Kate Burkholder 01-Sworn to Silence

by Linda Castillo

  I push my hands into warm dough. Bored with bread making, I wish for a radio, but Datt has expressly forbidden it. Instead, I hum a tune I heard in the Carriage Shop in town. A song about New York, and I wonder what the world is like beyond the cornfields and pastures of Painters Mill. They are dreams I shouldn’t have, but they are mine and they are secret.

  I sense someone behind me. When I turn, I see Daniel Lapp at the door. He wears dark trousers with suspenders and a gray work shirt. A flat-brimmed straw hat covers his head. He looks at me the way a man looks at a woman. I know I shouldn’t, but I smile.

  “God will not forgive you,” he says.

  That’s when I notice the burgeoning red stain on his shirt. Blood, I realize. I want to run, but my feet are frozen. When I look down, I’m standing in a lake of blood. I see flecks of red on the curtains. Handprints on the counter. Smears on my dress.

  Outside the window, a crow caws and takes flight. I feel Daniel’s breath against my ear. I hear vile words I do not understand.

  “Murderer,” he whispers. “Murderer.”

  I wake in a cold sweat. For an instant, I’m fourteen years old, helpless, terrified and ashamed. Throwing off the covers, I sit up and put my feet on the floor. My breaths echo in the silence of my bedroom. Nausea climbs up my throat, but I swallow it and slowly the dream recedes.

  Sitting on the side of the bed, I put my face in my hands. I hate the nightmare. I hate even more that it still wields the power to reduce me to a frightened adolescent. I breathe deeply and remind myself who I am. A grown woman. A police officer.

  As the sweat cools on my body and I rise to dress, I swear to the God I have forsaken—the God who has forsaken me—I will never be helpless or ashamed again.

  Farmers begin their day early in Painters Mill. At seven o’clock sharp I stand outside the double glass doors of Quality Implement and Farm Supply and think about the conversation I’m about to have with Donny Beck. The sign on the door tells me the store opens for business at seven A.M. Monday through Saturday. Someone is running late this morning. Peering through the glass, I tap with my keys.

  A short woman wearing a red smock and a nametag that reads “Dora” smiles at me through the glass. The keys in her hand jingle as she twists the lock. “Morning,” she says. “You’re the first customer of the day.”

  I flash my badge. “I need to talk to Donny Beck. Is he here?”

  Her smile falters. “He’s in the break room getting coffee.”

  “Where?”

  “It’s at the back of the store.” She points. “Want me to take you?”

  “I’ll find it.” I start toward the rear of the store. I shop here every so often. It’s a nice place to pick up yard stuff like flowers, pots, hand tools. The police department buys tires for city vehicles here. But Quality Implement mostly sells farm supplies. Plowshares. Tractor tires. Fencing. Augers.

  The rubber smell of new tires fills my nostrils as I approach the back of the store. I make a left, walking between massive, floor-to-ceiling shelves stacked with tires of every shape and size. Ahead, I hear laughter. A door stands open at the end of the aisle. I purposefully arrived at the start of the business day to catch Beck off guard. I want him unprepared so I can gauge his unrehearsed reactions when I ask him about Amanda Horner.

  I find Donny in the break room wolfing down a breakfast sandwich from the diner. A petite blonde wearing a Quality Implement smock sits across from him, slurping Coke through a straw. Both young people look up when I enter. The sandwich stops midway to Beck’s mouth. He knows why I’m here.

  I give the girl a pointed look. “Can you excuse us?”

  “ ’Kay.” She grabs her Coke and leaves the room.

  Closing the door behind her, I face Donny Beck.

  He swallows hard. “I guess you want to talk to me about Amanda.”

  I nod. “I’m Kate Burkholder, Chief of Police.”

  “I know who you are. You gave my dad a speeding ticket once.” Rising, he leans over the table and extends his hand. “I’m Donny Beck. You already know that, though.”

  I shake his hand. His grip is firm, but his palm is slick with sweat. He seems like a decent young man. A farm boy. Probably uses the money he earns here to fix up his muscle car and raise hell on Saturday night. “When’s the last time you saw Amanda?” I begin.

