by Unknown
But before she could say anything, he spoke. “You have to let us do this, Maddy. We can work out ways to make it easier on you, but you have to let us protect you. Just think about the girl who’s missing. She’s gone. She might never be found again. Do you want to be her?”
Maddy pushed to her feet. It didn’t help; all three of the men still towered over her. She opened her mouth. “But—”
”Think about us,” Eli said. “If you won’t think about yourself, think about what it would do to us if you disappeared. You’ve seen what it’s like when mates lose one of their own. It would kill us.”
She took a deep breath, not quite a sigh. “Fine.”
Donovan wanted to kiss Eli for saying just the right thing, but didn’t want Maddy to think they were crowing over their victory. Still, he put his hand on Eli’s back and rubbed. “Any more questions, Caleb?”
“That’s enough for now. You can take her home.” He stepped away from them to talk to one of his deputies.
Donovan immediately pulled Maddy into his arms, resting his cheek against the top of her head. “I can’t believe I almost lost you.”
She hugged him back. After a couple of minutes, she said, “Let’s go. I’m ready to eat.”
Eat. He was ready to tuck her in bed where he could examine her in minute detail and then confirm for himself she was still every bit alive. But instead she wanted to eat.
She could eat. And he could make sure it didn’t take long. “Eli, you follow Maddy back to my house. I’ll pick up food at the diner and meet you there.”
Eli was nodding before Donovan had even finished. “Good plan.”
“Wait, why can’t we just go eat at the diner?” Maddy said.
“No,” both men responded in unison.
As Eli steered her toward her car, he said, “We’re feeling over-protective right now. Indulge us. Besides, this way we’ll be able to go to bed much sooner.”
Sounded like he and Eli were of one mind. Now they just needed to get their little mate thinking the same way.
#
Later, the containers from the food Donovan had picked up lay strewn across the coffee table in his den. Maddy had fought them all the way, but once she’d gotten to Donovan’s house, she’d kind of collapsed. Eli had curled up with her on the couch, and when Donovan got home, he’d suggested they stay there.
It was as good a place as any to start a seduction.
Seeing Maddy attacked had made everything crystal clear, like it had burned away years of pain in mere seconds. If Eli lost her, life would be meaningless. Nothing else. Simple as that.
And while lying on the couch curled around her in a tangle of arms and legs was great, he could think of something even better. His hand found a patch of bare skin underneath someone’s clothing. The skin was super-soft, so he figured it was Maddy’s and not Donovan’s, but from how he was lying, he couldn’t be sure.
It didn’t matter anyway.
He stroked, tracing gentle, slowly widening circles. When his finger brushed the underside of a breast, he knew exactly who and what he was touching.
“Maddy,” he whispered.
She moaned softly.
Donovan chuckled. “Should we move this upstairs? More room there.”
“I don’t want to move.” Maddy’s voice sounded soft, sleepy.
And Eli was getting all sorts of ideas. “Let’s stay here for now. After we’ve made her come a few times, we can carry her upstairs.”
“And get violent,” Maddy whispered.
“Violent?” Donovan pushed the hair back from her face.
“Mm-hmm. Eli said you two make love violently.”
Eli slid his hand a little higher to cup her breast. What a memory his little mate had. “That’s right. We’d be too much for one tiny couch.”
With a happy moan, Donovan slipped to his knees beside the couch. As he shifted Maddy around, he said, “Come here. I want to lick your pussy.”
She gasped, her cheeks turning pink.
Eli ran his finger from her temple to her chin. “I wonder how long it’ll take until you don’t blush at dirty talk.”
“Hopefully a long time.” With a jerk, Donovan pulled Maddy’s skirt, stockings and panties down her legs all at once. “I like it.”
“Me, too,” Eli said.
“It’s just–I’m not used to hearing things like that. Especially about me,” she said.
“I like that, too,” Donovan said. He ran his hands up her bare thighs, parting them as he stroked. “God, you’re gorgeous.”
