Carr, Cassandra - Head Games [Buffalo Intimidators] (Siren Publishing Ménage Amour)

by Cassandra Carr

“I’ve…” Kelly paused, taking a deep breath. “I’ve started a relationship with Leo and Scott.”

  “A relationship? What kind of relationship?”

  “A sexual one. With both of them.” She blew out a breath and watched Bonnie’s face to gauge her reaction.

  Bonnie grinned. “Both of them, huh? I’d suspected as much.”

  “Are you serious? This doesn’t surprise you?”

  “I wouldn’t say it doesn’t surprise me, but it doesn’t shock me. How’s that for being clear?” Bonnie chuckled, and Kelly sat back in her chair, relieved that Bonnie hadn’t run from the room screaming. “What I mean is—I’m a little surprised that you would do this, considering your generally cautious nature, but I’m certainly not surprised that you would want to. They’re hot, they’re rich, and they obviously adore you.”

  “Is it really that obvious?” Kelly pinched the bridge of her nose. If Bonnie wasn’t really surprised, how many others suspected? Did her staff know? What about Leo and Scott’s teammates? She knew it wasn’t a secret they shared, but she wondered if they’d told anyone about their relationship.

  Bonnie pulled Kelly’s hand away from her face. “It is to me. But I know you, remember? I’m sure it’s not so obvious to everybody. I’m sure the staff knows you guys are close, considering how often they come in here and how long they stay, but if you’re worried about them knowing something you’re not comfortable with, I wouldn’t be too concerned.”

  “Do you think I’m a total slut?”

  Bonnie snorted. “Honey, if those two wanted to make me the meat in their man sandwich, I wouldn’t say no!” Kelly barked out a laugh at that visual. “Seriously, though, hon. If they make you happy, who the hell is anyone to say it’s wrong?”

  “That’s what they said, too. Did they pay you to say that?” Kelly reached out to hug Bonnie. “Have I told you lately how grateful I am for you?”

  “Yeah, but feel free to say it again.” Bonnie grinned and then stood. “If that’s all you needed, I’m going to get started on the German potato salad for tonight.”

  “Thanks. I’ll be out after I finish up the food order.” Bonnie left, and Kelly propped her feet up on her desk, lost in thought for the moment. That had gone far better than she’d ever imagined. Bonnie was a nice girl, but you just never knew how someone would handle news like that. Hopefully most of the other people who found out about her relationship with Leo and Scott would react the same way. She knew it was a pipe dream, but it was nice to consider.

  Her cell phone beeped in her pocket and she withdrew it, glancing at the screen. There was a text message from Leo.

  If you have time, could you make an apple pie and bring it home?

  Scott and I would like to fulfill a fantasy tonight. See you soon, babe.

  A fantasy, huh? Kelly smiled and replied. If they wanted an apple pie, she’d make them an apple pie. A few moments later her phone buzzed again.

  You won’t regret it. We’re already planning how to make you scream until you’re hoarse.

  Oh my. She fanned herself as her body temperature spiked. Her pussy clenched, and she actually considered trying to make herself come before going out to the kitchen. His messages had revved her right up.

  Two can play at this game. Or, well, three.

  Smirking, she picked up the phone and began to type.

  I’m sure I won’t regret it—as long as I get to lick some off your cocks.

  She didn’t have to wait long to get his reply.

  Are you trying to kill us?

  Kelly giggled and wrote back immediately.

  Turnabout is fair play, my friend.

  It took Leo a few minutes to write back, so Kelly returned to her food order, her blood still sizzling in her veins. Then her phone buzzed.

  We aren’t just your friends, we’re your lovers. Remember that.

  Another rush of heat flooded her body at his words. She loved Scott’s gentle way with her and his easygoing nature, but there was something about Leo when he got all pushy and demanding that thrilled her. Shaking her head to clear it, she put her phone away. There would be plenty of playtime later. Bonnie was closing down the bistro tonight, so Kelly would be able to make it over to the guys’ house at a decent hour. She wouldn’t be going anywhere unless she finished up and called in this food order, though. Besides that, she had an apple pie to make…

  Chapter Twelve

  Leo adjusted his cock again as he tried to concentrate on the movie. Finally, he gave up. “I’ll be right back.”