  “The night we broke up. About six weeks ago.”

  “How long had you two been seeing each other?”

  “Seven months.”

  “Was it serious?”

  “I thought so.”

  “Who broke up with whom?”

  “She broke up with me.”

  “Why’d she do that?”

  “She was going back to college. She didn’t want to be tied down.” He grimaces. “She said she didn’t love me.”

  “You get pissed off when she dumped you?”

  “No. I mean, I was upset, but I didn’t get mad.”

  “Really? Why not?”

  He chokes out a sound of denial. “I’m not like that.”

  “Did you love her?”

  Emotion flashes in his eyes, and he looks down at his half-eaten breakfast sandwich. “Yeah, I guess I did.”

  “Were you sleeping with her?”

  To my surprise, his face reddens. He gives me a nod.

  “She sleep around with anyone else?”

  “I don’t think so.”

  “Did you two fight?”

  “No.” As if catching himself, his gaze snaps to mine. “I mean we did. Sometimes. But not often. She was pretty easygoing.” He shrugs. “I was crazy about her.”

  “Did she have any enemies?”

  He shakes his head. “Everyone liked Amanda. She was sweet. Fun to be with.”

  “Where were you Saturday night?”

  “I went to Columbus with my dad and little brother.”

  “What were you doing in Columbus?”

  “We went to a basketball game. Special Olympics. My brother’s handicapped.”

  “You spend the night?”

  “Yeah.”

  “Where did you stay?”

  “Holiday Inn off of Interstate 23.”

  “You know I’m going to check.” I jot everything down.

  “It’s okay. We were there.”

  “When Amanda told you she didn’t want to be tied down, did you get jealous?”

  “No. I mean, a little. Like, when I imagined her going out with other guys. But not like that.”

  “What do you mean?”

  “I’d never hurt Amanda. Jesus Christ, not like that.” A quiver runs through the last word.

  “Like what?”

  “I heard … what he did to her.”

  “Who’d you hear it from?”

  “Waitress at the diner said he … you know.” Sweat beads on his forehead and upper lip. Wrapping the sandwich in a napkin, he tosses it into the trash. “Makes me sick.”

  “I need you to think hard about this, Donny. Is it possible Amanda was seeing someone else?”

  He shakes his head. “I don’t think so. She wasn’t guy crazy or anything. Amanda had a level head.”

  “So you think she was being straight with you?”

  “She said she wanted to stay friends.” He lifts a shoulder, lets it drop. “I figured that was a lot better than never seeing her again.” His eyes mist. “Doesn’t matter now. I’m never going to see her again, anyway, am I?”

  I shove my notepad into my coat pocket. “Don’t leave town, okay?”

  His gaze meets mine. In his eyes I see the kind of pain a twenty-two-year-old farm kid probably can’t fake, and I feel an uncharacteristic need to reassure him.

  “You guys think I did it?” he asks.

  “I just want you to be available in case I have more questions.”

  Leaning back in the chair, he swipes at his eyes with the back of his hand.

  “I don’t have any plans to go anywhere, anyway.”

  I offer my card. “If yo
u think of anything else, call me.”

  He looks at the card. “I hope you guys catch the lowlife who did that to her. Amanda didn’t deserve to die.”

  “No, she didn’t.” As I make my exit, I mentally cross Donny Beck off my list of suspects.

  It’s not yet eight A.M. when I arrive at the station. Glock’s cruiser is parked in its usual spot. Next to it, Mona’s Ford Escort is covered with a thin coating of snow. I wonder what new catastrophe waits for me inside.

  Mona looks up from her phone when I enter. “Hey, Chief. You’ve got messages.”

  “Now there’s a surprise.” I take a dozen slips from her.

  Her hair is piled on top of her head with little ringlets spiraling down. Her lipstick is almost as black as her nail polish. Maroon eyeliner makes her look like she’s got a bad case of pinkeye. “Norm Johnston is getting pissed about having to leave messages, Chief. He’s like, you know, taking it out on me.”

