Their Stepsister

by Alexa Riley

  She moves back a little and I stand up and start ripping at my clothes. I need this moment to bind us. I’m ready for Logan and me to seal the deal and make Sarah ours.

  “Logan, get those fucking perfect tits in your mouth and start sucking on them. I want those fat nipples hard as rocks and rubbing my chest when I get on top of her.”

  I’m finally naked and I don’t hesitate to dive in between her legs. I’m aggressive and angry as I eat her pussy and I don’t care. She is shouting and moaning as I go to town and all it does is fuel my fire. If she wants sweet and gentle that’s why she’s got Logan. But me? This little princess needs to brace herself.

  I work my tongue all over her pussy, licking her clit, her outer lips and every millimeter surrounding it. I push my hands under her ass and raise her up to my mouth so I can eat her harder. I plunge my tongue in her opening and I can taste her honey as it pours down my chin. This sweet cunt is greedy and I’m more than happy to satisfy it.

  I grip her ass cheeks harder and raise her up a little more. My tongue hits her tiny pink asshole and my cock starts to weep. I grind my erection into the bed so it can have some relief. It’s not enough, but I need to get myself under control before I fuck her pussy.

  “Sweet mother of God, this asshole is tasty. Logan, you’re going to bust when you get inside it.”

  I hear him moan around a nipple in approval and Sarah lets out a cry of ecstasy as we both treat her body to pleasure. I go back to eating her ass and I see Logan make a move to finger her clit while still sucking on her tits.

  I spread her ass cheeks wide so I can really get my tongue in there. I need to get it ready for Logan’s cock, but this is for my enjoyment too.

  I’m so hungry for her pussy and ass I feel my control slipping. I’m getting too fucking turned on and I can’t wait too much longer.

  “You need to cum fast. Get that pussy cherry nice and soft for me. I don’t want to hurt my princess.”

  I sit back a little and Logan moves his hand. We are so together on this that he knows what she needs. I take the flat of my palm and bring it down on her tight cunt, smacking her pussy into an orgasm. I feel her whole body tense and she lets out a scream. Logan holds her down and I smack it again. It’s so wet and sticky, my hand is covered in her juices. The sound is like a goddamn symphony to me and I keep popping her over and over while I feel her cum.

  “Please!” Sarah screams and I smile. I love when she doesn’t know what she wants. But her sweet little body knows exactly what it needs and I’m going to give it to her.

  I give her clit one last sweet soft kiss, and nuzzle it a little with my nose. “This pussy, baby. This beautiful, pink, sweet, perfect pussy is the honey pot on the love of our lives. I’ve never tasted anything so amazing in my entire life.” I felt like I owed an apology to Sarah as well as to her kitty.

  I move up her body and kiss her belly and tits along the way. I can see that Logan has worked them over nicely. I give her a tentative kiss on the mouth and look into her eyes. “Before I get inside you, I want you to know how sorry I am for saying that. I hope I can continue to make it up to you.”

  Sarah looks so sleepy and happy and smiles at me with so much love. “I forgive you, Luke, but feel free to keep making it up to me.”

  “All right, princess.” I look to Logan for confirmation. He is kneeling beside us, jerking his cock. He nods to me to go ahead. I lock eyes with Sarah and line up my cock at her entrance. “It’s time for that virgin pussy to open up. This is going to hurt, but you’ve got to be a big girl and let me do it. My cock is big, but you’ll take me because you love me, right?”

  Sarah looks at me with soft eyes, and then looks at Logan. She reaches out and touches his face and then puts her other hand on my cheek. “I love both of you so much. This feels so perfect. I want both of you to fuck my virgin holes and make me yours. I want one of my cherries to belong to each of you. I need you both to own me, heart and body.”

  Logan leans down to kiss her mouth and I thrust all ten inches in at once. Sarah lets out a scream, but it’s muffled by Logan’s mouth. I can see tears running down the side of her face but he’s kissing them and soothing her. I feel her tight pussy around my cock and I know I’m going to nut any second.

  “Oh goddamn, baby, it’s too tight. FUCK. I can’t. Oh god. Just hold still. I need to fuck you. Jesus.”

