Complete Stories 3 - Second Variety and Other Stories

by Philip K. Dick

  "I'm accustomed to the uniform Galactic culture," Rogers said. "Relay keeps the technocratic and ideological level constant throughout. It's hard to adjust to such a radically different social stage. But you've been cut off."

  "Cut off?" asked Williamson.

  "From Relay. You've had to develop without help."

  In front of them a surface vehicle crept to a halt. The driver opened the doors manually.

  "Now that I recall these factors, I can adjust," Rogers assured him.

  "On the contrary," Williamson said, entering the vehicle. "We've been receiving your Relay coordinates for over a century." He motioned Rogers to get in beside him.

  Rogers was puzzled. "I don't understand. You mean you hooked onto the web and yet made no attempt to --"

  attempt to --"

  The surface vehicle hurried along the highway, past the rim of an immense red hill. Soon the city lay behind them -- a faintly glowing place reflecting the rays of the sun. Bushes and plants appeared along the highway. The sheer side of the cliff rose, a towering wall of deep red sandstone; ragged, untouched.

  "Nice evening," Williamson said.

  Rogers nodded in disturbed agreement.

  Williamson rolled down the window. Cool air blew into the car. A few gnatlike insects followed. Far off, two tiny figures were plowing a field -- a man and a huge lumbering beast.

  "When will we be there?" Rogers asked.

  "Soon. Most of us live away from the cities. We live in the country -- in isolated self-sufficient farm units. They're modeled on the manors of the Middle Ages."

  "Then you maintain only the most rudimentary subsistence level. How many people live on each farm?"

  "Perhaps a hundred men and women."

  "A hundred people can't manage anything more complex than weaving and dyeing and paper pressing."

  "We have special industrial units -- manufacturing systems. This vehicle is a good example of what we can turn out. We have communication and sewage and medical agencies. We have technological advantages equal to Terra's."

  "Terra of the twenty-first century," Rogers protested. "But that was three hundred years ago. You're purposely maintaining an archaic culture in the face of the Relay coordinates. It doesn't make any sense."

  "Maybe we prefer it."

  "But you're not free to prefer an inferior cultural stage. Every culture has to keep pace with the general trend. Relay makes actual a uniformity of development. It integrates the valid factors and rejects the rest."

  They were approaching the farm, Gene Williamson's "manor." It consisted of a few simple buildings clustered together in a valley, to the side of the highway, surrounded by fields and pastures. The surface vehicle turned down a narrow side road and spiraled cautiously toward the floor of the valley. The air became darker. Cold wind blew into the car, and the driver clicked his headlights on.

  "No robots?" Rogers asked.

  "No," Williamson replied. "We do all our own work."

  "You're making a purely arbitrary distinction," Rogers pointed out. "A robot is a machine. You don't dispense with machines as such. This car is a machine."

  "True," Williamson acknowledged.

  "The machine is a development of the tool," Rogers went on. "The ax is a simple machine. A stick becomes a tool, a simple machine, in the hands of a man reaching for something. A machine is merely a multi-element tool that increases the power ratio. Man is the tool-making animal. The history of man is the history of tools into machines, greater and more efficient functioning elements. If you reject machinery you reject man's essential key."

  "Here we are," Williamson said. The vehicle came to a halt and the driver opened the doors for them.

  Three or four wooden buildings loomed up in the darkness. A few dim shapes moved around -human shapes.

  "Dinner's ready," Williamson said, sniffing. "I can smell it."

  They entered the main building. Several men and women were sitting at a long rough table. Plates and dishes had been set in front of them. They were waiting for Williamson.

  "This is Edward Rogers," Williamson announced. The people studied Rogers curiously, then turned back to their food.

  "Sit down," a dark-eyed girl urged. "By me."

  "Sit down," a dark-eyed girl urged. "By me."

  The girl and her companion laughed. Rogers sat down awkwardly by Williamson. The bench was rough and hard under him. He examined a handmade wooden drinking cup. The food was piled in huge wooden bowls. There was a stew and a salad and great loaves of bread.

