Sold at the Games

by Sierra Sparks

  My gut instinct was more traditional. It would’ve said, “What? Are you crazy? You can’t have a relationship with three men!” That probably would’ve been true with a lot of other women and in a previous time, but not Lexi. Lexi was strong. She could handle three guys. She could handle anything.

  Quite frankly, I just wouldn’t mind it. In fact, this would probably be the best thing for all of us. It would keep Kyle from getting trapped in an awful marriage and keep Carey from being alone the rest of his life. As for me, I’d finally have someone to save the tigers with. Changing the world can be fun, but not if you do it alone. Plus I would have my two best friends around.

  You know, a few years ago this all would’ve sounded crazy to me. Times change and I guess people do too. I was ready for this. This just felt right.

  Chapter 10

  Lexi

  Getting all three of them together was a lot easier than actually saying the words. How did I say this? How did anyone say this? That was something the polyamorous website didn’t cover.

  “Guys, I’ve come to a decision and I wanted you all here when I explained it,” I began.

  Carey straightened himself up, automatically thinking he was the winner. Kyle looked a little nervous and Jackson just smiled. He seemed to know what I was going to say already. The waiter entered with menus, but I waved him off.

  “We’ll just take four of the samplers. One vegetarian, but give us a minute,” I instructed him.

  “Okay, whatever you have to say is cool,” said Kyle. “But I just want to be clear, we having tapas, right?”

  “Fool, she’s got something important to say and you’re worried about tapas?” said Carey.

  “Hey, I’m hungry. Just saying,” said Kyle.

  “Go ahead, Lexi,” urged Jackson.

  “The three of you are awesome,” I started. “More than that, really. When I kissed each of you there was a spark. Real chemistry. I can’t choose just one of you, so I’m choosing all you.”

  “Wait, what?” said Kyle.

  “Did you know about this?” Carey said, suspicious of Jackson.

  “I suspected,” admitted Jackson.

  Carey was looking like he was trying to process.

  “So you’re saying you want to continue to date all three of us until you can choose?” he surmised.

  “No, I’m saying I want a relationship with all three of you. I want to be with all three of you together,” I said.

  “Wait a minute, like together? Like each of us takes turns with you?” asked Kyle, who was also obviously trying to understand.

  “I call Fridays,” said Carey. “I have to have Fridays.”

  “No, not like that,” I clarified. “I want all three of you together. At once.”

  Carey stood up. He looked a little cornered.

  “I don’t know, I don’t know,” he muttered. “Are you hearing this?”

  “Yeah,” said Jackson. “And quite frankly, it makes sense. Some animals do it like this.”

  “I don’t see how this makes sense,” said Kyle. “And I’m not a wild animal; I’m a human being. I’m not trying to judge or anything, but I don’t even see how it would work.”

  “You said you were a virgin,” pointed out Carey. “You go from virgin to a group orgy thing? Just like that?”

  “It’s not like I’ve known anything else,” I pointed out. “I think I’m falling for all three of you. You’re all great. Is that so crazy?”

  “Why don’t you date us for a while longer?” suggested Kyle. “We’re in no hurry. You’ll make up your mind.”

  “Yeah, Lexi, I haven’t even taken you to half the fabulous places I planned,” agreed Carey. “Besides, no offense Kyle, but you aren’t ready for Lexi.”

  “What’s that supposed to mean?” asked Kyle.

  “I’m just saying, you’re a little young; women are more mature than us guys,” said Carey.

  “Then by that logic, you should bow out for me,” added Jackson.

  “So you’re okay with this, Jackson?” asked Carey, incredulous. “You’d share a woman with me and Kyle? You’d have sex with all us naked together?”

  “We shower all the time,” pointed out Jackson. “What difference would that make?”

  “It’s a big difference if we’re having sex with the same woman,” snapped Carey.

  “You’ve been on the road,” reminded Jackson. “We’ve had sex in the same room at the same time.”

  “Not with the same person! And not someone I’m— someone that I care about. Not that I— froupies are just different, Jackson, you know that,” said Carey feeling cornered.

  “Chill out, man. We’re just talking,” said Kyle.

