Our First Time: Anthology of a Menage

by Jennifer O'Donnell

  Nancy was an open book when it came to talking about her sex life. “I want you to break that long, dry spell with me tonight.” “Are you sure?” He feigned some surprise. “Why not,” she answered. “Women don’t usually ask me in such an open way.” “Well, I’m straightforward,” she replied looking directly in his eyes. “Okay, so how do you want to play it? What are your plans?” “Plans…I’ve got a lot of plans. Lets finish our meal and I’ll show you.” Her seductive behaviors continued to be evident, as she moved in a provocative manner while she served him his food.

  After their meal she excused herself and returned momentarily wearing an evening dress that left little to the imagination and sent shivers through his body. “How about this?” she inquired seductively. “You are amazingly hot in that outfit.” “Not just hot…I am hot and randy, too.”

  Make a wish and it will come true!” She replied. “I will leave the wishing to you, and your wish is my command,” “Fine,” she said, “How about this? She went down to the floor and crawled towards him with her butt raised high in the air. “Come and get it, Duke.” Duke became confused about what was in front of him. “Get off your pants, you silly. Can’t you see what I want?” This was getting too out of control for him. He took off her gown and raised her onto the kitchen counter, and began kissing her. “Wait,” she stopped him. “We don’t want to have the whole world watching. I want you inside.” Her words made him randy and his penis was alert. In fact, the alcoholic erection was ready for action, and it didn’t take long to get the job done. In no time at all they were both exhausted and feeling sleepy.

  Mike and Stacy’s sex marathon was winding down. Sweat was dripping down from his waist. “You were great tonight.” Mike was exhausted and acknowledged with a nod. “I enjoyed it,” he told her. “Okay, let’s hit the sack, babe.”

  As the rising sun slowly brightened the room, Duke found himself a bit disoriented. He got up and walked toward the window. Thoughts of Stacy had returned, and he had no particular concern for the gorgeous woman half tucked in the bed next to him. He was giving consideration to his escape plan, and how he was going to get on the road and away from Nancy---not that he hadn’t enjoyed every bit of their sport.

  Nancy interrupted his reverie, “Morning handsome.” “Morning to you, how was your night?” “It was great, but I should be going.” “Can’t you at least stay for breakfast?” “No can do, babe, I AM in a hurry.” In the back of his mind Duke was thinking of calling Stacy. He took his coat from the rack and headed home.

  Mike had loosened up and was more conversational. “I have this college friend by the name of Duke, who does construction work and I’m going to get in touch with him soon. I need to start working with him. He must be thriving in his career.” “You mean the guy from Bartam Design Group?” she intervened. “Yeah….do you mean that you two know each other?” “I found a telephone number written on a dollar bill, and dialed it, only to realize that it was this guy, Duke from Bartram Design Group.” “Are you kidding, I’ve been looking for this guy’s phone for quite some time now.” “Can you give me the number? I need to talk business with him.” Stacy went to her drawer removed the bill and handed it to him. “Yes, this is Duke’s number. I used to have it on my cell phone before I managed to lose it. Sure...yeah…he’s been using that number since college. I’m going to call him later” “Is he married nowadays?” Stacy asked. “I got no clue, but I think he must have a family.”

  Stacy secretly harbored a crush on Duke, and Duke certainly reciprocated. Duke was just reaching for his cell phone when there was a knock at the door. He wasn’t expecting anyone, but he put down the phone and went to answer. “Excuse me, Nancy, but what are you doing here? How did you know where to find me” he asked disconcertedly. “Technology,” she replied in a perky tone. “Okay, Nancy, tell me what you want at this time, please?” “I was just passing by just to see you and maybe make some plans to get together.” “Well, that’s good, but I’m very busy with some work right now.” “Oh, really, can I help you?” “No thanks…” “There must be something I can do for you, Duke,” she asserted, placing her purse on the couch. “Duke, we should talk.” “What about?” “We should talk about last night.” “Why, wasn’t it a good thing?” “Well, you are a good guy for taking me home, and everything you did ….”

