Breaking Her Innocence

by Madison Faye

  “Get up here, beautiful,” Roman purred, his hands grabbing my ass tight.

  My hands went to their shafts again, stroking as I felt two breaths blow across my bare, exposed backside. I whimpered when I felt one man’s lips on my thigh, the other kissing down the small of my back. My eyes shut tight as I felt a tongue brush across my inner thigh. It centered, and I cried out as the tongue dragged wetly though my trembling pussy lips. I choked out a gasp, moaning and stroking them both as one of their tongues pressed deep inside of me. It dragged down to my clit, and I almost shrieked before I suddenly and wantonly leaned forward and inhaled one of their cocks, muffling my moans.

  The lips on my back moved lower, across one ass cheek and then the other, before I felt hands grip me tight and pull me wide. I blushed, knowing they could see everything, and feeling so exposed and open for them. The lips moved closer, and closer, and my back arched as I felt hot breath there, across my most private place.

  “Wait, what—”

  “Shh, baby,” Roman’s deep baritone husked.

  “Not there,” I whimpered.

  His tongue suddenly flicked out, and I cried out as it swirled over my tight little asshole. He pulled away, leaving me gasping for more, my body aching for his tongue there again.

  “Does it feel bad?”

  I panted. “No— no.”

  “Then relax.”

  The tongue pressed hotly to my ass again, and it felt incredible. It felt like lightning sizzling through me — like white light oozing through my whole body. I didn’t care right then how dirty and how filthy it was, I just knew having both of their tongues on me at the same time felt divine.

  I moved back to the cocks in front of me, bobbing my head on one and then the other. Slowly, I learned what made them moan louder — what made their balls draw up tight and what made their hips pump against my lips and tongue.

  The two of them moved faster, tongues swirling over my clit, my ass, my pussy lips. Fingers slid inside my slit, curling deep inside and making my head spin as they stroked some magical place inside. A second finger began to tease my ass as the tongue swirled over it, and my whole world started to crumble.

  The two cowboys licked me harder, and faster, and more insistently, and I could feel my whole body start to melt. Tongues swirled over my most private places, hands slid over my body, teasing my nipples, gripping my ass, and tightening in my hair as I sucked them as hard as I could. My eyes squeezed shut as the pressure started to build past the point of being contained.

  Lips fastened around my clit as a tongue batted across it. The other one pushed hot against my quivering ass, and the whole thing exploded.

  I screamed into the sheets, my whole body shattering and writhing as the two men held me fast and made me come like I’d never come before — like I’d never even imagined I could come. They licked me right through my orgasm, tonguing me right into a second as I clutched the sheets in my fists and arched my ass back towards them.

  Slowly, they pulled away with lingering kisses on my skin. I was panting as they pulled me around, sandwiching me between both of their hard, chiseled, perfect bodies. I whimpered as I felt their hard cocks press into me, the two of them stroking themselves against my skin. Hands pulled one of my legs up, and I suddenly froze as I felt the head of Colt’s cock begin to tease over the lips of my pussy.

  He started to push forward, when my hand flew to his chest.

  “Wait, I—”

  I panted.

  “I’ve— uh, I’ve never…”

  I trailed off, my cheeks going red. God, how was I even going to tell them this? How was I going to tell them that this was my first time, and that I’d probably be awful, and that whatever idea they had in their heads of me being this little sex kitten was completely wrong?

  Roman’s lips brushed my ear. “Never been with two guys?”

  I shook my head, and he chuckled darkly.

  “Just relax and enjoy baby.”

  His hands slid down to my ass, cupping me tightly as he ran his cock up and down the crack of my ass. Colt did the same with my opening, his head slipping up and down my lips and making my head spin.

  “No, wait, I mean—”

  I bit my lip, and Colt stopped, his brow furrowing.

  “What’s wrong?”

  I took a deep, shaky breath and closed my eyes. “I’ve never been with one guy before.”

  I felt them freeze. “Wait, what do you— oh holy shit.”

  I felt the two of them tighten their grips on me.

  Shit.

