
between science and theology, S on, ;
consensus test in international morality,
versus politics, ME on, –;
P: GCV
ind.xml
CY/Schultz
February ,
:
Index
ethical theory ( cont.)
Eyre, Governor Edward, Tennyson versus
as not for philosophers alone, S on, ;
Gladstone on,
and economics, PPE on, , –; and
politics, philosophy, PSR on, –; S,
Fairlamb, Anne,
EP on politics and, –; S to Lytton
faith, see religion; theism
on politics and, –; and S on
Fawcett, Henry: S uses as reference in letter
international morality and, –; P.
to J. S. Mill, ; Phillipa’s father, ;
Singer on impartiality and, ; and S’s
Marx attacked,
work with ethical societies, –; S on
Fawcett, Millicent: as Phillipa’s mother, ;
reverence for common sense and, –;
as a political woman, S on,
S on how theism cannot ignore, –; S
Fawcett, Phillippa, and success of Newnham,
on work of an ethical society and, –;
see also dualism of practical reason; egoism;
Fay, Annie,
intuition/intuitionism; perfection/
Federalist Papers,
perfectionism; utilitarianism
feelings: Donner on J. S. Mill on, ; J. S.
Eton, and Browning controversy,
Mill on, –; S on how idealism
eudaimonia, see Aristotle/Aristotelianism;
ignores, ; James on how idealism
good/goodness; happiness
ignores, –; see also poetry;
eugenics: and Galton’s plan for Newnham,
reason/reasonableness; symmetrical
; popularity of, –
persons; sympathy
Euripides, Symonds on,
feminism, ; classical utilitarianism and,
Evans, Charles, S studies under at Rugby,
–; S’s, , ; and Walker’s critique
Evans, Thomas, S studies under at Rugby,
of S, ME, –; and Balfour family,
evil: Green fails to solve problem of, –;
; and epistemology, ; development
Tyrwhitt on Symonds and, –;
of, in S, EMS, , –; and S’s
Symonds on, –; S on aesthetics and,
critique of Courthope, ; and EMS’s
,
critique of Marshall, –; and EMS
evolution/evolutionism, , ; Myers’s
on marriage and education, –; and S
cosmic version of, –; versus
on M. Fawcett, ; S, Eliot, and feminine,
Idealism, as S’s rival, ; and Kantism,
–; EMS and stereotypes of, ; V.
; see also Darwin/Darwinism; Huxley;
Woolf’s, ; Prins on Newnham,
Spencer, Herbert
Harrison, Victorian Maenads and, ; of
Ewing, A. C., shared orientation with S,
S, EMS, , –; and critique of S,
Moore, and Rashdall,
EMS, ; and S, EP on enfranchisement
excellence, see good/goodness,
of women, –; see also equality/
perfection/perfectionism
egalitarianism; higher education for
experiments in living: J. S. Mill and H. Taylor
women; Mill, J. S.
on, –; S’s life as, –, , , ;
Ferrers, Norman MacCleod, EMS studies
and friendship/sympathy, ; tension in
under,
S’s, ; and experiments in ethics and
Feuchtwanger, E. J., on England and
intuitive theism, ; Symonds’s life as, ;
agricultural depression, –
and women’s higher education, ; see
Fichte, Johann G., Rorty on,
also Mill, J. S.; symmetrical persons
Fisher, Edmund Henry, and S’s illness,
experts/expertise: and S’s formal
flirtation, S on Myers as genius of,
epistemology in ME, –; S, PPE on
–
consumer sovereignty and, ; and need
Forster, E. M., on poetry and poets,
for aristocratic element in democracy,
Foster, Michael, S’s support of,
–; S on international relations and,
Foucault, Michel: limited grasp of
–; S on consensus of, against
utilitarianism of, ; Symonds defies
Pearson, ; and S’s later epistemology,
constructionist account of sexuality of,
–; see also epistemology;
; Dellamora on aesthetics of existence
science/scientific method
and,
externalism/internalism: Brink on S and,
foundationalism, see epistemology;
, ; and right versus good, –;
i
ntuition/intuitionism; metaethics;
and Kant,
reason/reasonableness
P: GCV
ind.xml
CY/Schultz
February ,
:
Index
Fox, Kate,
Galileo, G.,
Foxwell, H. S.: S’s influence on, ; and
Galton, Sir Frances: and S family as case of
Oxbridge political economy,
hereditary genius, ; and proposed
Frankena, William: on Broad’s criticism of S,
dower fund for Newnham, ; and
; on S, ME, OHE, and history of ethical
eugenics, –
dualism, –; versus Schneewind on S
Gardner, Martin, as against parapsychology,
and Butler,
Frankfurt School, mythologies of,
Gauld, Alan: on Myers’s personality,
fraternity, J. F. Stephen as against, –
–; on Myers’s poetic sense of
Free Christian Union, ,
delight, ; on Gurney’s unconventional
free will: S on irrelevance of, –; and
thinking, aversion to pain, ; on birth of
Cambridge moralists, ; Green on,
S Group, –; on tiresome exposure
–; and Kantian conception of self,
of Myers’s mediums by S, –; on
–; see also determinism; ethical
W. Barratt and birth of SPR, –; on
theory
research work of W. Barratt, –; on
freedom: and perfection versus hedonism,
Gurney’s Phantasms, ; on the main
–; indirect pursuit of, –; S,
claims of Phantasms, –; on S Group
