———. “Beethoven, Freemasonry, and the Tagebuch of 1812–1818.” In Beethoven Forum (University of Nebraska Press) 8 (2000).
———. “Beethoven’s ‘Magazin der Kunst.’” Nineteenth-Century Music 7, no. 3 (April 1984).
———. “Beethoven’s Productivity at Bonn.” Music and Letters 53, no. 2 (April 1972): 165–72.
———. “Economic Circumstances of the Beethoven Household in Bonn.” Journal of the American Musicological Society 50, nos. 2–3 (Summer–Fall 1997): 331–51.
———. Late Beethoven: Music, Thought, Imagination. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2003.
———. “The Masonic Thread.” In Solomon, Beethoven Essays.
———. “The Ninth Symphony.” In Solomon, Beethoven Essays.
Sonneck, Oscar G. T. Beethoven: Impressions by His Contemporaries. New York: Dover, 1967.
Specht, Richard. Beethoven as He Lived. New York: Smith & Haas, 1933.
Stader, Karl Heinz. “Bonn und der Rhein in der englischen Reiseliteratur.” In Aus Geschichte und Volkskunde von Stat und Raum Bonn: Festschrift Josef Dietz zum 80. Geburtstag, edited by Josef Dietz, Edith Ennen, and Dietrich Höroldt. Bonn: Röhrscheid, 1973.
Stanley, Glenn, ed. The Cambridge Companion to Beethoven. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2000.
Steblin, Rita. A History of Key Characteristics in the Eighteenth and Early Nineteenth Centuries. 2nd ed. Rochester, N.Y.: University of Rochester Press, 2002.
Steinberg, Michael. “The Late Quartets.” In Winter and Martin, Beethoven Quartet Companion.
Sterba, Editha, and Richard Sterba. Beethoven and His Nephew: A Psychoanalytic Study of Their Relationship. New York: Pantheon, 1954.
Stowell, Robin. Beethoven: Violin Concerto. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1998.
Sturm, Christoph Christian. Reflections on the Works of God and His Providence Throughout All Nature. Mountain Valley, Va.: Funk & Sons, 1848.
Swafford, Jan. “In Search of Lost Sounds.” Slate, March 2, 2010. http://www.slate.com/articles/arts/music_box/2010/03/in_search_of_lost_sounds.html.
———. “Silence Is Golden: How a Pause Can Be the Most Devastating Effect in Music.” Slate, August 31, 2009. http://www.slate.com/articles/arts/music_box/2009/08/silence_is_golden.html.
———. “The Wolf at Our Heels.” Slate, April 20, 2010. http://www.slate.com/articles/arts/music_box/2010/04/the_wolf_at_our_heels.html.
Teschner, Ulrike. “Bartholomäus Fischenich: Ein rheinischer Philosoph und Jurist der Aufklärungszeit.” Bonner Geschichtsblätter 21 (1967): 17.
Thayer, Alexander W., et al. Life of Beethoven. 2 vols. Edited by Elliot Forbes. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1964. In the notes, called “Thayer/Forbes.”
Thompson, Bruce. Franz Grillparzer. Boston: Twayne, 1981.
Thomson, Katharine. “Mozart and Freemasonry.” Music and Letters 57, no. 1 (January 1976): 25–46.
Travis, James. “Celtic Elements in Beethoven’s Seventh Symphony.” Musical Quarterly 21, no. 3 (July 1935).
Tusa, Michael C. “Music as Drama: Structure, Style, and Process in Fidelio.” In Robinson, Ludwig van Beethoven.
Tyson, Alan, ed. Beethoven Studies. 3 vols. Vol. 1, New York: Norton, 1973. Vol. 2, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1977. Vol. 3, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1982.
———. “Beethoven to the Countess Susanna Guicciardi: A New Letter.” In Tyson, Beethoven Studies, vol. 1.
———. “The 1803 Version of Beethoven’s Christus am Oelberge.” In Lang, Creative World.
———. “Notes on Five of Beethoven’s Copyists.” Journal of the American Musicological Society 23, no. 3 (Autumn 1970).
Valder-Knechtges, Claudia. “Andrea Luchesi, ein Italiener im Umkreis des jungen Beethoven.” Bonner Geschichtsblätter 40 (1990): 29.
Walden, Edward. Beethoven’s Immortal Beloved: Solving the Mystery. Lanham, Md.: Scarecrow, 2011.
Wallace, Robin. Beethoven’s Critics: Aesthetic Dilemmas and Resolutions During the Composer’s Lifetime. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1986.
Walter, Horst. “Die biographischen Beziehungen zwischen Haydn and Beethoven.” In Bodsch, Joseph Haydn und Bonn.