  They started to pull away, and I felt my whole face crumble.

  “No, please—”

  “You’re a virgin?” I opened my eyes at the sincerity in Colt’s voice, and I nodded.

  “Shit,” he husked.

  “I’m sorry! I didn’t want to tell you because I didn’t want you to be disappointed when I’m not that good—”

  “Shh, hey, angel,” Roman purred into my ear, pulling me close. He turned my head to the side and kissed me, and I swallowed thickly as I felt Colt move in close again as well.

  “It’s not that baby, it’s Jeb. If he knew, you’d be sold in a second, for triple the price.”

  “I want you to,” I whispered, feeling it with every single bit of my body.

  “We can’t, baby,” Colt said, his voice tight and his eyes blazing into mine. I could feel his cock rock hard against my belly.

  “Please.”

  “We can’t take that,” Roman groaned into my ear. “That’s a gift we can’t accept.”

  “I want you to,” I gasped, feeling their hands moving over my skin.

  “Why us?”

  “You— you feel right. You feel like I’ve known you forever, and you make me feel safe. And I want this so bad.” I bit my lip as I looked into Colt’s eyes and kissed him, before turning and pulling Roman into my lips as well.

  “Please, before Jeb finds out and sells me, just let me feel this. I want you two to show me the first time, not some rich old guy.” I looked at each of them again, feeling my body pulse for them, and feeling their hands holding me tighter.

  “I want you both to take it.”

  They groaned, moving tighter against me. Cocks throbbed against my skin, and I gasped as I felt a finger trace over the soaking wet lips of my pussy.

  “Shit, Johanna,” Colt groaned, eyes on fire as he looked into mine.

  “Please,” I whispered, gasping as I felt them both start to stroke themselves, their pulsing hard, gorgeous cocks hot against my skin.

  “Lay back, angel,” Roman whispered into my ear. “Lay back and let us show you.”

  12

  Roman

  A virgin.

  This sweet young thing — this sexy, gorgeous, perfect girl was a fucking virgin.

  Untouched.

  Innocent.

  Ours.

  She moaned when I leaned down to kiss her, arching her back and letting her fingers trail up my arms. I slid my hand into her hair, tangling my fingers in it and pulling tight as I crushed my lips to hers. My cock throbbed, my blood pounded like a fucking diesel engine in my ears. Everything I was in that moment was centered on claiming her.

  But, not just fucking her. I wanted this to be her everything. I wanted to make this so fucking good for her that she’d never forget it. I wanted to drive my cock so deep, and make her come so perfectly, and scream my name so loud that nothing would ever touch how high she’d place this moment.

  I pulled away as Colt dove in, growling as he kissed her fiercely. I slid down and brought my mouth to her sweet untouched pussy, tasting her one last time before we claimed that cherry forever.

  I tongued her until she was gasping, before I pulled up, kissing my way up her belly. Colt pulled away from her and nodded at me.

  “You.”

  We both wanted her, and we’d both have her. But only one of us could be “first.”

  Part of me wanted to argue with him. Part of me wanted to hav
e this big back and forth about which of us would get her first, but that was fucking tasteless at a time like this. Arguing over her about which one of us went first, like she was some piece of meat, was no way to start this.

  So I just nodded. If my best friend and my blood brother wanted me to go first, so be it.

  I turned to look her in the eye as I slid up her body. “That okay with you, angel?”

  She nodded, her eyes blazing into mine, hooded with lust as she sucked on her bottom lip.

  “I’m going to go slow.”

  “Don’t make it different, just—” She chewed on her lip. “Just do what you’d do for anyone.”

  I shook my head. “Except you aren’t just anyone, beautiful.”

  Her brow went up.

  “You’re a whole lot fucking more than that.”

  She smiled as I moved between her legs. I took her hand and brought it down between us, letting her fingers slide over her slippery lips.

  “Feel how wet you are, baby,” I growled, dragging the head of my cock up and down her folds. “Now spread those lips for me.”

