Radiation Nation

Home > Other > Radiation Nation > Page 37
Radiation Nation Page 37

by Natasha Zaretsky


  My parents are not just generous people, but brilliant thinkers and editors as well. My father Eli Zaretsky and my stepmother Nancy Fraser read the entire manuscript and encouraged me to tease out the connections between this project and my prior scholarly work, which improved this book immeasurably and, no less important, helped me make sense of my own intellectual journey. Having my ideas filtered through their sharp minds feels like a ridiculous home-court advantage. My mother, Linda Zaretsky, has been my staunchest, proudest champion. Her anger at injustice and her empathy toward suffering are an inspiration. All three of my parents were and remain movement people. Among many things, this book is a love letter to their younger selves. If it makes even a modest contribution to honoring the enormity of what their generation accomplished, then I will consider the last ten years time well spent.

  Researching and writing this book required delving into material that was at times frightening and sad. Yet the years that I have worked on this project have been the happiest of my life, because I have gotten to share them with my two children, Daniel and Julian. I thank them for their dependency on me and for needing to be clothed, fed, sheltered, and hugged. Those demands reeled me away from atomic nightmares and planted me back in the routine world of daily living. I bristle when parents say that their children give them hope for the future, as I suspect those comments are not so much for the benefit of children, but rather to relieve parental anxieties and guilt about the fractured world that we are leaving behind. Yet I would be lying if I did not say that my children’s capacities for kindness and reflection do help me look toward the future with expectation, curiosity, and, yes, even hope.

  Finally, I must thank my mensch of a husband, Jonathan Wiesen, whom I have taken to referring to as my secret weapon. He has read every word of this book more than once and brought his own considerable talents as a historian and writer to bear on it. He has stood by my side through many a “meltdown” and then had me laughing about it soon after. Again, I bristle at the aspiration of “having it all”—a pipedream, if ever there was one, for men and women alike. But any success I have had with balancing work, marriage, parenting, and health can be credited to Jonathan, who lives his feminism every day through his devotion to my career and to our family. What got me to this book’s finish line was imagining this very moment, when I could dedicate it with love to him.

  INDEX

  Page numbers refer to the print edition but are hyperlinked to the appropriate location in the e-book.

  Aamodt, Marjorie, 120–21, 142

  Aamodt, Norman, 120

  Abortion: in atomic age, 38–39; conservative Christian Right and, 230n156; disarmament and, 167–68; fetal health and, 95–96, 173; freeze movement and, 167–68; nuclear war and, 167–68; politics and, 96–98; religion and, 96–98; rights of unborn and, 39–40, 167–68; TMI and, 84–85, 92–93, 97, 122, 230n152; women’s rights and, 84–85, 96–99, 167–68

  Abstraction, of military, 19

  Accidental activists, 53

  Acquired immune deficiency syndrome (AIDS), 206n15

  AEC. See Atomic Energy Commission

  Africa, 21–22

  Agent Orange, 91, 133

  Agriculture, 62, 90, 119–20

  AIDS. See Acquired immune deficiency syndrome

  Alcohol, 95–96

  American Century, 193

  ANGRY. See Anti-Nuclear Group Representing York

  Animals, 93, 116–20, 127–28, 181–82

  Anthropocene, 2–3, 72–73, 192, 204n3

  Anti-Nuclear Group Representing York (ANGRY), 104

  Antinuclear movement, xv–xvi, 17; accidental activists, 53; antiwar activists and, 55, 106–7; body and, 49–51, 51; Cold War and, 52–53, 55; freeze movement, 151–73, 244n36; Invisible Violence and, 54; on ionizing radiation, 49–51, 51; maps by, 46–49, 49, 53–54; nuclear power plants and, 45–51; physician activists, 154–60; politics and, 46–47, 51–56; radiation activists, 51, 55, 218n121; religion and, 99–100, 111–13; reluctant activists, 103–13; SANE and, 39–41, 42; social movements influencing, 45–46, 98–99; on TMI, 61, 104–13; Vietnam War and, 55–56, 106–7; women’s health movement and, 54, 98–100; women’s rights and, 99–100

  Antiwar activists, 55, 64, 106–7

  Antiwar movement: freeze movement and, 162–63; patriotic body politics

  and, 9–10, 98–100, 194–95; political trust relating to, 6–7, 55; protests and, 7

  Asteroid extinction theory, 180–81

  Atom: domestication and popularizing of, 16, 23–26, 185–86, 210n29, 210n31; middle class and, 24, 185–86; peaceful, 16, 18–21, 47–48, 48; publicity for, 23–28, 27

  Atomic age: abortion in, 38–39; to ecological age, 2–6, 147, 200, 224n72; fetal health and, 38; nuclear energy during, 2; panic during, 16; politics of, 2–3

