Hidden

by Catherine McKenzie

  So I knew I was in trouble.

  I just didn’t know how much.

  In the midst of all this thinking, I finally broke up with Lily, driving twelve hours to do it in person. Six hours there, a two-hour prolonged and tearful—on her part—conversation, then six hours back, knowing I’d done the right thing but still feeling shitty. Would I have tried harder to work things out if Claire wasn’t in the picture? But Claire wasn’t really in the picture, so why was I acting as if she were? My brain wheeled round and round until I took the final turn off the highway for home and my spirits began to lift.

  I was now twenty-four, free, and half in love with my brother’s ex-girlfriend. I did a few stupid things to try to get her out of my system. Like hanging out in the local hook-up bar, taking home girls I knew I was never going to ask out again, who’d become someone I avoided in the grocery store. I was having fun, but I was brooding too. Assuming Claire did want to go out with me, how was I ever going to get past the Tim factor?

  Then she did it for me.

  About six months after we’d first met, we were having lunch at a deli that had opened recently near her office.

  I’d received a postcard from Tim. Welcome to Coolangatta it read, with the words Learning to scuba written on the back. I had to look up the name to figure out he was in Australia. It was in my pocket, and I was fingering it nervously, wondering if I should show it to her. I eventually decided to do it, and tried to act casual as I pulled out the slightly moist card and slid it across the counter towards her.

  “Heard from Tim,” I said, taking a large bite of my sandwich.

  “Oh?”

  She picked up the card, staring at the azure ocean, the cloudless sky, the red sand beach. I watched her out of the corner of my eye as she turned it over and read the words on the back.

  “Well, that’s that, then.” She pushed it back to me.

  “What’s that?”

  “Tim wanted to go to Australia. That’s why we broke up.”

  “You didn’t want to go?”

  She shook her head, looked away.

  “I know how that feels.” I took a sip of my Coke to wet my drying throat. “Lily, I told you about her, right? Anyway, she didn’t want to move here. So …”

  “So?”

  “We broke up.”

  “I heard.”

  I wondered what else she’d heard. Not too much, hopefully.

  “Small towns.”

  She played with her napkin. “The funny thing is, I would’ve gone with him if he’d really wanted me to, but the minute I expressed some reluctance he blew it up into this big thing, like he was looking for an excuse to break up.”

  “Idiot.”

  “Pardon?”

  “I said, my brother’s an idiot.”

  “Yeah, well, some things aren’t meant to work out. I mean, if he really loved me, we would’ve figured it out, right?”

  Did that mean I hadn’t really loved Lily? Because I thought I had. It certainly felt like love during the good parts. But one thing was certain: Claire loved Tim enough to move around the world for him; I’d better put my dreams away if I knew what was good for me.

  She put her hand on my knee. Thoughts of Tim receded.

  “You won’t tell Tim about any of this, will you?”

  “Of course not.”

  “Thanks, Jeff, you’re a really good friend.” She leaned forward and kissed me on the cheek, then pulled back, looking confused. “I’m sorry.”

  “No, don’t be. I … I’ve wanted that for a while now.”

  “You’ve wanted me to kiss you on the cheek?”

  “Among other places,” I said, hoping I was striking the right flirty tone, my heart racing against my chest.

  “Well, then, maybe we should do something about that,” she said slowly.

  “What did you have in mind?”

  She thought about it for a moment. “Do you like Asian food?”

  As I stood in the shower two nights later, a riot of rationalization skipped through my brain. He broke up with her. She’d asked me out. He’d barely communicated with any of us for months. Maybe he was never coming back. Besides, if I even wanted to ask his permission, he’d made that impossible. We had no address, no phone number, no way of contacting him. He’d untethered himself from us. How could he complain if things happened? How could he be surprised if life moved on?

  I towelled off and climbed into fresh clothes: a new pair of jeans, a collared shirt, and my trusty blazer. Maybe it was too dressy for the occasion, but it felt like a time to dress up.