  She moaned, her soft, lithe fingers parting her delicate folds. I glanced down and met her eye as I eased my cock forward, right against that sweet virgin cunt.

  “You sure you want this?”

  “I’ve never wanted anything more than this,” she gasped out, her fingers rubbing her own clit as her chest rose and fell with her breath. “Please, do it.”

  And who was I to deny a lady?

  I groaned as I eased in, letting my head slide its way into her impossibly tight pussy. Johanna gasped loudly, her eyes going wide and her mouth making this sexy fucking “O” shape as I inched inside.

  “Oh God,” she moaned, her hands clawing at my biceps and her eyes suddenly dropping to glue themselves on where we joined. Her fingers held her pussy lips open as I rocked forward, pushing another few inches inside.

  Holy fuck.

  She was the tightest thing I could have ever imagined, her small body gripping my fat cock like a velvet glove as I slowly fed her every damn inch. Her moans got higher and higher, and sweeter and sweeter, until finally, I was all the way inside. I could feel my heavy balls resting against her lips as I looked down and met her gaze.

  “Now, I’m going to fuck you like you deserve to be fucked, angel.”

  I slid out until just the head was resting inside those lips, before I pushed forward again. Johanna cried out, her back arching and pushing her perfect tits skyward as I buried every inch of my big dick inside her.

  Colt was stroking himself to the side of her, watching as I started to slide in and out of her. He reached forward, cupping her breasts with his other hand and teasing her nipples. He slid his hand higher, and she moaned as he slipped two inside her mouth. Her soft, pouty lips closed around them, and goddamn if I didn’t almost come right there watching her suck his fingers so eagerly, her eyes closing in ecstasy.

  Colt moved forward, stroking his cock and kneeling next to her head. She turned, and when her eyes opened, she fucking moaned at the sight of my buddy stroking his cock.

  She wet her lips, and that’s the only invitation he needed. He pushed forward, letting her lips close over his head as he groaned and slid his hand into her hair. Johanna whimpered as he pulled her onto him, her small mouth stretching around his thick girth while I filled her to the brim on every damn stroke.

  We started to fill her like that from both ends, all three of us slowly moving faster and faster, until I was grabbing her hips with both hands and slamming my cock into her. She was so fucking tight, that hot little pussy gripping me with every damn stroke. But it seemed the harder I drove in, the more she loved it and the wilder she got. She was bobbing her mouth up and down on Colt like a girl possessed, one hand stroking his shaft and the other flicking back and forth on her little clit as I fucked her.

  She was whimpering and moaning louder and louder, her whole body flushed and her back arching to meet my every stroke. I knew I wasn’t going to last much longer — not with how insanely tight she was, and how much she was loving this. Watching her slurp and slobber all over Colt’s cock, her little hand stroking him faster and faster, only got me going even more. I gritted my teeth as I pounded into her, driving deep and hard on every stroke, until I knew I was out of time.

  I reached down and started strumming her clit along with her, and she went off like a rocket.

  Johanna screamed around Colt’s cock in her mouth as she came, her entire body jolting off the damn bed like she’d been struck by lightning. Her already impossibly tight little pussy clenched down on me, and I saw white light as I lost it completely.

  I groaned as I buried myself to the hilt inside her and just erupted. I roared as I pumped shot after shot of my cum deep inside her small body. She just kept moaning and coming, and it felt like she was milking me for all I was worth deep inside of her until I had nothing left to give.

  Slowly, we came to a stop. I pulled out, leaving a leaky trail across her thigh, and moved up to cradle her against me. She panted, sucking in air as I held her against me, letting both our pulses find a more normal pace.

  “Oh my God,” she moaned quietly. “That was so…” She giggled. “Holy shit.”

  I chuckled as I pulled her little body tight and kissed her. She moaned quietly into my mouth, her hand stroking my stubbled cheek as she pulled away.

  “Thank you,” she whispered.

  But then she squirmed in my arms, twisting to face Colt with a devilish look on her face.

  “I think I want more.”

  I belted out a laugh as Colt grinned. “Well shit, girl.”

  “Please?”

