Their Little Girl

by L. J. Anderson

  “Lay on your tummy, okay, sweet girl?” Daddy encouraged, and I did as he said, allowing David to spread my legs so he could move between them.

  Without hesitation, his slick fingers returned to my back entrance, sliding inside easily, stretching me more and more till my body finally began to relax again, and the painful burning stretch was replaced with something infinitely more intense and satisfying.

  As David changed positions, I could hear a brief rustling sound coming from behind me, and it set my nerves on edge, filling me with anticipation. Would I finally know what it was like to have a thick cock buried in my ass?

  Oh yes...

  David was back in seconds, his cock nudging against my tight entrance, but this time, I felt so much more relaxed as he began pushing inside. The burn returned, but with nowhere near the same uncomfortable intensity as before.

  “Yeah. That’s it,” David grunted, pushing his cock in a little more.

  “Ahh.” It felt so strange, so acute, so full, making me whimper and cry out as my ass began stretching around him, the sensation exquisitely painful, but that sense of satisfaction and pleasure was there too. It was strong, pushing me beyond the pain, making it easier to resist the urge to jerk away from the intrusion.

  “You’re doing so good, sweetie,” Daddy encouraged, running his fingers through my damp hair, just as David pressed in a little more. I didn’t think he was all the way in, but I wasn’t sure I could take much more anyway.

  My breath came in gasps as David pulled back slowly, and I shuddered as he pushed back in again. “Never felt anything this fucking tight,” he panted, sounding strained and tense, while I was speechless, afraid that if I opened my mouth, that I’d moan so loud, I’d embarrass myself.

  “Fuck... Erica, you still want us both at the same time?” His voice sounded desperate, as desperate as I felt to see this through – to fulfill my darkest fantasy.

  “God, yes,” I gasped, my voice barely recognizable through the haze of lust surrounding me.

  “Then we need to switch positions, okay?” I nodded, breathing hard as David began to pull out of me, my body tensing as I adjusted to the loss of fullness. “Lay on my chest.”

  I followed his direction, unfamiliar with this position, and not entirely sure how it would work until David took his hard cock in his hand and began guiding it back, till he could push inside me once more. I tensed, but he was able to slide it in much easier than before, his hips doing the brunt of the work, letting him push up into me until his thighs were nearly flush with my own.

  With David’s big cock stuffed deep inside my ass, I carefully lifted my legs up, resting my heels on his knees, just as I had while sitting on Daddy’s lap earlier. “That’s it,” he encouraged as I strained to move.

  “Hottest fucking thing I’ve ever seen,” Daddy groaned from beside me, and I realized he was moving into position in front of me, hard and ready.

  Unable to look anywhere else, I watched as Daddy wrapped his fist around his cock, stroking it slowly as he guided it toward the swollen lips of my pussy, making me grit my teeth the moment his thick head pushed past my entrance.

  “Oh god!” I cried out as he tried to push in. It was as if there was some kind of barrier there now, preventing him from entering me any further. I wasn’t sure whether Daddy’s cock was going to fit with David’s already stuffed inside my ass.

  “Relax,” Daddy warned, while David slid a securing arm around my waist, preventing me from wiggling around. As tight my pussy felt before, it was nothing compared to how it felt now with a second cock pushing into my body, stretching me to my limit.

  “F-fuck, Daddy,” I stuttered, my eyes watering as he pressed harder, moving past that barrier till he was finally sliding inside, making my pussy clench in response to the dual sensation – the absolute fullness and intensity beyond anything I’d ever imagined.

  And then he began to move.

  My body froze in place, legs spread wide as I took two big cocks – my body stretched to its capacity. The pain and pleasure swelled and swirled, deepening as stars began to dance behind my eyelids. Nothing else could ever feel this good – this perfect. Nothing.

  “Oh, sweetie, you’re gonna make Daddy come so hard,” he told me as David tightened his grip on my tummy, his fingers massaging me as Daddy started to fuck me harder.

  In this position, I could tell David was having a hard time moving, but he still managed to swivel his hips in a way that had me gasping for more, silently begging while Daddy worked me just right.

  “Fuck, I’m gonna come too,” David grunted, and I could feel his cock pulsing as he gripped my tummy tighter, his hips thrusting erratically.

  “Come inside me,” I begged, wanting that more than anything. “Please.”

  “Erica,” David grunted harshly, just as I felt the warmth of his release spilling deep inside my tight little ass. “Fuck, that felt good.” Just the thought of having his cum in me, was enough to trigger my own orgasm, making my pussy clench and spasm, squirting my juices all over Daddy’s cock.

  An almost animalistic noise spilled from Daddy’s lips as he continued to fuck me, making me shiver in response to the the wet sucking sound our bodies seemed to create with every thrust.

  “Does my sweet girl want Daddy to come in her cute little pussy?” The harsh tenor of his voice only managed to make the naughty words he spoke sound even naughtier, making it obvious he was losing his composure fast.

  “I want it, Daddy,” I whined desperately, unable to understand why I needed it so bad.

  Suddenly Daddy pulled back and slammed into me hard, his hips stilling as he released within me, filling my pussy with his white hot cream.

  ...

  The three of us collapsed in a tangle of limbs on the floor, breathing heavily as we each tried to gain a bit of composure. Exhaustion nipped at my heels, soreness probably the only thing preventing me from falling asleep.