  She thought that Duke would be thinking about her, but he was in a completely different world. He wasn’t thinking about anything except Stacy, who had become an obsession. Nothing had ever dominated his mind like his obsession with Stacy. “Is something bothering you,” Nancy questioned. “Not really, I’m okay.” Nancy persisted. “You seem worried. Are you regretting what happened between us.” “I said I was fine…just a little hung over.” “Sorry have you taken anything for it yet? She asked with some sensitivity. “Yeah,” he said, lying to her” She ignored his reply, “Let me get something for you.” She stormed into the kitchen and came back with a glass of juice, and some aspirin. “You need something refreshing like this.” “Thanks.” He grabbed the juice and aspirin and took them in one gulp. One of Duke’s problems was that he never did well on an empty stomach. He lost focus and couldn’t face his thoughts. The drink refreshed him and he began to concentrate on Nancy. “So what’s your plan now?” he inquired. “I want to take you on an evening out, how about that?” “That’s cool but what are we going to do this morning?” “Maybe cook up something special for you…so let’s go for it.” They went into the kitchen.

  Mike and Stacy started their busy day with chores. In the back of her mind Stacy was thinking about how she was going to face the challenge of her husband working with Duke in the same office. These two men had both won her heart, but the idea of seeing them together was going to change how she felt about her husband. She prayed that Mike would get a good job in a different place so that she could maintain a good marriage, although a small part of her heart wanted to reconnect with Duke.

  Her Beverly school crush was now fully on her mind and she was thinking of how she was going to approach Duke before Mike could make the call he was planning. She became so restless that she decided that she would be the one to make contact with Duke first. Mike interrupted her thoughts, “Babe, I need to make a run to the grocery store.” “Okay, the list is on the counter.” Mike grabbed the list and took off for the store.

  This was Stacy’s chance to make the call, so she went to the phone to check the call history and recover Dukes number, but it wasn’t there. Mike had probably cleared the call history, she thought. Where might he have put the $100 bill she asked herself, as she moved from room to room in search of it.“Oh yeah! I found it.” She took the number and dialed it, but there was no answer.

  Good old Duke was getting the better of Nancy, cuddling on the couch after a nice meal. No more plans for a night out. “I think we should spend the time here in the house,” he suggested. Nancy couldn’t have agreed more. Everything was moving along fine and she was getting to know more about him. The bond was growing a little. When there eyes met, there was some magic. He could see that Nancy was a strong woman, who could turn his life around. He thought to himself, that she would make a good partner. But at the same time, Duke didn’t really want to settle down. He was only in his late twenties. He felt he needed more time to explore and meet new and different people in his life before making the move that seemed to freak him out. How was he going to handle this woman? She was getting under his skin.

  Stacy tried again and again, but no one picked up the phone. Duke never bothered about the phone when he was in good company. Now Stacy wanted to talk with him, but didn’t have a clue what to say. She knew she wanted to make things lighter and tell him the truth about her identity.

  “I think I should be going now---got some errands to run” Nancy announced. “You didn’t tell me you had plans, come on…” he coaxed “I’d postponed something I was supposed to do, but now I’ve decided to complete it before the start of the week, I’ll be having an ap
pointment somewhere next week.” She picked up her bag. “Can you see me off?” “Sure, but why so quick, “he replied, raising himself up from the sofa. ““Why so quick?” “I need to be going, please,” she replied. He hesitated. “Alright, let me get the door for you.” With a total “Miss Independent” attitude she walked out, clicked the automatic unlock button on her car keys, bid him goodbye and drove away. Duke was in the dark. Again, he felt like he had wasted time with her, but again, it was worth it.

  Mike returned from the store, and found Stacy a nervous wreck. “Is everything okay? How come the house is so messed up? Were you looking for something? She answered on her feet, “No, I’m changing everything around and rearranging, but then wasn’t satisfied. I’ll get it straightened around.” “Okay,” he said. “Do your thing, but can’t we have something to eat first, I’m pretty hungry.” Stacy didn’t want to stray too far from the phone in case a call came in from Duke, but Mike’s request pretty much forced her into the kitchen. Mike had picked up a newspaper and he stretched out on the couch and went through the employment section, hoping he could find something that would peak his interest. He was beginning to get worried again, and suddenly he thought of giving his friend, Duke another call.

