Alpha Ever After

by Casey Morgan

  My brain caught. I needed the love of my life. Did that mean one person? I didn’t love one of the boys better than the other. Did the spell expect only one man? I sighed and stuffed the parchment with the spell into my pocket. I would just have to have all of them up at Heart’s Lake. Hopefully that would satisfy the spell’s requirements.

  I ran downstairs and right into Tina who was coming up the stairs to find me. Grabbing my hand to keep from falling down the stairs, she let out a large “Ekk!” I pulled her to me.

  “Thanks, Gwendolyn. We already have customers downstairs and the cook’s not…” She stopped and regarded me with wide eyes. “Oh my God! Your pregnant! I can feel the change in your aura.”

  A big grin broke out on my face. “Yes! Yes! I know. I can’t believe it.” I turned her towards the bar and we both shuffled down the steps.

  “Last I remember you were dating those four guys,” she continued. “Which one did you decide to get serious with?”

  I felt my face go pale. How was she going to react to me being serious with four guys? “Um…Well…I…”

  “Which one are you going to marry?” She asked, impatiently.

  “I don’t know if I’m going to marry any of them, Tina. I haven’t been able to choose. I love all of them.” I looked away, not wanting to see the shocked expression on Tina’s face.

  “Oh!” she said. “So you don’t really know who the father is?”

  I cleared my throat. “I like to think that it’s all of them,” I explained sheepishly.

  She regarded me and raised an eyebrow. “And they are okay with that?”

  “They are okay with sharing me. I haven’t officially told them about the baby yet,” I admitted. “But I think they suspect. We are going to try to do the Seeding Spell tonight.”

  Tina’s face broke out into an expression of pure joy. Her eyes were wide and she grinned like a mad woman. “Oh my God, Gwendolyn! That would be so awesome. I would love to have my magic back. I haven’t been able to do a full spell in ages.” She grabbed me and pulled me into a big hug.

  Our mini celebration was interrupted by several patrons asking for menus. Tina and I hurried into action as the pub started to fill up.

  The day went by in a flash. I was so busy filling drink and food orders I could hardly think about anything else. The Harvest Festival was bringing in more people than I had ever seen before. Every table, booth and bar seat was filled and I could hardly get them clean before the next group was being seated.

  I was overjoyed. True, I didn’t really need the money anymore since my auction, but it still helped and it made me proud to see the old pub hopping. My grandmothers would be proud too.

  About 3pm, the phone behind the bar rang. Tina answered and then called me over. I told her to take a message, but she shook her head.

  “He says it’s Eric and it’s important,” she explained.

  I nodded and took the phone from her. “Eric, what’s up? Are you okay?”

  “I’m fine, Gwendolyn.” It sounded like he was smiling. “I have news. Good news. I gave all that information and recordings to a friend of mine at the FBI. Carl has a record for arson in several states. He and Maxine were arrested this morning. They are being charged with arson, intimidation and theft. They are never going to bother anyone ever again.”

  “Oh thank God,” I breathed. “Thank you, Eric! Thank you so much!”

  He chuckled. “Sure, babe. Try to relax as much as you can today. I’ll see you tonight.”

  I hung up feeling on top of the world. Sure, Carl and Maxine would have been kicked out of Love’s Hollow tonight, anyways, if I got the Seeding Spell to work, but now they wouldn’t bother any other small businesses. They deserved to go to jail.

  Chapter Thirty-Seven

  Gwendolyn

  Just as I felt like I could stand no more, my four guys walked into The Lucky Spell Pot. Of course, they would be here tonight. I smiled to myself. Thankful for their presence.

  And, like the first night we met, I would lock up with them. Except this time, we would leave, and I would go to the forest with them. Make love to them at Heart’s Lake and finally succeed in casting the Seeding Spell. My heart swelled and then started to break.

  Life was so, so unbearably sweet sometimes. Even if it didn’t always last. I was sure of that.