  “Did he say what he wants?”

  “Your head on a platter, probably.”

  I give her a look.

  “Just a wild guess.”

  I laugh. “Where’s Glock?”

  She glances down at the switchboard where a single red light stands out.

  “On the phone.”

  “When he gets off, tell him to call me.” I walk to the coffee station and fill the biggest mug I can find. In my office I turn on my computer, then drape my coat over the back of my chair. I’m anxious to see if OHLEG came back with a hit on Daniel Lapp.

  My hopes are dashed when I log in. If he’s alive, he’s being careful. Probably using an alias. Maybe even a stolen identity or false social security number. Under normal circumstances, I’d start flashing his photo around town. But I can’t risk raising questions. People will want to know why I’m asking about a man who hasn’t been seen for sixteen years. They’ll put two and two together, and Daniel Lapp will rise out of obscurity like some Amish version of Jack the Ripper.

  I dial Norm Johnston’s number. Miller’s pond would do the job. It’s a good size body of water with a muddy bottom.

  Johnston answers on the first ring. “I’ve been trying to reach you for almost two days, Chief Burkholder.”

  “I’m tied up with this murder, Norm. What can I do for you?”

  “The town council and mayor want to meet with you. Today.”

  “Norm, look, I need to work—”

  “With all due respect, Kate, you are obligated to keep us informed. We want an update on how the investigation is progressing.”

  “We’re working on a couple of leads.”

  “Do you have a suspect?”

  “I put out a press release—”

  “That doesn’t say squat.”

  I sigh. “To be perfectly honest, I don’t know much.”

  “Then a meeting won’t take long. I’ll have everyone in the city room at noon. We’ll have you out of there in twenty minutes.”

  He hangs up without waiting for a response and without thanking me. He’s still pissed about that DUI. Self-serving bastard.

  “Chief?” I’m so immersed in my thoughts I didn’t hear Mona approach.

  “There’s someone here to see you.”

  Something in her eyes puts me on alert. Now what? I think. A moment later my sister appears in my doorway. I’ve been the chief of police for over two years. In all that time, neither Sarah nor my brother have visited me here. For a moment I almost can’t believe what I’m seeing. Then I remember my conversation with Jacob the night before.

  “Hello, Katie.” Sarah wears a navy dress with a black apron and a heavy winter cape. Her blonde hair is parted severely at the center and drawn into a bun at her nape, all of which is covered by the traditional Amish kapp. She’s two years older than me, pretty and expecting her first child in just over a month.

  Rising, I round my desk, pull out the visitor chair for her and close the door.

  “Have a seat.” After an awkward moment, I ask, “How are you feeling?”

  It’s an uncomfortable question. This isn’t the first time Sarah has been pregnant. There have been three times that I know of. Each time she’s miscarried late in the second trimester.

  She smiles. “I think it is God’s will that I have this baby.”

  I return her smile. She’ll be a good mother; I hope she gets the chance.

  “Did you drive the buggy into town all by yourself?”

  She nods, her gaze flicking away briefly, and I know she’s here against her husband’s wishes. “William is at the horse auction in Keene.”

  “I see.” Waiting, I watch her struggle with some internal conflict I can’t quite identify.

  “I talked to Jacob,” she says after a moment. “He told me you went to the grain elevator. That Daniel Lapp may be alive.”

  “It’s only a theory.” I can’t keep my eyes from sliding to the door to make sure we’re not overheard.

  She continues as if she didn’t hear me. “All these years we believed he was with God.”

  God. The word burns away the last of my patience. I want to tell her the son of a bitch who raped me is burning in hell where he belongs. “Even if he’s dead, I doubt he’s with God.”

  “Katie.” Her eyes meet mine. “Someone was in the barn. Three days ago.”

  The hairs at my nape prickle. “Who?”

  “I do not know.”

  “Tell me what happened.”

  “I was milking and heard the hay chute door slam. When I looked, no one was there. But I saw footprints in the snow.”

