Two Cowboys in Her Crosshairs [Hellfire Ranch] (Siren Publishing Ménage Amour)

by Jennifer August

  Olivia realized it wasn’t the speaking he was having trouble with. His jaw clenched, and the muscles in his shoulders bunched and flexed as he continued to fuck her with the carrot.

  No, it wasn’t the talking. He was using all his control not to spear her right then and there.

  The slight hint of danger thrilled her. Knowing Hudson could lose his control and ram into her sparked an even darker lust within in. She bit her lip against begging him to take her like that now.

  She was just as close to the edge of tossing caution and preparation to the wind as he was.

  Jake lowered her head, and his angular face filled her vision. He cupped her jaw. His thumb stroked over her lower lip. “No cheating, Olivia. If we go too fast, you’ll tear.”

  She wrinkled her nose. “Damn,” she whispered. “How’d you know what I was thinking?”

  He grinned and kissed her then moved back to her tits. His hands cupped one mound and pressed the flesh tightly.

  Olivia’s hips churned on the bed as Hudson continued to pump inside of her. She tried to drive the carrot deeper inside, but he wouldn’t let her.

  “Stop that,” he scolded when she arched as hard and high as she could on his upstroke. He pinched the inside of her thigh and pulled the carrot out.

  “No,” she wailed. “I was getting close to coming.”

  Hudson slapped her butt a few times and spread her cheeks.

  Jake continued to hold and caress her tits.

  She loved the way his hands felt on her. His big palms surrounded her with warm confidence.

  “How’s she looking?” Jake asked.

  A blush crawled up her chest and over her cheeks. She felt like her ass gaped like a porn star’s. But damned if it didn’t feel really good.

  “She’s almost there,” Hudson said. He reached down and grabbed the narrow cucumber. “We’re going to move up, okay? How are you feeling?”

  Olivia nodded eagerly. “It feels really good. I could have come if you’d have let me.”

  Hudson grinned as he poured lube over the cucumber. “Don’t worry, darlin’. I have a feeling you’re going to be having so many orgasms you’ll lose count.” He crouched down. “Jake, pull her legs back a bit.”

  Jake winked at her and nipped her tummy as he leaned over her to accommodate Hudson’s request.

  His cock bobbed in her peripheral view. Olivia grabbed at him. They both gasped. His cock was silky hot and harder than her M40.

  “Jesus, Olivia,” he said. “Don’t let go, sweetheart. Your hand wrapped around my cock feels too damn good.”

  “I won’t,” she promised. She caressed him with long, even strokes. Beneath her palm his skin tightened and swelled.

  He caught her behind her knees and tugged backward. Her hips popped with the shift in position, and she winced.

  “You okay?” Hudson asked. Worry was on his face and in his words.

  She looked at him and nodded while smothering a laugh. He stood naked between her widely splayed legs holding a glistening cucumber and sporting a cock so stiff it rivaled a baseball bat.

  Maybe that’s where the expression morning wood comes from?

  She stifled another giggle. Lord, her nerves were getting to her.

  “Okay, relax again,” he said. This time he didn’t give her nearly as much time or gentle insertion as he had before. The rounded tip of the cucumber hit her sensitive rosebud with eager pressure. She could feel her sphincter easily parting. Her ass seemed eager to be filled.

  Jake’s cock jumped in her palm, and she clamped her fingers tight. She began to stroke him again.

  The cucumber stretched her small hole to pleasantly full but not quite enough. Hudson started to fuck her with it in slow and easy motions. She knew he was letting her get accustomed to both the size and length, but she found herself growing impatient.

  She squeezed Jake’s dick and lifted her hips. “More,” she rasped.

  The cucumber stilled, and Jake’s pelvis ground into the bed. “We’ve got to take it slow,” Hudson cautioned.

  “Fuck. Slow.” Her words were tight. “I want to get fucked. Now.”

  Jake let go of her knees and sat up. He encircled her wrist and guided her back to a stroking motion. “Keep going, baby,” he said. “It feels good. Hudson, keep fucking her with it.”

  “But Jake,” she protested. “I want more.”

