Building the Family

by Amy DeMeritt

  Both Madison and Candi squeeze me closer and Sam looks at me like she’s going to either break down crying or be sick. I turn and give Madison and Candi a kiss on their cheeks before I pull back. I pull Candi’s tank top out of my back pocket and hand it to her. I frown as I watch her slip it back on, hiding her cute body and black with white polka dot bra. She moves closer to Madison and I slightly step in front of them in a protective way.

  “Sam, why are you here?”

  She walks over to me, closing the several feet gap between us, and stops a foot in front of me. She looks in my eyes and scans my face. She looks sad, hurt, and confused, like when she broke up with me. I feel my indifference breaking and I want to hold her. She notices the slight shift in my mood and gives me a small smile.

  “Do you love me, Kayla?”

  “I’m in love with Madison.”

  “I know, but you can be in love with more than one person. Do you love me?”

  I start to turn to walk away from her because I don’t want to do this, but she grabs my arms and pulls me into her. She grabs the back of my neck and presses her mouth to mine. I try to pull away, but she bites my lip and holds it firmly, making me wince in pain. She slowly brings me to my knees again. When she releases me, I have tears in my eyes from the pain of her teeth cutting into my lip and the emotions of the night.

  “Sam, stop fucking doing this to me. You broke up with me. I don’t owe you anything anymore.” I wipe at my lip and there’s blood where she bit into me. “You fucking made me bleed again. And on my fucking lip. Why the lip?”

  “Because, when you kiss her later, I’ll be there, in the ache you feel.”

  I start to stand up, but she reaches for my hand and kisses my palm, before entwining her fingers with mine.

  “I know you love me, Kayla. That’s why you can’t answer me.” I rip my hand back and quickly stand up and she is fast to follow. “Just stop it already, Sam. I’m done doing this crazy mind game of yours. You already told me you don’t love me and don’t want to be in love this young. You can’t just show up after I’ve found someone that does love me and wants to be with me and try to fuck with my head.”

  “Who said it first?”

  “I did. Did you really come all this way just to try to get me to say those words to you? We haven’t even talked in at least a week. Why would you just…”

  She pushes my shoulders roughly, knocking me backwards into Madison and Candi, and then storms out of the room. I start to follow, but Madison and Candi grab my arms. Madison grabs my chin to look at my lips and gently kisses me.

  “Do you love her?” I throw my head back and groan. “Oh, my god! What the hell is happening with my life?”

  I grab their hands and pull them with me through the house. By the time we get outside, Sam and her friends are a couple houses away walking down the sidewalk.

  “Hey! Get your little ass back here.” Sam turns around and stops, but doesn’t start walking back. I get to the sidewalk in front of Josh’s house and stop. I look at Madison and she looks concerned. “You love me?” She smiles and nods. “I do.”

  “I love you too. Don’t forget, you’re the only person I’ve ever allowed to make me their puppet. Just don’t let this change us.” She looks confused, but I kiss her lips and she smiles. “Ok, I trust you.”

  I start walking towards Sam and she starts walking towards me. We meet in the middle where we’re alone and out of earshot of everyone.

  “Sam.” She smiles and steps closer to me, leaving only a few inches between us. “Kayla.” She takes my hands in hers and looks in my eyes. “You knew my hands, before we danced. You recognized me, even blindfolded.”

  “Yes.”

  “It was good dance. One of our best. I could tell it was turning you on when I was fighting you towards the end. I really liked when you got a little rough and spanked me.”

  “Well, you weren’t being obedient. You had to be punished.” She smiles and laughs a little bit. “Do you want to dance with me again? Like, the next time we see each other.”

  “Yes, but you have to behave next time. You have to understand that I’m with Madison now and I can’t be with you that way anymore.” She smiles and presses in closer to me. “You sure? Your girlfriend might not mind me borrowing you for a little bit every so often. I miss us.” Sam releases my hands and wraps her arms around my neck, looking deep into my eyes. “I miss your eyes. Kiss me, Kayla.”

  “No.”

