Loved by the LumberJacks_A MFMMMM Reverse Harem Romance

by Sierra Sparks

  I could only find a handful of photos of him with women. Maybe he was gay, or maybe he preferred to keep his private life very private. There were a few gossip pieces about a broken engagement. His ex-fiancée was in prison for money laundering. She’d stolen trading information from him and passed it on to her employers. What a bitch.

  I studied bio and questions Alec had emailed me for the interview. Wyatt lived near Central Park in an apartment building called The Avalon, and as luck would have it, his apartment building was a few blocks away from the Expose club.

  I’d kill two birds with one stone. On the way to his apartment, I would stop by Expose Club and maybe ask if anyone had handed in a phone. No one needed to know I’d been a guest on the third floor. I would play it off as if I was just a regular club goer who’d lost her phone. Going back there was playing with fire, and I hoped I didn’t get my fingers burned.

  Chapter 7 – Paige Matthews

  Standing outside the club, I hugged my puffy winter coat around my body and looked up. I had called the club before coming, but no one answered so I decided to take my chances.

  The building was as day and night as it could ever be. There were no LED snowflakes floating over the exterior, and there was no blue carpet leading to the front door. There were also no Rottweilers or Pit bulls disguised as doormen guarding the entrance.

  Not only did the building look as different as day and night, but so did I. I had wanted to go home and change out of my chunky sweater and skinny jeans before my interview with Wyatt Palmer, but I’d fallen down the Google rabbit hole when researching him and lost track of time. I’d figured it was better to show up dressed casually and on time, than show up late and dressed professionally, but now I was second guessing that decision.

  Anxiety and nerves churned around my insides, but I couldn’t deny I was excited. I still couldn’t understand why he’d requested that I be the one to interview him, but I guess I’d find out that reason soon enough, when we met.

  I walked up to the club door and knocked, which was probably a dumb thing to do. What was I expecting: Jimmy the Rottweiler to throw the door open and invite me in for a cup of coffee? After a few minutes, when no one answered, I gave the door a push and was surprised when it opened.

  In daylight, with no lights flashing and no glamorous people walking around, the club was a cold and empty space that stank like stale booze. I headed straight to the cloakroom, hoping that maybe the checkin clerk from last night would be there. If she was, I would ask her if anyone had handed in a phone.

  Shutters covered the cloakroom door. I gave them a push, but they were locked tight.

  “Who the fuck are you and what the fuck are you doing here?” boomed a voice from behind.

  I spun around, and Jimmy stalked towards me with thunder filling his eyes. He wore a long sleeve black T-shirt and a pair of black pants. He was even more intimidating than he had been last night. There was no way he’d recognized me. Not with my glasses on and my hair scraped back.

  “Who the fuck do you think you are waltzing in here?”

  Screw him. I would not let this jumped-up douche intimidate me.

  “Number one, your door was open and number two, I don’t appreciate you talking to me like something you wipe off your shoe. It’s not like I’m an armed robber or thief. I came in to see if anyone handed in a phone last night. I dropped it somewhere in here.”

  He didn’t need to know exactly where I’d been in the club when I dropped it or who I’d been with.

  He grunted, and said, “You should know better than to even try to bring a phone here. If you had listened to the rules, you never would have lost it.”

  I just glared back at him, because I didn’t have a good argument to that one.

  Finally, softened a bit and said, “Stay here. I’ll have a look in the lost and found box.”

  It didn’t take him too long to reappear.

  “Well?” I asked expectantly.

  He shook his head. “Come back later. Maggie might know where it is.”

  “Thanks. I appreciate you checking. It has pictures of my grandma before she passed.”

  “Do you see anything on my face that looks like I care?”

  He was back to using gruff words but something close to sympathy flashed in his eyes, and I could tell he was lying. Maybe there was a heart beneath all that beef.

  He sighed.

  “Leave your name and a number, and if I find anything, I’ll call.”