  I’m speaking in monosyllables because I can’t fucking think straight. I take deep breaths and try to find my brain, but I’m pretty sure it’s somewhere in my dick.

  I put one hand on her lower belly to keep her still and the other grips her thigh. “Okay, baby, be a good princess and lie really still. I’ve got to cum before I pass out.”

  I hold her lower half down and start to pump. Watching her tits jiggle and bounce as I fuck her isn’t helping me in holding back my own orgasm. My eyes close and it’s almost painful how tight she is. Her sweet untouched pussy is squeezing me so hard I can feel the cum being sucked from my cock. I look down and see where my cock is going in and out of her pussy. I can see her virgin blood on my cock and it makes me leak more cum. Her pink pussy is open and her clit is shiny and hard. As if reading my mind, Logan reaches down to pet her for me. He can feel that I’m so far gone I’m not remembering to be careful with her precious body.

  “Get her off, bro, I’ve got to unload.” Logan looks up and gives me a big smile.

  “With pleasure,” he says and brings his mouth to her clit. He’s licking her pussy while I’m fucking her and Sarah is losing her mind. I don’t think she is speaking English. This may seem strange to her, having both of us so close together while fucking her, but hey, if you’re going to play as a trio, you’re bound to accidentally cross some streams.

  I go back to holding her legs wide open and sliding my dick in and out. I don’t make it three more pumps before I feel her contract around my cock and I cum inside her virgin pussy. Big, thick jets of cum are gushing out of me and my body locks up as I cum harder than I ever have in my life. My throbbing cock is filling up her untouched womb and I look down to see we’ve all just had the same thought. Logan and I smile to each other because we know what the other is thinking. Sarah looks up with big eyes and I can see a little panic set it.

  “Easy, princess.” I’m still inside her and my cum is starting to leak out from around my cock and down her ass. Logan is now lying beside her and petting her tits to try to keep her calm.

  “We want to get you pregnant.” The moment I say the words I feel their stark truth. Thoughts of her pregnant with our child makes me cock jerk inside her, forcing some more cum from me.

  “What?” she nearly shouts.

  “Shhh. Calm down, baby. Logan and I love you so much. We want to bind you with us forever. We want a family with you and we want to keep you pregnant as often as we can. We want you carrying our seed and giving us babies. So what just happened,” I push my still hard cock back inside her to remind her of all my cum still filling her, “is going to keep happening. So deal with it.”

  Sarah nods her head in agreement, which is a good thing, because in no way was that a discussion. It was a fact. We plan on cumming in this prime pussy multiple times a day until we can get her pregnant.

  I look over at Logan and we both have the biggest grins on our face. I’ve never been so happy in my life. My family is complete.

  “Looks like it’s time to take that ass cherry, bro. We aren’t stopping tonight until her ass and pussy are overflowing with our cum. I’m ready for both of us to fuck her together so she’s going to need a good hard anal ride to work her open. Go easy, but make her know it’s yours. Meanwhile I think she needs to lick my messy cock clean.” Looking down at my still hard cock I’m thankful there’s not any of her cherry blood left, only my cum and hers.

  “It’s about fucking time,” Logan shouts. “Get on all fours, princess; I need to see my prize.”

  CHAPTER 7 *Logan*

  Watching Luke fuck Sarah was one of the most
amazing moments in my life. To see them, my family, together in this way was how we always envisioned it. It was perfect. Sarah was so beautiful as she took Luke’s cock, and even more beautiful when she came. I can’t wait to see it again when I’m inside her.

  Luke pulls out of her sweet cunt and a huge gush of cum spills out. “Holy fuck. Baby, that is so pretty. Turn over on your tummy and scoot to the end of the bed. Knees up, asshole on full display. Luke is going to sit in front of your face and you’ll lick him clean. Meanwhile this pink pucker is mine.”

  We all move into position and I kneeled behind her round, lush ass. I can see her head bobbing up and down. Luke has his head thrown back and his eyes are closed. Her sucking noises around Luke’s cock put me more on edge. This feels so natural, sharing her this way. I grab her ass roughly with both hands and spread her wide. Her asshole is so pink and pretty and begging me to eat it. I dive face first without hesitation and moan at her sweet taste. I don’t lick her anywhere else because this sweet spot is all mine. Sarah is moving her hips and moaning around Luke’s cock – so loud I think we could get her to cum just from ass play.