  Scott smirked. “Take your time, man. You want me to pause the movie?”

  “No. And what’s the shit-eating grin for?”

  “Because it’s pretty funny watching you lose your mind.”

  “Whatever...” Leo muttered as he left the room. Ducking into his bedroom, he shucked his pants and boxer briefs on the floor and climbed onto the bed, a box of tissues handy. Fisting his cock, he started slow, teasing himself a little as he imagined peeling away the pink “Kelly’s” T-shirt and revealing her full, gorgeous tits to his gaze. He’d lay her down and pull off her checkered chef’s pants, leaving her clad in only her bra and her little bikini panties.

  Climbing up to straddle her, he’d undo the front clasp of her bra and let her breasts spill into his hands. Clutching his dick with a firmer grip, he began to stroke faster, thinking about taking globs of the apple pie and dropping them on each pert nipple, only to lick them clean and start again. It didn’t take long for the images assaulting his brain to take him over the edge, and he came on a low moan, his cum spilling over his hand and onto his stomach.

  Leo knew if he hadn’t jerked off, there was no way he’d be able to keep control tonight. Reaching over, he pulled a couple of tissues out of the box and wiped off his hand and belly. He couldn’t wait for Kelly to arrive, but a quick look at the clock confirmed his suspicion. She wouldn’t be here for hours yet.

  * * * *

  As soon as the door to Leo’s bedroom closed, Scott made for his own room. He hadn’t wanted to admit it, but the thought of having Kelly at their mercy while they spread her apple pie all over her luscious body had his dick twisted in knots.

  He quickly laid down on the bed and pulled his jeans and briefs down just enough to expose his hard cock. Leo would be a little while, but Scott wanted to be back in the living room by the time his friend was done with his own self-service pumping. For some strange reason, knowing he’d jerked off without alerting Leo and letting Leo think he was the only one with no self-control would be very satisfying. He was a sick man…

  Taking his cock in hand he began to rapidly jerk himself off. Tonight there would be no teasing touches, no finesse—he needed to come. It didn’t take long. As he kept a tight grip on his cock, he felt the orgasm working its way through his groin, and he came on a quick, harsh release of breath. Continuing to jerk, though more slowly, he milked his dick and then his head fell back. He couldn’t wait until it was Kelly on his cock, however he could get her.

  Rising, he sat on the edge of the bed and cleaned up. Sighing, he buttoned up again before going back out to the living room.

  Several minutes later, Leo appeared. “Don’t say a damn word,” he snarled, detouring into the kitchen for a beer.

  When he came back into the room Scott held up his hands. “I didn’t say a thing.”

  “Asshole.” Scott just laughed and turned the movie back on. He noticed Leo checking the time repeatedly. Finally he said, “Man, this sucks. Let’s go somewhere.”

  Scott smiled to himself. Yes, it truly was very satisfying for Leo to think he was the only one being driven insane. “Frustrated much?”

  “Bored. She’s still gonna be a while yet, man. Let’s go shoot some pool or something.”

  “Fine, fine. I know you won’t stop bitching until you’re entertained. I’ll drive since you’ve been drinking.”

  “Whatever, man. Let’s just fucking go.”

  They went to a local tavern and
played pool, shooting the shit with the patrons while Leo enjoyed a few drafts and Scott stuck to water. A while later, Scott looked at his watch and tapped Leo. “We should go.” He showed Leo the time and he nodded.

  “Yeah, we should get home.” They said their good-byes and hopped back in Leo’s Range Rover, heading for home to get ready for their girl.

  She called a short time later to tell them she was on their way, and they put the finishing touches on their seduction scheme. They’d picked up a bunch of candles on the way home and strewn them around Leo’s bedroom to create an intimate atmosphere. Now Scott was lighting them as Leo changed the bed sheets. No doubt they’d be changing them again after they were through playing, but for some reason he felt compelled to create the perfect setting.