  I drove to Claire’s, wishing I’d taken the time to clean out the inside of my beaten-up Toyota. She was waiting on the stoop—something I took as a good sign—wearing a wool skirt and a turtleneck sweater. She had on some makeup and her hair was shiny. I was glad I’d gone with the blazer.

  We went to dinner at the only Thai restaurant in town, and the conversation flowed in an easy way I hadn’t felt in a while, maybe never. She teased me about my lack of knowledge of Asian cuisine, and I ate whatever she put in front of me, struggling with my chopsticks. Some of it was slimy, and some of it was too spicy for my taste. I washed it all down with too many Chinese beers, and by the end of the meal I was slightly drunk.

  After dinner, we took a walk through the town square. The bare trees had lights strung through them, a leftover from Christmas. They glinted off Claire’s hair, and to me, she looked perfect. It was coming on spring and the air was warm, though there was still some snow on the ground. A gentle breeze blew through the trees, and I breathed in the loamy smell of wet earth, dead grass, and old snow. I’d be golfing in a month if I was lucky.

  I felt light on my feet and happy.

  Happy in my soul.

  Claire strolled next to me, her hands clasped behind her back, like she was keeping them to herself. I wanted possession of her hand — I wanted more than that, but the hand would do for now—so I said something silly to distract her, and it worked. Her arms fell to her side and I seized the opportunity. She started slightly, looking down at her soft, white hand encased in mine, then up at me.

  By the smile on her face, I knew we’d be kissing soon.

  Any moment now.

  Any moment now.

  CHAPTER 4

  A Shot through the Heart

  One of the police officers (the one I can’t place) tells me he’ll check on Seth. The other leads me to the couch, giving me the barest of details before asking if he can call anyone for me. I mutter something about the emergency contact list taped next to the kitchen phone. And all the time I’m feeling stunned, detached, a million miles from the tragedy that’s unfolding in my house like space after the big bang.

  Time passes. People start arriving. My mother. My father. My doctor. Friends, friends, friends, until the house is full, there have never been this many people in the house, I couldn’t get away from them if I tried.

  At one point I begin calling Seth’s name and my mother, I think it’s my mother, shushes me and says Seth’s fine, Seth’s being taken care of, what do I need? I give her a look that says, Are you seriously asking me that? She knows what I need. Everyone knows what I need, but I’m not getting that again. Not ever.

  More time passes, and now I have to go to the bathroom, but I seem glued to the couch, kept there by the prison of people talking low, some fighting back tears, some crying openly. They all want to hug me, but the feel of their skin on mine, the words they say in my ear, make me feel worse. I’m convinced in this moment that if I choose to, I can leave my mind and never come back again.

  A family friend and my lifelong doctor, Dr. Mayer, sits next to me and presses something into my hand. Pills. I don’t want to take them, but he guides my hand to my mouth and gives me a glass of water to swallow them down with. I do it and he nods approvingly. He takes me by the elbow, manoeuvring me through the throngs of people (do I really know this many people?) and up to my bedroom.

  Without asking, he tak
es me into the bathroom and suggests I use the facilities. He leaves me alone long enough to pee, and to register, as I stand up, that whatever he gave me is acting fast, that I really am in space now.

  I wobble as I come out of the bathroom. Dr. Mayer catches hold of me and walks me to my bed, removes my shoes, pants, and sweater. He folds me into the covers, and in an instant all is black but the stars.

  I spend most of the weekend in bed, in proper pyjamas now, courtesy of my mother. Every couple of hours someone comes to check on me, or bring me food I can’t swallow, or more pills, which I reluctantly do. My bedroom’s been transformed into a hospital ward, all the comings and goings, the checking on the patient. It reminds me of the days I spent in the hospital after Seth was born by emergency Caesarean. It was too loud to sleep, and food and meds were pushed on me there too. All I wanted to do then was hold Seth, and that’s the same now. He’s spent the last two nights sleeping next to me, in Jeff’s place, his body in the same half-pike position his father sleeps (slept, slept, it’s slept now, Jesus) in.