  “Bro, she’s sucking my dick down. Keep at her ass, man. She fucking loves it,” Luke marvels.

  I pull back to spit on it and then stick my thumb straight in. She lets out a mix between a squeal and a moan and I take it as a good sign. “Looks like we’ve got a little butt slut on our hands. You fucking love it, don’t you, princess?” Sarah moans some more and wiggles her ass, begging for attention. I pull my hand back and give her cheek a nice loud smack. A red handprint blossoms right away as she gags on Luke’s dick.

  “You’ll get your attention, baby. Let me work this ass a little more and big bro will give you his cock.”

  I pull my thumb out and spit on her ass again. I slip two of my fingers in this time and start pumping. Sarah works her hips and makes all kinds of noises. I reach down and stroke my cock and lube it up with all the pre-cum that’s dripping down from the head. I’ve got so much cum leaking out of my cock that I know this is all we’ll need for my dick to slide home. Just to be safe, I slide into her warm snug pussy and take three quick thrusts to get my cock fully wet before pulling it back out.

  By the time I’ve got a third finger in her ass I look up to see Luke has Sarah by the hair and is thrusting into her mouth.

  “Sarah, baby, you’re being such a good girl. Taking Luke’s cock all the way to the back of your throat and having three fingers fuck your virgin asshole at the same time. We’re so proud of you, baby. It’s time to make that ass mine, princess. Open up and let me in.”

  I pull my fingers out and line up my slick cock. Sarah reaches around and grabs her ass cheeks, spreading them wide for me. I push my cock in and feel the head of my cock pop though her tight ring. She lets out a little cry and Luke is there to calm her down. He makes soft noises and runs his fingers through her hair. Her face is lying on his lap, and she has her eyes closed tight.

  “It’s okay, baby girl,” Luke coos. “Just let Logan get in there and then we can both fuck you at the same time. Don’t you want us to fuck as a family?”

  Sarah takes a deep breath and nods her head.

  “Yes, I do. I want both of you fucking me at the same time. I want to be filled up with cock and cum. Do it, Logan. I’m ready.”

  With her acceptance I slide my cock in until I’m bottoming out and balls deep. “FUCK.” My vision is blurry and sweat has broken out all over my body. I’ve never in my life experienced anything so perfect as being inside this sweet hole.

  “Just give her a few pumps and then I’ll get inside too, man. Try to hold off until then. I know how you feel. It’s like a goddamn dream, isn’t it?” Luke says.

  “Fucking perfection,” I answer as I pull out almost all the way before pushing back in. Sarah is taking all ten inches of me in her virgin ass like a champ. She feels so good. “Good girl, baby,” I whisper to her. “Such a good girl.”

  I feel Sarah tense up and I know she’s going to cum. Jesus, she’s so quick to orgasm. We’re going to have to teach her to control it, make it last longer so she can cum harder. Right now, though, since it’s her first time doing anal, I want her to cum as often as she can.

  “Go ahead, baby, cum for me while I’m in your ass,” I demand.

  I hear her cry of release and feel her clench around my cock. I’m able to make it a few more seconds before I look up to Luke in desperation. “It’s time.”

  He leans down and gives Sarah a kiss on the lips then sits her up and slides down to the end of the bed where she and I are joined. I hold still while Sarah spreads her legs wide and Luke slips between them. His cock is hard and he looks like he’s ready to burst any second.

  I help Sarah lean back against me and I hold her up while Logan works his cock inside her tight pussy. I lick up her neck and kiss the sweet spot under her ear. I want her to relax and I whisper to her, “Your ass is completely full of my cock right now, baby.” I hold her gently by the throat with my left hand and my right reaches down to pet her clit. Luke is slowly working his cock in so we don’t hurt her. “You’re doing so good, baby girl. We are so proud of you for taking both of us. You’re not a virgin anymore, Sarah. Luke and I took your sweet cherries. You belong to us now.”

  Sarah whimpers and works her hips. She’s greedy for it, and as soon as Luke is inside her, she’ll get everything she wants.

