Anathema

by Colleen Coble

  “You didn’t.”

  “It looked like you were deep in conversation.” He nearly winced when he saw Asia grin. Even if Hannah was too innocent to recognize his interest, her savvier friend saw everything.

  “I’ve known him all my life.”

  “They were engaged,” Asia put in. Her smile widened, and she glanced at Matt as if to see him squirm.

  “That was a long time ago. He’s married with four kids now.”

  It almost sounded as though she didn’t want him to worry. Matt couldn’t help but smile. Maybe she was transparent too. And Asia understood.

  She stood. “Listen, Hannah, since Matt is here, I’m going to go back to the house and call the producer to see if they got all they needed today. Why don’t you have Matt take you over to see Irene? You’ve been wanting to go. She’s probably got some of your mom’s quilts. See if you can borrow them for a few days for me to photograph them.”

  “But I should go back and work on the quilt too.”

  “Yeah, you should, but you’re not going to, so just get your sleuthing out of your system. See you two later.” Asia grabbed her coffee and sashayed out of the coffee bar.

  “You sure you don’t mind taking me over to Irene ’s?”

  How was he going to get out of this one? Irene would recognize Caitlin in one glance. “Not a problem. I need to question Irene myself. You just need to borrow quilts?”

  “I was going to ask her about the little girl, but now there ’s no need.” She blinked rapidly at the moisture flooding her eyes.

  “Why not?” Was she giving up?

  “One of my cousins. We look a lot alike. I think the girl might be hers. She might have given her up for adoption.”

  “I’m sorry.” He reached across the table and took her hand in both of his. He rubbed his thumb along her palm.

  One part of him was rejoicing that he wouldn’t be found out, and the other was responding to the touch of her hand. An impossible situation. He didn’t dare explore his feelings for her when it would all come crashing down the minute she found out the extent of his deceit. Besides, she ’d never filed for divorce.

  Her fingers clutched his hand, and her eyes held a naked appeal for him to make it all better. But he couldn’t. Not without destroying his daughter and himself.

  twenty

  “The Mariner’s Compass Quilt reminds me that in murky times,

  the Amish rely on the Word to steer their course.”

  —HANNAH SCHWARTZ,

  IN The Amish Faith Through Their Quilts

  The desire to be certain burned Hannah’s veins. “Could we stop and see my cousin Mary before we go to your aunt’s?” she asked as Matt pulled out of the parking lot. Rain drummed against the top of the vehicle and sluiced over the windshield.

  “Do you think she ’ll talk to you about such a personal matter?”

  “I don’t know. But I have to ask. If I know she gave a child up for adoption, I’ll know for sure that Reece is lying to me. It will put my mind at rest. And if she knows who has the child, that might lead us to important information. The little girl is on my mother’s quilt.”

  “You’re sure about that? The picture isn’t that big.”

  He seemed determined to disbelieve her. “I’m positive. I’m a quilt expert, remember?”

  “I’m just not sure the quilt means anything more than that the killer finally started selling them off.”

  She didn’t want to admit he might be right. Craning her neck, she pointed out an older house in Nyesville. “There ’s her place.” Matt parked at the curb, and Hannah got out as soon as the SUV stopped rolling. She dashed through the downpour to the porch. When she knocked, the door opened immediately.

  Mary’s face lit when she saw Hannah. “I didn’t think you’d really come.” She opened the door wide. “Come in out of the storm. I just put on a fresh pot of coffee. And I made some peanut butter cookies. They’re still warm.” She led them into an immaculate living room decorated in blue and yellow. The chintz fabric on the sofa and overstuffed chair looked new.

  Hannah settled onto the sofa. “I hope you don’t mind us barging in without calling first.”

  “I’m tickled to death to see you! There’s no one left on my mom’s side of the family. My parents live clear across the country, and I get lonesome for family sometimes.”

  Her cousin’s eager welcome made Hannah want to crawl under the sofa. She should have come sooner. Her gaze lingered on some pictures on the table. Standing beside her mother, Cathy, Mary smiled out from the photo.