  “Um, Pa— Patricia.” I rummaged through my bag for a piece of paper and a pen and scribbled down the burner phone number. “Call me anytime.”

  He flashed me a mischievous grin. “Is that a proposition?”

  “No,” I said and laughed. I could tell he was joking.

  “Hey, don’t I know you?” he asked. “You look sort of familiar.”

  “I come here a lot. Maybe you know my face because of that, but I don’t think we’ve ever met.”

  “Now we have. I’m Jimmy.”

  “Nice to meet you, Jimmy. Thanks again for your help.”

  I left the club. I would go back later to see if anyone had handed in my phone, but I doubted it would turn up.

  ***

  Since it was a beautiful, crisp winter day and the aura of Christmas filled the air, I walked the three blocks to The Avalon apartments. It would be faster than taking a cab, anyway. As I made my way to my destination, I told myself to calm down and not be nervouse, mentally reciting the information I’d read about Wyatt.

  I had researched and prepared as best as I could with such short advance notice. I told myself “you’ve got this. You’ll be fine.” But I wasn’t quite sure I believed it. There was a rumbling in my stomach that told me things could go badly, and I’d be out a job.

  The Avalon apartment building held more billionaires than should be legally allowed to exist in one area. The building sat on the corner of 5th and 69th and gave stunning views of Central Park.

  I hurried my pace, not wanting to be late. But when I looked at the time on my burner phone I realized I was already a couple minutes late. Talking to Jimmy had taken longer than I’d anticipated.

  Crap. I briskly walked up to the door and a portly man with black hair and dressed in a red bellhop uniform greeted me. He introduced himself as George Worthington.

  “Can I help you ma’am?” he asked.

  “I’m Paige Matthews, and I have an appointment with Wyatt Palmer at midday. I’m a little late. Sorry.”

  “Mr. Palmer is a bit of a stickler for punctuality, but I’m sure he’ll understand. Step inside, and I’ll let him know you’ve arrived.”

  George picked up the phone by a small checkin desk and dialed a number. After a few beats, he said, “There’s a Miss Paige Matthews here from The New York Reporter.”

  After a pause, he nodded, and then said, “Very well, Sir.” He hung up and looked at me. “You can go on up.”

  George gestured to the elevator at the far end of the lobby. “Forty-eighth floor.”

  “Thank you.”

  As I walked through the Christmas tree-lined lobby, the rich scent of coffee wrapped around me and enveloped me in a hug. To my left was a café advertising all kinds of goodies, including hot chocolate surprises.

  I vowed to myself that after the interview, I would treat myself to one, with an extra helping of whipped cream. I didn’t know what the surprise was about, but I made it my mission to find out.

  Once inside the elevator, I consulted the notes Alec had given me— boring, boring, and boring. They were the same old questions everyone asked.

  How bad would it be if I asked my own questions? And, the first question on my list would be why this guy had requested that I be the one to interview him.

  I was a good journalist. That much I knew, but nothing I’d written suggested I was any better than any other graduate, so the question remained: why me?

  Chapter 8 – Wyatt Palmer

  I wasn’t angry. Pissed maybe
, but not angry. Who was I more pissed at? The little mouse or me? The jury was still out on that.

  It didn’t take much digging to find out about Paige Matthews. She was a recent graduate from Emerson. She’d won several awards and had a promising career, so what I wanted to know was: why was an obviously talented journalist answering letters about cheating husbands and unrequited love?

  After I’d found her phone, I scrolled through her social media apps for about thirty minutes until the lock screen kicked me out. From her bookmarks and notes, the young journalist was obviously working on a story on Expose and had somehow managed to sneak a phone in. Her snooping would uncover too many people’s secrets, including mine, and that wasn’t an option.

  Since last night, I’d left countless messages for Vivian, but she hadn’t returned any of my calls. She had, however, sent a text message asking if I had missed her, and informing me that she was enjoying the money she’d gotten from the sale of the invitation.