  Atomic bomb, 2, 15, 47, 154–55. See also Nuclear bombs

  Atomic docility, 23–25

  Atomic Energy Commission (AEC), 210n31; atom publicity and, 23–26; creation and mission of, 17–18; Manhattan Project and, 17–18; nuclear testing by, 28–29; nuclear weaponry and, 17–18; on radiation exposure, 31

  Atomic imaginary, 16; unborn and, 166–69

  Atomic research, 21, 44–45

  “Atoms for Peace” address, 16, 21, 209n6

  Atoms for Peace program, 19–20

  Beers, Paul, 64

  Beliefs, 93, 206n13

  Bennett, Kathryn, 159

  Bernardin, Joseph L., 167

  Bethe, Hans, 187

  Biological citizenship, 72–77, 224n71

  Biological injury, 93–94, 115–20, 117, 127–28. See also Genetic injury

  Biology, xvi–xvii

  Biotic nationalism: betrayal and, xvii–xviii, 13–14; body and, xvii–xviii, 13–14; during Cold War, xvii–xviii; conservatism and, 98–99; description of, xvii, 13–14; ecology and, 192; ethnonationalism and, 86, 195–96; social movements and, 98–99; TMI and, 59, 85–89, 189–90; Trump and, xviii; women and, 194–95

  Birth defects, 4, 36–37, 59, 95, 114, 128

  Bisgard, Jay C., 159–60

  Black freedom movement, 194, 251n5

  Blacks, 98–99, 207n21, 251n5

  Blame, 207n19; credibility and, 140–43; at TMI, 103, 137, 140–43

  Blitzer, Jeff, 136–37

  Body: antinuclear movement and, 49–51, 51; biotic nationalism and, xvii–xviii, 13–14; black, 251n5; bodily infringement, xvi–xviii, 147–61; of children, 59, 81–89; civil defense and body under assault, 147–61; ecological, 32–43, 212n60; ecology and, xvi–xvii, xviii; feminism and, 8, 206n15; ionizing radiation on, 49–51, 51; irradiated, 58–59, 195; masculinity and, 207n19; maternal, 59; nation and, xviii–xix, 49–51, 51; New Left and, 8; nuclear war and, 153–61; political authority and, 58–59; political right and, 8, 12; radiation exposure thresholds and, 30–32; suffering, 6–14, 98–99, 195–96; TMI and, 58–59, 81–89; Vietnam War and, 8, 91, 98. See also Patriotic body politics

  Bohr, Niels, 15

  Brown, Phil, 115–20, 127, 237n119

  Browner, Carol, 198

  Buell, Lawrence, 102

  Bush, George, 148

  Caddell, Patrick, 161–62

  Caldicott, Helen, 18, 118, 145, 163–64

  Campos, Luis, 37–38

  Cancer: carcinogens and, 35–36; culture and, 213n71; nuclear power plants and, 44–45; nuclear testing and, 15, 33, 35; oncology and, 35–36; radiation and, 35–36, 44–45, 51–52, 114, 120–22, 218n118, 218n121; from radioactive fallout, 33, 213n67; Strontium-90 and, 29–30; TMI and, 114, 120–22

  Cancer-cluster theory, 120–22

  Cannon fodder, 99

  Capitalism, 198

  Carbon-based fuel, 184, 197, 252n15

  Carcinogens, 35–36

  Carson, Johnny, 115–16

  Carson, Rachel, 1–2, 3, 4, 127, 183–84, 193, 205n6

  Carter, Jimmy, 92, 108, 121, 125, 141

  Carter, Stephen Reed, 108

  Cartography, 48–49


  Cartoons, 23–24, 25, 123–26, 124, 140

  Catholic Church, 166–67

  Chemical spills, 251n10

  Chemical toxicity, 1–2, 3, 4

  Chernobyl accident, 186–88

  Children: body of, 59, 81–89; Chernobyl and, 186–87; Cold War, women, and, 84; future relating to, 206n10; infant mortality, 122, 174; Japanese, 35; nuclear testing and, 33, 35, 52, 215n97; patriotism and, 169; radiation exposure to, 4, 32–43, 52, 213n67; Strontium-90 in, 32–33, 34; TMI and, 59, 67, 71–72, 77–78, 81–89, 87, 88, 105–6, 122. See also Fetal health; Reproductive futurity; Unborn

  China Syndrome, 60, 69–70

  Chipman, William, 149

  Chomsky, Noam, 170–71

  Christians, 111–13, 149–50, 230n156

  Citizens Call, 218n121

  Citizenship, biological, 72–77, 224n71

  Civic nationalism, 191–92; ethnonationalism and, 13, 208n27

  Civil defense, 79–80, 208n4; body under assault and, 147–61; crisis relocation, 150, 158; neoliberalism and, 197; nuclear shelters, 150–51, 158; during nuclear war, 150–61; policy-making and, 158–59; social reproduction and, 174–77