  After my most successful Harvest Festival in years, after hearing that both Maxine and Carl were charged with multiple counts of arson, intimidation and theft, I was ready to fulfill my destiny. I was ready to save Love’s Hollow, even if it caused me to lose the loves of my life.

  I put a gentle hand on my belly and searched my heart for the presence that I knew was my growing baby. My daughter. At least I would have her as a reminder of the men I loved. And that was more love that I ever had before.

  The guys immediately started to help out. It was late and patrons were slowly leaving the pub. Travis started to buss their tables and get the dishes into the kitchen. David took a position behind the bar, he rang up checks and ran credit cards. Alex cleaned and put away the liquor bottles behind the bar, and Eric helped people with their coats.

  Tina came bouncing up to me, eyeing the men. “My last table is gone, Gwendolyn. Okay if I skip out a little early. I hear the Harvest Festival party is still rocking on main street.” She gave me a wink, that let me know that she was really leaving so I could be alone with my men.

  I threw a dish towel at her grinning face. “Go on, Tina. I’ll see you tomorrow.”

  She grabbed her coat and scarf, grinning at me her whole way out the door.

  A few minutes later, we were alone. Eric locked up the pub. I took a seat in one of the wooden chairs and watched as my men continued working. Travis started on dishes. Eric grabbed a broom. David started counting the till. And Alex started whipping down the bar. They were all so sweet, and helpful.

  My breath caught and I had to fight to hold back tears. My baby would be without her fathers, but I had to do the spell. I couldn’t choose my love life over the wellbeing of the town. Could I?

  Eric came up to me worried. “Did you overextend yourself?” he asked, his eyes searching my face. “Should we go? Is it too much for you to have more people around?”

  I reached out and took his hand. “No, love,” I assured him, “I’m fine. I have news. Everyone gather round.”

  All the boys stopped what they were doing and wandered over. They took a seat in a booth, the same booth they were sitting in the night we met. It was bittersweet.

  I turned my chair to face them. “I have news. I’m pregnant.”

  “Oh my God!” Travis actually squealed, then looked embarrassed. The other boys laughed at him, but it wasn’t harsh. I could see the joy on all their faces.

  David took my hand and gave it a squeeze. “I'm glad. I know that you wanted this and we…” He gestured to all the boys. “We are excited to be fathers. We all talked about it and have decided to consider this child all of ours. No need to know who the biological father actually is.”

  “That’s how I feel about it!” I grinned at all of them.

  “So now that you are pregnant,” Alex leaned forward to look right in my eyes. “We have a spell to do, don’t we?”

  “Yeah,” Eric joined in. “How do we do the spell, Gwendolyn?”

  I looked over them all. Memorizing their loving faces. “We go on a hike.”

  ****

  Heart’s Lake was a fifteen-minute drive outside of downtown. The lake itself was not shaped like a heart at all. It was named for one of the Love’s Hollow’s earliest citizens: Jacob Heart, a werewolf who had saved numerous wolves, gathering them from all over the country and bringing them to our town. Jacob and my great great grandmother had been friends. Tonight, I wondered if they had been more than friends.

  The sky above us was a deep black-blue. Just a few stars visible. The great Harvest moon was hidden by clouds. I hoped it would clear up and lend its gaze to my efforts tonight.

  We
hiked to the lake proper in silence. Travis laughed occasionally. This was his kind of adventure. Eric was solemn and thoughtful. David made sure Alex didn’t wander off the path chasing after a fleeing rabbit or some other distraction.

  Finally, the lake stood before us. It’s cool waters as dark as the nights sky, reflections of the surrounding trees ringing its edges. It was beautiful. A wonderful spot for my last night with my men.

  “What now?” Alex asked.

  I started to undress. “I need to have each of you in the lake, one at a time. That will start the spell.”

  “Sex? For a spell?” Eric asked, scratching his chin.

  I nodded.

  “I’m going to like magic!” Travis exclaimed, pulling off his clothes quickly.

  Since he was the first undressed, I took his hand and lead him to the water. It was so cold, it took my breath away. I practically jumped into Travis’ strong arms.