  Colt chuckled, pulling her against him. “Don’t have to ask me twice, baby.”

  He rolled over onto his back, and she squealed as he pulled her astride his hips. “How about we try this.”

  She gasped as he eased his throbbing cock against her freshly fucked pussy.

  “Just like that, baby,” he purred, letting her sink down just a little on it. Johanna’s eyes went wide, her mouth opening slowly as his hand went to her hips. He pulled her down, and slowly, every damn inch of his cock slipped inside.

  “You’re a good farm girl, right?”

  She bit her lip and grinned down at him. “You wondering if I know how to ride a horse?”

  Colt chuckled, but then groaned as she smiled coyly and rolled her hips. “I want to ride you now.”

  She dropped her hands to his chest and rose up, letting his head nestle just inside her little pussy before she rocked back down, swallowing every inch of him. Colt groaned, and she cried out, gasping as his girth filled her up.

  And then she damn well rode him. I growled, my cock immediately coming back to full mast as this cute little angel started to bounce up and down on my friend’s lap. His hands grabbed her tight ass, guiding her up and down, his balls slapping her ass on every thrust, her moans filling the room.

  I started to stroke myself as I reached up to play with her tits, teasing her nipples and making them harden into little suckable points. She was going crazy, whimpering and panting and bouncing up and down on Colt like she was born to ride his cock.

  I had to have more.

  I stood, fisting my cock as I moved towards her and slid my hand into her hair. I took a fistful of it, the beast roaring up inside of me as I pulled it tight and twisted her head around to my cock.

  She moaned.

  Fuck, I loved that she liked it rough like this.

  “Suck my cock, baby,” I groaned, pulling her to my throbbing dick.

  “Yes, please,” she whimpered as she opened her lips, leaned forward, and swallowed my cock.

  “Just like that, angel,” I hissed, throwing my head back and groaning as her tongue swirled over my head. I looked back at her.

  “Can you taste your pussy on that cock, angel?”

  She moaned, her brow crumbling and her tongue moving faster as she bounced up and down on Colt.
>
  “Yes,” she gasped, pulling away from me for a second.

  “You like how that tastes?”

  She cried out, and her only response was to hungrily suck me back into her mouth.

  I reached down between her and Colt and strummed her clit, feeling her juices coat my finger. I bought my hand back up, feeling the fire roaring inside as I pushed it against her mouth, sliding it right in beside my cock.

  Johanna moaned like a demon girl, slurping loudly on my cock and hungrily tonguing my finger clean.

  We’d created a monster, and this sexy as sin, perfect little monster was going to be the sweet death of me.

  Colt’s hands gripped her hips, moving her, rocking her, bouncing her up and down every single inch of his cock as she started to crumble and moan. She suddenly pulled away from me, gasping, her fingers digging into Colt’s chest.

  “Oh God, I’m going to— you’re going to make me—”

  “Come for us, angel,” I groaned, her hand coming up to pump my cock. “Make that sweet little pussy come for us.”

  She screamed, the orgasm exploding through her as she slammed down on Colt’s lap and shattered. He groaned as he grabbed her ass and ground deep inside of her, pumping and filling her with every drop of his own cum.

  It was all I could take.

  My hand tightened in her hair, pulling her down on my cock. She opened those sweet lips, still writhing in her orgasm as she hungrily swallowed me in just as I exploded. I’d wanted to warn her — hell, I was pretty sure it wasn’t just fucking she’d never done before, but I was out of time. I groaned as the cum jetted into her hungry mouth, half expecting her to freak, or spit, or whatever.

  She moaned and eagerly swallowed every damn drop, sucking hungrily on my cock for more long after I was spent.

  My legs gave out then, and the three of us tumbled into her sheets. We were sweaty, panting, and fuckin’ laughing as we pressed her tight between us, kissing her skin, tracing our hands over her body — luxuriating in her.

  Shit, falling for her.

  “We’re getting you out of this place.” My lips brushed her ear, my fingers entwining with hers. “We’re going to get all of us out of here,” I growled. “I swear.”