  “Now you’re warming up to this?” said Carey.

  “I’m thinking about it. If that’s what she wants and I really want her,” said Kyle. “And you guys are my best friends. I mean, it’s different, but I can’t see the down side.”

  “Look, I’m not trying to talk you into something you don’t want,” I offered. “I’m just asking you to consider it, okay?”

  “What about the team, man? If this gets out— Hell, you’re a reporter, Lexi. You know what they would do if this got out?” said Carey. “People would freak the fuck out.”

  “It’s none of their business, quite frankly,” said Jackson.

  “I know it’s none of their business, but they’ll make it their business and then what?” said Carey.

  “Well, it’s not like the coach is going to kick us off the team,” said Kyle. “I don’t even think he’d care.”

  “I don’t know, man. I don’t know,” said Carey.

  “C’mon, Carey. Open up. Total honesty,” I urged.

  “I guess I’m just worried because I’ve never been in a situation like this. You know, me and Ringo were kinda friends before the Tina situation. Now he hates me. I don’t want something like that to happen with my boys here,” Carey confessed.

  “Dude, I promise, it’s cool,” assured Jackson. “None of us are like that punk Ringo. You’re a great guy and you can show Lexi a great time. I’m not into all those fancy restaurants and expensive clothes.”

  “Yeah, me neither,” added Kyle.

  “Well, I definitely can’t do all that conservation stuff,” admitted Carey. “That’s all you, brother.”

  “I don’t even know what I bring to table,” admitted Kyle.

  “You bring a lot,” I assured him. “You’re sweet and warm. Always thinking of others. Plus, you love family. I like family oriented men.”

  Kyle looked deep into my eyes. Something clicked with him.

  “You know what? I’m in. Let’s do it,” he agreed.

  “I’m in too,” said Jackson. “Carey?”

  “Maybe I should just bow out and let you three try this,” said Carey, unsure.

  “No, it’s all or none,” I insisted. “Don’t be afraid, Carey. We’re all here for you.”

  “How would it even work, ya know?” asked Carey. “The three of us? I mean, no disrespect, but I’ve seen some pornos. I didn’t think this thing happened in real life.”

  “This isn’t just about sex,” I assured him. “I have real feelings for all three of you. You all won my heart. How could I resist such strong, wonderful men?”

  Carey had a moment too. Here he was, Mr. Confident, superstar— Nothing had ever shaken him to the core of his being like being confronted with this offer. Life had always been easy for him. Born with talent and money, Carey had skated through life, never really having to think much about it. There was little challenge. But here he was now, for the first time, facing a challenge.

  He sighed, exasperated and finally said, “If it were anyone else other than y’all, I would’ve walked out of here so fast. But all right, let’s try this. How’s it gonna work? Technically speaking?”

  “If I may,” offered Jackson. “I probably have the biggest apartment out of all of us. Why don’t we go back to my place?”

  “I’m re
ady to leave now,” I said, excited, grabbing everyone’s hand.

  “Aw, no,” said Kyle. “I’m not leaving without tapas. No way.”

  “Plus, I need a drink,” added Carey. “I wanna loosen myself up for this.”

  The tapas arrived and everyone ate. Jackson mainly focused on the cheeses and olives. He was missing out on some of the amazingly cured meats. There were also vegetable tapas just for him. Carey commented on every plate, but Kyle just shoved the next course into his mouth. I didn’t even think he even tasted it. He was clearly excited about starting off on our new venture.

  Afterwards, there was a bit of a fight over the check, but I won out. I felt obligated. After all, I was asking these three to embark on a new journey. No one knew what would happen. If it somehow all went south, I wanted them to know that I could at least pay my own way.

  On the way out of the restaurant I could’ve sworn I spotted Ringo. He immediately looked away and walked towards the coatroom. I rushed there to find him., to see if he had seen me with the guys and to make up a story to cover up for us— I was going to say it was an interview and ask him if he had anything to say about the big upcoming game.

  He was gone. Or else he was never there in the first place. Perhaps it was my imagination playing tricks on me, and that the guys’ paranoia about being caught had rubbed off on me. The only person that was back there was the woman who takes the coats. She made a fuss so I left, but I couldn’t shake the feeling I had missed something somehow.

