The Good Friday Murder

by Lee Harris

  A Fawcett Book

  Published by The Ballantine Publishing Group

  Copyright © 1992 by Lee Harris

  All rights reserved under International and Pan-American Copyright Conventions. Published in the United States by The Ballantine Publishing Group, a division of Random House, Inc., New York, and simultaneously in Canada by Random House of Canada Limited, Toronto.

  Fawcett is a registered trademark and the Fawcett colophon is a trademark of Random House, Inc.

  www.ballantinebooks.com

  Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 91-93154

  eBook ISBN 9781101968369

  ISBN 9780449147627

  v4.1

  a

  CONTENTS

  Cover

  Title Page

  Copyright

  Epigraph

  Chapter 1

  Chapter 2

  Chapter 3

  Chapter 4

  Chapter 5

  Chapter 6

  Chapter 7

  Chapter 8

  Chapter 9

  Chapter 10

  Chapter 11

  Chapter 12

  Chapter 13

  Chapter 14

  Chapter 15

  Chapter 16

  Chapter 17

  Chapter 18

  Chapter 19

  Chapter 20

  Chapter 21

  Chapter 22

  Chapter 23

  Chapter 24

  Chapter 25

  Chapter 26

  Chapter 27

  Chapter 28

  Chapter 29

  Chapter 30

  Chapter 31

  Chapter 32

  Dedication

  By Lee Harris

  A man’s real possession is his memory. In nothing else is he rich, in nothing else is he poor.

  ALEXANDER SMITH

  The author wishes to thank

  Ana M. Soler and James L. V. Wegman,

  without whom this book could not have been written.

  1

  I still wake up at five in the morning.

  It’s hard to break habits practiced for fifteen years, especially when those fifteen years are half your life. Five o’clock comes and my mind starts to work, setting sleep aside. It had been three weeks since I left the convent, three weeks since I established myself in Aunt Meg’s house—which would be mine as soon as the will was probated—but 5:00 A.M. still worked its powers on me.

  I turned over, looked at the clock, and closed my eyes, hoping sleep would work its own magic, but it failed again. It was nearly the first day of summer and the sun had risen at its earliest. After fifteen fruitless minutes of trying to sleep, I got out of bed and went to the bathroom, automatically opening the medicine cabinet as I entered so that I would not see myself in the mirror. During the years that I had visited Aunt Meg once each month, she had dutifully taped a carefully cut cardboard cover over the mirror before my arrival. But the prohibition, like the early awakening for morning prayers which I no longer said, still maintained its hold on me. I had not looked at my reflection since the day I left St. Stephen’s, although nothing but custom prevented me from doing so. Everything in its own time, I told myself.

  My morning washing completed, I pulled the medicine chest shut as I left the bathroom and returned to my bedroom. On my arrival three weeks earlier, I had chosen to sleep in the room Aunt Meg had set aside for me rather than the one she had shared with Uncle Will for so many years and then occupied alone after his death. The master bedroom was considerably larger than the one I had chosen, but I knew why I was not yet ready to enter it. It was not the idea that it had been hers and she was only three months gone. Rather it was the large mirror over the dresser in which I had once glimpsed myself years ago and, shamefully at that time, lingered to see my face and figure, an infraction I had confessed to a priest upon my return to St. Stephen’s.

  Now I opened the closet in my old room and saw again the yellow silk dress hanging on the inside of the door, the hanger hooked over the top of the door. I had gone on a necessary buying spree when I left the convent, purchasing skirts, blouses, dresses, and pants, and had picked the yellow dress because I was enchanted with its daffodil color and fluid texture. But I had not yet been able to bring myself to wear it.

  “Too warm for silk,” I said aloud, and pulled out Old Faithful, a pair of khaki slacks and a short-sleeved white camp shirt, both of which had been washed and ironed half a dozen times since their purchase. A pair of crew socks and sneakers finished my outfit and I was ready for my morning outing.