  After a while, Daddy and David carried me upstairs, running a hot bath so I could relax away the pain. I wasn’t in agony or anything, but I didn’t feel all that great either.

  Not physically, at least.

  Mentally, though, I was thoroughly blissed out.

  “You did, so good, sweetie,” Daddy told me, his grey eyes still hooded with lust.

  “Did you enjoy what we did?” My eyes turned to my stepbrother, surprised to hear him sounding slightly nervous.

  “It was the most amazing... it was just perfect.”

  “You were perfect,” David whispered, his warm lips brushing against my ear.

  I couldn’t help but smile at their compliments. They made me feel so sexy, and more desired than I’d ever been in my life.

  But would I ever get the chance to feel this way again? Too afraid to ruin the moment, I kept a satisfied smile on my face and luxuriated in the tub while Daddy and David took their time washing and massaging my sore body.

  “Is our little girl sleepy?” Daddy asked when a yawn escaped my lips. My head felt heavy, but I managed a small nod of agreement.

  By the time they dried me off, I could barely keep my eyes open – I was on the verge of falling asleep as soon as my head hit the pillow, but within minutes of laying down, I already needed to get back up again to relieve my bladder.

  Tiredly, I stumbled through the darkness, vaguely realizing I was still naked and achy. While crossing the hall to the bathroom I shared with David, I could just barely hear the two men downstairs talking animatedly in the kitchen.

  Unable to deny my curious nature, I’d already decided to sneak downstair, but first I had to take care of other needs. Knowing I wouldn’t be able to hold my bladder long while creeping around downstairs, I rushed to the bathroom first.

  Once I was done, I crept down the hall, taking each step with care not to make too much noise. Aside from the sound of the television playing some show in the background, I could hear Daddy talking quietly to David, his voice low and serious. “It came in the mail this afterno
on.”

  “I’m surprised you didn’t tell her yet,” David replied, his voice concerned.

  “I’ll admit I’ve acted selfishly. I just didn’t want the news to detract from our little surprise,” he admitted, sounding embarrassed. Unsure of what news they might be speaking about, I sat quietly, leaning back against the wall as they continued to discuss the arrival of this mysterious parcel. “We’ll tell her tomorrow. Together.”

  “Honestly, I think this is going to be good for her. I mean, I know it’s not enough to cover everything, but she can get a part-time job, and I already told you she could stay with me if it worked out this way,” David considered. “I’m sure Benny can find another place to stay.”

  Oh my god... he was discussing the idea of having me stay with him at the university!

  Realization began to sink in. I must have gotten one of the scholarships I applied for... and I was going to be moving in with David!

  An enormous grin stretched across my face, and I suddenly felt the urge to jump up and down, screaming out my excitement, but the last thing I wanted to do was ruin their surprise by letting them know I’d been eavesdropping.

  After all, I loved their surprises...

  “After today, I have to admit, I’m happy you decided to let Erica stay. She needs someone like you around to watch out for her and make sure those horny frat boys don’t try to take advantage of her innocence.” Daddy sounded relieved, his words giving me a warm and fuzzy feeling in my tummy. “I know you’ll take very good care of our little girl.”

  “Yeah, and I’m sure the three of us will have a ton of fun during Parent’s Weekend.” The excitement and lust in my stepbrother’s voice set my nerves on edge, making my face flush with desire at the realization that he and Daddy were planning on sharing me again.

  As deliciously sore as I was, my pussy still clenched at the sweet reminder of the fun the three of had just an hour earlier.

  “And I’ll be sure to bring my video camera again,” Daddy added, his voice filled with mischief.

  ***

  Mayhem Erotica

  L.J. Anderson on Amazon

  Sophie's Sweet Temptation (Sweet Temptations #1) - Eighteen year old Sophie is dying to finally feel passion, to experience what sex is like, but all the boys her age not only bore her, the mere thought of being with one actually turns her off.

  On a weekend over at her best friend Abby’s house, Sophie bumps into Abby’s father who's usually away on business. Single and in his early forties, Mr. Taylor inspires in Sophie the type of lust all the boys in her school could only dream of causing her. Sophie assumes, however, that the chances of Mr. Taylor returning her ‘affections’ is nil so she does her best to suppress them.

  After an embarrassing incident involving a sauce stain and basketball shorts, an immense lust is unleashed that neither can deny. They both know it’s wrong. Still, as the night goes on, will Mr. Taylor hold back his desire for Sophie? Or will he give in and take what she is so willing to offer?

  Tied to You (A Bondage and Dominance Short) - Professor Robert Mason is finally ready to collar his submissive/girlfriend. Wanting to make the event as memorable as possible, he decides to take her on a picnic in the meadow near his country estate where they will spend the day eating and enjoying one another's company before Robert has her bound to a tree and at his mercy.

  Gabriella, a student from Professor Mason's Human Sexuality class, is more than eager to submit to Robert and finally be able to claim him as her Master.

  About the Author

  L.J. Anderson is an up-and-coming author of erotica and contemporary romance. She has been writing for a few years, publishing short stories on various blogs under a different nom de plume, and has only recently ventured into self-publishing her original fiction. She has since released Tied to You and Sophie's Sweet Temptation, the first story in the Sweet Temptations series. L.J. Is currently a part-time writer, graphic artist, and photographer living in Alabama with her husband.

  L.J. Anderson

  On Goodreads

  On Twitter