  “Were the tracks made by a man?”

  “I think so. The shoes were large.”

  “Why didn’t you tell me this sooner?”

  “At the time I did not think it important. But now …” She averts her gaze, then looks back at me with nervous eyes. “Do you think it could be Daniel? Is he back and killing?”

  To consider the possibility that Lapp is not only alive but a possible threat to my family adds an edgy new dimension to the situation. “I don’t know.”

  “What if he is angry with us for what we did and seeking revenge?” She lowers her voice. “Katie, I do not wish to burden you with my fears, but I believe the time has come for you to tell your English police about Lapp.”

  I flinch. “No.”

  “You do not have to tell them … all of it.”

  “No.” The word comes out more harshly than I intend, but I don’t take it back. “Don’t ask me to do that.”

  Sarah’s gaze remains steadfast on mine. “What if Daniel returns? What if he tries to hurt me or William?” She sets her hand on her swollen abdomen. “I have this child to think of now.”

  Dread curdles like sour milk in my gut. I try to think of some way to reassure her. But I have no words. Leaning forward, I take her hand and lower my voice. “Sarah, listen to me. Jacob believes Daniel died that day. I think so, too.”

  “Then why were you looking for his body?”

  My brain scrambles for answers that aren’t there. “All I can tell you is that I’m good at what I do. Please. Trust me. Let me handle this my way.”

  My phone rings again. I look down to find three lines blinking in discord, but my attention stays focused on my sister. “You know I’ll do everything I can to keep you safe.”

  “How can you keep us safe when you don’t even know where he is?”

  I hate it that I don’t have the answers she needs. A knock on the door draws my attention. “Sarah, I’m sorry.” I release her hand. “I have to get to work. We’ll talk more about this later.”

  “I do not think this will wait.”

  “Please, just give me some time.”

  The door opens. Mona steps in. “Sorry, Chief, I just wanted to let you know the sheriff called.” She passes pink slips to me.

  “Would you ask T.J. to escort Sarah home?” I ask Mona.

  Sarah tosses me a sheepish look. “That is not necessary.”

  “I’d feel better if he did. The r
oads are slick in spots.”

  Mona offers Sarah a grin. “Come on, Sister Sarah. Let’s find T.J.”

  Watching my sister walk away, I try not to be troubled, but I am. Who was in her barn and why? Is she right about Lapp? Has he targeted my family? Are they in danger? The questions taunt me with terrible possibilities.

  … the time has come for you to tell your English police about Lapp.

  Sarah’s words echo inside my head like a hammer strike against steel. I tell myself she doesn’t understand the implications of a confession on my part. That it would irrevocably harm my career. My reputation. My credibility. This case. Maybe even land me in jail. That’s not to mention the damage that would be done to my family. If Lapp is dead, it would all be for nothing.

  There’s no way dredging up the past will help.

  No way at all.

  Ten minutes later I find Glock in his office, the phone stuck to his ear. He looks at me when I peek in and raises his finger, telling me to hold on. After a moment, he hangs up and shakes his head. “That was the BCI lab in London.”

  “Any luck with the tread or footwear imprints?”

  “They got a partial tread that doesn’t match any of the first responders.”

  My heart rolls into a staccato. “Can they match it with a manufacturer?”

  “Their tire guy is working on it.” He shrugs. “Fifty-fifty chance of IDing the tread.”

  The news isn’t great, but I’ll take anything positive at this point. “I’m going to talk to Scott Brower.” Brower was at the Brass Rail the night Amanda Horner disappeared. He’s of particular interest because he’s got an arrest record, one of which involved a knife. “Wanna come?”

  “Wouldn’t miss it. You buying breakfast?”

  “As long as it’s fast.”

  Ten minutes later we’re in my Explorer heading toward Mr. Lube, where Brower works as a mechanic. Next to me, Glock finishes his breakfast burrito and stuffs the napkin into the bag.

  “Any luck with Donny Beck?” he asks.

  Shaking my head, I tell him about my conversation with the kid. “I don’t think he did it.”