  "We could be back in the fourteenth century," Rogers said.

  "Yes," Williamson agreed. "Manor life goes back to Roman times and to the classical world. The Gauls. Britons."

  "These people here. Are they --"

  Williamson nodded. "My family. We're divided up into small units arranged according to the traditional patriarch basis. I'm the oldest male and titular head."

  The people were eating rapidly, intent on their food -- boiled meat, vegetables, scooped up with hunks of bread and butter and washed down with milk. The room was lit by fluorescent lighting.

  "Incredible," Rogers murmured. "You're still using electric power."

  "Oh, yes. There are plenty of waterfalls on this planet. The vehicle was electric. It was run by a storage battery."

  "Why are there no older men?" Rogers saw several dried-up old women, but Williamson was the oldest man. And he couldn't have been over thirty.

  "The fighting," Williamson replied, with an expressive gesture.

  "Fighting?"

  "Clan wars between families are a major part of our culture." Williamson nodded toward the long table. "We don't live long."

  Rogers was stunned. "Clan wars? But --"

  "We have pennants, and emblems -- like the old Scottish tribes."

  He touched a bright ribbon on his sleeve, the representation of a bird. "There are emblems and colors for each family and we fight over them. The Williamson family no longer controls this planet. There is no central agency, now. For a major issue we have the plebiscite -- a vote by all the clans. Each family on the planet has a vote."

  "Like the American Indians."

  Williamson nodded. "It's a tribal system. In time we'll be distinct tribes, I suppose. We still retain a common language, but we're breaking up -- decentralizing. And each family to its own ways, its own customs and manners."

  "Just what do you fight for?"

  Williamson shrugged. "Some real things like land and women. Some imaginary. Prestige for instance. When honor is at stake we have an official semi-annual public battle. A man from each family takes part. The best warrior and his weapons."

  "Like the medieval joust."

  "We've drawn from all traditions. Human tradition as a whole."

  "Does each family have its separate deity?"

  Williamson laughed. "No. We worship in common a vague animism. A sense of the general positive vitality of the universal process." He held up a loaf of bread. "Thanks for all this."

  "Which you grew yourselves."

  "On a planet provided for us." Williamson ate his bread thoughtfully. "The old records say the ship was almost finished. Fuel just about gone -- one dead, and waste after another. If this planet hadn't turned up, the whole expedition would have perished."

  "Cigar?" Williamson said, when the empty bowls had been pushed back.

  "Thanks." Rogers accepted a cigar noncommittally. Williamson lit his own, and settled back against the wall.

  "How long are you staying?" he asked presently.

  "Not long," Rogers answered.

  "There's a bed fixed up for you," Williamson said. "We retire early, but there'll be some kind of dancing, also singing and dramatic acts. We devote a lot of time to staging, and producing drama."

  "There's a bed fixed up for you," Williamson said. "We retire early, but there'll be some kind of dancing, also singing and dramatic acts. We devote a lot of time to staging, and producing drama."

  "We enjoy making a
nd doing things, if that's what you mean."

  Rogers stared about him. The walls were covered with murals painted directly on the rough wood. "So I see," he said. "You grind your own colors from clay and berries?"

  "Not quite," Williamson replied. "We have a big pigment industry. Tomorrow I'll show you our kiln where we fire our own things. Some of our best work is with fabrics and screen processes."

  "Interesting. A decentralized society, moving gradually back into primitive tribalism. A society that voluntarily rejects the advanced technocratic and cultural products of the Galaxy, and thus deliberately withdraws from contact with the rest of mankind."

  "From the uniform Relay-controlled society only," Williamson insisted.

  "Do you know why Relay maintains a uniform level for all worlds?" Rogers asked. "I'll tell you. There are two reasons. First, the body of knowledge which men have amassed doesn't permit duplication of experiment. There's no time.