Webster, James. “The Falling-Out Between Haydn and Beethoven: The Evidence of Sources.” In Beethoven Essays: Studies in Honor of Elliot Forbes, edited by Lewis Lockwood and Phyllis Benjamin, 3–29. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1984.
Weck, Bernhard, “‘Wer ist ein freier Mann?’ Beethoven und universelle Freiheitsideen der Aufklärung: Ein Problemskizze.” In Verfassung im Diskurs der Welt: Liber Amicorum für Peter Häberle zum siebzigsten Geburtstag, edited by Alexander Blankenagel, et al. Tübingen, Ger.: Mohr Siebeck, 2004.
Wegeler, Franz, and Ferdinand Ries. Beethoven Remembered. Arlington, Va.: Great Ocean, 1987. In the notes, called “Wegeler/Ries.”
Wetzstein, Margot, ed. Familie Beethoven im kurfürstlichen Bonn: Neuauflage nach den Aufzeichnungen des Bonner Bäckermeisters Gottfried Fischer. Bonn: Verlag Beethoven-Haus, 2006. In the notes, called “Wetzstein/Fischer.”
Will, Richard. “Time, Morality, and Humanity in Beethoven’s Pastoral Symphony.” Journal of the American Musicological Society 50, nos. 2–3 (Summer–Autumn 1997).
Winter, Robert, and Bruce Carr, eds. Beethoven, Performers, and Critics. Detroit: Wayne State University Press, 1980.
Winter, Robert, and Robert L. Martin, eds. The Beethoven Quartet Companion. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1994.
———. “Plans for the Structure of the String Quartet in C Sharp Minor.” In Tyson, Beethoven Studies, vol. 2.
———. “The Quartets in Their First Century.” In Winter and Martin, Beethoven Quartet Companion.
———. “The Sketches for the ‘Ode to Joy.’” In Winter and Carr, Beethoven, Performers, and Critics.
Wolf, Christa. “Your Next Life Begins Today: A Letter about Bettina.” In Bettina Brentano-von Arnim: Gender and Politics, edited by Elke P. Frederiksen and Katherine R. Goodman. Detroit: Wayne State University Press, 1995.
Wyn Jones, David. Beethoven: “Pastoral” Symphony. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995.
———. The Life of Beethoven. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1998.
———. The Symphony in Beethoven’s Vienna. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2006.
Yates, W. E. “Cultural Life in Early Nineteenth-Century Vienna.” In Austrian Life and Literature, 1780–1938: Eight Essays, edited by Peter Branscombe. Totowa, N.J.: Rowan & Littlefield, 1978.
Zehnder, Frank Günter, ed. Die Bühnen des Rokoko: Theater, Music, und Literatur im Rheinland des 18. Jahrhunderts. Vol. 7 of Der Riss im Himmel: Clemens August und seine Epoche, edited by Frank Günter Zehnder and Werner Schäfke. Cologne: Dumon, 2000.
Notes
1. Bonn, Electorate of Cologne
1. Thayer/Forbes, 1:44–45.
2. Ibid., 1:12.
3. Closson, “Grandfather Beethoven,” 369.
4. MacArdle, “Family van Beethoven,” 533.
5. Closson, “Grandfather Beethoven,” 370; Clive, Beethoven and His World, 23.
6. Blanning, Pursuit of Glory, 366.
7. Pfeiff, Bonn, 25.
8. Wetzstein/Fischer, 5n12.
9. Pfeiff, Bonn, 32.
10. Zehnder, Die Bühnen des Rokoko, 157.
11. Pfeiff, Bonn, passim.
12. Knopp, “Die Stadtgestalt Bonns,” 52–54.
13. Thayer/Forbes, 1:16.
14. Siebengebirge denotes “seven mountains,” but they are mostly hills and there are more than forty of them, so one finds various theories about the origin of the name.
15. Victor Hugo, quoted in Scherman and Biancolli, 5.
16. Knopp, “Die Stadtgestalt Bonns,” 51.
17. Stader, “Bonn und der Rhein,” 122.
18. Thayer/Forbes, 1:40.
19. Madame de Staël, quoted in Knight, Beethoven, 10.
20. Marek
, Beethoven, 26.
21. Raynor, Social History, 299. He gives 50,000 thalers as the cost of an opera production, which is about 75,000 florins. Here and throughout I will convert most sums to florins, for comparison.
22. This bon mot may be traditional or may be Thayer’s.
23. Pfeiff, Bonn, 43.
24. Wetzstein/Fischer, 11nn33–34.
25. Thayer/Forbes, 1:17.
26. Ibid., 1:11.
27. Valder-Knechtges, “Andrea Luchesi,” 46.
28. Wetzstein/Fischer, 13 and n42, 151.
29. Solomon, “Economic Circumstances,” 334.
30. In Germany and Austria, the “first” floor of a building is the one above the ground floor. In American terms, then, the Beethovens rented the third floor of the Fischer house. Here, American floor numbers will be used.