  I would deal with the scorned sub later because right now, I planned to find out what Miss Matthews’ deal was. Since she worked for The Reporter and had somehow gotten her hands on Vivian’s invitation, I believed she wasn’t a plant from a competitor. At least that was some good news.

  But the fact that I had done what I had done with an intruder was eating at me. I couldn’t remember a time when a woman had gotten under my skin as fast as she had. Her body filled my every thought along with guilt at my actions.

  I knew better than to act like a junior and untrained Dom unable to control his urges. I still wasn’t able to justify to myself why I’d acted the way I had.

  My cock hadn’t stopped throbbing, and no matter how many times I’d jerked off, my need for her hadn’t sated. The memory of the sounds she made when she climaxed was sweet music to my ears, and something I wanted to hear again and again and again.

  I still wasn’t sure what I was going to do when she arrived. Would I confront her about her phone or would I let the interview go ahead as planned?

  Alec had been furious when I’d demanded that Paige, and Paige only, be the one to interview me, and he had had every right to be. But I promised him I would give him an exclusive and soon. For now, that seemed to mollify him.

  Having the mouse come to my apartment was my way to unnerve her and maybe to make her sweat in more ways than one. Sure, I could’ve invited her to my office, or somewhere less personal, but I wanted her alone and in my fucking territory.

  With my clothes on and mask off, she wouldn’t recognize me. The light in the room last night was purposefully dim. Plus, we were in two completely different environments.

  A devious idea popped into my head, and I searched for an episode of The Office. When I found a Christmas special, I put it on and left it playing in the background. Her choice of a safe word still brought a smile to my face despite my best intentions to feel nothing but anger towards her.

  How would she behave during the interview? Would she still have the same quirky sense of humor as last night? I hoped so. Or would she find interviewing me intimidating?

  In my everyday life, I was as intimidating and as driven as the next investment banker, but I wasn’t as intimidating as when I was at the club. I saved that side of my personality for my subs.

  The doorbell rang, and my balls tingled. She was here.

  I strolled to the foyer, and when I opened the door, my breath caught. Standing in front of me wasn’t the masked vixen in the little black dress from last night, but she was just as stunning.

  She wore her hair back in a tight ponytail and a flash of yanking her head back while I took her from behind, crashed into the forefront of my mind. She wore black-rimmed glasses that accentuated her green eyes. Last night, I hadn’t been aware of how vivid they were. Her skin was fresh and scraped free of makeup, and the Manhattan wind had reddened her cheeks and nose.

  She stood there, biting her inner cheek the way she had last night. As if my cock wasn’t already hard enough.

  She held out her hand and said, “Mr. Palmer, I’m Paige Matthews from The New York Reporter. You were expecting me? Sorry, I’m a little late.”

  She gave me a dimpled smile, and I wondered how I’d missed her dimples the previous evening.

  “I’m not a fan of lateness. I usually make people pay in some way to teach them a lesson, but I’ll let it go this one time.”

  Her smile faltered a little. “Um, thanks and good to know. Can I come in, or would you like me to interview you in the hallway?”

  She grinned, and my heart stuttered. I hated myself for loving to see her smile. She glanced down at her fingers, and I realized I’d ignored her outstretched hand.

  I took her small palm and enveloped it in mine, and the second our hands touched, it was like she’d reached down and caressed my cock. Inviting her to my apartment could turn out to be a bad idea for both of us.

  I had iron willpower, but this little mouse could possess enough power to bend it.

  A flash of something ran across her eyes. Was it recognition? Did she feel the same thing I did when our hands touched?

  She quickly blinked and stepped into my apartment— like everyone who entered my home always did. Her eyes widened, and her jaw slackened at the view of Central Park from my living room windows. It was something I would never grow immune to. From my vantage point, I could see the entire fucking span of the park.

  “Wow. Just wow.” She turned to face me, her face filled with awe. “You live here alone?”

