Taking a Gamble on Three of a Kind (Siren Publishing Ménage Everlasting)

by Kalissa Alexander

  Jenny was better than any of them. Her beautiful ass still dripped his cum as Luke released her and pushed her back down her knees to suck his waiting cock. Her skin was pale and translucent. The cheeks of her ass were plump and still pink from Luke’s spanking. He had never seen his brother into a woman the way he was with Jenny. From the moment he had sat down at the bar, Luke had been different. Adam had felt the attraction, but Luke was consumed by it. And now Adam knew why. One night with her, and he was ready to ask her to marry them. However, he knew that tomorrow everything could look different. Besides, this was only their first night together, and having her mother and his father practically married already presented a slight complication and one he was sure had not escaped Luke. It just reinforced their uncontrollable desire for her.

  Luke was totally oblivious to them as he pushed his erection deeper into Jenny’s mouth. Adam didn’t think he would ever tire of seeing Jenny naked and sucking either his, Justin’s, or Luke’s cock. He loved the way she opened so readily for them and wanted nothing more than to pleasure them with her body. Luke was close to coming. She sucked him faster and harder, her entire body shaking with her efforts. Luke groaned, his head back, his body spasming with each spurt of his cum that Jenny drank. Some of it escaped from the corners of her mouth and dribbled down her chin. It was beautiful to watch.

  “Surprised by her?” Justin asked, his own voice thick. He stood naked beside Adam.

  “She’s amazing.”

  “I know. Maybe too amazing. Have you ever seen Luke quite like this before? I haven’t.”

  “She’s always held an attraction for him, even when we were kids. I think the fact that her father didn’t like us much intensified it.”

  “You don’t think it’s a one-time thing, do you?”

  “I hope not. She’s got something special, and I for one want her back in our bed again and again.”

  “Oh, I do, too. I’m just not entirely sure about her.”

  “What do you mean?”

  “Just a feeling that she’s got something going on that we don’t know about. Don’t ask me why. I just think we should be careful.”

  “You could be right. I hope you’re wrong.”

  Both men returned their attention to Luke and Jenny. They watched as she licked his cock and drank as much of him as possible. Luke had a big grin on his face.

  “Are you ready to get some rest? I’d say it’s about time we all got a little sleep,” Adam said, looking down at Luke and Jenny.

  “Just as soon as our sweet Jenny cleans herself,” Luke said, smiling at Jenny.

  Jenny scooped cum into her mouth from her pussy and breasts. All three men watched as she cleaned herself. Adam went into the kitchen and returned with a warm cloth that he used to clean whatever cum was left on her body.

  When she was clean, Luke carried her upstairs and laid her on Justin’s bed. “You know,” he whispered in her ear, “that when I call you my sweet slut, it means you please me. Do we please you, Jenny?”

  “More than you will ever know,” she whispered back before her eyes closed.

  Chapter Nine

  Justin woke up first and went into the kitchen to put on a pot of coffee. They had debated about sleeping with her but had decided that since not all three of them could fit in the bed, they would all sleep in the living room. Justin knew that if they had been in bed with her, they would have wanted to take her again, and it was probably best that they control their urges where she was concerned.

  The thought of her sweet ass, pussy, and mouth already had him hard. She had the power to make them want her without any forethought to the fact that she was practically a stranger to them. Luke and Adam hadn’t seen her since high school, and yesterday was the first time he had ever laid eyes on her.

  Luke had encouraged him to ask her back to his place because he wanted to find out more about why she was staying in Brilliance and not going back to school. Sex with her had never entered the equation. At least he thought it hadn’t. However, he was never entirely sure about Luke’s agenda. His cousin had always kept one step ahead of him and Adam.

  He poured himself a cup of coffee as Luke entered the kitchen wearing just a pair of jeans. “Good morning, cousin.”

  “Morning, Justin. I smelled the coffee brewing, and I could sure use a cup.”

  “Thought you might need one. I guess Adam’s still snoring.”

  “Yup.”

  Justin poured Luke a cup of the strong liquid and handed it to him. “This will grow hair on your chest.”

  “I like it strong.”

  “Good.”

  “One helluva night, wouldn’t you say?” Luke asked, pulling a rickety chair up to the kitchen table that looked more like a workbench. He sat down.

  “You’re not kidding. I can’t get her out of my head.”

  “We need to be careful with this one,” Luke said before he took another sip of his coffee.

  “I pretty much said the same thing to Adam,” Justin said, leaning against the sink. “When I’m with her, I’m consumed with her. I’m not used to getting so wrapped up in a woman so quick.”

  “Hell, I knew I wanted her, knew we all did, but it wasn’t until after she fainted that I felt a change in her. It was as if she threw all caution to the wind. She wanted us every bit as much as we wanted her.”

  “I know. She surprised me, too, yet it all seemed so natural. It was like it was meant to happen. It was almost too perfect.”

  “She scares the shit out you, doesn’t she?”

  “If I’m scared,” Justin answered. “It’s the kind of scared I wouldn’t mind getting used to. It’s just I’ve never been with anyone I felt so in tune with so quickly. It was like I inhaled and she exhaled. Can’t help it if I’m feeling a bit unbalanced.”