  Jackson’s apartment was far from the restaurant. It was a spacious spot in Northern Liberties, currently the hippest area of Philadelphia. It was a place for dive bars, young hipsters, new bowling alleys and tiny shops.

  The neighborhood had once been a desolate wasteland of drug dealing, but developers moved in and rebuilt the whole place. Now it was the area of the city where all the cool people would hang. The place was ton he top floor of a brand new apartment building.

  “Let’s do this,” I thought, as I went in. “Ready or not, here we go.”

  I was so happy they had said yes. I didn’t want to get nervous now, when it mattered most. I wasn’t sure about all the guys, but I was definitely more “ready” than “not.”

  Chapter 11

  Lexi

  We went into Jackson’s bedroom. He had a huge king-sized bed. That was good, since we were going to need it. I kissed Jackson first, then Carey and then Kyle.

  “Go slow, guys,” I announced. “I’m new at this. Remember, I’m still a virgin.”

  “You are definitely not a virgin after tonight,” said Carey.

  Carey made the first move. He grabbed me boldly and caressed my breasts while kissing my neck. His strong arms lifted me up a little and I could feel my nipples tingling at the touch of his fingers. Jackson took me by the chin and kissed me deeply. His hairy bristled face rubbed up against mine. After a few seconds, I looked up. Kyle was still trying to find his way over.

  “Sorry,” he laughed, embarrassed. “I wasn’t sure what angle to come in at.”

  This time, I took the initiative and strutted over to him. I grabbed the back of his head and kissed him. He took me by the waist. Then I whispered in his ear, “It’s okay. We’re all new at this.”

  Jackson put on some light jazz music and lowered the lights a little bit. Carey pulled the covers down on the bed. Kyle, while kissing me, gently laid me down on the bed. Now everyone had access to me. I was on my back, willing, breathless, waiting.

  “Take me,” I said, my breasts practically heaving out of the dress.

  Jackson took off his shirt and threw it aside. Carey brought his hand up the inside of my right thigh. Kyle kissed me on my neck and breasts. I reached out and found Carey’s cock. It was already rigid in his pants.

  “Oh, yeah, baby. This is hot!” he said.

  Jackson was suddenly at the foot of the bed. He reached down and slid of my panties. He could already see I was wet for him. Wet for all three of my men.

  “Oh, my God, you have a beautiful pussy,” he gasped.

  He fell to his knees and sliding his hands under my ass he pulled me forward toward him. I felt his warm, wet tongue in my nether regions. I started to moan.

  “Yeah, yeah!” I gasped.

  Kyle stood and started taking his clothes off. Carey unzipped his pants so his magnificent cock could emerge. It was the biggest I had ever seen, not that I had seen many as a virgin. But anyone, anywhere who might have seen it would’ve been impressed by its girth and size. I gently rubbed the shaft.

  “Oh!” I said moaning for Jackson and Carey. “It’s so big, Carey. It’s so big!”

  Kyle was down to his underwear, which could barely contain his hard cock. I pulled them down and immediately started stroking it.

  “Oh, shit,” he whispered. “You get it, Lexi. You get it.”

  He bent down and buried his face in my breasts, licking and sucking. Every cell of my body was becoming hyper sensitive. Everything was arousing and aroused. Jackson stuck his tongue deep inside me and I let out an awkward scream. It was the first time of many times I would cum that night.

  I turned toward Kyle’s cock. It was so hard. It had a sheen to it in the dim light. I touched it with my tongue. It was salty. Gently I started licking around it. I was tentative at first, but then I started sucking it. It took up a good portion of my mouth.

  “Aw, aw, yeah,” said Kyle gratefully.

  Out of the corner of my eye, I saw Jackson pull back and stand up. He must’ve made eye contact with Carey.

  “You want to get some of this?” he asked.

  “Yeah, let me get in there,” said Carey.