  “How about that coffee and cookies?” Mary asked.

  “I’d love some,” Hannah said, even though the thought of more caffeine didn’t appeal. Her cousin was so eager to please. “You need some help?”

  “No, you wait here. I’ll be back in a flash.” And she was. Two minutes later she returned to the room with coffee and cookies on a tray. “There’s creamer in the little pitcher, and sugar as well,” she said.

  Hannah stirred creamer into her coffee and tried to think how she might bring up the subject of children. Maybe just show Mary the picture. She could ask if Mary had seen the child. She sipped the coffee, then put it down on the table and picked up her handbag. “I wondered if you might be able to help me.” She pulled out the picture and handed it to Mary.

  Mary took it and glanced at it. Her smile turned plastic. “What a cute little girl. Who is she?”

  “That’s what I’m trying to find out.” She launched into the story of how she came to have the picture. Mary listened intently, but her expression didn’t betray what she was thinking. “I’ve got to find out if this child is mine,” she said. “Do you have any idea who she could be? You said you didn’t have children?”

  Mary handed back the picture. “Not now. I had a little boy, but he died when he was a week old.”

  Which explained the sadness in Mary’s face when Hannah had first asked. So this little girl might still be Hannah’s daughter. Elation made her voice raise. “Have you ever seen this child?”

  Mary shook her head. “I’m sorry, no. Do you believe Reece? He would have needed help hiding the baby from you and the police.”

  Had Reece been with her every minute after her tumble down the stairs? She vaguely remembered drifting in and out of consciousness, and he ’d been by her bedside every time. “Maybe he had an accomplice. I’m going to ask him to explain it the next time he calls.”

  She and Matt finished their visit, then managed to get away from Mary after promising to come back when Hannah could stay longer.

  “You ready to go home?” Matt asked.

  “I want to go see Irene,” Hannah said. “We ’ve still got enough time.” A frown crouched between his eyes, and she wondered what had made him so quiet and grumpy.

  “I guess,” he said. “But let’s not stay long. I’ve got things to do this afternoon.” He hesitated. “Just to warn you, Irene can be a little strange. She ’s got some mental issues and may seem a bit off now and again.”

  Hannah nodded. She hadn’t seen Irene in over ten years and had never known the woman well. “I might ask her about my mother as well as using the quilts,” she said. Ajax thrust his nose in her hair, and she rubbed his muzzle.

  “I’ve been wanting to talk to her about the murders,” Matt said. “She knew all the victims well. I didn’t realize that until recently.”

  Matt parked on the street in front of a two-story house with a rounded brick turret on the front. Oak trees shaded the quaint house, and hyacinths lined the brick walk to the front door. Hannah’s pulse quickened, but she didn’t know why. There should be nothing dangerous about talking to Irene.

  Matt let Ajax out, then went around to Hannah’s door, but she ’d already exited the vehicle and stood looking at the red front door. Before they reached the door, it swung open and a smiling Irene knelt to pet Ajax, who had leaped forward to greet her. With a final pat, she stood. Nearing sixty, she had only a little gray at the te
mples of her short dark hair. She was still slim and attractive in her capris and sleeveless top. She had a greenhouse in the yard like so many people in the area did.

  “What a nice surprise,” she said, hugging first Hannah and then Matt. “I didn’t even realize you two knew each other.”

  “We ’ve known each other for over ten years,” Matt said.

  Hannah glanced at him, then away. That was stretching it a little, but maybe only a little.

  “Come in. I just made chocolate chip cookies, and they’re still warm.” Irene led them to the living room and went to kitchen.

  “I’ll help you,” Matt said. He hurried after her.

  Hannah heard the low tones of his voice but couldn’t make out any of the words. He sounded intense. The exchange wasn’t any of her business. Clearly he wanted to talk to his aunt in private. She glanced around the room. Pictures from years ago covered one wall. She got up and studied them. One in particular caught her attention. Irene, Nora, and Hannah’s mother stood with their arms around each other. They all had hair that reached their waists, parted in the middle and held in place with a headband that encircled their foreheads. They wore caftans.