  His finger snagged her nipple and twisted. “When you’re ready and not a moment before. Look,” he ordered her. “Look at Hudson’s cock. See how big it is? See how wide and red the head is? I bet it’s hot, too. So hot it’ll burn you as it splits your little ass in half.”

  Olivia panted and pulled. Her pussy spasmed. She could feel a trickle of juice seep down her wide spread legs and pool against the slow-moving cucumber.

  “I see,” she said.

  He pulled up on her tit, and she arched off the bed. Her ass clamped on the cucumber, and she groaned at the overwhelmingly full sensation.

  “Lie back down,” Hudson barked. Sweat sheened his broad shoulders, and the frown furrowed so deep on his forehead she was afraid it would be permanent.

  “I can’t go much longer,” he gritted out. “If I don’t get into her soon, I’m going to explode.”

  Jake nodded. “Okay. Livvie, your choice. You want ass up or down when I fuck your pussy?”

  The nasty words thrilled her, and another blast of warmth poured from her. Her thighs glistened with the juices they’d pulled from her. She looked at Hudson. Then her gaze dropped to his big, straining cock. She licked her lips, and the head bobbed toward the ceiling.

  “Fuck, Livvie,” he groaned. “Don’t do that.”

  She grinned. Never had she felt such immense power and love for any man, much less the two staring down at her with lustful eyes.

  “Which way is easiest for you to sink into my ass while my cunt is filled with Jake’s cock?” She loved the way the dirty words felt coming off her tongue. She loved how uninhibited she could be with these two guys. They made her want to do anything and everything with them.

  Hudson closed his eyes, and the muscles of his throat flexed and worked. Then his green gaze popped open and bore into her.

  “It’ll be easiest if you straddle Jake while he’s lying down.” He licked his lips. “Then, I’ll take you from behind.”

  The cucumber jerked in her ass.

  She grinned and winked. “Sounds good to me.”

  Olivia let go of Jake’s cock and waited for Hudson to remove the cucumber.

  “Uh, aren’t you going to take it out?” she asked.

  His smile was laced with pure wickedness. “Nope. You need to feel just how stuffed you’re going to be.”

  Olivia shivered. “Oh, my.”

  Jake scooted to the edge of the bed and eased onto his back. He grabbed his hard dick and stroked. “Come over here, Livvie, and get on my cock.”

  She tried to sit up and felt her ass start to let go of the cucumber. She stilled as another blush crawled over her skin. “I can’t,” she whispered. “It’s gonna come out.”

  Hudson chuckled and pushed the cucumber forward again. “Nope, I’ve got a firm grip. Sit up.”

  She did and found it awkward as hell for a minute. The vegetable pushed uncomfortably against her tummy. Hudson reached for her hand.

  “Let me help you up.”

  He tugged gently as she slid her stuffed ass off the bed. Olivia took one step and stopped again.

  “What’s wrong?” Hudson asked.

  His warm hand nestled in the crack of her ass. He twisted the cucumber as he looked down at her. A smirk tipped up the right corner of his lip.

  “I’m waddling,” she muttered. “It feels weird.”

  He laughed. “Come on. Get moving.”

  She inched her way across the hardwood floor to the foot of the bed. Jake’s long, hair-roughened legs draped over the edge. His bare feet were flattened along the wood. The knuckles on his toes pressed whitely against his tann
ed skin.

  Hudson stopped her at the corner of the bed. “When you climb up, I’ll have to take the cuke out or else we’ll have some projectile vegetable shooting.”

  She smacked his chest. Embarrassment burned over her. “For God’s sake, Hudson.”

  He swatted her ass in return. “Sex is funny, Olivia. Didn’t you know that?”

  “No.”

  He winked again and tugged the cucumber out. “Then you’ve been doing it wrong. Climb aboard.”

  Her ass felt oddly bereft and empty. Olivia looked down at Jake. She thought he’d been patiently waiting but now realized that was not the case at all.

  Hunger burned from his eyes. He clenched his jaw, and his nostrils flared. “Olivia?”

  “Yes, Jake?”

  His hand on his dick slowed to a bare whisper of movement.

  “I want you to get that hot pussy on my cock. Right fucking now.”

  The deep growl combined with the snap of authority had her scrambling onto the bed. She leaned over him then straddled his lean hips. The hot tip of his dick brushed her tummy.