  “I said, kiss me.” She tightens her arms around me and hovers above my lips. “You are not behaving.”

  “When do I ever? You like that I’m disobedient because you like to punish me.”

  “You really are a little freak. Is that why you miss me? No one out there kinky enough for you?”

  She laughs hard and jumps up, wrapping her legs around my waist. I wasn’t expecting it, so I get off-balance and stumble backwards. I trip over a brick lining the lawn of the house we’re in front of, and I fall on my back with her straddling me. I grip her shoulders and push her up, but she laughs, hits my arms out, breaking my grip, and pins my arms down in the grass.

  “So, you like being called, Daddy, now, huh?” I smile and she giggles. “Well, Daddy, I’ve been a very bad girl tonight. What’s my punishment going to be?”

  I feel a ticking between my legs and inhale deeply. Sam smiles and presses her hips down into mine, grinding in a slow circle. I test her grip on my arms and try to get free, but she leans all her weight into them, pushing my wrists down hard in a painful way.

  I buck my hips against her to get her off-balance and try to roll her, but she was anticipating it and it doesn’t work. I try to squirm away, but she has me so firmly planted that I can’t move.

  “God, how is your tiny ass so fucking strong?”

  “You’re not a very good Daddy if you can’t get my tiny ass off of you.”

  Her taunting makes me moan and thrust hard and break my arms free. I quickly roll her and pin her down.

  “Now who’s your Daddy?”

  Sam moans and wraps her legs around the backs of my thighs, pulling me down hard on top of her and pulls me into a kiss. Our lips and tongues fight each other, lashing and sucking hard against the other. After a couple minutes, she suddenly pushes up on my shoulders and smacks me across the face. Not hard enough to hurt or bruise, but hard enough to sting. She then rolls us back over, straddling me on my chest with her knees pinning my arms down.

  “You are really asking for a beating.”

  “Oh, Daddy, please.”

  I swallow hard and she smiles. Sam thrusts her groin against my face, grinding down into me. My hands are pinned under her knees so I’m helpless against resisting this. I kick my legs out, trying to twist my body to get free, but it does nothing. Thankfully, she’s wearing leggings and not jeans or she would really be tearing my face up right now. She’s starting to pant. Her groin is hot and fragrant with her arousal and its making me wish this fabric was not separating her from my face. I open my mouth against her and pinch her between my teeth. She moans and thrusts harder against me. My mouth pinches and presses into her. I try to thrust my tongue up through the thin fabric into her opening, making her moan and buck against me harder.

  I suddenly realize what I’m doing and close my mouth against her. I lift my legs up and wrap them around her chest and rip her backwards. When she’s lying flat on me, I’m able to roll us again. She’s now face down on the grass. I try to keep my weight on her enough that I can turn around and she can’t get up. I straddle her ass and take a few deep breaths. I was getting hardly any air while she was humping my face.

  I look over to where I left Madison and Candi and I’m glad to see she’s still standing there. Candi’s holding her hand, but she doesn’t look like she’s about to run away and never speak to me again. I rub my face and turn my attention back to Sam.

  “You wish you could fuck me right now, don’t you?”

  “That’s going to be your punishm
ent.” She tries to turn over in an excited way, but I push her shoulders back down. “Not so fast, naughty girl. You have been very bad.” I bend down and whisper, “You’re going to finish what you started against my face while I hold you down. Slide your right hand under yourself and get to work. Now.”

  “Oh, fuck. I wish you had this confidence when we were together, before we left for college. I really fucking like this Daddy attitude. Does your new girlfriend even know how lucky she is? Have you shown her this side of you yet?” She slides a hand down her pants and releases a small moan as she starts rubbing herself. “I really wish you could be fucking me in this position.”

  “Insert three fingers, Sam.”

  She moans and raises her hips some to be able to penetrate herself. She releases a small moan as I push my hips down slow and deep against her, pushing her down onto her fingers, to take them in deep.