  Civilian-Military Contingency Hospital System (CMCHS), 159–60

  Cleanup efforts, 107–9, 189

  Climate change, 188–89, 196–201, 248n103

  CMCHS. See Civilian-Military Contingency Hospital System

  Cold War: antinuclear movement and, 52–53, 55; biotic nationalism during, xvii–xviii; culture of dissociation and, xviii; The Day After and, 145–46; nuclear testing during, 15; radiation, 52–53; Second, 147–53, 171–72; women, children, and, 84

  Committee for Sane Nuclear Policy (1957) (SANE), 35, 39–41, 42, 47, 49, 50

  Commoner, Barry, 127, 177

  Community of fate, 102–3, 126, 139, 140–43

  Conservatism, 193–94; biotic nationalism and, 98–99; TMI relating to, 59–60, 64, 102–3, 128–29, 140–41

  Conservative Christian Right, 230n156

  Conservative ecological politics, 8, 12–13; TMI and, 89–100, 109–10, 128–29

  Conservative imaginary, 13, 128–29, 143

  Conservative nationalism, 193–94

  Court cases. See Lawsuits

  Cousins, Norman, 15, 41

  Credibility, 140–43

  Creitz, Walter, 66, 70

  Crisis relocation, 150, 158

  Cronkite, Walter, 1, 31, 68

  Crutzen, Paul, 204n3

  Cultural history: individual rights and, 13; during 1960s and 1970s, xvi–xvii, 13; TMI and, xv–xix

  Culture: cancer, 213n71; wars, 11–12

  Culture of dissociation: Atoms for Peace program and, 19–20; Cold War and, xviii; coming apart, 43–56; creation of, 17–28; fragility of, 16–17, 43–44; nuclear bombs and, 5–6, 23–26; nuclear energy and, 5–6, 16–28; nuclear power plants and, 23–26; nuclear testing and, 15–16; peaceful atom and, 18–20; radiation and, 16–17; return of, 189–90; TMI and, 5–6, 17

  Curie, Marie, 16

  Cuvier, Georges, 180–81

  Darwin, Charles, 181

  Dauphin County, 62, 64, 220n15

  Day After, The, 144–46, 146, 154–55, 158, 175–76, 183

  Deindustrialization, 62

  DeLillo, Don, 4

  Democracy, 127

  Demographics, 62, 64, 220n15

  Dennan, Charlotte, 112

  Denton, Harold, 61, 70–71, 79, 141–42

  Department of Agriculture, 90

  Department of Defense, 159

  Department of Environmental Resources (DER), 65–66

  “Depolarizing Disarmament Work” (Mogey), 172–73

  DER. See Department of Environmental Resources

  Dinosaurs, 180–81

  Disarmament, 151–61, 174–75; abortion and, 167–68; “Depolarizing Disarmament Work” on, 172–73; politics and, 169–73; WAND for, 164. See also Freeze movement

  Disaster films, 144–46, 146, 154–55, 158, 175–76, 183, 241n9

  Disasters: Chernobyl accident, 186–88; evacuation research, 79–80; Fukushima-Daiichi accident, 198, 199; society and, 57–58, 219n1; technological, 59, 65, 71, 221n21; visibility crisis, 72–77. See also Environmental disasters; Three Mile Island

  Discrimination, 98–99, 206n15

  Diseases, 154, 173, 214n81

  Dissociation, 18. See also Culture of dissociation

  Documentary film and photos, 154–57, 196, 198–99

  Domestication, of atom, 16, 23–26, 185–86, 210n29, 210n31

  Doroshow, Joanne, 130

  Downwinders, 52–53, 121–22, 218n121, 219n132

  Dunaway, Finis, 32, 212n60

  Duplicity, of government, xvi–xvii

  Earth Day, 147, 189

  Earth science, 2, 29, 204n3

  ECNP. See Environmental Coalition on Nuclear Power

  Ecological age, xviii, 128–29; during Anthropocene, 204n3; atomic age to, 2–6, 147, 200, 224n72; description of, 1–2; environmental disasters and, 2; politics in, 200–1; reproductive health and, 193; social movements and, 193; TMI and, 1–2, 59–60, 89–100; unborn in, 192–93

  Ecological body: defining, 32; Dunaway on, 32, 212n60; radiation and, 32–43

  Ecological imaginary, 8, 183–84

  Ecology, 128–29; biology and, xvi–xvii; biotic nationalism and, 192; body and, xvi–xvii, xviii; nuclear winter and, 177–78

  Economics: nuclear power plants and, 21–22, 24, 184, 252n15; TMI and, 57–58, 61–62, 64

