Taking What's Theirs (Siren Publishing LoveEdge)

by Kalissa Alexander

  “I’m not worried about my mother, I’m worried about you.”

  “You’re staying here with Jessica. That’s it. If you leave, I swear I’ll never forgive you, either of you.” Chrissie looked pointedly at her and Jessica before she turned to the other girls. “I did this to myself.”

  “Well?” Jessica looked at Abby, her eyes begging her to say she would stay.

  Abby wanted to stay just as bad or maybe even more than Jessica, even though she knew staying shouldn’t even be option. However, Chrissy really did want them to stay, and maybe if they did it really would make her feel better. Against her better judgment, she sighed and then said, “I just feel bad about staying when you have to leave like this.”

  “Feeling bad won’t change anything,” Chrissie said, her eyes flashing in sudden anger. “I’ll be pissed as hell if you leave. I mean it. I’m not kidding.”

  “So, it looks like at least you and I are staying, right, Abby?” Jessica asked.

  “Okay. But someone has to call me with an update on Chrissie.”

  “I’ll call you,” Katie said flatly. Her disapproval was more than clear.

  Obviously Jessica didn’t care what Katie or the others thought. She went over to Chrissie and gave her an air hug. “I’m so sorry, sweetie. I really am. I’ll pick you up some of that caramel popcorn you love.”

  Chrissie smiled. “A big bucket that comes with the plastic bag to catch the overflow?”

  Jessica smiled. “And I’ll throw in some fudge too.”

  It didn’t take the girls long to pack. When they were leaving, Joanne gave Abby a hug and whispered, “I know you wanted to leave, but Jessica was hell bent on staying. Don’t worry, I’ll call you if Katie forgets. Try and enjoy yourself if you can.”

  When the hotel door had closed behind the girls, Jessica sighed. “Okay, I know they think I’m the bitch, but tell me you didn’t want to stay.”

  “I would have left, but yes, I’m glad we’re staying. And I really think Chrissie would have been even more upset if we hadn’t stayed.”

  “Especially since I told her I had another date tonight.”

  Abby shook her head. “You really like this guy?”

  “Yes. A lot. It was like karma or something. I can’t explain it. I wouldn’t have come back to the room at all if I hadn’t felt I had to.”

  “I don’t think I’ve seen you so taken with someone so quickly.”

  “He’s like no one I’ve ever met before. I’m getting horny just thinking about him.”

  Abby laughed. “Are you actually blushing? I don’t think I’ve ever seen you blush before either.”

  Jessica looked away. “It’s crazy to feel so strongly about someone so soon, but I can’t help it.”

  “No. It’s not crazy. I feel the same way about the guy I met last night.”

  “I know we don’t talk about the details of our sex life, but I have to tell someone. I’ve never had sex like this before. It was incredible. Like off-the-charts incredible.”

  “Me too,” Abby said, feeling a blush creep into her cheeks.

  “I’m so happy that you let loose last night. I wanted you to have fun. You’re always so”—Jessica looked for the right phrase—“I don’t know, so not in the moment. You overthink everything.”

  “Sometimes, I guess I do. But he made me forget about everything except him. I’m also”—she hesitated—“glad you took me with you to the sex store.”

  Jessica’s eyes widened, her voice raising an octave as she said, “You did things you’ve never done before last night didn’t you?”

  Abby nodded her head. “Yes. It was off-the-charts incredible too.”

  Jessica jumped up and ran to Abby, giving her a tight hug. “Regular sex is okay, but when you find someone who is adventurous and wants to try new things, it’s fucking fantastic.”

  “Yes, it is,” Abby said shyly, knowing her face had become a permanent shade of red.

  Jessica pulled away. “Look at you, all blushy and mushy eyed. You’re really into this guy.”

  “I guess we both got lucky.”

  They talked for a few more minutes before they dressed for dinner. Jessica made reservations at an Indian restaurant. Abby loved Indian food and had introduced Jessica to many different dishes, but the tandoori chicken still remained her favorite.