  —

  I’m not an exercise fiend or a health nut, but I enjoy a brisk walk or jog in the early morning. It makes a nice substitute for morning prayers and builds an appetite, which seems sensible since I don’t wake up hungry. Halfway down the block I ran into a woman about my age who was walking off a pleasing plumpness.

  “Good morning,” I called, measuring my pace to hers.

  “Hi. Are you the new neighbor?”

  “I guess I am.” I held out my right hand without breaking stride. “Christine Bennett. Call me Chris.”

  She grasped my hand in a firm handshake. I like that. “I’m Melanie Gross. Mel. We live at 507.”

  We ran in tandem for a minute or so, turning right at the corner.

  “You aren’t Margaret’s niece, by any chance, are you? The nun who always came to visit?”

  “I am, but I’m not a nun anymore.”

  “I see.”

  She was probably being tactful, asking no questions, ruffling no feelings.

  “There’s no secret about why I left,” I volunteered. “I made the decision nearly a year ago and my permission came through in April. I stayed on to finish the semester. I taught English at the college.”

  “Really?” Mel smiled broadly, almost with relief. “I had no idea. Margaret never mentioned…A teacher. Will you be staying on in the house?”

  “I hope to. I’m very fond of the house, and it’s mine now.”

  “Well, that’s really nice. Are you coming to the meeting tonight?”

  “What meeting?”

  “The last council meeting of the year. They’re taking the vote, you know. Or maybe you don’t know. Whether to let that group house into town. You ought to be there. It’ll probably be one of those knock-down-drag-out affairs, till the wee hours, I expect. Would you like to drive over with Hal and me?”

  “Thanks, but I wilt at night. If I decide to go, I’ll take my own car so I can leave before the weest of hours.”

  We turned another corner and I could see Pine Brook Road just ahead. “I’m going back,” I said, moving away from her. “See you later.”

  “ ’Bye, Chris. I have to give it fifteen minutes more.”

  Fifteen minutes later I was just setting out my cholesterol-laden breakfast of eggs, buttered toast, a couple of sausage links. I ate it all with relish.

  —

  It was five weeks to the day since I had last visited my cousin Gene. Gene was the reason for my monthly visits to Aunt Meg, the reason she kept a room for me all those years. On the third Monday of every month I would drive from St. Stephen’s to Oakwood, have dinner with Aunt Meg, sleep in my room, and visit Gene the next day. My teaching schedule was arranged to accommodate the monthly trips, and I had been granted permission to own a car so that I could make the trips without using the trains, thereby saving myself hours of travel time. Oakwood was nowhere near the train that came down along the Hudson.

  Gene was one year older than I, born when Aunt Meg and Uncle Will had been married almost fifteen years, Aunt Meg on the eve of her fortieth birthday. He had been born retarded, a sweet, loving, handsome boy who would never grow up to be the d
octor or lawyer or schoolteacher everyone else’s son would become. At an early age I had realized that Gene wasn’t like the other children I knew, and my mother had explained it to me allegorically. For Aunt Meg and Uncle Will, Gene had not been an allegory. As much as they loved him, he had been a constant trial. He could never be left alone. After a certain age, he could not even be left with an ordinary baby-sitter. When Uncle Will died nearly ten years ago, Aunt Meg could no longer cope. Tearfully she put Gene in Greenwillow, an institutional home some ten miles from Oakwood. But the good news was that Gene loved it.

  I drove over after lunch. I had changed into a plaid shirtdress and exchanged the morning’s sneakers for sandals. The yellow silk had beckoned to me when I opened the closet door, but I had declined once again. I didn’t need silk to visit my cousin Gene.

  Greenwillow was housed in a wing of an old hospital which had been spiffed up some years ago for the occupants and now sorely needed a respiffing. I parked the car in the area reserved for visitors and walked to the door. As I approached, I had an unexpected attack of something like anxiety. I had never walked through that door without my habit on, never been addressed by my birth name by the staff. Probably, I thought, that’s why I had put off this first post-convent visit. There had been no reason to wait for today to see Gene. In fact, now that Aunt Meg was gone, I intended to visit him frequently, as she had done.

