Hardy 11 - Suspect, The

by John Lescroart

  "That's what I mean."

  "Then you're on time. Come on in."

  He turned to reveal the two people who'd just gotten up off the couch behind him. "Gina Roake, Stuart Gorman. And this is Debra . . ." He stopped on a questioning note.

  The beautiful young woman stepped forward. "Dryden," she said, shaking Gina's hand with a cool, firm grip. "Debra Dryden. I'm Stuart's sister-in-law. Caryn's sister." She half-turned and rested her hand protectively on Stuart’s arm, bringing him up into the introduction, her body language trumpeting at the very least a strong attraction for her dead sister’s husband. "We're so glad you could come."

  "I just hope I can be of some help." Gina reached around Debra and extended her hand. "Mr. Gorman, nice to meet you."

  "Stuart," he said, "not Mr. Gorman." He took her hand. "Everybody seems to agree that I need a lawyer, so thanks for coming."

  Gina cocked her head. "So I gather you don't agree."

  He shrugged. "As I've mentioned to all and sundry, I wasn't here when my wife died, so I think it might be a stretch to conclude that I killed her."

  "It might be at that," Gina said. "But you want to be careful what you say when you talk to the police. Did Jedd tell you that just coincidentally I had lunch with Inspector Juhle today? I didn't get the impression that he thought your wife's death was a suicide. Or that you couldn't have been involved."

  Stuart lifted his shoulders, then dropped them. "Well, he'll find out. I wasn't around."

  "Where were you?"

  "Up at my cabin. We've got a place up on Echo Lake."

  Gina took a beat. "You were at Echo Lake this last weekend?"

  "Yeah. Why's that such a surprise?"

  "Because so was I. Tamarack Lake, actually, right beyond Echo."

  "Hey, I was there too. I mean, at Tamarack. God, could that have been just last night? It seems like a year ago. You really were at Tamarack?"

  She nodded. "Camping. On the western shore."

  Stuart was warming to the conversation, his face showing signs of animation now through the fatigue. "I was on my favorite rock on the east side just at sundown."

  "Oh my God." Gina was caught up in it herself. "I think I might have even seen you."

  But Debra cut in. "Well, all this is really special, but whether or not anybody saw Stuart up there isn't really the point, is it? Unless"— she spoke to Gina—"unless you saw him leave his cabin early this morning."

  Debra's tone brought Gina up short. There was more, it seemed to her, than mere protectiveness here. It struck her as jealousy, which might mean something going on between Debra and Stuart.

  Debra again put her hand on Stuart’s arm, and this time he covered it with his own and left it there for a moment. "It doesn't matter where you were last night at sundown, Stuart. It matters that you didn't leave your cabin until sometime early this morning."

  Gina realized that everybody else in the room knew more about the particulars of the case than she did. "What time, Stuart?" she asked.

  "Two," he said.

  Gina's face showed her dissatisfaction with that answer. "Two in the morning?"

  "Maybe we all ought to sit down?" Jedd said. "Catch up on our facts."

  Two chairs bracketed the small couch. Gina and Jedd took them as Stuart and Debra went around the coffee table and sat next to each other on the couch.

  As soon as everyone was settled, Gina came forward in her chair and repeated her earlier question. "Stuart, you're telling me you left your cabin at two this morning?"

  He nodded. "I couldn't sleep, so I decided to drive on down and beat the traffic."

  "Did you stop anywhere for gas or anything like that?"

  Another nod. "I pulled off and got gas just outside Sacramento. Used the bathroom." He suddenly shifted and brought his arm off the back of the couch, reaching into his back pocket, coming out with his wallet. "Here you go," he said after a quick search. "ARCO All-Nite in Rancho Cordova. Four fifteen a.m., this morning." He held the receipt out to Gina.

  But striking quickly, Debra took it first and gave it a glance.

  When she was done, she passed it over to Conley, who looked at Stuart and said, "Well, there's your alibi." Finally, he gave it to Gina.

  "I told you," Stuart said. "I wasn't here."

  "If they've got a security video there," Gina said, "it's even better."

  Jedd Conley nodded. "There you go."

  "Well," Gina added, "it's not a lock, but it's a help."

  Finally, the pressure and weariness seemed to weigh in on Stuart. He came forward on the couch, frustration etched in his features. For the first time, he raised his voice. "I don't understand how I keep hearing things like 'It's not a lock.' What's not a lock? I didn't kill my wife. What's so hard to understand about that?"

  Debra put a restraining hand on his knee and left it there. Depleted, Stuart sank back into the seat of the couch.

  Gina, noting the physical connection, drew a breath to give herself a minute. If Stuart and Debra were lovers, it complicated matters considerably. She forced a conversational tone. "Stuart, she had a large bump on her head."

  "I know that," he said.

  "Possibly enough to have knocked her out."

  "Possibly," he said, "but even Juhle said not definitely. Maybe she fell down. That happens too."