  Someone had drawn red horns on Hannah’s mother’s head. Hannah gulped, then found her voice. It would probably be rude to mention the horns. Maybe a child had gotten hold of the picture. “Why isn’t Aunt Nora dressed Plain? Was this during her rumspringa?”

  “Yes, her brief stint with freedom.” A flush ran up Irene ’s neck and cheeks as she and Matt came back. She didn’t look at Hannah. “Here we go. Would you like some coffee? Or maybe milk?”

  “I just had coffee. Two cups, in fact. A cookie is fine.” The day was going to make her gain five pounds. Hannah gestured to the picture. “Where was this taken?”

  “We had a commune out near Sugar Creek.” Irene came to stand beside her. “We lived there for about a year. It wasn’t a free-love kind of place like you hear about. We grew our own vegetables, were one with nature.”

  Hannah peered closer. “Is that a peace symbol on the shed in the background?”

  “Yes. We thought if everyone lived as we did, there would be no war.” Her smile turned sad. “We were so young and naive.”

  Hannah turned to go back to the sofa and caught sight of another photo out of the corner of her eye. The two young people weren’t touching in the photo, but Irene was gazing at Hannah’s father, Abe, with longing. Hannah said nothing. The last thing she wanted was to embarrass Irene.

  Hannah selected a cookie and bit into the warm chocolate. “Do you have any of my mother’s quilts?”

  “No, I’m sorry, I don’t. I have four of your grandmother’s, though, one for each bed plus an extra. I bought them when your grandmother was still making quilts. Why do you ask?”

  Hannah barely remembered her grandparents. They and Luca’s parents had died in a buggy accident when she was five. “I’d love to photograph them for an Amish quilt book I’m working on.” They would be a nice addition.

  “I read your first one. Lovely book. I was so proud of you. What a lovely tribute to your father. And, ah, your mother.” She cast a wary glance at Matt.

  Surely he wouldn’t have told his aunt not to talk to Hannah about her mother. Hannah frowned at him, but he smiled in her direction.

  “I’m sorry about your cousin and aunt,” Irene said. “Such a nasty business. Why do people show such prejudice? The Amish are good people, the best. Remember that time someone torched your barn, Hannah?”

  She didn’t care to revisit that memory. Something about Irene’s tone seemed flippant too. “My rabbits died in the fire,” she said. Even now, her chest hurt when she remembered it.

  “But you forgave the kids who did it.”

  “Only because Datt made me,” she blurted out. It should have been a clue to her true nature. “I’m still angry about it. It was so senseless.”

  “That’s terrible,” Matt said.

  She pressed her lips together. “About Moe and Aunt Nora. Aunt Nora sent me a picture.” She fumbled in her purse for it. “I realize she ’s likely not my daughter, but when Nora sent it, she knew it would draw me back here. She suggested later that she shouldn’t have sent it, that someone was angry she had.” She held the picture out to Irene.

  The picture trembled a little in Irene ’s hand as she looked at it. She handed it back. “Darling child.” She didn’t look at Matt or Hannah.

  What was wrong? Hannah couldn’t figure out the tense air swirling in the living room. “Yes. But about Moe and Nora. What could Nora have known that she wasn’t supposed to tell anyone? Could it be something she knew about this child that caused her death?”

  Irene shrugged. “I don’t know, Hannah. Your mother and I went our separate ways long ago. And I rarely talked to Nora once she returned to your community.”

  Hannah sighed. “I’m more inclined to think Nora’s secret might be from long ago. You’ve known her a long time. My parents too.”

  “That’s true. I met Abe before he was baptized Amish.” Irene stood. “I need to throw some clothes in the dryer.”

  The initial welcome had worn off, but Hannah wasn’t quite sure why. She stood. “We ’d better go anyway. I need to get to work on a quilt I’m trying to get finished. Could I take a quick look at the quilts?”

  “They’re in the bedrooms. Help yourself.” Irene walked away quickly.

  Hannah exchanged glances with Matt. “Do you know the way?” she asked.