  My sister, Beth, arrives Sunday night. I can hear her downstairs talking to my parents, asking how I’m doing. Unlike everyone else, she makes no effort to talk low, despite my mother’s shushing. Instead, she takes the stairs two at a time and, in an instant, she’s climbing into bed next to me fully clothed, curling onto her side like we used to do as kids.

  “You look like shit,” she says.

  “God, Beth. Jeff—”

  “It’s awful, so awful, I’m barely functioning myself. But I think you might feel better, I truly do, if you get up and take a shower, maybe change into some real clothes. Eat something. Mom tells me you haven’t had anything since Friday.”

  “Not hungry.”

  “Will you try, sweetie? For me?”

  I glance at the bedside clock behind her. Two more hours until someone arrives with the magic pills that keep the world at a safe distance.

  “Funeral pills,” Dr. Mayer called them yesterday when I asked what they were. Then he turned bright red, like he couldn’t believe the words had escaped his mouth. He apologized, but I told him it was okay. I mean, it wasn’t, it was never going to be okay, but there’s going to be a funeral, and as much as I thought I was done with taking pills, it’s clear to me now that I’m going to need them to get through it.

  “I don’t have anything to wear,” I say to Beth.

  “Of course you do, hon. You’ve got a closet full of clothes.”

  “I meant for the …” I pause to gulp in air, not sure I can get the word out. “Funeral.”

  Beth brushes my tears away. “Oh, Claire. I’m so, so sorry.”

  Sunday night is a fog of drugs and bad, vivid dreams. Seth’s still sleeping with me, and though he hasn’t said much, his sleep speaks for him. He thrashes and kicks and moans, behaviour I’ve never seen before, not even when he was a tiny thing. I rest my hand on his chest, above his heart, and it seems to calm him. But if I drift away and my hand follows suit, it’s only minutes until he’s back at it again, a whirling dervish of grief who doesn’t have access to the medicinal solace I’ve been allowed.

  When I asked Dr. Mayer if something could be done for Seth too, he told me it wasn’t standard procedure. Kids are resilient, he said.

  Meaning what? I almost asked.

  And if I need the drugs, what does that make me? Weak?

  Pliable?

  All I know is that we’re both broken and it’s too soon to tell if it’s beyond repair.

  I open my eyes in the early light of morning. Seth’s face is inches from mine. He’s also awake. He looks so like Jeff in this moment, same chocolatey-brown eyes, same dark, unruly hair. I stop myself just in time from using his name.

  “Were you having a bad dream, baby?”

  Usually this term of endearment is met with an eye roll and a reminder to never call him that in public, but today all he says is “Yeah.”

  “Do you want to talk about it?”

  “Nah.”

  “Maybe if you told me, it wouldn’t seem so bad?”

  “Don’t think so.”

  “How do you know if you don’t try?”

  A tear rolls down his face. “Because when I woke up the dream was still true.”

  Whatever pieces of my heart that are still intact break in this instant. I can’t make things better for my son. I can’t take away his nightmares because life is a nightmare now.

  Jeff, Jeff. How could you leave us like this?

  “I’m sorry, baby.”

  He buries his head in my neck. We lie there like this for a while, the room brightening around us, the day marching on, even if we’re frozen.

  Around seven, Seth sits up abruptly. “I want to go to school.”

  “I don’t think that’s a good idea. Not yet.”

  “But there are so many people here, all the time.”

  “Won’t school be full of people?”

  “I’m used to that.”

  “Things might be different now.”

  “I think I’ll feel … better there than here. Can I? Please, Mom?”

  I nod. “Don’t feel like you have to stay if things are hard, okay?”

  “Okay. Are you going to be all right?”

  “Beth’s here.”

  He kisses me on the cheek. “Thanks, Mom.”