  “God,” she whispered. “You’re so hot.”

  His hand sped up a little bit. “Hurry,” he muttered. “I need to be inside you again.”

  Olivia gave a jerky nod. She scooted down until her knees just brushed the edge of the bed then lowered her hips.

  Her pussy tangled with this dick, and she stopped. “You’re too high,” she said.

  The head of his cock slid over her clit, and she nearly toppled herself off the bed when she jumped. Only Hudson’s strong grip on her hip prevented her from falling.

  Jake eased himself lower, and she felt him at the entrance to her pussy. He pulsed, and she groaned then slowly sank down until she took his entire length.

  She stopped only when they ground pelvis to pelvis.

  “Oh, Livvie,” Jake said. “You feel so damn good.”

  She panted a little as she nodded her agreement. Her lower body tensed. She couldn’t tell if it was an effort to keep Jake’s cock firmly embedded and pushing against her pussy walls or from anticipation.

  “Fuck me, sweetheart,” Jake muttered. He caught her hips and squeezed.

  Olivia lifted upward. Every vein on his cock skittered across her highly sensitized inner flesh. She pushed back down then up until she found a slow rhythm that tortured both of them.

  Jake moaned softly as she moved. His eyes ensnared hers. Fierce emotion flared from his blue eyes and sweat dampened his brown hair to nearly black. His lips pressed together tightly.

  Olivia leaned down and kissed him until his mouth softened then parted. She darted her tongue inside and flicked at the edges of his mouth. He made a low, rough sound in the back of his throat then his hand caught her nape. He took control of the kiss and plundered her mouth with his tongue. His hips took overtook the slow pace she’d established. He created a harder motion that had her gasping for breath even as she tried to absorb his every thrust.

  His tongue lashed at hers as he filled her mouth and tickled her lips.

  An orgasm burst from her, and Olivia tore her head from his. She squeezed her eyes shut and slammed her hips down while she came.

  His fingers clenched and unclenched on her hips.

  “That’s it, sweetheart. Come for us.”

  She shuddered again and writhed on his dick. He swelled inside of her.

  “Fuck,” she moaned.

  His answering groan made her open her eyes. He stared up at her with slitted eyes that demanded more.

  Olivia lurched forward and pressed a kiss to his jaw. “God, Jake.” She started to lift her hips again.

  “Hold on, darlin’,” Hudson ordered. “I want to get this back inside of you.”

  She slowly turned her head and lifted up a little bit. “No.”

  He stopped with one hand on her ass and the other holding the cucumber aloft. “No?”

  “Uh-huh.” Olivia wiggled her butt. “Play time is over, Hudson. I want you in my ass.”

  She drew in a deep breath and bent a little more so she could see his face fully. “I want you to slide your cock in my ass. I want to watch your face as you stretch me out.” Her pussy clenched again.

  Jake groaned. “Holy fuck,” he muttered.

  Hudson nodded and tossed the cucumber over his shoulder. “Jake, pull out to the tip. Livvie, lift your hips to help.”

  She kept her cheek pressed to Jake’s shoulder and did as Hudson ordered.

  The snap of the lube lid was loud in the room as it mingled with their harsh breathing. She held still as the cold trickle hit her still-open asshole. She didn’t have time to worry over the temperature because Hudson’s finger delved inside. She could tell when he inserted a second.

  His eyes bored into hers, and he nodded sharply then slid a third inside of her.

  Her back bowed, and she bit her lower lip.

  He stopped. “Too much?”

  “No,” she said. “Don’t stop.”

  He pumped in and out of her for a moment then slowly pulled free. He grabbed the bottle and liberally applied the lube to his cock. When he stepped between Jake’s wide spread legs, Olivia could not help but tense her butt muscles.

  “Jesus,” Jake said. “That feels too damn good, Livvie.”

  “Sorry,” she said. Her gaze was glued to Hudson’s face. He wore an expression of intense pleasure and determination. Her knees started to shake, and she half closed her eyes.

  Hudson strong fingers parted her cheeks, and the slick head of his hard dick pressed against her small hole.

  She whimpered, and Hudson stroked her back. “Relax, darlin’.”

  “Easy for you to say.”