31. Wetzstein/Fischer, 7.
32. Ibid., 27.
33. Thayer/Forbes, 1:18–19.
34. Wetzstein/Fischer, 14.
35. Ibid., 12n35.
36. Ibid., 12. As in much of Gottfried Fischer’s memoir, this would have been his sister Cäcilie’s recollection, because old Ludwig died before Gottfried was born.
37. Wegeler/Ries, 14.
38. Closson, “Grandfather Beethoven,” 372.
39. Wetzstein/Fischer, 22.
40. Thayer/Forbes, 1:50–51.
41. Wetzstein/Fischer, 21–22.
42. Ibid., 29 and n113.
43. Ibid., 33.
44. Schiedermair, 97.
45. Wetzstein/Fischer, 28.
46. Thayer/Forbes, 1:23. In January 1773, a singer applying to fill Ludwig’s place in the court choir describes him as “incapacitated.” Wetzstein/Fischer, 7n18, says that Amelius is the painter’s correct first name, not Thayer/Forbes’s Johann.
47. The description of this painting is based on Owen Jander’s article, “Let Your Deafness,” 54–60. The detail concerning where Ludwig’s finger points is mine. It seems significant that Ludwig points not toward the musical score but rather to his hand turning the page, which suggests that it was not only music itself that saved him but also his engagement with it.
48. Closson, “Grandfather Beethoven,” 371.
49. Thayer/Forbes, 1:55.
50. Solomon, “Economic Circumstances,” 337–38.
51. Davies, Character of a Genius, 4.
52. Solomon, “Economic Circumstances,” 336n22.
53. Wetzstein/Fischer, 32n129.
54. Ibid., 27n107.
55. Zehnder, Die Bühnen des Rokoko, 153.
2. Father, Mother, Son
1. My sense of a prodigy’s upbringing and the risks and problems it entails comes from a variety of sources about rearing children in exacting disciplines such as music and athletics, but mainly from an interview of ca. 1984 with the celebrated violin teacher Dorothy DeLay about musical prodigies she had known and taught at Juilliard.
2. Wetzstein/Fischer, 45–46. Again, memories of Ludwig van Beethoven’s first thirteen or so years that appear in Gottfried Fischer’s memoir would have largely come from his sister Cäcilie, because Gottfried was born ten years after Ludwig, and Cäcilie eight years before.
3. To a degree, this is speculation about Johann’s goals for his son, based on old Ludwig’s training of Johann, which would have been his model—but with the added element that Ludwig the younger was far more talented than his father and was trained as a keyboard soloist rather than as a singer.
4. Wetzstein/Fischer, 46–47.
5. Skowroneck, “Keyboard Instruments,” 154–57. He points out that Johann sometimes forced Ludwig to play in the middle of the night. This implies he was playing the quiet clavichord so as not to disturb the Fischer family one floor below.
6. Wetzstein/Fischer, 22.
7. Ibid., 57–58. This story also shows that Johann, like his son, honored old Ludwig’s memory.
8. Ibid., 65–66.
9. Solomon, “Economic Circumstances,” 11.
10. Wetzstein/Fischer, 36n140; Thayer/Forbes, 1:17. Belderbusch did not yet have the title Graf, or Count.
11. Ohm, “Zur Sozialpolitik,” 193.
12. Quoted in Solomon, Beethoven, 47–48.
13. Im Hof, Enlightenment, 27.
14. Quoted in Marek, Beethoven, 145.
15. Blanning, Pursuit of Glory, 518.
16. Quoted in Brandt, “Banditry Unleash’d,” 20.
17. Gutzmer, Chronik der Stadt Bonn, 76.
18. Pfeiff, Bonn, 47. Wetzstein/Fischer, 48, includes a contemporary print of the fire showing the injured and dead lying in the courtyard.
19. Wetzstein/Fischer, 50n183.
20. Quoted in Schiedermair, 173.
21. The story of the Electoral Residence fire is in Wetzstein/Fischer, 47–52.
22. Ibid., 30.
23. Solomon, “Economic Circumstances,” 347–48.
24. Wetzstein/Fischer, 41.
25. The stories on these pages are from ibid., 37–42 passim.
26. Ibid., 57.
27. Zehnder, Die Bühnen des Rokoko, 162.
28. Thayer/Forbes, 1:57–58. Barry Cooper, in Beethoven, 4, notes that “concerto” in this case probably means a concerto arranged for one player, as was often done in those days. The “trios” are more puzzling unless there were other players involved.
29. Solomon doubts that Johann deliberately lied about Ludwig’s age (Beethoven, 4). I am inclined to think Johann did, for three reasons: It is unlikely that both parents would lose track of their son’s real age. When Ludwig later went to Holland with his mother and played at court in the Hague, his correct age was listed on the program. And adjusting his son’s age to make him look more Mozartian seems like a typical scheme of Johann’s. Probably because of Johann’s deception, for most of his life Beethoven himself was confused about his age.