  “Oh, yes. Again.” We repeat it a few more times and then she starts breathing erratically and biting her lips, trying not to moan loud enough for anyone to hear. I bend down some to whisper, “You are such a bad girl, masturbating on someone’s front lawn with so many people watching you.” She moans and starts moving her hand more quickly. “Taste yourself, Sam.”

  She hesitates to pull her hand out, but she slowly obeys and releases another moan as I thrust her fingers deep into her mouth a few times before I allow her to return it to her clit.

  “Finish it. Cum all over this person’s front lawn.”

  “I really want to cum against your face right now. I want to hump you so hard and fast that you have to hold your breath till I cover your whole face with my juice. Fuck, I’m going to cum. Kayla, oh fuck.”

  I press my hand against her mouth to stifle her moans and outbursts and she inhales deeply through her nose and her eyes roll back before she closes her eyes. Her whole-body shudders under me and she slowly pulls her hand out and takes my hand off of her mouth.

  “Kayla, I love you.” I bend down and kiss her lips. “I know. I love you too, but I love Madison more.”

  “I know. Thank you for this. I really fucking miss you so much. Can I turn over now?”

  I stand up and help her off the ground. She wraps her arms around me and lays on my chest. I hold her for a couple minutes and then she pulls back and looks in my eyes. She smiles and then firmly smacks my cheek, just enough to sting. I smile and she giggles.

  “I hope your new girlfriend can handle you, but if she can’t, I would love to tumble around another front lawn with you any day. Next time, you’re going to be strapped up so you can fuck me.” I laugh and push her off of me. “Get the fuck out of here, Sam. You’re going to get me kicked out of school.”

  “How? Are you going to fuck me on the dean’s desk?”

  “You leaving town tonight?”

  “Hell no. We’ve been driving for two days. We’ll probably sleep all of tomorrow and then get back on the road. I’ll text you before we leave so I can get a goodbye fuck.”

  “I won’t give you one of those, but I’ll take a hug.”

  “Ok. Goodnight, baby. I love you. I wish I had been able to say that a long time ago, but at least I finally said it. And you finally said it. God, I knew you fucking loved me. You’re such an ass for not telling me sooner.” I laugh and shake my head. “So are you.”

  She smiles and starts walking backwards to where her friends are waiting for her.

  “You’ve gotten better while you’ve been here. With doing the puppet dancing I mean. Can’t wait till the next time we dance.”

  I start walking backwards and dust off my shoulders in a cocky way and she laughs as she bends over in a mocking bow.

  “Goodnight, Kayla.”

  “Goodnight, Sam.”

  We both turn and walk the rest of the distance to our waiting parties. Madison and Candi are still holding hands and are searching my face as I return to them. I kneel down in front of Madison and hang my head in a sign of submission and she runs her hand through my hair and lifts my head to look at her. She smiles and pretends to grab me by the throat and lifts me back up.

  “Can Daddy have a kiss?” She flashes me a big smile and wraps her arms around my neck as she presses her lips to mine, but doesn’t enter me with her tongue. She pulls back and looks in my eyes with a teasing grin. “How was that?”

  “More. I want all of you.”

  She smiles and returns to my lips. This time, she gives me a whole mouth passionate kiss. I run my hands down her back and over her ass, gripping it firmly and pulling her against me. She moans and sucks my bottom lip hard before pulling back.

  “Daddy, I want you on your knees in front of me again. Between my legs.”

  “Whitney is supposed to be staying out all night. Let’s go back to my dorm.” Madison gets a shy smile on her face and glances at Candi a moment before looking at me and pressing in closer. “Can Candi come?” I raise my eyebrows. “Really? Is this because of Sam showing up?” She shakes her head. “No, Sam doesn’t concern me. I just think it could be fun.”

  “It could be, if it’s not going to change us.”

  “Hey, uh, I love this whole family thing we created tonight, but a lot happened tonight that you both probably want and need to talk about. I really want to go home with both of you, but how about we wait till you can talk about it more so you both are sure that’s what you want. I know you two are in love and I don’t want to ruin anything between you. I’m ok just being friends and dancing with you both if you don’t want to add a third to your bed.”