Guess Eli got her upper half for now. He pulled her shirt up, revealing her pale stomach inch by inch, then her lacy bra encasing her perfect tits, and finally those creamy shoulders and arms. He tossed the shirt to the side before he buried his face in her chest. The soft curves of her breasts, still held together by her bra, cushioned his cheeks as he laid moist kisses against her flesh.
Maddy threaded her fingers through his hair. “My two men. I got so lucky.”
Eli had to pause a moment at that, breathing in her scent and accepting that she was his. Really his. “We’re the lucky ones.” He lifted his head enough so he could meet her eyes.
She smiled at him, a dreamy I’m-in-love-with-you kind of smile that warmed him from the inside out. Then she abruptly closed her eyes and tipped her head back, moaning. From behind Eli, Donovan grunted.
Eli had work to do, if he was going to rock her world the way Donovan was. Peeling back the cups of her bra bit by bit, he kissed and licked and gently bit his way toward her nipples. Such pretty pink nipples, all hard and waiting for him. He sucked one into his mouth while thumbing the other to a hard nub.
This was great, but he wanted more. Down her body, Donovan had his head buried between her legs as her hips rolled against him. There had to be a way Eli could get in on that.
“Let’s put her on her side,” Eli said.
Donovan looked up at him, his forehead a question mark, but didn’t move his mouth from her pussy.
“Let’s put her on her side,” Eli repeated, “so I can lick her…rear.” He’d been going to use a different word, but didn’t want to scandalize Maddy too much. As it was, she started turning red as her eyes widened.
“Why…why would you do that?” she said.
“When I do it, you’ll know why.” He didn’t want to give her a chance to say no. Luckily, Donovan was on board and in seconds, they’d lifted her enough so Eli could get in behind her. It was an awkward position, but worth it.
Holding her leg in the air, he got himself in place. The first thing he noticed was the amazing scent. Her juices had run down from her pussy so her puckered hole smelled of sex and mate. Then he licked her and felt the soft but ridged surface against his tongue, now tasting as well as smelling like Maddy’s pussy. His cock hardened even more, if that were possible.
As he lightly sucked, Maddy mewled and thrashed. He and Donovan held her lower body in place so they could continue. Her body tightened as she made little cries and gasps that went straight to his groin. Her muscles clenched harder and harder until she erupted, shaking, shuddering, keening. With his tongue still pressed against her, Eli could feel the walls of her pussy clenching as she came.
Donovan raised his head, lips glistening. “Wanna change sides?”
Chapter 8
“Hell, yeah,” Eli said. This was exactly what he’d wanted.
The two men shifted position, as Maddy put her hand out. “Wait. Aren’t we going upstairs now? Violent mating and all that?”
“We’re not done with you,” Donovan said.
“I think I’m done.” She brushed her hair out of her face. “Totally done.”
“Nah. You’ve got at least one more orgasm in you,” Eli said.
“For now.” Donovan pushed her leg up in the air again. “And a few more later.”
Her head fell back against the couch. “You two will be the death of me.”
“Death by orgasm?” Eli said.
> “Sounds good to me.” Donovan dipped his head between her nether cheeks.
Maddy’s bra was still on, the cups pulled down to reveal her beautiful breasts. Eli rested a hand against one of them, rubbing his thumb over her nipple again and again while his other hand stroked her pussy. She was so wet. Amazing.
His fingers slid over her clit, slippery. Then he pushed two of them into her and put his tongue against her clit. She’d be hyper-sensitive right now, on the heels of that last orgasm. He needed to be gentle, increase her arousal until she was ready for more.
Maddy reached her hands toward each of her mates. She could just barely reach Eli’s head. Her fingers brushed against his scalp so lightly it tickled. Her breath shortened, her hips moving slightly against him.
Sucking more forcefully, Eli watched her response. Would she cringe at too much sensation too soon? No. She sucked in her breath, her eyes fluttering closed.
Perfect.