ME on Kant and grounding of morality
and Myers’s account of subliminal self,
and, –; positive, in Green’s
; on Podmore’s letter to S,
liberalism, –; S, GSM versus Green
gay studies: Weeks on Symonds and, ; and
on, –; and Kantian conception of
friendship problem, –;
self, –; laissez faire and, S on,
constructionist approach in, ; Symonds
–, –; fatuous smile of, ; S,
as pioneer of, –; S as pioneer of,
EP on different meanings of, ; S, EP on
press and, –
genius: Myers’s romantic notion of, ; Noel
Freemasons, S on joining,
on, –; Pearson on, –
French Commune, ,
George, Henry,
Freud, Sigmund, , , ; see also Myers;
Ghost Society: E. W. Benson and, ; S’s
psychical research; psychology
interest in, –
friendship, ; Shanley on Mill on, ;
ghosts, see death; miracles; psychical
importance for Mill, –; and Greek
research
love, ; in post-Christian era, ; with the
Gibbard, Alan: on Moore’s Principia, ; and
Universe, Myers on, –; and Apostles,
Russell and S,
; and Tennyson’s “In Memoriam,” ;
Gibbins, John, on J. Grote, –,
and Victorian Platonic revival, ;
Girton College: versus Newnham, Tullberg
philosophical significance of, for ME, ,
on, –, ; architecture of,
; and tensions in S’s utilitarianism,
Gizycki, Georg: presses S on defense of
–, ; Brink on, ; S to Myers
egoism, ; S’s response to, on egoism,
on, ; S and Massey and, ; and S’s
–,
life project, –; significance of, for S
Gladstone, Helen: on, –; move for
and Symonds, –, –; S on
equality, ; EMS advises,
loyalty and, –; S’s with Symonds,
Gladstone, William E., , ; impressed by S,
, ; and “friendship problem,”
; effect of S’s resignation on, ; on
–; and S on “My Friends,” ;
psychical research, ; as member of
Symonds, Whitmania and, –,
SPR, ; Hobsbawm on mass
–; and S’s reformism, –,
electioneering of, ; S becomes alienated
; and Millian ideal in education,
from over Home Rule, , –; on
Newnham, –; and S, ME on
Balfour and Mitchelstown, ; S and
marriage, ; and S’s politics, –;
conservative reaction to, ; and
and Cowell’s Alpine Club, ; and
Midlothian campaign, ; appoints Seeley
homogenic love, Brown to Carpenter on,
to Cambridge professorship, ; and
–; S’s loyalty to, –; see also
Egypt, ; versus Tennyson on race, ;
Greek love; sympathy
Shannon on Seeley, Jowett and, ; see
Fusato, Angelo, and Symonds’s sexual
also Home Rule; Liberal Party
development,
God, see Christianity; religion; theism
P: GCV
ind.xml
CY/Schultz
February ,
:
Index
Godwin, William: Symonds on, ;
government, S, EP on organization of,
P. Singer on,
–; see also politics; state
Goethe, Wolfgang: Noel on, , ; S defends
Government House utilitarianism, see
against Hutton, –; as one of the
imperialism; utilitarianism
symmetrical persons, , ; and Greek
Gower, Sir Ronald, and Symonds,
perfectionism, ; and Great Books, ;
Graham, Cyril, –
on teaching virtue, ; and dualism of
Gramsci, Antonio,
practical reason, ; as “lower” ideal, ;
Great Books: S’s criticism of M. Arnold on,
and S’s defense of egoism, ; and
; versus speeches, S on,
perfectionist id
eal and sanctions, –;
Greek Anthology,
Iphigenia of as a favorite of S’s, ; and
Greek ethical theory, see ancients versus
Symonds’s development, ; as hero of
moderns; Aristotle/Aristotelianism;
Pater, Symonds, , ; Proemium to
ethical theory; perfection/perfectionism;
“Gott und Welt” as a favorite of
Plato/Platonism; Socrates/Socratic
Symonds’s, ; and Noel, ; S on Noel
method
and, ; ranked with Shelley, –;
Greek love: as better served by Bentham and
Noel on Christ versus, –; S versus
S than Byron, ; L. Crompton on, ; and
Noel on, –; S on, versus Saint Paul,
Byron and Shelley, ; and sexual identity
; and Symonds on living in whole, ;
of S and his circle, , ; and A. H.
S to Symonds on, ; see also egoism;
Clough, ; and Tennyson, ; and
perfection/perfectionism
Whitman, ; and Symonds, –, ;
good/goodness versus right: ME on,
ignored in previous reception of S, ; and
–; ME and full-information
Minnie Benson, ; Platonic eros and
accounts of, ; S’s hedonistic
Apostles, ; and Victorian Platonic
interpretation of, in ME, –; Shaver
revival, ; and Rugby, ; Dover on, ;
on S, ME on, ; hedonistic account of
and Noel, ; and Lowes Dickenson, ;
and perfectionism, –; S, ME versus
and early Symonds circle, ; and Myers’s
Bentham’s definition of, ; and time,
Hellenism, –; at Cambridge and
; and statement of principle of
Oxford, ; and S’s life project, –;
benevolence in ME, –; Moore on,
and Oxford Hellenism, –, –;
; Skorupski on agent neutral/relative
publicity of, and Oxford Hellenism, ;
reasons and, –; S on Rashdall on,
Symonds versus Tyrwhitt on, –;
; S’s uncertainty concerning, ; and
Symonds’s consistent defense of, –;
Schneewind’s Rawlsian reading of ME,
Pater versus Symonds on, ; Symonds
–; S on virtue as only a species of,