  "When a discovery has been made it's absurd to repeat it on countless planets throughout the universe. Information gained on any of the thousand worlds is flashed to Relay Center and then out again to the whole Galaxy. Relay studies and selects experiences and coordinates them into a rational, functional system with contradictions. Relay orders the total experience of mankind into a coherent structure."

  "And the second reason?"

  "If uniform culture is maintained, controlled from a central source, there won't be war."

  "True," Williamson admitted.

  "We've abolished war. It's as simple as that. We have a homogeneous culture like that of ancient Rome -- a common culture for all mankind which we maintain throughout the Galaxy. Each planet is as involved in it as any other. There are no backwaters of culture to breed envy and hatred."

  "Such as this."

  Rogers let out his breath slowly. "Yes -- you've confronted us with a strange situation. We've searched for Williamson's World for three centuries. We've wanted it, dreamed of finding it. It has seemed like Prester John's Empire -- a fabulous world, cut off from the rest of humanity. Maybe not real at all. Frank Williamson might have crashed."

  "But he didn't."

  "He didn't, and Williamson's World is alive with a culture of its own. Deliberately set apart, with its own way of life, its own standards. Now contact has been made, and our dream has come true. The people of the Galaxy will soon be informed that Williamson's World has been found. We can now restore the first colony outside the Solar System to its rightful place in the Galactic culture."

  Rogers reached into his coat, and brought out a metal packet. He unfastened the packet and laid a clean, crisp document on the table.

  "What's this?" Williamson asked.

  "The Articles of Incorporation. For you to sign, so that Williamson's World can become a part of the Galactic culture."

  Williamson and the rest of the people in the room fell silent. They gazed down at the document, none of them speaking.

  "Well?" Rogers said. He was tense. He pushed the document toward Williamson. "Here it is."

  Williamson shook his head. "Sorry." He pushed the document firmly back toward Rogers. "We've already taken a plebiscite. I hate to disappoint you, but we've already decided not to join. That's our final decision."

  The Class-One battleship assumed an orbit outside the gravity belt of Williamson's World. Commander Ferris contacted the Relay Center. "We're here. What next?" "Send down a wiring team. Report back to me as soon as it has made surface contact."

  Ten minutes later Corporal Pete Matson was dropped overboard in a pressurized gravity suit. He drifted slowly toward the blue and green globe beneath, turning and twisting as he neared the surface of the planet.

  Ten minutes later Corporal Pete Matson was dropped overboard in a pressurized gravity suit. He drifted slowly toward the blue and green globe beneath, turning and twisting as he neared the surface of the planet.

  His earphones clicked. "Any sign of activity?"

  "None, Commander," he signaled back.

  "There's what appears to be a village to your right. You may run into someone. Keep moving, and watch out. The rest of the team is dropping, now. Instructions will follow from your Relay web."

  "I'll watch out," Matson promised, cradling his blast rifle. He sighted it experimentally at a distant hill and squeezed the trigger. The hill disintegrated into dust, a rising column of waste particles.

  Matson climbed a long ridge and shielded his eyes to peer around him.

  He could see the village. It was small, like a country town on Terra. It looked interesting. For a moment he hesitated. Then he stepped quickly down from the ridge and headed toward the village, moving rapidly, his supple body alert.

  Above him, from the Class-One battleship, three more of the team were already falling, clutching their guns and tumbling gently toward the surace of the planet...

  Rogers folded up the Incorporation papers and returned them slowly to his coat. "You understand what you're doing?" he asked.

  The room was deathly silent. Williamson nodded. "Of course. We're refusing to join your Relay system."

  Rogers' fingers touched the trace web. The web warmed into life. "I'm sorry to hear that," he said.

  "Does it surprise you?"

  "Not exactly. Relay submitted our scout's report to the computers. There was always the possibility you'd refuse. I was given instructions in case of such an event."

  "What are your instructions?"