  “Sure.”

  She followed him down the hall past other pictures from a lost era. She lingered a moment to look. There were so many of her father. She paused to look at one last picture. “Does Irene have any children? She looks pregnant in this picture.”

  “No kids. Maybe she just gained some weight.”

  Hannah didn’t argue with him, but Irene looked clearly pregnant. Hannah followed the sound of his voice and found him in the first bedroom. A beautiful quilt in royal blue and black lay on the bed. “It’s gorgeous. The colors will look great in the book. Any others in the closet?” She went to the closet door and shoved it aside. It held only clothing and boxes.

  “The other spare room is across the hall. I’ll get the quilt out of there.” Matt stepped across the hall and pushed open the door.

  He closed it behind him, but not before she caught a glimpse of a crib and a wall covered in pictures. He closed the door too quickly for her to see who was in the pictures. Maybe Irene didn’t like people in there.

  When Matt came out carrying the quilt, she asked him about the room. “I thought you said she didn’t have kids.”

  “She didn’t, but she was a foster mother to many,” he said. “She had this set up for when she took in babies.”

  “Oh right, that makes sense.” The crib quilt looked a little like the one that had covered the bodies of her family. Same design but pink instead of black. Maybe Matt hadn’t noticed. It didn’t matter anyway. This must be a design her grandmother had taught her mother.

  “Could I see the pictures? Maybe there are some of my mother.”

  “There aren’t,” he said in a clipped voice. “And the master bedroom is here.”

  Hannah followed him to the last large room. Austere with nothing on the walls and only plain wooden shades on the windows, it could have been a room in her parents’ home. The quilt on the bed made the room, though. Breathtaking. One of her grandmother’s masterpieces. The intricate Mariner’s Compass radiated in all directions in vivid colors. Another quilt, a pure white one with hummingbird stitches, was on a rack at the foot of the bed. It was equally gorgeous.

  “I’ve never seen this one,” she said. “It looks like my mother’s work.”

  “She wasn’t the only one to make hummingbird stitches,” Irene said from the doorway. She dumped a basket of towels on the bed, then disappeared through the door.

  What was Irene’s problem? Hannah’s gaze caught on one last photo by the bed. A smaller one of the same pose with Ir
ene and Hannah’s father. “I think she never got over my dad,” she said. “Maybe that’s why she never married.”

  “Makes sense.” He took her arm. “Let’s get out of here.”

  They went to the door just as Irene came back to the room.

  “Come back and see me sometime,” Irene said in a voice that suggested the opposite. Matt left the Tumbling Blocks Quilt with Irene before they left.

  Back outside, Hannah glanced at Matt. “She dated my dad. I’m shocked he was interested.”

  “Why?”

  “I always thought my parents had eyes only for each other.”

  “Maybe they did once they met.”

  “Maybe.” Something didn’t sit right with her, and she couldn’t figure it out. Was it jealousy that had broken up Irene ’s friendship with Hannah’s mother? That could explain why her mother had always grown quiet when Irene ’s name was mentioned. Shame at stealing away a man Irene loved, maybe? But why would Irene have bought Abe’s mother’s quilts?

  Hannah couldn’t think of a thing to say on the drive back to the farm. The rain continued to come down in buckets. They slowed to pass a buggy, but she didn’t know the occupants, not even the half-drowned children peering out the back. Her gaze lingered on them, taking in their features, searching for auburn hair.

  “You okay?” Matt asked.

  “Sure. Just—just disappointed. I’d hoped to find out more today about the girl.” Her voice hoarsened on the last word. She ’d never even held her, never kissed her downy head. Never said goodbye. “I wonder if there ’s a grave back in Wabash.”

  “For your daughter?”

  “Yes, could you check?”

  “Sure, I’ll make a call.” He cleared his throat. “Do you really think she is your daughter? Deep down?”

  “I don’t know. I’ve tried not to get my hopes up, but I guess they rose anyway. She looks so much like me. If you could see pictures of me . . .” Being here had made her realize how much she missed her childhood, the community, the simple way of life.