  “Don’t worry, babe,” he whispered in my ear. “It will warm up as we move.”

  He walked into the water, until we were both wet and freezing. Then he started running his hands all over my cold body. Where his hands glided, my skin turned warm. He ran his hands over my stomach, down my thighs, and then settled on my breasts. My nipples were so cold and hard that his mouth felt like a furnace when he bent to suck them.

  Leaning back, I wrapped my body to his, bringing my legs up and wrapping them around his waist. He pushed me against the dirt bank that surrounded the lake.

  Chapter Thirty-Eight

  Travis

  The moment I sunk my long, perfectly-curved and thick cock into Gwendolyn’s pussy, it had been worth the wait. Breathtaking, to be honest with you. In a way I didn’t regret, even when I made softest, gentlest sound I think I’ve ever made fucking a woman. But it didn’t matter, because she wasn’t just any woman. She was the one. The one woman I decided it was okay to drop my guard around.

  And, oh my God, did she make it worth it! The moan she gave me in return was priceless. Unforgettable. I would never forget the sound of that, not even when I was ninety years old, and I had forgotten most things.

  Sinking my cock deeper into her sweetness, I wrapped my hands around hers. They were currently clutching the bank of the pond I had pushed her to, looking out over Love’s Hollow in all of its Harvest finery. I pressed my lip to her exposed neck, beginning to pump her pussy soft and fast.

  As I moved inside her, I felt her tremble, shiver, yet she was warm at the same time, all around my dick. I moaned again, moving a little faster and harder than before. Lingering as I pressed further in, and as I pulled out. As I raked my smoothness along ridges, sparking them to more and more life. More and more readiness. On both ends. On mine and on hers.

  While my shaft felt more and more held by a textured, silky pillow made just for my manhood, I knew she felt more and more stimulated. More and more stirred up. I knew this by the way her insides rippled. The way they warmed from bath-water temperature to volcano. To molten-lava status. The way she’d begun to quake with me filling her, and not just from the cold air that surrounded us.

  From the little snowflakes who were making their way down to the ground. A soft dance of snow around us.

  Eric couldn’t stop fretting over as her bare breasts as he watched me push her further and further into the bank, massaging her tits more and more. As he did so, I saw each chubby, nubby raspberry nipple getting harder. Stiffer. Pokier with each passing second.

  Each thrust in and out pushed her deeper into this little section of the bank, and I heard how much joy it was beginning to bring her. How much surprise.

  “Oh, Travis!” she said. “It’s so hot! And so cold!” She panted wildly. Hungrily, even as I fed her more of me. Stuffed her full of every inch, and swiveled around inside. “I don’t know which I like more… I don’t know which feels better! They all feel so… So amazing!”

  Here, she grunted. It was a cute, soft grunt compared to the ones I made sometimes, but it let me know I was really pushing all of her buttons. Getting fully and completely inside her. Indeed, I could feel her cervix opening just kissing the edge of my cock head as I press forward.

  “You don’t have to like one more than the other,” I said, staring at Eric, who had started fisting his own cock, despite the snowfall beginning to happen around us. “You already chose to love all of us. All of our thick, big cocks that we get to fuck you silly with.” As I said all this, I pounded her in earnest. I plundered her depths hard and fast, willing her to come on my length, spill her juices on my shaft, at the same time I spilled my seed in her.

  Speaking to her this way, reminding her of what a greedy and satisfied girl she was about to be, getting stuffed with not one cock, but four, she clenched around me. Rippled and rolled around me under the beginnings of an orgasm. The beginnings of which rocketed through her as I plunged my fingers into the front of her. Past the water that surrounded her, and straight to her eager clit. Fingering that as fast and hard as I could while I continued to fill her. Jam her full and fast of me, enjoying the feel of water around us. The slap of our wet, cool skin against one another.

  Suddenly, my cock was huge and full of cum ready to blow in her. I gargled and groaned against it, trying to hold it back. I hadn’t planned to go just shy of her coming, but the way she was moaning, wiggling back and forth on my cock frenetically, that was enough to finish me.