  Just as he reached for the phone, the phone started to ring. He picked it up and it was Duke! “Hey, Mike its Duke.” “What a coincidence, I was just going to call you.” “Yeah, well I just found your message that you tried to call twice.” Of course, Mike was surprised, he couldn’t let on that it wasn’t him calling. He knew now that this was somehow behind Stacy’s stress. “So Duke, how’ve you been?” “Good, good…how’s your family doing? Mike replied, “Doing great. Are you married?” “No, I’m still searching for the right girl.” “Hey, wish you all the best on that.” “So, Mike, what do you do nowadays?” “Recently quit my job, and now I’m looking.” “Really! I’ve been searching for a partner to help me with the design work. Remembering the old days, you were an excellent design man back in college. Why don’t we work together?” Mike couldn’t believe how lucky he was to get a job offer right off from his friend. Duke, on the other hand, was wishing it had been Stacy on the line. “I’ve been thinking about a start up in your area, the competition here is fierce, and we could be doing better financially. Do you think there’s office space available” “Duke, I think you’re right. People haven’t ventured here so much in our line of work, and yes, I could find us a good place at a decent price.” “Well, I’m planning on moving sometime next month. Let’s talk about how we’re going to work this out. “Mike, I’m so happy to have heard from you, and I’ll give you a call this week.” Mike thanked him and hung up the phone.

  Stacy was looking at him, “Who were you talking to?” “It was The Duke. I decided to call him and he returned the call. “What was the call about?” “Well, it was about a job, and I’m going to be working with him. She turned back and headed for the kitchen, and offered approval, but it sounded half-hearted. “Aren’t you happy that he asked?” “Why wouldn’t I be happy that you got a new job?” “Well, great, and he’ll be coming over soon so we can work to develop a plan to start up in this area.” This freaked her. She knew she couldn’t handle both of them, but now she had no option because she wanted her husband to be happy and working. “Well, let me know when he’s planning on coming over.”

  Duke thought it was the right time him to see Stacy and Mike couldn’t wait to see Duke. He really wanted to be doing something different with less stress, and where he could be his own boss, or at least a partner.

  Mike thought about having Duke spend the night at the house, although the guest room wasn’t in the best shape, but that didn’t bother him too much. “Stacy,” he called her. “Do you think Duke can spend night at the house?” She wasn’t expecting this question. “You mean the room with the leak in the ceiling?” “No, but we can fix up the lounge for him.” “That’s better” she responded. “But let’s get the room fixed up because he could come anytime, you never know. “

  It was three o’clock, and driving from his town to Mike’s place would take about three hours. Duke was thinking about it, and he did want to talk to Mike about the business plan, but his greater intention was to find out if Stacy was the main woman in his life. He made a bold choice. He got in the car and drove to Mike’s and it didn’t take him three hours to get there either.

  “I appreciate the infrastructure in this town; the flow of traffic has really improved.” “Yeah, Mike replied, “It was three hours ago when you told me you told me you would be here and you made it fifteen minutes early.” “Unlike the days when it used to take us four hours.” Duke replied. They walked through the front door, and Mike shouted, “Honey, we have a visitor.” Stacy came over and greeted them, and Mike put his arm around her waist. “Stacy,” Duke greeted her, “You look happy.” She replied, “So good to see you too.” Mike interrupted, “Do you two know each other?” “Oh yeah, Duke responded, “Since fifth grade Beverly school. Wow!” “Stacy, why didn’t you tell me you knew him? “Well, Mike I thought you were talking about a different guy.” She hadn’t wanted to meet him, but now everything was going so well, she felt comfortable with having the two of them around.