  The restaurant was packed, and it took over a half hour before they were seated. Jessica ordered her favorite drink, a piña colada. Abby ordered one this time too. By the time dinner was over, they had both consumed three of the sweet drinks and Abby knew it was time to put the brakes on. She didn’t want to be drunk when she went to Rod’s room. It was important that she have her wits about her. Besides, she had a feeling Rod wouldn’t be pleased if he thought she had too much to drink. And goodness knows, all she could think about since she met him was how much she wanted to please him.

  That thought, along with how quickly she had submitted her body to his demands, was daunting. Her desire was out of control. But from what Jessica had told her, she felt the same way about the man she had met. However, Abby knew that after tonight, their situations would be very different.

  When they returned to their room, Jessica checked the time. “I have to leave soon. He gets off work in a few minutes.”

  “He works here?”

  “He’s a blackjack dealer on the weekends. He’s working his way through college. He graduates next year. He’s studying to be an accountant.”

  “A sexy accountant? And all I thought they were interested in was the bottom line,” Abby teased.

  “Oh yes.” Jessica smirked. “He’s very interested in the bottom line.”

  They both laughed. Jessica picked up her purse and gave Abby another hug. “See you tomorrow. And thanks for sticking with me. I know you stayed for me.”

  “We’re here and that’s all that matters now. Go and have fun. We’ll catch up in the morning or afternoon or whenever. Now scoot.”

  For a few minutes after Jessica left, Abby just sat staring into space. It was the first time she had been alone since they arrived and she had to admit she had missed the solitude. She decided to take a shower, but first she wanted to call Joanne. She should have known Katie wouldn’t call her.

  Joanne answered on the second ring. “Sorry I didn’t call. We just got out of Emergency.”

  “So you did stop. How’s Chrissie?”

  “She’s going to be fine. But she was in a lot of pain in the car. We all got scared. The doctor really tore into her about being negligent. When she started crying, he backed off a little.”

  “Did they give her anything for the pain?”

  “Yes. She’s already asleep in the backseat of the van. We’re taking her home. I called her mom. She’s waiting for us.”

  “You did the right thing. I should have come with you.”

  “Listen, she’s good. She’ll be sore for a while and I don’t think she’ll ever do that again. But have fun, please. She really wanted you and Jessica to stay.”

  “Thanks. I still feel guilty.”

  “I know. But don’t. Everything worked out okay. Tell Jessica that too.”

  Abby could hear the other girls in the background. Joanne said she had to go and they hung up.

  Feeling a little better, Abby stripped down for her shower. She walked by a full-length mirror and stopped to look at herself. She knew she had nice breasts. She had seen both Jessica’s and Chrissie’s. They were smaller than hers and she was glad even though hers were larger, that were very firm. Her areolas were high and puffy with hard little nubs. She ran her fingers across them and they responded instantly.

  She was also glad she had shaved her pubic hair, even though she had debated doing it. Her pussy looked ready for what was to come. She felt herself getting wet. She wanted this to happen. She imagined what it would be like to have three men touching her and caressing her with their hands and mouths. She trembled slightly. And now that she had experienced anal sex, she wanted
it again. She could only try to imagine what it would feel like to have one cock in her pussy with another one filling her ass.

  “What have I become,” she said out loud as she walked into the bathroom. She needed a cool shower.

  It was almost eleven fifty when she slipped into her heels. She had worn an olive-colored short dress and regular hose. She didn’t know why she took such care in dressing when they weren’t even going to see her with her clothes on. Rod had told her to come to his suite, take off her clothes, put on a blindfold, lay down on the bed, put her hands behind her head, and spread her legs wide. His instructions, even now, left her breathless. He wanted his brothers’ first impression of her to be of her submission. The visual made her knees weak. She sat down for a moment and took a deep breath before she walked purposely out of the suite.