  "Yes, it does." Gina wasn't going to argue. "You told Inspector Juhle that she told you Friday she was filing for divorce. Yes?" She didn't wait for a reply. "How much insurance did your wife carry?

  "I think the policy was for three million on each of us."

  Gina's eyebrows went up a fraction of an inch. "Three million," she said flatly. "And besides that, how much money are you worth today?"

  "I don't really know. I haven't thought about that."

  "All right. But in any event, your own personal net worth is many millions more than it was on Friday, isn't it?"

  "I suppose so."

  "You suppose so. And Inspector Juhle knows that too, doesn't he? Because you told him, am I right?"

  "Maybe not all the details, but yeah. All right. Generally."

  "And you also told him about how resentful you felt toward your wife? And in fact, that you'd spent all of this past weekend just thinking about how much you hated her?"

  Jedd spoke up. "You didn't say that, did you, Stu?"

  A shrug. "I might have. 'Hate' sounds a little strong. I don't remember saying I exactly hated her."

  "I don't think Juhle was making stuff up when he was telling me about it at lunch, to say nothing of the fact that he'll have your exact words on tape anyway," Gina said.

  Clearly, the fact that Juhle had secretly taped him began to sink in and shake him.

  She softened her voice still further. "All I'm saying, Stuart, is that you are a big blip on Juhle's radar, and you shouldn't let the bare fact of your innocence, and even an apparently strong alibi, lull you into thinking that you couldn't find yourself in a world of hurt and charged with your wife's murder. That bump on her head is bad news. So is your newfound wealth, like it or not. And let's not even talk about the fact that you have something of a public face, which the media will eat up before you know what hit you. Even innocent, even with your alibi, you could turn into the next O.J. Simpson in a heartbeat." She sat back, nearly finished. "That's why it's better to err on the side of caution here, and not let you talk to the cops alone anymore."

  "But unlike me, O.J. actually did it," Stuart said.

  "No." Gina shook her head. "According to the law, which did not prove him guilty, he was innocent, even if in fact he was not. And— listen up, Stuart—just as easily, the law could find that you did kill your wife, even if in fact you didn't. You've got to understand that and take it very, very seriously. The law is not about the fact of guilt or innocence. It's about the settlement of disputes. So basically what we're trying to avoid here is having you become any part of the dispute about who killed your wife. And you're already damned close to being smack in the mi
ddle of it, which is where you don't want to be. Is that clear enough?"

  Stuart said, "I think it stinks."

  "I couldn't agree more. But it's reality. Now, if you don't mind, I'm going to place a call to Inspector Juhle and tell him that you've retained me and that of course we're anxious to cooperate with his investigation in any way we can, but that I've instructed you not to talk to him outside of my presence from now on. You think you can live with that?"

  Stuart still didn't like it, but he gradually started to nod. "It sounds like I have to."

  "That's the right answer." No nonsense now. Gina got her cell phone out of her briefcase and started punching numbers.

  "And now, if both of you don't mind," Gina said, "I wonder if Stuart and I could have a private discussion."

  Debra's back straightened, an electric shock through her. Her eyes suddenly blazed as she whirled around on the couch. "What for?"

  Gina, annoyed, threw her a quizzical look. "I'd think that would be obvious enough. We need to talk about strategy and then he can catch me up on everything I've missed."

  "You haven't missed anything. Haven't we just established here between us that he didn't do anything wrong? He got home this morning and called emergency, then had the talk with your inspector, which you already seem ..."

  Stuart butted in. "Deb. It's okay. That's why she's here."

  "But you need ... I mean . . ." She couldn't express exactly what she meant, and tried it again. "I don't think we should have to go. We can be here to help you if you need anything."

  "It's the attorney-client privilege," Jedd said. "If you talk to your lawyer and you let somebody else listen in, the privilege doesn't apply."

  "But," Debra said, "this isn't a good time for him to be alone."

  "He won't be alone," Gina told her. Matter-of-factly, putting on a tight smile, she added, "I'm afraid that this isn't really a request." She spoke to Stuart. "It's a condition."

  Stuart nodded. "Don't worry, Deb. I'll be fine. She's on our side."

  Jedd was already on his feet. "Stuart's right, Debra. The best thing we can do is let them go to work."

  Worrying her lower lip, Debra seemed to be fighting it for another second, but finally she shrugged, huffed an "Okay, then," and stood up. Stuart got up with her. She put a hand on his arm one more time and told him she'd be on her cell phone if he needed her. "Have you had anything to eat? I could bring you dinner when you're done here. Or we could go out."

  "Maybe," he said, "but I've got to be picking up Kym sometime. She's taking the bus up from Santa Cruz."

  "Oh God, that's right. Kym. We could go down to Greyhound and get her together. Just let me know."

  "I will."

  Jedd Conley was standing by the open door, holding it. "Gina, if you need anything else from me, you've got all my numbers. And again, thanks for coming." He cast an expectant glance at Debra, motioned to the doorway.

  Debra turned and clipped a cold "Yes, thank you" in Gina's direction.