  I rang the doorbell and waited for someone to open the heavy door. It was Clarice, one of the aides, who came.

  “Hi,” I said. “I’m here to see my cousin, Gene Wirth.”

  She looked at me oddly and I felt a little guilty. “He’s up in his room. Do you know where it is?”

  “Sure. Thank you.” I escaped her puzzled gaze as I walked to the stairs.

  The door to Gene’s room was open, and I stood in the doorway and watched him for a moment. He was sitting at the table where he kept his collection of tiny cars. He had been collecting them for as long as I could remember, and in my bag I had a new one for him, as I usually did when I visited. He moved them in a careful, deliberate way, lining them up, then selecting two to travel side by side down an imaginary road.

  “Hi, Gene,” I said, stepping into the room.

  He looked up, momentarily startled, looked at me piercingly, then broke into a smile. “Kix,” he said, and I felt tears come to my eyes.

  Someone, probably my mother, had tried, when we were very young, to get Gene to say “Chris.” He hadn’t been able to wrap his tongue around the sounds and it had come out “Kix,” a name that had remained forever my nickname to my most intimate friends. When I had first begun visiting him dressed in my habit, Gene had been terribly confused. He could not associate the habit-clad woman with his cousin. Once I had even pulled off my veil to show him who I was, but he remained unconvinced. Sometimes he would ask where Kix was, and it was clear to me that it was quite unclear to him where indeed I was.

  “Kix is here,” Gene said. He stood up, his face beaming.

  “I sure am.” I went over to get my hug.

  “Where’s Mama?”

  “Mama’s gone to heaven, Gene. Remember we talked about that last time I was here?”

  “Don’t remember.”

  But he did remember; he just didn’t want it to be so. We sat down, he on his chair next to the car table, I in the easy chair.

  “I have something for you.”

  “A car?” He brightened up again.

  “A very special car.” I dug it out of my bag and handed it to him.

  He looked at it and touched it and played with it. Then we settled back to have our visit.

  —

  An hour later, Gene accompanied me downstairs. I knew many of the residents by name and I stopped to say hello to some. Eventually they would get used to me, as Gene would. At the bottom of the stairs I ran into the custodian, sweeping up with his broom and pan.

  “Hello, Alex,” I said, pausing.

  He looked at me, bringing me into focus with narrowed eyes. I was about to tell him who I was when he said, “You look like that: Sister Edward used to come here.”

  “I was Sister Edward. I’ve left the order, Alex. I’m Christine Bennett now.”

  He pursed his lips and nodded. “You sure look like Sister Edward.”

  “I’m—”

  He interrupted. “You Gene’s cousin, too?”

  “Yes, I’m Gene’s cousin.”

  “You got a lotta nice cousins, Gene,” Alex said, but Gene wasn’t paying attention.

  “I’ll be visiting regularly from now on,” I told Alex. “I’m sure I’ll see you around.”

  “You see our famous murderer?” Alex asked, cackling.

  I wondered if I had misunderstood. “Your famous what?”

  “The poor old fella who’s causing all the trouble. Over there.” He indicated an easy chair near the fireplace.

  A gray-haired man sat rocking softly, his eyes somewhere on the ground.

  “ ’Bye, Kix,” Gene said. He had spotted a small group and now made his way toward them.

  “ ’Bye,” I called after him. I turned back to Alex. “You say that old man over there—”

  “Killed his mother. Stabbed the life out of her.” He shrugged. “That’s what they say. I don’t believe a word of it. He’s just a nice old gentleman, sits by himself, don’t bother no one.”

  “He looks harmless enough.” I was intrigued. “What’s his name?”

  “James. Don’t bother trying to talk to him. He won’t answer. Just ask you where his brother is.”

  “Where is his brother?”

  “I dunno.”

  “I’ll see you next time, Alex.”