  “So Duke, why aren’t you married? You should get a wife and stop wasting time, get settled.” “Women don’t love me…” “Why would that be? They both flattered Duke as they walked him into the living room. “By now, you should be planning on having a kid” “Do you have one?” ”No, but we’re planning to get pregnant before the end of the year”. “Hey, that’s great” Stacy spoke up, “Duke, why don’t you get settled and I’ll get you some refreshments. Driving is so exhausting.” “Sure is, thanks.”

  Mike chimed in again, “Well tell me, it’s been so long, do you still play baseball like you used to?”No, I’m too old for that; I’m not as dexterous as I used to be.” “So what do you do during your free time”? Mike asked. “Fishing sometimes, also I play my piano.” “How about you?” “The truth? Nowadays things are getting a bit boring. Relationship is a hard thing, it changes everything.” He spoke in low tones to keep Stacy from hearing. Duke nodded. “I know what you mean, I’ve tried, but it doesn’t work for me. I guess commitment scares me; maybe someday, but that time hasn’t knocked yet.”

  Stacy was now becoming infatuated with Duke’s looks and charm; his physique was toned and sculpted, unlike Mike whose stomach and flesh was lose all over, “Thanks, hey make yourself comfortable, let’s catch up.” “Let me get dinner ready first.” “OKAY!” They both shouted in unison.

  ‘Men will always be boys.’ Laughter filled the living room, memories of fun moments, basketball and baseball; and old friends spilled forth, and talk of new opportunity. Stacy hadn’t thought of sleeping with another man, but this time her feelings were all about how to get to Duke. His body was hot and fueled a powerful attraction, let alone the crush she still carried from the old days. Mike had a better looking face, though Dukes was great too, but Duke’s masculine body had real power to lure. She couldn’t evaluate just what she wanted, but began to fantasize about both of them doing her at the same time. But who could allow such a thing to happen to someone he loves? Then she felt the need to speak to Mike.

  Stacy called him aside. “What do you want to talk about, Stacy”? She told him to fix up the lounge for Duke so he could spend the night. After convincing him to get started fixing, she went back and boldly lured Duke into taking a shower. You must be tired she said. Why don’t I show you the bathroom is so that you take shower?” “I would love that.” This was now the right opportunity to explore the personal terrain.

  Mike was busy in the other room and she knew it would take him some time to get things ready. “Okay, this is where you’ll be staying temporarily as we fix up the other room. She pulled him to her and kissed him, and without resisting, he responded to her kiss as they dragged each other towards the bath. He lifted her by her ass so that he could get the most of her lips exposin
g the bare skin behind the sleazy dress she was wearing. They paused to close the door behind them. Still panting they resumed their tryst. Duke started working her on top while Stacy concentrated on removing his belt, and grabbing for his erect penis. She pushed him to the wall as she went down to suck him. Duke held the back of her neck as her head bobbed up and down on his shaft. The more she sucked him, the more his moans intensified. She lowered one of her hands to quench the urge in her clit, her finger keeping pace with the movement of her mouth on his shaft. This sensation was too much for him almost making him cum before he could direct his dick into her warm folds. “Stop… stop…let me enter into you .” Duke couldn’t waste much time, since Mike could come back anytime. She knelt facing the bathtub allowing him to take her from behind. This was the only reasonable position given the small amount of space in the room. He positioned himself to get the best view of her relaxed pussy…she was so wet and he could hardly wait to feel this massive dick in her wanton pussy. She grabbed his shaft and guided it towards her hole. Then the tip of his dick slid down her clit into her vagina. Hell, she was wet, allowing him to slide in easily. She grabbed onto the bathtub as he penetrated deep inside her. She could feel his balls hit her with each powerful thrust. She couldn’t imagine handling a member as large as Duke’s, but at last it was all in her. His hips started slapping against her ass as he rode her hard; then he flipped her over to do her from the other side whipping himself back inside her warm pussy. The burning feeling and need for more made her close her eyes and rub her clit as Duke positioned himself for the next round. He rubbed the tip of his cock against her ass. She could feel a surge of nervousness through her body as her vaginal muscles tightened.