  Edelman, Lee, 206n10

  Ehrlich, Anne, 178

  Ehrlich, Paul, 4, 183–84

  EIS. See Environmental Impact Statement

  Eisenhower, Dwight D., 16, 18, 21, 209n6

  Emotions, 16, 109, 197

  Emshwiller, John, 74, 76

  Energy Act (1954), 22–23

  Energy Act (2005), 197–98

  Energy assessments, 198

  Environmental Coalition on Nuclear Power (ECNP), 104

  Environmental consciousness, 147

  Environmental disasters: Anthropocene and, 2–3, 72–73, 204n3; ecological age and, 2; government and, 196–97; oil spills, 2, 192–93; reproductive health and, 192–93

  Environmental Impact Statement (EIS), 138

  Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), 73, 189

  Environmental risk, 192, 220n3

  EPA. See Environmental Protection Agency

  Erikson, Kai, 30

  Ethnonationalism, xviii; beginning of, 13; biotic nationalism and, 86, 195–96; civic nationalism and, 13, 208n27

  Evacuation: NRC on, 78–79; panic myth, rehabilitation of state, and, 77–89; plans, 78–80; research, 79–80; of TMI, 67–68, 77–89, 227n108

  Evolution, 154, 181

  Extinction, 2–3, 192, 200–201; asteroid extinction theory, 180–81; Cuvier on, 180–81; of dinosaurs, 180–81; fear of, 182; nuclear winter, reproduction, and threat of, 173–84; unborn and, 182–83

  Factories, 15, 193

  Falwell, Jerry, 169, 230n156

  Family, xv, xix, 10–11, 98, 111, 161, 185–86

  Fate, community of, 102–3, 126, 139, 140–43

  Fate of the Earth, The (Schell), 182–83

  FDA. See Food and Drug Administration

  Fear: of climate change, 200; of extinction, 182; invisibility and, 73; living with, 134; for men, compared to women, 226n98; of nuclear testing, 15, 17; of nuclear war, 144–50, 160–61; of radium, 20–21; at TMI, 73, 77, 89–91, 129–40; trauma and, 129–40; of unknown, 15, 77

  Federal Emergency Management Association (FEMA), 149, 150

  Feld, Bernard, 149

  FEMA. See Federal Emergency Management Association

  Feminism: body and, 8, 206n15; freeze movement and, 164, 166; gender, race, and sexuality relating to, 84–86, 194; nuclear energy and, xvi, 98, 110–11; sexuality and, 58, 206n15; women’s health movement and, 206n15

  Fetal alcohol syndrome, 95–96

  Fetal health: abortion and, 95–96, 173; atomic age and, 38
; birth defects and, 4, 36–37, 59, 95, 114, 128; diseases and, 214n81; prenatal injury, 38; radiation contamination, to fetuses, 4, 44, 213n72; reproductive health and, 36–43; thalidomide and, 128, 214n81; TMI and, 59, 92–100, 122, 128; unborn and, 93–97, 174

  Films: disaster, 144–46, 146, 154–55, 158, 175–76, 183, 241n9; documentary, 154–57, 196, 198–99

  Fisher, Wallace, 113

  Food and Drug Administration (FDA), 73

  Fordism, 57–58

  Forsberg, Randall, 151

  Fossil fuels, 184, 188–89, 197–98, 252n15

  Fossils, 180

  Francis, Les, 121

  Frederick, Edward, 65

  Freeze movement: abortion and, 167–68; antiwar movement and, 162–63; disarmament and, 151–61, 164, 169–73; feminism and, 164, 166; future and, 171; militarism and, 170–73; mothers and, 164; partisanship and, 161–63, 172–73; patriotism and, 168–70; physician activists and, 154–60; political realignment and, 161–73; PSR and, 155–60, 244n36; religion and, 166–67; social movements and, 161; women and, 164–68, 165

  Fukushima-Daiichi accident, 198, 199

  Future: children relating to, 206n10; freeze movement and, 171; militarism and, 170–71; radiation contamination as crime against, 28–43; reproduction and, 201; social good and, 206n10. See also Reproductive futurity; Unborn

  Futurology, 152, 243n23

  Gallina, Charles, 66

  Gaonkar, Dilip Parameshwar, 206n13

  Geiger, H. Jack, 157, 160, 175, 178, 180, 247n89

  Gender, xv, xix, 84–86, 161, 194

  General Electric’s Nuclear Division, 45

  General Public Utilities (GPU), 102–4, 140–42

  Genetic injury: biological injury and, at TMI, 93–94, 115–20, 117, 127–28; multigenerational genetic mutations, 36–38; nuclear testing and, 37; from radiation exposure, 35–38, 54; reproductive health and, 36–38; to unborn, 40–41

 

‹ Prev