  Madison grabs her hand and pulls her between us and we sandwich her like earlier. She giggles and nuzzles into my chest, wrapping her arms around me. Madison leans forward and kisses my lips and teases my lips with her tongue. With us holding Candi between us, she pulls me into a hot kiss that makes me want to slip my hands between both of their thighs and make them cum at the same time.

  When Madison pulls back, she smiles and Candi lifts her head between us, looking at us both. Madison smiles and kisses her on the mouth. I feel both a bit of arousal and a twinge of jealousy watching. I can tell that Madison is not kissing her the same way she kisses me though. She’s not putting as much into it. When she pulls back, she nods her head towards me.

  “Now, kiss Daddy.”

  Candi turns back to face me with excitement in her eyes. She grips my back hard, and presses her mouth to mine. Her kiss is more passive, as if she’s trying to allow me to dominate. So, I take control. While our lips and tongues slide together, I slide my hands over Madison’s amazing ass and start massaging it. She moans and presses in closer. Her hands grip Candi’s hands and she moves them down my back into my back pockets and squeezes my ass. We all release a small moan.

  Madison grabs both of our heads and pulls us apart. She flicks her tongue against Candi’s lips and then repeats the same tease to me. I smile and chomp at her tongue with my teeth as if I’m really going to bite her. She giggles and pulls me back into another kiss. I slide my hands between Madison and Candi and palm over Madison’s breasts and pinch her nipples, making her moan. While we kiss, I have two sets of hands moving over the front and back of me. It’s so fucking hot. I’m ticking so badly between my legs that I wish I could just push one of their faces between my legs right now. Preferably, Candi, so I can keep kissing Madison.

  I hear the sound of a picture being taken and a bright white flash of light cuts through my closed eyelids. I pull back and look around. Josh is standing right next to us with his cellphone out and a huge cheesy grin on his face. We look around and there’s over a dozen people watching in the yard and on the porch. We pull apart and they start clapping and throwing out comments like, “don’t stop!”, “Josh, you fucking ruined it!”, and “so, fucking hot!”.

  “You’re lucky it’s too dark out here to record this. Everyone was trying, but it wouldn’t come out. How much did you guys drink?”

  “None. You better send me that picture.”

  He smiles and quickly texts m
e the picture. The picture is hot. All three of us are tightly pressed together with Madison and I kissing, while Candi is sucking on my neck and squeezing my boob. You can’t see it in the picture, but at that particular moment, Madison had her hands in my back pockets and Candi had her other hand holding the inside of my thigh.

  “So, what was that shit with Sam in the house and on the lawn over there?”

  “How long you been watching me and my girls, perv?” He laughs hard and shakes his head. “Please. Practically the whole house has been watching you since you got here and started dancing with these two. You guys should come back in. We’re getting ready to do body shots.”

  “Why, so you can watch us some more? I don’t think so.” I wrap an arm around the hips of Madison and Candi and start to turn them to walk away. “See ya. My girls need my attention.”

  He laughs and drops to his knees and starts bowing with his arms above his head as if he’s worshipping me. When I have them both turned around, I grab their asses for emphasis and he laughs. Madison and Candi wrap an arm around my waist and kiss my cheeks as we continue walking away.

  Chapter Sixteen

  On the short walk back to my dorm, my cockiness and excitement mellow out and are replaced by worry. I need to talk to Awenasa. I suggest we go to the bathroom and get some waters so I can try to text her. While I’m waiting for them near the vending machines in a small common area in my dorm building, I pray and hope she’s still awake.

  Me: I’m sorry if I’m waking you up, but I really need to ask you something very important.

  Awenasa: I’m awake. What’s up?

  Me: I don’t have much time, but remember when I told you about my breakfast conversation with Madison after our first night together?

  Awenasa: Yes, I remember.

  Me: She asked me for that tonight with a girl we’ve danced with at the last two parties. I told her yes, but before I do this, I need to make sure you’re not going to hate me or think I’m disgusting.

  Awenasa: Have your feelings for me and what you want from me changed?