  The card key worked. She opened the door to Rod’s suite. As he had told her, no one was there. She put the card key on the table in the foyer and walked directly to the bedroom. She stripped off her clothes and folded her underthings, which she placed on a nearby chair. She found a hanger in the closet and hung up her dress.

  Lying down naked on the coverlet, she took the blindfold from the nightstand and slipped it over her eyes. She then put her hands behind her head before she spread her legs wide open. She was wet with desire and anticipation. She waited.

  She wasn’t sure how much time had passed when she heard the suite door open. Her heart was in her throat. Rod would see the card key. He would know she was there.

  She heard rustling and low voices. She wanted to take off the blindfold, but she knew he wouldn’t like that. She heard movement in the room and felt someone move to the side of the bed.

  “You came back to me.” It was Rod’s voice. He sounded awestruck, as if he hadn’t expected to see her again.

  “Yes. Do you still want me?”

  She heard him groan softly as his lips lightly touched hers. “Very much. But I have to ask, one more time, while my brothers are standing witness, do you want this?”

  “Yes,” she breathed. “Very much.”

  “We are going to undress and then my brothers are going to get to know that luscious body of yours. And then, my sweet girl, we are going to fuck your mouth, your ass, and that lovely pussy without mercy.”

  “Yes, please.”

  “You are not to move or we will tie you down. You are not to speak. If you do, I’ll gag you. And then we’ll spank you, and not with our palms. Do you understand?” His voice was no longer tender but hard and demanding.

  “Yes, Sir,” she responded. When he used that tone of voice, she immediately became submissive to his every wish. She wanted to please him.

  “Good. You will please my brothers as you have pleased me.”

  She knew he didn’t expect a response. She was silent. She didn’t want him to gag her or tie her down or especially spank her. Not yet anyway.

  Chapter Nine

  Fingers lightly caressed her feet, running up her legs to caress her inner thighs. She moaned softly, biting her lip to stop herself. She was supposed to be quiet. Rod said nothing. She sighed silently with relief.

  She felt her labia parted as another man’s fingers moved across her stomach and up to her breasts, lifting them upward to knead them expertly. She loved their touch. Over and over they teased her clit and her hard nubs. She felt her legs being lifted as a finger was inserted into her anus. Not one word was spoken between them. Her body was on fire with a hunger that only one thing could stop. She tried desperately not to move. It was difficult since they were invading every intimate part of her with no other objective than to make her need them. She wanted to scream for one of them to put her out of misery by fucking her. Instead she groaned loudly, biting her lip to try and stifle it.

  When she felt hot breath on her pussy, she turned her head and tried to stifle another moan. Her legs were spread wider. Her ass was lifted. A tongue flicked her clit and pushed inside her. An unwanted moan escaped between her parted lips.

  “Open your mouth.” Rod barked out his order.

  She parted her lips further.

  “Use your teeth to grab the ball.”

  He was really going to gag her. She wasn’t sure she would like this, but she did as he instructed. Her head was lifted and the gag tied behind her head.

  “Just breathe through your nose. If you want us to stop at any time, your hands are free, just flex them and we will stop.”

  Hands continued their assault on her body along with tongues that were kissing and licking every inch of her, even her ass. She wanted more. So much more. This was becoming torturous. She needed release desperately. But they obviously weren’t ready to let her come.

  One hand pulled her right nipple to affix a clamp with what felt like tiny teeth. The same was done to her left nipple. It was tight and painful, but it was arousing. Her pussy gushed with pleasure. A warm mouth suckled one nub and then the other before the clamps were tightened slightly. She groaned but it was muffled by the gag.

  Suddenly her body was lifted from the bed and her feet were placed on the carpet. She stood with someone’s help. He smelled good, kind of spicy and woodsy. She liked feeling helpless. She liked everything about what they were doing to her.

  “My brother is on the bed,” Rod said in her ear. “His cock is ready for you. I will help lift you and slide it inside your pussy. He will lie back on the bed. Your ass will be exposed for my other brother. He will fuck your ass.”