  I continue petting her clit and I can feel the moment Luke fills her with his cock. Sarah lets out a deep breath and Luke and I groan at the same time. “You did it, baby sis. You took both of your brothers’ cocks at once. Feel how full we make you? You love it, don’t you? Whose are they? This pussy and ass… whose are they, baby? I want to hear you say who you belong to while you’re stuffed full of cock.”

  “Yours. Both of yours. My pussy and ass, my body, my heart, it all belongs to both of you.”

  “That’s right, princess. Now lean forward and hold on to Luke. Let us fuck you and fill both your holes up with cum.”

  Sarah leans forward and Luke and I start out slow. We alternate our thrusts, ensuring that she’s constantly full of dick. We’re all in a cloud of ecstasy and sensation.

  We thrust harder and Sarah rides both of us. I’m on the edge but she’s begging me to pound her ass harder so I keep going. I look to Luke for help but he looks like he’s struggling to hold on as well. Our eyes meet and he nods. We’ve got to get her off before we both bust a nut.

  Luke leans down and bites one of her nipples. Hard. Sarah lets out a scream and I slap her ass repeatedly until she starts cumming. Her orgasm hits her hard and she’s still screaming as we both thrust in at the same time and empty our cocks. I can feel my balls draw up and give her ass every single drop of my seed. From the top of my head to the tips of my toes, I feel myself go into her. It is the greatest orgasm I’ve ever had and I can tell that Sarah and Luke feel the same way. We are a sweaty, cum-covered heap of bodies and I have never been happier.

  I pull out at the same time as Luke and see Sarah go limp on top of him with her legs wide open. She has cum pouring out of both holes and, as drained as my cock is, I feel myself get hard again.

  I go over to my pants and grab my phone. “What are you doing?” Sarah asks and Luke just smiles.

  “Stay still, princess. I want to commemorate this moment.” I get close and take a picture of just her pussy and asshole swollen with her orgasms and covered in our cum. “I’m making this my goddamn home screen picture.”

  “Send that to me, bro. I want to do the same thing.”

  “You can’t have a picture of my pussy and ass on your phone! What if someone sees it! I’m so embarrassed!” Sarah squeals and buries her face in Luke’s shoulder.

  I lie down beside them and get her to look at my face. “Princess, do you think either of us would let that happen? And honestly, who gives a fuck? You’re ours now. Your body belongs to us.” I look back at the picture on my phone and smile. “I’d tell you I’ll
jerk off to this every day, but I plan on fucking you so much I won’t have any alone time to do it.”

  Sarah looks at me shyly and says, “Maybe you could jerk off in front of me.” She has a huge blush on her cheeks and I look up to see Luke smiling.

  “Looks like our girl is a pervert. I fucking love it.”

  Epilogue

  Spreading my legs wide I slide my finger over my clit and take a quick picture with my phone. Then I slip the same finger between my lips and take another before readjusting my skirt. Luke said if I was going to keep working in the office, I could only wear skirts. Logan, of course, demanded no underwear, getting a grunt of approval from Luke. I pretended the idea annoyed me but secretly I loved it. I had to let them think they were winning some battles, but Luke wouldn’t be winning the one I have in mind now.

  One month after my brothers made me theirs, they had a ring on my finger. Another month after that, I found out I was expecting. Both of them have been trying to get me to quit working in the office but I’ve been fighting it. I plan on staying home once our little one is here but right now I like being here with them.

  Unbuttoning the top two buttons of my blouse I send the two pictures I took to Luke. Since we found out I was having a baby, Luke’s lovemaking has changed. Now he’s even more gentle than Logan. I still sleep tied to the bed, and I would often wake to Luke rolling on top of me and thrusting into me hard and quick. He would bite my breast and demand my orgasm until he came deep inside me. Then he would roll off me to let Logan slide in after him. Logan would worship my body with his slow tender loving. Now Luke just worships like Logan too. I need both. My gentle lover and my demanding one. I will have them both. I just have to poke the beast.

  I hear the beep of Luke’s phone go off in the next room and I feel my pussy clench with excitement. Suddenly the door flies open and Luke is filling the doorway.