  He was more than just a little unbalanced by what had transpired between them. Just saying her name could make him hard for her. He shook his head and went back for another cup of coffee.

  “I felt it, too. So, what do we do now?”

  “You tell me.” Justin laughed. He had known from before he could remember that his cousin Luke was the alpha male. He and Adam were dominant in their own right, but Luke called the shots. So why was he asking him what to do?

  “I always want to know what you think, and because we’re so close, I usually do without asking. The same holds true for Adam. However, with Jenny it’s different. She makes me question everything I thought I knew. I want her.”

  Justin smiled. “I think you just answered your own question. Maybe it’s time we went to check on our guest.”

  * * * *

  Jenny rolled over into something hard and firm. She snuggled down deeper into the covers. She didn’t want to open her eyes. It felt so good to just relax.

  From behind her, she felt the covers lift. Within seconds she was wide awake. She gasped as she realized she was sandwiched between two men with very large, very hard cocks pressing into her naked body.

  Luke’s cock was hard against her stomach. She lifted one leg over his, giving him access to her pussy. Strong hands grabbed her breasts from behind, pulling on her sore nipples. She moaned softly, pushing into Luke’s cock.

  “So glad you woke up for us, Jenny.” Luke smiled into her wide eyes. “I missed you.”

  Jenny hid her face in Luke’s chest as his cock slid inside her. She couldn’t believe this was happening again. She should get up and leave, but her body had other ideas. What am I doing?

  She should have never let them talk her into visiting Justin’s, but if she were truthful, she was glad they had. Last night had been incredible in every way. Was that why she had gotten that damned migraine and fainted? Had she somehow known she was destined to be in their bed even when she knew it was more than wrong? She had told her mother to break it off with Jack, and here she was enjoying his sons and nephew in ways that she never thought possible. And the worst part was she was going to let it happen again.

  Groaning inwardly
, she bit her lip to stifle her cries of need as she felt a cock slide in between her ass cheeks. Nothing mattered but the way they made her feel. She could already distinguish their cocks. It was Justin’s that pushed into her tight hole. She was so ready. There was no doubt in her mind that she must have been dreaming about sex. Without words they simply took their pleasure with her. Each stroke took her closer and closer to an explosion of what she knew would be multiple orgasms.

  Wrapping her legs around Luke, she lost herself between the two men who continued to fuck her forcefully and without mercy. Her whole body was shaking uncontrollably when they both exploded inside of her. Their warm liquid filled her with an unbelievable sense of well-being that only served to heighten the experience. They had taken her as if she belonged to them. She was still trembling with the aftershocks of the climax that she had felt in her toes when Luke and Justin rolled away from her, allowing her a few moments to try and catch her breath. She dragged the sheet up to cover herself. It would be so easy to forget her problems and to want this to be more than it was or ever could be.

  “Good morning, Jenny,” Luke said, rising up on one elbow to look down at her. “I don’t like it when you cover yourself,” he said, yanking on the sheet. “I like you like this. Naked and dripping with our cum.”

  Jenny lay still as Luke dragged the sheet down until her body was completely exposed to their eyes.

  “Good morning, Luke.” She turned to smile at Justin. “Good morning, Justin.”

  “It is a very good morning,” Justin said, returning her smile.

  “Where’s Adam?”

  “Still sleeping. He’s going to wish he woke up.” Luke laughed. “He’s always required more sleep than I do.”

  “I may have to go downstairs and wake him up,” Jenny said and then giggled, feeling reckless and carefree. “He was always my favorite twin.”

  “Is that so?” Luke yelled playfully, cupping her wet pussy. “Looks like I’ve got my work cut out for me.”

  “Yes,” she said, enjoying the laughter in his eyes. “You certainly do. Think you’re up to the task?” Now why did I say that?

  “I’m surprised you’d even ask after last night and this morning.”

  “You’re right. I shouldn’t have asked. In fact, I really should get dressed and go home. My mother will be waiting for me.”

  “You think she’ll be home?”

  “Why wouldn’t she be?”

  “Are you really that naïve or did you forget she spent the night with my father?”

  “Oh.”

  “Oh? Is that all you have to say?”

  “All the more reason why I should leave. I don’t want her to know about what happened. It’s not part of our plan.”

  “What do you mean, your plan?” Justin asked, confusion in his voice.

  Lying there naked made it hard for her to think rationally or logically. Telling them that being in their bed was not part of the plan was just plain stupid. Groaning, she tried to get up, but Luke pushed her back down onto the bed.

  “You didn’t answer his question,” Luke said, all the playfulness gone from his voice.

  There was something about Luke when he got serious like this that turned her on like a light switch. It was crazy, but she liked it that he wasn’t about to let her get away without explaining herself. It wasn’t like her to allow a man to dominate her like this. What, she wondered, would he do if she refused to answer?

  “Jenny.”

  She heard the warning in his voice. It just intensified her need to challenge him further. “I don’t have to answer your question. My plans are my business.”

  Luke stared down at her, his eyes cold, his features like granite. She held her breath. Had she gone too far?