  I walked away to where I could stand and watch James. He had an extraordinary head of white hair, which was bent and moved slightly as he rocked himself. I thought I saw his lips moving, but I could hear nothing.

  I took a wooden chair and pulled it over to where James sat. “Hello, James,” I said.

  If he heard me, he kept it to himself. The rhythm of his rocking never changed.

  “My name is Chris,” I said. “My cousin Gene lives here. I visit him.”

  The man rocked. Now I was certain his lips were moving, like a nun’s in silent prayer.

  “Have you lived here long?” I asked. “I don’t remember seeing you before.”

  “Do you know where my brother is?” he asked, speaking very quickly, not moving his head.

  “No, I don’t. What’s your brother’s name?”

  More rocking.

  “If you tell me his name, maybe I can find him.”

  The rocking stopped, but nothing else changed.

  “I’ll say hello to you the next time I come to see my cousin Gene,” I said. “Okay?” I stood and picked up my handbag.

  James made a sound and I stopped. “Did you say something?”

  “Robert.” He spoke without moving, his eyes still fixed on something on the floor.

  “Is Robert your brother’s name?”

  “Robert,” he repeated.

  “Thank you, James. I’ll see if I can find him.”

  2

  I had not quite reached the front door when a woman’s voice called, “Sister Edward.”

  I turned to find the director of Greenwillow standing before me. “Mrs. McAlpin.” I held out my hand.

  “It is Sister Edward, isn’t it?” she asked hesitantly, shaking hands.

  “It’s Christine Bennett. I left my order at the beginning of the month.”

  “I see. I wonder if you’d step into my office for a moment.”

  I followed her into her attractive, comfortable office and took a chair. She sat behind her desk, a handsome woman with an air of toughness about her.

  “I understand you’re taking over Gene’s guardianship,” she said.

  “I am.”

  “Allow me to say that I’m delighted. He couldn’t have a more concerned guardian than you.” She smiled, and I wondered what she had inv
ited me in for. Now that I was to be my cousin’s guardian, I would be told when he misbehaved, would be consulted on changes in therapy. “The attorney said I could reach you at Mrs. Wirth’s house in Oakwood.”

  “My aunt left me the house. I’ll be living there.”

  “You’re the only person from Oakwood with a connection to Greenwillow.”

  I had no idea why that fact might be worthy of mention, so I smiled foolishly and waited.

  “Surely you know about our plans?” Mrs. McAlpin said.

  “What plans?”

  “Our plans to move Greenwillow to Oakwood. There’s a wonderful old house we hope to renovate for our special needs.”

  I was flabbergasted. Aunt Meg had taken several buses in each direction for all those years to visit Gene, and now Gene was coming home to Oakwood. “That’s wonderful,” I said. “Gene’ll be a neighbor.”

  “Only if the Oakwood Council approves us.”

  “Why wouldn’t they? You’re quiet, you don’t play loud music, you don’t have all-night parties. You won’t even use the schools.”

  Mrs. McAlpin smiled patiently. “I see being cloistered has kept you out of touch with some of society’s modern battlegrounds. No one wants a group like Greenwillow next door or down the block. People imagine our residents are potentially violent, and no amount of medical testimony can convince them otherwise. In our case, there’s a special aspect to their objection.”

  “What’s that?”

  “We have a new resident here, James Talley, who has been unfairly tarnished with the blame for a violent crime.”

  “I was just speaking to James before I ran into you.”

  “Speaking to him?” She sounded mildly disbelieving.

  “A word or two. What’s he supposed to have done?”

  “Killed his mother.”

  “How long has he been here?”

  “Nearly three months. He was incarcerated in a high-security institution for nearly forty years. It took that long to bring about a determination that he was no longer dangerous. If he ever was.”

  “He told me he had a brother.”

  “A twin brother, Robert. They’re both what’s called ‘idiot savants,’ although James is no longer a savant. They had wonderful abilities at one time, but James lost his long ago.”