He alternated sucking the top bit of her clit with licking down its length to where his fingers continued to slide in and out of her. He’d learned that along the way–a woman’s button was only part of her clit. Know how to stroke and lick and massage all of it and you’d make her very happy.
Breathing becoming ragged, Maddy rubbed her hands over her face. “Oh, God. I can’t—”
Yes, she could. She could explode into a million pieces all over again, lose control and trust in her men to bring her to a shattering orgasm. She could. But he didn’t want to remove his mouth from her sweet, sweet pussy long enough to tell her that.
“Soon,” she crooned. She leaned over a little so she could reach him, and rubbed her hand over his head. “Soon, soon.”
He couldn’t wait to watch her again, to see her fall apart and forget herself, all because of him. He tongued her harder, sucked her longer, fucked his fingers into her faster.
She gasped for breath, crying out, then her body tensed. The world stilled for a moment, her breath caught, silence filling the room. And then she let go. Her pussy tightened around his fingers in spasms as her body rolled through a long, long shaking shuddering shattering orgasm.
He’d done that.
Eli sat back, still lightly stroking her as her body slowed and then stilled, her breathing returning to normal.
After lowering her leg, Donovan rested his cheek against her hip. “Amazing.” He kissed her thigh. “You want to carry her upstairs or should I?”
“I’ll do it,” Eli said. Anything to keep touching her. He pulled her into his arms and carried her toward the stairs.
#
Donovan followed behind, grabbing Maddy’s clothes and hitting light switches. Eli lay Maddy in the middle of the bed then stripped. While he did that, she reached behind her to unclasp her bra and drop it on the floor. He lay down next to her, skin to skin. Soon after, Donovan–naked–joined them.
Donovan had never experienced anything quite like what they’d done on the couch. Oral sex, sure–he’d had oral sex before. But this had been something more. Partly because there were three of them. But mostly because he’d gotten such incredible pleasure from giving someone else pleasure. He’d nearly come the first time Maddy did. And the second time, he’d only held himself back by clamping his fingers around his cock like a cock ring. Never, never had anything like that happened before.
Now the three of them lay together on the bed in a Maddy sandwich, her tight butt pressed against his cock. And Donovan was ready to take things to a whole new level.
He brushed the hair back from Maddy’s ear. “You ever try anal sex?”
She choked out a laugh. “You’re kidding, right? No one’s ever done anything down there until Eli…I mean, until you just…” The blush turned her ears red.
“But you liked that.” He knew she did. No way would she have come like that if she didn’t.
“Yes.” Her voice was soft.
“You’ll like this, too.” He kissed the tender spot behind her ear. “Anal sex, with both of us inside you at the same time.”
She tensed. “Both of you in my—”
Eli laughed.
“No. One in front and the other in back.” Donovan rubbed her arm. “It’ll feel good. Promise.” He shifted his hips so his cock slid up the seam of her ass.
“That sounds really good.” Eli cupped her cheek and kissed her.
When they parted, she said, “Won’t it hurt?”
“We’ll make sure it doesn’t.” Eli pressed another kiss against her lips. “Just imagine the three of us, all connected, all making love at the same time. It’ll be great.”
Maddy’s body relaxed. “We could give it a try.”
And again, Eli said just the right thing. This time, Donovan really could kiss him. He pushed up onto his elbow, grabbed Eli by the back of the neck, and pulled him into a kiss. “Perfect,” he murmured against his lips.
Eli gripped Donovan’s shoulder as the two of them kissed. Donovan felt a soft hand slide down his chest to grip his cock. With a moan, he pushed himself more firmly against her butt, trapping her hand between them.
When they broke off the kiss, Donovan and Eli gazed into each other’s eyes. Donovan rubbed his thumb across Eli’s cheekbone. “Someday we’re going to have to try some anal of our own.”
Eli swallowed. “I’m looking forward to that.”
Looked like both his mates were nervous about anal. Not surprising; he was too. Receiving anyway. Not at all nervous about being on top. “I went to the store today.” He crawled out of bed and went into the adjoining bathroom. When he returned, he tossed the bottle onto the bed. “I was hoping Maddy would say yes.”