  Carey took his spot at the edge of the bed. While I sucked Kyle’s dick on my left, I could hear Jackson taking off his clothes to my right. I felt Carey’s big, manly fingers enter me. He started to finger fuck me. Gently at first. Then, as I got wetter and the water started to flow, he added a finger. His two fingers were going in and out of my pussy at an ever-increasing speed. I took Kyle out of my mouth for a moment while still rubbing his shaft.

  “Mmm, mmm!” I cooed. “Oh, yeah, Carey. Like that!”

  I turned to my right and Jackson’s rock hard member was there.

  “Ooo,” I said. “Who is this? He looks ready!”

  I hungrily put Jackson’s cock in my mouth. Oh, God, how I loved the taste of it! I held it against the roof of my mouth a second so I could feel it throbbing against my tongue.

  “Oh, yeah, baby,” whispered Jackson. “You suck it. You suck me good.”

  While Kyle’s cock was circumcised with a more nuanced head, Jackson’s cock was uncircumcised with a very large head fully engorged. It was almost like a mushroom at the end. I rubbed my tongue and bottom lip around the tip and he moaned in pleasure.

  Downstairs, things were building again. I don’t know how Carey’s hand wasn’t getting tired, but he was blasting my tight little vagina with his fingers. Water was pouring out of me and I was in ecstasy. I leaned back and held Jackson and Kyle’s cocks in either hand while spreading my legs go give Carey better access.

  “Y-y-yes, please! Don’t stop!”

  I was over come with orgasm after orgasm while jerking Kyle and Jackson. They were so hard and so strong, I was basically being held up by their dicks.

  “Oh, my God,” I squealed. “Oh, my God! Please fuck me! All of you, fuck me!”

  I tore my open dress off. I couldn’t be bothered to stand up and take it off at this point. I had to have them inside me. All of them! Carey stood up and finished getting undressed. I marveled at each of my men, perfect athletes, muscular and cut. There were all a credit to their manly gender.

  Jackson got out a package of condoms and dropped them on a nearby table. He slipped one on and then slipped inside of me.

  “You like this? You like this?” he asked.

  I felt his hardened man shaft press into me. It was amazing, but I couldn’t speak. I was overcome with sensation. I just moaned and squealed in
pleasure. I pulled Kyle in closer with his cock so that his balls were at my mouth. I started licking and sucking his hairy balls.

  “Oh, God, yes!” he said in surprise and pleasure. “You do that right, baby. You do that ri-ight!”

  “Oh, shit!” I found myself saying into Kyle’s balls. “Jackson! Oh, Jackson!”

  “Ah! Ah!” said Jackson.

  He looked like he was about to cum, but I thought it was too early.

  “Oh, no-no-no, not yet. Not yet,” I said, cooling him down.

  Carey strode back over and there was no other way to say: he basically unfurled his massive cock.

  “You ready for a taste of anaconda?” Carey asked.

  “Jesus, Carey!” joked Jackson. “Do you take pills are something? That thing’s not natural.”

  “I’m just gifted in many ways, Jackson,” assured Carey.

  I moved over to Carey. His giant penis filled my mouth with ease. I couldn’t really suck on it, it was so big. I had to just move my open mouth around on it.

  “Aw, that’s it, Lexi. That’s the way we do it!” said Carey satisfactorily. “Mmm! This girl has some talent! I know that!”

  I laughed at that one. We were all having such a great time. Now it was Kyle’s turn at my wet little pussy. He put on a condom, then teased me a bit with his cock, rubbing it against my little sensitive clit.

  “Ooo! Ooo!” I said. “That feels good! Keep doing that!”

  Jackson had now moved to my left and started fondling my breasts. I returned the favor and fondled his junk. We couldn’t let his hardness go to waste. I was determined to keep all my men happy.

  Kyle was keeping me happy now, thrusting in and out like a jackhammer. He pounded my pussy for what seemed to be forever. I started cumming on his cock. I lost control for a minute.

  “Oooo! Ooo! C-cumming!” I squeal. “Oh, yes! Gimme that cock! So much cock! Gimme all of it!”

  Was this how all the polyamorous groups felt when they had sex? How could this not be the norm? It was so wild, wet and wonderful! I couldn’t imagine anything else! These amazing toned athletes, their hot sweaty muscles pleasing every inch of me. I had never been so alive!