  Seth gets up. I stay in bed, wishing he hadn’t wanted to go. I keep imagining what it will be like for him, wondering (because I can’t keep my mind from going to dark places) whether it will be like my first day back at work after we lost the baby.

  About four years ago, we got pregnant again. We’d been trying for years. We never intended such a large gap between Seth and our second. We’d even discussed having three, but we tried and tried and nothing happened. We saw Dr. Mayer. He tested both of us and found no medical reason for my inability to conceive. These things take time, he said, sometimes. We shouldn’t stress about it. In fact stressing about it would be a bad thing. Stressing about it could make it not happen.

  But how do you not stress about something like that? Especially when it’s your body you’re constantly looking for changes in. Do my breasts feel sore today, or is it the usual premenstrual soreness I get sometimes? Do I feel bloated? Is this the way I felt when I was pregnant with Seth?

  These thoughts would turn around and around in my mind every month until I was sick of it. I didn’t want to try anymore, I told Jeff. It was driving me crazy. He was disappointed but supportive. He wouldn’t admit it, but I think the pressure was getting to him too. And it was so nice to have regular sex again. When we wanted, without thinking about timing and body temperature and keeping my legs in the air for minutes afterwards. Just sex. Sometimes good, sometimes great, sometimes rushed in between Seth’s various activities, sometimes languid and slow and tender. Just us, again.

  Then we got pregnant.

  I didn’t believe it at first. In fact, I never really believed it. Not when my period was weeks late. Not when I finally peed on a stick and the second, blue line appeared, or when the doctor confirmed it with a blood test. Jeff was elated, and I pretended I was too, but deep down, I knew there was something wrong. I didn’t feel pregnant. Not like I had with Seth, not even like I had sometimes all those years when we were trying.

  Jeff wanted to tell people right away, too early, but I convinced him to hold off until we passed the third month. That way, if something went wrong, no one would have to know. Nothing was going to go wrong, he said confidently, and in his certainty, I almost found belief. Then night would come, and I’d hold my hand on my still-flat belly and wait for that feeling, that flutter, that extra rush of blood that was supposed to be bringing sustenance to the cells supposedly dividing inside me. I never felt it, not once.

  The three-month mark came, and Jeff was pressing me to tell someone, anyone, Seth, our parents, our friends. Wait until the ultrasound, I said, it’s only a few weeks away. Then we can tell. He looked at me for a long moment and asked m
e in a very quiet voice whether I wanted to be pregnant.

  “Of course I do. You know I do.”

  “Then what is it? Why won’t you tell anyone?”

  “I’m just worried—”

  “No, Claire, I don’t want to hear that again. There’s nothing wrong with the baby.”

  “You don’t know that.”

  “You weren’t like this with Seth. Why are you so convinced … what’s going on, really?”

  I gathered the breath to tell him, to confess to my nightly vigils, but in the cold light of day it sounded absurd.

  “It’s nothing. I don’t know why I’m so … we can start telling people, it’s okay.”

  “Are you sure?”

  “Of course. Who do you want to tell first?”

  We told Seth, my parents, his, our friends, and soon it felt like the whole town knew. They were all happy, so happy, for me, for us. I accepted the congratulations, the hugs. I told myself that the night flutters would come, that everything was fine.

  Then, one of my friends would say in a certain tone of voice, “You don’t even look pregnant,” and a shot of doubt would go to my heart and stay there, joining the others, building, building.

  As the ultrasound drew nearer, I started sleeping less and less. I know now that I was in the first throes of depression, but somehow, in the daylight, I was able to put on a happy face and keep it all inside. I was pregnant at last. I was happy. No, we didn’t want to know the sex, we preferred the surprise, thank you, thank you, oh, right, I’m sure I’ll be blowing up any day now. Any day now.

  On Ultrasound Day I woke up at four. I turned my head away from Jeff’s and watched the darkness turn to light. When it was a passable hour to get up, I pulled off the covers and hid in the shower. Looking down at my still-flat belly, I counted out the hours like the beats on a metronome until I’d know what I already knew.