  The doorbell rang, and both he and Leo went to open it. She handed Leo the pie and stepped inside. Scott seized upon the opportunity to take her in his arms, luxuriating in the feel of her ample curves as he ran his hands up and down her back and sides. He took her mouth in a blistering kiss and then handed her off to Leo, who swept her into his arms, fusing his mouth to hers. Scott watched the two of them, his cock hardening at the sight of his lover and his best friend getting physical. There had never been any sexual attraction between himself and Leo, but both found the sight of the other with their mutual lover incredibly arousing, and Scott didn’t know about Leo, but the fact that lover was now Kelly made the feeling even stronger.

  “Let’s move this into the bedroom,” Leo suggested, shucking off her coat and tossing it onto the sofa on their way to the bedroom. Scott picked up the pie and followed, a wicked grin on his face.

  “What’re you guys planning to do with the pie?”

  “Wouldn’t you like to know?” Scott teased. Setting it down on the dresser, he turned to Kelly. “Strip.”

  “Aren’t you bossy today?”

  “Yes. Today I’m playing the role of Leo. Now strip.” Leo chuckled and Kelly rolled her eyes, but reached for the hem of her T-shirt and pulled it over her head. She shed her bra as well, and Scott groaned, remembering how good her breasts had felt in his hands and his mouth. Kelly made quick work of her pants and underwear and then stood there looking a little self-conscious.

  “You’re fucking gorgeous, you know that?” Leo asked. She glanced over at him, and he said, “Oh, honey, don’t look at me like that. Do you think you could keep Scott and me constantly hard as a spike if you weren’t so hot and sexy?” He grabbed his dick through his jeans and squeezed. “I could pound nails with this thing, baby.”

  Scott tamped down on the urge to roll his eyes. “Get on the bed on your back.” He’d pulled the comforter and other blankets down while Leo had been talking, and Kelly settled herself into the middle of the bed. Leo immediately climbed on one side of her, and Scott joined them after plucking the pie off the dresser.

  Leo looked at Scott. “Take turns?”

  “Sounds good, man. I can’t wait.”

  “I know. I’m fucking hungry.” Leo reached for the pie and plunged his fingers into it. “Mmm, still warm.” He painted each of Kelly’s nipples with the pie and leaned down to take first one and then the other between his lips to suck and lick them clean. Scott scooted between her legs and began to lick at her pussy, and Kelly writhed, grabbing Leo’s head. “Uh-uh…we’re running the show here.” She made a noise that sounded half amused and half frustrated. “Arms over your head or we’ll tie your wrists to the headboard.”

  “I think she likes that idea, man. Her pussy clenched when you suggested it.” He looked up at Kelly’s flushed face, her eyes full of need, and his dick twitched again.

  “What a little vixen you are.” Rising, Leo delved into his nightstand, quickly finding the item he was seeking. Her eyes widened a little when she saw the pair of fur-lined handcuffs in his hands. “Arms up, darlin’.” She gulped, but obediently raised her arms, and he locked her wrists into the cuffs. When he was done, he stood back. “Very nice. I like it.”

  Scott looked up the length of her body and nodded. “I do, too.”

  Kelly’s gaze shifted from one to the other. “Aren’t you guys going to take your clothes off?”

  “All in good time, baby, all in good time,” Leo told her, winking. “For now, just lay there and enjoy yourself. I know we intend to.” He scooped up a big handful of the pie and dropped it onto her torso.

  “You’re going to eat the pie off of me? Seriously?” She struggled a bit in her bonds, and Scott couldn’t hold in his chuckle.

  “What can I say? I love pie.”

  Scott snorted. “You have such a sweet tooth.”

  “Yep, and our girl’s pretty sweet.”

  “I’ll say,” Scott answered, taking another lick of her pussy. “She’s all the sweet I need.”

  “Okay then, I’ll eat the entire pie.” Leo started to dip into it again, but Scott slapped his hand away.

  “Get out of there. Eat what’s already on her, you pig.”

  Kelly giggled, and they both looked up at her. “You guys sound like brothers fighting over the last piece of dessert.”

  “You are the last piece of dessert, honey,” Leo answered, and then nibbled at more of the pie on her belly. Her stomach started to shake. “I think she’s ticklish.”

  “Of course I’m ticklish!” She struggled again.

  “You’re not getting out of those handcuffs until we decide you are, so just sit back and relax.” Leo laughed and nibbled again. Any further protest was cut short when she moaned and arched up as Scott took her clit in his mouth. “Don’t let her come yet.”