  Not giving me a chance to answer, she continued, “How big is this place? How do you get any work done with this view?”

  I smiled at her childlike enthusiasm.

  “Almost 4000 square feet. And to answer your other question, yes, I live here alone, and I get a lot of work done that way. You should see the view of Central Park when it’s covered in snow. It’s breathtaking.”

  “I bet. When I was a kid, I used to dream about having the ice rink all to myself. I’d imagine gliding across the ice with the skyline in the background.”

  She lost herself to her thoughts, and a happy sigh floated from her lips, reminding me of how she’d sounded after her second orgasm.

  “If you’d like to see the view at night, you’ll have to stop by some evening.”

  I was flirting and enjoyed the way her cheeks reddened at my not-so-subtle invitation. I stood behind the sofa, hoping it would hide the hard on straining against the crotch of my jeans. I wanted to order her to strip her clothes off, so I could view her body in the daylight to see if it was as exquisite as I remembered from when we were in the dimly lit club.

  But if I wanted to find out more about this little mouse who didn’t seem so mousy today, I had to bide my time. She dropped her bag onto the sofa and shrugged off her coat. I noticed she didn’t take as much care of her things as she had last night. Probably because she didn’t have a phone hidden anywhere.

  Her tight jeans accentuated the curve of her ass. The ass that had been on the end of my hand, but her sweater sadly only showed a hint of her beautiful tits.

  She tilted her head, and a perplexed expression crossed her face. “You don’t decorate for Christmas?”

  I shrugged. “There’s no point since I’m the only one who is usually here and when I am, I’m working. No one would get to enjoy it.”

  “Shame. You could fit a twenty-foot tree in here and still have room for more.”

  “I’ll take it under consideration,” I said with a smile.

  “Ready?” she asked.

  I grinned— it was the same question I’d asked her last night.

  “Ready,” I replied. “Promise you’ll be gentle.”

  She gave me a lopsided grin. “If I get too tough, you can use a safe word.”

  She giggled, and it was a delightful tinkling sound.

  I did a double take and raised an eyebrow. “Excuse me.”

  “Sorry.” She said, taking a pad of paper and pen from her bag. She pointed the pen towards th
e TV. “Looks like you were watching The Office before I got here. It’s one of my favorite shows. Michael and Jan’s safe word is Foliage.”

  “I know,” was my only reply.

  She sat a voice recorder in the center of the table and pressed record. And once I had my dick under control, I sat down on the sofa directly opposite her.

  Paige began her interview by asking, “Wouldn’t you prefer someone who’s much more experienced than I am?”

  “Is that your first question?” I asked, startled.

  “Yes.”

  She pursed her lips at me, and I wasn’t sure if she meant the question to be a double entendre. This little Paige Matthews was full of big surprises. Oh, how I wished I could tie her up and teach her that I was the one in charge. Instead, I had to act professional and answer her questions, but she was making that task— and my fucking cock— very hard indeed.

  Chapter 9 – Paige Palmer

  Wyatt looked a little uncomfortable when I asked my first question— which was exactly my intention, because I liked to be the one in charge of my interviews, and plus I was having fun toying with him— but he soon cleared his throat and regained his normal, impressive, composure.

  “On the contrary,” Wyatt replied, “I prefer someone who’s learning the ropes. I find it much more satisfying that way.”

  Oh, boy! I hadn’t expected that answer. Everything he said had a hint of innuendo, and that wicked smile of his was all I needed to picture those innuendos.

  Something about him was so familiar, and I couldn’t shake the feeling that I knew him from somewhere. But I’d never met him before, and I’d never been in his social circles and never would be.

  If he kept flirting with me, getting through the interview with my panties still intact would be tough. There was no denying he was as sexy as all get out. The slightly tousled brown hair and roughened square jaw left me weak at the knees. Mischievousness filled his silvery blue eyes, and every deep word that fell from his full lips sent shivers down my spine. If I were into older men, which I was not, I could fall for him.