  His words were all she needed to come, but she somehow stopped herself, knowing it was not what he wanted. She nodded.

  “And then,” he whispered, his lips caressing her neck before he continued, “I will lift your head by your ponytail and bring your mouth to my cock. You will suck it and I will fuck that beautiful mouth of yours until I come.”

  How could she have thought she didn’t want this? Her body was in tune with everything they were doing to her and were going to do to her. She couldn’t wait to have their cocks buried deep inside her. Rod’s voice was hypnotic and made her want nothing more than to open herself to him and his brothers. She wasn’t sure there was anything she wouldn’t do if he asked.

  She heard the familiar rip of foil. They were putting on their condoms. She wanted to tell them they didn’t need to because she wanted to feel their cocks naked inside her, but she had been silenced.

  Rod lifted her until she felt the head of his brother’s cock at the entrance of her pussy. She moaned as the man pushed his cock upward, filling her. As Rod had told her, the man leaned back into the bed and brought her with him. Her hands went to his shoulders. Her knees were on either side of hips. She instinctively lifted her ass while still gripping the man’s cock with her pussy. Two fingers lubricated her anus. She shivered with anticipation moaning into her gag.

  The man beneath her reached down and found her clit. He pulled on it as he worked his cock in and out of her. It felt so good. She began to ride the hard, thick cock that now fucked her. She wanted to see him. Damn, she hated this blindfold, but there was no doubt that it intensified her other senses. She heard the man beneath her groan. She smiled, knowing she was bringing him to orgasm.

  “Now, it’s time to have your ass fucked too, baby.” Rod’s voice was in her ear again as he reached down and squeezed her breasts roughly, tugging on the clamps before he released them. Delicious pain from the blood flowing back into her nubs made her cry out into the gag.

  “Beautiful,” Rod said as he pulled them outward so the man who was fucking her pussy could suck her sore nubs. She gasped from the exquisite but torturous feelings that flooded her senses.

  The man behind her pushed the head of his cock into the opening of her anus. She stilled slightly as his cock penetrated and pushed slowly inside her. There was a little discomfort, but it didn’t last long. She pushed back. The man beneath her released her nipples and leaned forward. She assumed he was resting on his elbows as his angle changed slightly. Both cocks began to move inside
her, finding their rhythm.

  They fucked her together. Each stroke increased the pleasure of the other. She hated the ball gag and wanted it removed so they could hear her cries of pleasure.

  As if reading her mind, the ball gag was removed. She breathed deeply, taking air into her lungs. While her mouth was still open, she felt one hand on her cheek moving her head while the other gripped her ponytail. Rod’s cock filled her mouth. She suckled it eagerly. She craved his taste. He began to fuck her mouth in earnest, his cock plunging deeper into her throat. His hand tugged on her ponytail to force her to take more. She had no choice but to take him completely. She couldn’t seem to get enough of him. She wanted his cum down her throat again.

  With three cocks fucking her, her orgasm built swiftly. There was no stopping it. She had no control. All she could do was go with it as it swept through every inch of her body until she was nothing but a receptacle of pleasure. Rod groaned and came first. His cum glided down her throat. He removed his cock as she screamed her pleasure with his cum on her lips.

  The cocks still inside her swelled as both men came at the same time. She heard their cries. She loved the sound and the feel of them coming inside her. She rocked back and forth as another orgasm overtook her. She was riding on a wave of such magnitude she thought she might lose consciousness. She held on until the cock in her ass slipped out and she fell onto the man beneath her. She had never in her life experienced anything that could ever compare to the most fucking awesome thing that had ever happened to her.

  She felt her naked and now lifeless body being lifted. She was gently placed on her back. She wanted to open her eyes, but what did it matter? She was still blindfolded.

  She felt a man behind her. He lifted her between his legs. She could feel his now soft cock up against the cheeks of her ass. Was it Rod who was holding her? She wasn’t sure.

  “You were magnificent,” Rod said in her ear. “More than we could have ever hoped for.”