  Scott backed away. “Switch?”

  “So what do you think? When should we let our girl come?” Leo asked Scott.

  Scott dropped another piece of pie on her breast and looked up at her with an evil grin. “Not quite yet.”

  “I thought you were the nice one,” Kelly grumbled, then moaned again as Leo took his own long lick.

  “I am the nice one. I’ll show you.” Reaching up, he smeared some of the innards of the pie across her lips and leaned down to lick them off. Then he fed her a piece and licked her lips again.

  “Mmm, I make damn good pie.”

  “You do, honey.” Scott turned to Leo. “I can’t take it. Make her come. I want to watch her.”

  “Can do,” Leo replied, speeding up his licks to her pussy. Soon the handcuffs rattled, as Kelly began to thrash. Scott put his hands on her hips to hold her down for Leo’s assault, and soon she was writhing in her bonds.

  She began to chant “Don’t stop”, and Scott chuckled. It wasn’t long before her back arched and her legs locked, as her orgasm swept through her.

  They let her come down from her orgasm high, and Leo removed the handcuffs while Scott started the shower. All three of them got in, and both men crowded into Kelly, sudsing their hands and running them up and down her body to clean the stickiness of the pie off her. She turned to Leo and grinned.

  Leo raised an eyebrow. “I don’t trust that grin for a second. What’re you up to?”

  “You’ll see,” she answered, then dropped to her knees. Reaching for each of them, she began to pump their cocks and then took Leo into her mouth. Scott got interested real fast when her hand closed around his erect cock.

  “Fuck!” Leo bit out. She smiled a little around his cock, and he looked down at her. “Oh, you think you’re pretty funny, huh?” Taking her head in his hands, he growled, “Let’s see how well you can laugh with me pumping in and out of your mouth.”

  “Hey, save some for me,” Scott grumbled. “Ahh! She just squeezed my dick!” Kelly pulled free of Leo and turned to Scott, taking him inside. “Shit yeah, that’s more like it.”

  She took a hold of Leo and steadily pumped up and down his shaft while she sucked Scott’s cock. Scott closed his eyes, enjoying the sensation as she reached down and cupped his balls and then slid her slippery fingers back up to spread his pre-cum around. He shuddered when she took him inside again and fumbled for pu
rchase as his knees locked. Before he could stop it, his orgasm took over, slamming through him as he poured his cum down her willing throat. Kelly moaned and continued to suckle him until finally he pulled free, fighting to breathe.

  Leo came shortly thereafter, but Scott didn’t bother to open his eyes. Only when the water turned off did he do so, blinking to clear the water out of them.

  He saw Leo lean down to give Kelly a quick kiss and then slap her wet ass. She shrieked and he grinned.

  “Stop that!”

  Leo reached down and ran two fingers through the lips of her pussy. Pulling them out, he showed Scott the abundant cream. “Doesn’t look like she hated it too much.” Kelly snorted, and he grinned again and then stuck his fingers in his mouth to suck off the juices. “Mmmm.”

  Scott shook his head at his friend’s antics, and then stepped out of the shower. Reaching into the linen closet, he pulled out towels and handed one to each of them. “I dunno about you, but that only made me want her even more.” He began to help Kelly out of the shower as Leo dried himself off. Then they both dried her, and after throwing the towels in the hamper, led her back into the bedroom.

  Leo climbed on the bed and reached for a condom. “Come on up here and sit on my cock, baby.” She straddled him and sank down. “So fucking good…” He pulled her down on top of him. “Let Scott get you ready, darlin’.” Scott approached with a tube of lube, and Leo whispered silly, sexy things to her while Scott prepared her for his cock. Finally, Scott wiped his hand on a towel he’d brought in from the bathroom and positioned himself behind her.

  He began to sink inside Kelly, and his eyes closed of their own volition. When he was finally, blissfully seated inside her, they began that same rhythm they’d employed last time, of one of them pushing in while the other pulled out. Scott resorted to reciting his own goaltending stats in his head to force his body to calm down. He’d come twice already, including once only a half an hour earlier, and yet still felt like he was going to lose it any second. Kelly was so freaking tight, gripping his dick like a hot velvet glove. He moaned as she shifted, and he sank even deeper inside her.