30. Skowroneck, “Keyboard Instruments,” 155, votes for early instruction in clavichord, then harpsichord, organ, and piano; Thayer/Forbes votes for piano.
31. Clive, Beethoven and His World, 99.
32. The Pfeifer stories are in Wetzstein/Fischer, 64–74. Cäcilie Fischer remembered the flutist fondly; there is much warmth in the stories recalled by Gottfried Fischer, who was born after Pfeifer left Bonn.
33. Schiedermair, 38. The Bonn court musical establishment was larger in the early 1700s than it was in Ludwig van Beethoven’s childhood.
34. Gutzmer, Chronik der Stadt Bonn, 73.
35. Mozart, quoted in Sisman, “Spirit of Mozart,” 46.
36. Thayer/Forbes, 1:37.
37. Bodsch, “Das kulturelle Leben,” 68.
38. Christian Neefe report, in Thayer/Forbes, 1:37.
39. Braubach, “Von den Menschen,” 109.
40. The public-versus-private performance equation varied from place to place: by the later eighteenth century, for example, England had a tradition of public performances of orchestra music, oratorio, and the like—some of that due to the efforts of producer Johann Peter Salomon—while in Vienna, musical life was still largely centered in private salons.
41. Sisman, “Spirit of Mozart,” 46.
42. Gutzmer, Chronik der Stadt Bonn, 72.
43. Ibid., 79.
44. Landon, Beethoven unabridged, 24.
45. Matthäus, “Beiträge zur Musickgeschichte Bonns,” 138–39.
46. Wetzstein/Fischer, 98.
47. Ibid., 41; B. Cooper, Beethoven, 4.
48. Wetzstein/Fischer, 98–100. Years later Cäcilie remembered Maria’s words in detail—and Cäcilie never married.
49. Ibid., 58–59.
50. Ibid., 61.
51. Ibid., 63.
52. Ibid., 114.
53. Memory of court musician B. J. Mäurer, in ibid., 65n238.
3. Reason and Revolution
1. Wetzstein/Fischer, 54. The console and pedals and bench from the Minorite Church organ Beethoven played now reside in the Beethoven House in Bonn.
2. Thayer/Forbes, 1:58–59. It is not known exactly when Beethov
en started school, but he likely attended five years at most. After he left the Tirocinium, someone named Zambona tutored him in Latin, logic, French, and Italian (Wetzstein/Fischer, 45n172). In adulthood his French was sketchy, his Italian reportedly fair.
3. Wetzstein/Fischer, 52.
4. Ibid., 91.
5. Gottfried Fischer’s copious account of Johann’s journeys with his son is in ibid., 90–98. (His spelling of Rovantini shows the Bonn pronunciation: Ruffangtini.) While he cites people and places in detail, Gottfried is probably enfolding a series of summer trips the Beethovens made in that period.
6. Gutiérrez-Denhoff. Die gute Kocherey, 33–34.
7. Wetzstein/Fischer, 100–102. Cäcilie Fischer said the kindly and handsome Rovantini was the only man she would ever have married.
8. Schiedermair, 140–41.
9. Andraschke, “Neefe’s Volkstümlichkeit,” passim.
10. Schiedermair, 151.
11. Ibid., 149; Weck, “Wer ist ein freier Mann?” 853.
12. Ohm, “Zur Sozialpolitik,” 198.
13. Quoted in Cadenbach, “Neefe als Literat,” 151. Cadenbach adds that Neefe in fact was “no matador” of the tonal art.
14. Schiedermair, 143.
15. Irmen, “Neefe,” 179.
16. Marek, Beethoven, 5–8.
17. Berlin, Age of Enlightenment: “The unprecedented successes of the mathematical method in the seventeenth century left its mark on philosophy . . . This led to notable successes and equally notable failures, as the over-enthusiastic and fanatical application of techniques rich in results in one field, when mechanically applied to another . . . commonly does . . . The eighteenth century is perhaps the last period in the history of Western Europe when human omniscience was thought to be an attainable goal” (14). My overall conception of the Enlightenment here is close to the spirit of Berlin’s conclusion: “The intellectual power, honesty, lucidity, courage, and disinterested love of the truth of the most gifted thinkers of the eighteenth century remain to this day without parallel. Their age is one of the best and most hopeful episodes in the life of mankind” (29). As we will see, Beethoven, for all his paranoia and bitterness, his lack of a coherent political agenda (except his admiration for the British parliamentary system), and his scarcely democratic contempt for most of the people around him, never really departed from the Aufklärung ideals of his youth.
Beethoven: Anguish and Triumph Page 110