  “You know what? You’re right. Your plans are none of my business. Justin and I are going to clean up and then we’ll leave you to get dressed. When you’re ready, I’ll take you home.”

  His anger was like a slap in her face. Jenny watched the two men get off the bed and walk away from her. They were gorgeous, and she wanted them back in bed with her, yet hadn’t she been looking for a way out of this? She should be grateful she had made him mad and they were letting her go. Luke had put her in her place, and she would do well to remember that she belonged anywhere but here with them.

  It didn’t take the two of them long to clean up and get dressed. No words were spoken as they walked out of the room. She got up and stripped the bedsheets that needed to be washed. When she was done, she went into the bathroom and showered. She couldn’t help but be reminded of the three men washing her with such care. She moaned. She wanted all three of them again, but that would selfish on her part. She had no intention of pursuing a relationship with them. And, she knew without a doubt, having witnessed Luke’s anger when she hadn’t answered Justin’s question, that when her mother broke it off with Jack, he would be livid by what he would think was her part in their breakup.

  Showered and dressed, she walked downstairs. Adam was still asleep in a chair. She couldn’t believe he had actually been able to sleep with his legs hanging off the arms of the chair and his body contorted in a position that looked anything but comfortable.

  Luke walked out from the kitchen with the keys to the car in his hand. He walked past her and opened the front door. Justin hadn’t even come out to say good-bye. She walked past Luke and down the steps to Adam’s Lexus. Luke got to the car first and opened the passenger door for her. She slid in.

  The drive to her house was thankfully short. She could have walked, but she didn’t want to argue with him. When he pulled the car into her driveway, she opened her own door.

  “Good-bye, Luke.”

  “Bye, Jenny.”

  She knew he was watching her walk up the steps to the porch. She opened the front door without looking back. She closed it behind her before she burst into tears. Looking around for her mother, she quickly got control of her emotions. The last thing she wanted was to have to explain her tears to her mother. However, she soon discovered that her mother wasn’t home. Luke had been right. Her mother must have spent the night with Jack and still wasn’t home.

  Climbing the stairs she went to her room and threw herself across the bed. Her body was still feeling the effects of their lovemaking or what she knew now was simply sex. She got up and stripped off her clothes and touched her nipples that were ultrasensitive. She could see her reflection in the mirror. She still had her need for them written all over her face. Damn them for making her want them.

  Chapter Ten

  Luke drove back to Justin’s in what seemed like seconds flat. He couldn’t remember being so angry with a woman before. Jenny had gotten to him in more ways than one. He had thought they would at least spend the rest of the morning enjoying that delicious body of hers and giving her what he thought she wanted. She had seemed so eager to please them last night and then again that morning. But she had plans, and he, Adam, and Justin obviously weren’t part of them.

  For a moment, he had wanted to physically throttle her, but he was not a man of violence, at least not the kind that resulted from anger. And even then, he had his limits that had been tested with a number of women he had bedded. Some of the more aggressive ones had wanted him to beat them, but that wasn’t his style. He enjoyed dominance, it was his nature, but never to the point of causing harm. Jenny was the first woman that had made him see red, and that in itself was enough to tell him his feelings where she was concerned were stronger than they should be. They were practically family already. He had made a mistake with her.

  When he walked back through Justin’s front door, Adam was standing there waiting for him.

  “What the fuck happened?”

  “She wanted to go home. Where’s Justin?”

  “He left a note. Said something about checking on a job.”

  “Okay. You about ready to go home?”

  “No. Not until you tell me why she left without even saying good-bye to me.”

&
nbsp; Luke shook his head. He knew he had to tell him. He just didn’t feel like talking about it now. But when had that ever stopped Adam from hounding him?

  “She made it known that she had plans and we weren’t a part of them. We had a feeling she was a bit of a bitch, and we were right.”

  “She’s also fucking fantastic in bed. There was no bitch in her last night.”

  “I guess I brought it out in her this morning, then.”

  “What did you do, Luke?”

  “You were sleeping. Justin and I weren’t.”

  “You can be a real bastard sometimes, especially when you don’t get your own way.”

  “I asked her a simple question, and her answer was that it was none of my business. You can ask Justin when you see him. Fact is, it’s probably better this way. It was a mistake to get involved with her.”

  “That’s what I thought. You pushed her, and she pushed back. You two were at odds right from the beginning, but I thought you had gotten past that. Guess I was wrong.”

  “So did I, but I was wrong, too. I lost it last night. I knew better, but I let my cock think for me. She brought me back to reality this morning.”

  “I guess it was after you fucked her.”

  Luke stared hard at Adam. His brother rarely ever got angry, and never about a woman. Adam was the most level-headed person he knew. But the tone of his voice was anything but calm.

  “Is that was this is about? You’re pissed because we didn’t wake you up? It’s never bothered you before when Justin and I have enjoyed some morning pussy while you were sleeping.”

  “I’m not pissed. But you should have woken me up.”

  “I was wrong to do that. I’m sorry. But believe me when I tell you she’s not right for us.”

  “But damn, if it didn’t feel right,” Adam said with a sigh. “It’s never been like that for the three of us with any woman.”