  Rogers examined his wristwatch. "To inform you that you have six hours to join us -- or be blasted out of the universe." He got abruptly to his feet. "I'm sorry this had to happen. Williamson's World is one of our most precious legends. But nothing must destroy the unity of the Galaxy."

  Williamson had risen. His face was ash white, the color of death. They faced each other defiantly.

  "We'll fight," Williamson said quietly. His fingers knotted together violently, clenching and unclenching.

  "That's unimportant. You've received Relay coordinates on weapons development. You know what our war fleet has."

  The other people sat quietly at their places, staring rigidly down at their empty plates. No one moved.

  "Is it necessary?" Williamson said harshly.

  "Cultural variation must be avoided if the Galaxy is to have peace," Rogers replied firmly.

  "You'd destroy us to avoid war?"

  "We'd destroy anything to avoid war. We can't permit our society to degenerate into bickering provinces, forever quarreling and fighting -- like your clans. We're stable because we lack the very concept of variation. Uniformity must be preserved and separation must be discouraged. The idea itself must remain unknown."

  Williamson was thoughtful. "Do you think you can keep the idea unknown? There are so many semantic correlatives, hints, verbal leads. Even if you blast us, it may arise somewhere else."

  "We'll take that chance." Rogers moved toward the door. "I'll return to my ship and wait there. I suggest you take another vote. Maybe knowing how far we're prepared to go will change the results."

  "I doubt it."

  Rogers' web whispered suddenly. "This is North at Relay."

  Rogers' web whispered suddenly. "This is North at Relay."

  "A Class-One Battleship is in your area. A team has already been landed. Keep your ship grounded until it can fall back. I've ordered the team to lay out its fission-mine terminals."

  Rogers said nothing. His fingers tightened around the web convulsively.

  "What's wrong?" Williamson asked.

  "Nothing." Rogers pushed the door open. "I'm in a hurry to return to my ship. Let's go."

  Commander Ferris contacted Rogers as soon as his ship had left Williamson's World.

  "North tells me you've already informed them," Ferris said.

  "That's right. He also contacted your team directly. Had it prepare to attack."

  "So I'm informed. How much time did you offer them?"

  "Six hours."

  "Do you think they'll give in?" />
  "I don't know," Rogers said. "I hope so. But I doubt it."

  Williamson's World turned slowly in the viewscreen with its green and blue forest, rivers and oceans. Terra might have looked that way, once. He could see the Class-One battleship, a great silvery globe moving slowly in its orbit around the planet.

  The legendary world had been found and contacted. Now it would be destroyed. He had tried to prevent it, but without success. He couldn't prevent the inevitable.

  If Williamson's World refused to join the Galactic culture its destruction became a necessity -grim, axiomatic. It was either Williamson's World or the Galaxy. To preserve the greater, the lesser had to be sacrificed.

  He made himself as comfortable as possible by the view-screen, and waited.

  At the end of six hours a line of black dots rose from the planet and headed slowly toward the Class-One battleship. He recognized them for what they were -- old-fashioned jet-driven rocket ships. A formation of antiquated war vessels, rising up to give battle.

  The planet had not changed its mind. It was going to fight. It was willing to be destroyed, rather than give up its way of life. The black dots grew swiftly larger, became roaring blazing metal disks puffing awkwardly along. A pathetic sight. Rogers felt strangely moved, watching the jet-driven ships divide up for the contact. The Class-One battleship had secured its orbit, and was swinging in a lazy, efficient arc. Its banks of energy tubes were slowly rising, lining up to meet the attack.

  Suddenly the formation of the ancient rocketships dived. They rumbled over the Class-One, firing jerkily. The Class-One's tubes followed their path. They began to reform clumsily, gaining distance for a second try, and another run.

  A tongue of colorless energy flicked out. The attackers vanished.

  Commander Ferris contacted Rogers. "The poor tragic fools." His heavy face was gray. "Attacking us with those things."

  "Any damage?"

  "None whatever." Ferris wiped his forehead shakily. "No damage to me at all."