  Pull me closer and closer to a fiery, white-hot release. A release that was bubbling and frothing through my shaft and toward the tip with relentless, agonizing speed.

  I grit my teeth, buckled down with the last bit of self-control I had, and pounded out a frenetic rhythm on her clit with my hand. Stroked and pinched it, until she buckled. Thrusting and shuttering, with quaking gasps. Both from her pussy and her mouth.

  It was then that I let myself go. Pump her full of everything I had ever wanted to bury deep inside of her, solidify my place as one of her four beloveds. A fact I relished almost as much as the feeling of hot, swelling liquid splashing around in her. Coating her insights in delightful, thick streams. I pulled my hand and cock away from her, kissing her bitterly-cold shoulders.

  I nodded to Eric, who was still working his shaft. Squeezing and pumping his head, fighting with his near-orgasm, as well as the cold air and tiny sprinkling of snowflakes.

  He nodded back, wading into the water and taking my place in front of Gwendolyn, while I pulled myself towards the bank and the sand beyond it. I flopped out of the water and looked up at the falling snow. It all looked so magical. I wasn’t sure if the Seeding Spell was done yet or if I really even believed it would happen.

  Chapter Thirty-Nine

  Eric

  The first thing I did when I slid up to Gwendolyn to take Travis’s place, was to check in with her. Make sure she wasn’t too cold, or wanted to quit, rather than take me directly inside her. I leaned into her, put my hand around her barely pregnant belly, and kissed her shoulders. Her neck, hoping to warm them through.

  “Are you too cold, darling?” I asked.

  Even as I asked her this, my cock betrayed me. Expressed an interest in fucking her right here, right now. Instinctually, my manhood wanted to conquer his rival. To overwrite the first one to taste of her tonight, but I was also conscious of how exposed she was. How cold it really was outside, since I had been fighting with that myself, while watching Travis take her.

  “I need you here, now,” she answered, her dark eyes starting to glow with an unearthly light. She rubbed her lower lips along my shaft. Her clit on the top of my head, as it explored her opening. “I think I need to have all of you to complete the spell. Here now.”

  The emphasis she put on that word made my cock shiver and my balls squeeze. Though I wished I could taste of her for a full hour, I knew my cock wasn’t going to last that long. Already, even with just rubbing along her folds, and testing the warmth and wetness of her hole the tiniest bit, I knew I was done for. I knew I was as good as gone the moment I put my
self inside of her.

  “I’ll make this quick but pleasurable, my darling,” I whispered, righting my cock in front of her opening, holding it in place as I slipped forward.

  My cock slipped inside her pussy. Dove inside her folds, feeling like he had just stepped into his own personal Jacuzzi. His own world full of warmth and texture. I murmured something in amazement. Didn’t have any clue what it was, and I didn’t care. Once inside of her, I wanted nothing more than to rub myself on her texture. Get off on the inner mosaic of her pussy walls, which is exactly what I proceeded to do.

  Cradling her belly as much is I could, and holding her exposed bits as close to me as possible, trying to keep them warm, I went all out on fucking her. I move faster inside her, but not harder.

  As I moved, I couldn’t help but imagine how much fuller and warmer she was going to feel when I exploded in a deep, welcoming warmth. When I sealed her with my own seed, and gave Travis a run for his money. These thoughts only made me sway in and out of her more and more, and my already-hard and ready cock swell. Fatten in her swirling insides.

  But it was when she leaned into me, when she squatted down on my length, and began pumping herself back and forth on it, holding onto the lakes’ bank, and telling me that she was going to milk me dry for all the times I didn’t get as much fun as the rest of them, that I lost it. That I picked her up in her legs, and held her aloft in the gathering snow storm, while I plunged deeply inside her.

  The moment my head slammed against the tight ring signaling the end of her pussy, and the beginning of her womb and cervix, I unleashed my bulk. My stream of seed and love, kissing her neck as I did.

  She clenched down on me at that moment as well, moaning and whimpering. As my cum filled her, I heard and felt her squeeze and come as well.