  Jake laughed beneath her, and his cock jerked inside her pussy.

  Hudson spread her ass a little more, and the tip slid in.

  “How’s that feel?” he asked.

  “Fucking amazing,” she said. The previous feeling of pleasantly full had been replaced with a tightness that caused a small burn in her flesh. The feeling wasn’t exactly pain but more like excited anticipation. Her skin was stretched tight and alive with prickles of tension.

  “More?”

  “God, yes.”

  Both men chuckled.

  Olivia held her breath as Hudson slowly drove into her. He would stop every inch or so and check to ensure she was still good. If she’d been able to talk with any coherence, she would have told him just how damn good she was.

  “Halfway in,” he said. His breath came in controlled measures, but his eyes snapped with impatience.

  Olivia watched him fight his baser instincts. She could tell he wanted to rip into her ass and plow her hard.

  She bit her lip to prevent herself from begging for just that. Jake was right when he said they needed to take it slow. Maybe later when she was more accustomed to taking Hudson’s massive cock in her ass they could play a little harder.

  Her ass and pussy both spasmed on that thought.

  “Hurry up, Hudson,” Jake demanded.

  “Yeah, I felt that,” his friend replied.

  “Got that lube?” Olivia asked.

  “Yeah,” Hudson said. “Why?”

  “Pour it over the rest of your cock then sink all the way into me, Hudson. I want to be filled by you. I need it. Please.”

  Her voice cracked on the last word.

  He hissed out a sharp breath as he grabbed the bottle and doused his throbbing cock. He tossed the lube back to the bed and gripped her hips.

  “Jake?”

  “Yeah?”

  “I’m going to slide all the way in her ass. She’s tight and hot, so it’ll take a minute for her to adjust. When she does, I’ll pull out and you push in, okay?”

  Olivia felt Jake shift beneath her. His hands worked over the flesh of her hips like he was kneading bread. Impatience lined every movement of his fingers. “Yeah. Hurry up.”

  Hudson nodded. “Yeah.” He locked eyes with her again. “Deep breath, Livvie, and push
back against my dick.”

  She barely had time to inhale before he started to push inexorably inward. She bit her lip harder and forgot all about breathing as he split and stretched her open. Fire raced along her anal nerve endings and sprang to her clit. Her eyelids started to drift closed, but she forced them back up. She wanted to watch as he took her.

  His blond hair was dark and damp from the exertion of holding back. His muscles continued to bunch at his shoulders as he steadied her ass and pushed forward. His green eyes glowed with intense passion. A drop of sweat rolled from his temple to hang at the sharp point of his chin before splashing down on her ass.

  She jumped and inadvertently pushed backward so his cock filled her completely. Another thrill of sensual pain raced through her. She gasped and stilled as her body got used to the girth of his dick.

  Olivia watched him fight the need to fuck her with hard, raw strokes.

  She began to sway. She moved just enough to tease him into maybe breaking that control. “You want to fuck me, don’t you, Hudson?”

  “Yeah.” His voice was as hard as the cock in her ass. “You ready?”

  Olivia took stock. Her ass pulsated with a sort of demanding need that echoed in her pussy. She was stretched and taut and absolutely loving it.

  “Yeah.”

  Hudson slid his cock from her ass until only the head was lodged in her. The tension remained, though, and Olivia couldn’t help clench her ring.

  “Thank God,” Jake muttered. He shoved his hips upward and filled her pussy.

  “Oh damn,” she whispered and lifted her head. He wore the same intent expression as Hudson. She leaned down to kiss him and was taken by surprise when Jake’s cock withdrew and Hudson’s plowed forward.

  She froze.

  Hudson pulled out, and Jake thrust in.

  Her clit twitched. Her ass burned. Her eyes drifted closed.

  “Oh, yeah,” she whispered. “Fuck me. Both of you, fuck me.”

  “Look at me,” Jake rasped.

  She forced her eyes open. His blue gaze ensnared her even as his body moved back and forth.

  Again and again they moved in tandem as they fucked her. An ache started to build deep inside, but she couldn’t tell if it was coming from her pussy or her ass or both.

  All she knew was it felt good. Olivia rocked her hips as she latched onto their rhythm. “Yes. Yes. Fuck me.”