“Lube?” she said.
“It’ll make everything feel better.” He settled back onto the bed beside her.
“You’ve done this before.” She handed the bottle back to him.
“Once or twice. Practice.” And he was glad for it now. He’d never do anything to hurt Maddy. And attempting anal without having a clue what he was doing would be a sure way to hurt her. “Slide onto your back, sweetie.”
“My back? Don’t you want me on my hands and knees?”
He coughed. Did he ever. “It’s going to feel better this first time if you’re on your back. Trust me.” And that’s what it came down to, didn’t it? Trust.
Eli helped her onto her back. “What about me?”
“Let’s get her warmed up first. Then we can do the double penetration.” Donovan pressed Maddy’s legs open, pushing her knees toward her shoulders. He could see every part of her sex, and when he shifted her hips, he could see her beautiful puckered hole as well. After pouring a little lube onto his fingers, he rubbed it against the tight little star. “Does it feel okay so far?”
“Yes,” she said. “But not as good as your tongues.”
Donovan felt warmth bloom in his chest. She was going to be a-okay. He pushed gently. “I’m going to put my finger in you now. Just relax.” He pushed a little more, added some more lube, then managed to slip his finger inside the tight ring. “Okay?”
“Fine.”
Eli rubbed her clit and leaned over to kiss her. So while she was distracted, Donovan took the opportunity to work his finger into her a little more, back and forth, spreading the lube and getting her used to having something inside her. When he felt she was ready, he added a second finger. She tensed a little but seemed to handle it okay. After a couple of minutes, she relaxed.
“I think you’re ready, sweetie,” he said. His cock was bigger than two fingers but she’d relaxed really well. She’d be all right.
Maddy didn’t answer, her mouth busy kissing Eli. Donovan got to his knees between her legs then lubed up his cock so it would slide in as easily as possible. He didn’t want his mate to feel a second of pain. Especially if he ever wanted to do this again.
Placing his cock at the small opening, he pressed forward. Maddy tensed and pushed on Eli’s shoulders.
“Relax,” Donovan said. “I mean that. Relax your muscles.
If you tense up, it’ll hurt.”
She took a deep breath.
“You’re afraid it’s going to hurt,” he said. “So you’re tensing up. Just trust me. Relax your muscles and it’ll feel really good.” He could see the muscles in her thighs, butt and abdomen releasing. Immediately he was able to slip a full inch inside her.
He stopped. “Doing okay?”
She took a breath before answering. “Yes. It doesn’t hurt, it just feels…odd.”
Donovan leaned forward so he could move his hips more easily, and slid in another inch. “Tell me if it hurts.”
“It’s okay.”
He’d never felt anything like it, even the other two times he’d done this. She fit around him like she was made for him. He pushed another inch in, and when she didn’t stop him, he took the chance of pulling out a little only to push in even further.
She made a noise but he couldn’t tell if it was pleasure or pain. He stopped moving. “Does it hurt?”
“No,” she moaned. “Don’t stop.”
Hallelujah. Exactly what he was hoping for. He picked up the pace slowly, watching for any signs of pain. But Maddy seemed to be loving it. She held tight to Eli and ran her hands over his body.
After a few minutes, Eli said, “Think we could go for it? All the way?”
“Absolutely.” Donovan pulled out. He’d already debated the best position. “Eli, you lie down on your back with Maddy on top.”
#
Maddy felt a small frisson of something but wasn’t sure whether it was fear or excitement. Donovan hadn’t lied about the anal sex; it hurt a little at first but then the sensual friction had felt amazing. Better than she’d ever have imagined. Although after feeling their tongues down there and how good that was, she shouldn’t have been surprised.
Eli grinned. “Hell, yeah.” He lay down, pulling Maddy over him in the same move, so her chest rested against his. He squeezed her tight and kissed her while they wriggled until their bodies fit together just right. Then he pushed his hips upward as she slid down, and his cock slipped into her with ease.