  When they'd gone, Gina sat down in her chair and let Stuart get comfortable on the couch. Meeting his eyes, she smiled. Sitting back, adopting a casual air, she crossed her legs. "So," she said, gently now, "how are you holding up?"

  The question caught him off guard. He rubbed a palm along his unshaved cheek. Finally, he drew in a lungful of air and let it out. "Not too well. I keep thinking this can't be real, that I'm going to wake up and it won't have happened."

  "I know. That's how it feels at first." Gina took in her own deep breath. "My fiancé was killed a few years ago. Sometimes it still doesn't feel real."

  "I'm sorry," he said.

  Gina shrugged. "You go on." Regrouping, not having meant to reveal even so little about herself, she said, "But you've already told Inspector Juhle that you and your wife were having troubles."

  "Having troubles doesn't mean I wanted her to die."

  "No, of course not. But how you felt about her may become an issue. It is an issue."

  "Is that a question?"

  "This is one: Did you love her?"

  He hesitated, scratched at the birthmark near his eye. "Once upon a time I did."

  "But not anymore?"

  "We just weren't very compatible anymore. We didn't like to do the same kinds of things. But until last Friday ... I don't know, I had more or less considered it another phase that we'd probably get through like we'd gotten through other ones. Our daughter just started college a couple of weeks ago, and the house felt different without her, but I figured it would settle back to normal sometime. Until then, I'd just wait it out."

  "So you didn't want the divorce? On your own?"

  "I wasn't actively thinking about it before she mentioned it, if that's what you mean."

  Gina nodded. "Close enough. So you weren't fighting?"

  "No. She worked all the time and I mostly tried to keep out of her way when she was home. But we hardly talked enough to fight."

  Gina took a beat, then came out with it. "What about her sister?"

  Stuart's face went dark. "What about her?"

  "You and her."

  "What are you talking about? There's no me and her. Deb and I are friends."

  "Yes, I could see that. Your wife wasn't jealous of her?"

  "No. Or, at least she had no reason to be."

  "That's not the same thing. I'm just telling you that if you have been having an affair with your wife's sister, and it gets out, which it will if you were, it's going to cause problems."

  Stuart's voice went up a notch. "It wouldn't mean I killed Caryn, for Christ's sake!"

  But Gina needed to nail down this fact. She uncrossed her legs and leaned toward him. "So for the record, Stuart, your relationship with Debra is not now and never has been intimate?"

  "No. Yes. Correct, is what I'm trying to say."

  Sufficiently ambiguous, Gina thought, and nicely camouflaged. But she simply said, "Okay. Because if you were involved with her, it would be a very strong motive."

  "I just said I'm not."

  "I know you did." She stared at him and waited.

  He returned her steady gaze for several long seconds, unbending. Finally, he came forward on the couch himself. "Besides which," he said, "I was at Echo Lake when Caryn was killed, or died, or killed herself. I believe I've said this once or twice. So who cares what motive I might or might not have? I couldn't have done it."

  "Yes," Gina said. "I know that." Again she waited.

  "What?" he asked.

  "You're not going to like what I'm going to ask you next, and I want you to know that I'm not being accusatory. I'm trying to get my arms around where you are."

  This almost brought him to a resigned grin. "I think I can take it."

  "All right. If you still loved Caryn enough to say that you were committed to your marriage before she mentioned divorce on Friday, I'm just wondering about where you're putting any sign of grief. Are you sorry, or even sad, that your wife of twenty-some years is suddenly gone? Because if you are, I'm not getting much of a sense of it."

  "I told you. It hasn't sunk in yet. I'm probably in shock. I don't know how I'm feeling, to tell you the truth. Conflicted, I guess. Confused. If there's a book or something on proper feelings you're supposed to have when your wife dies, I haven't read it. I loved her once.

  We used to be great. Lately we haven't gotten along very well. Last weekend I finally let myself get pretty pissed off at her, and this morning I come home and she's dead." His shoulders sank as he sat back, rubbed at his cheek again. "You mentioned sad. I don't know if I'm sad. I don't know how much I'm going to miss her. I'm sorry if that's the wrong answer."

  "There isn't a wrong answer," Gina said. "And even if there were, that was a pretty good one. So what was it that made you stop getting along?"

  He barked a one-note, bitter laugh. "Everything. Money, issues with Kymberly, money, me, her, time. Did I mention money?"

  "What about money?"

  "She became obsessed with it. I didn't.
"

  "Obsessed how?"

  "The way people get obsessed with anything. It's all she thought about, cared about, worked on, you name it. If it wasn't going to make her money, she wasn't interested."

  "And you didn't feel the same way?"

  "Not even close." He held up a hand. "It's a flaw in my character, I know. And if you didn't know, she'd tell you."

  "Are you saying she complained about you to other people? In public?"

  "I imagine so. She complained about me to me enough."

  "But you weren't fighting? Were you ever tempted to hit her?"

  "Tempted? Sure. Did I ever? No. Let me ask you one: Juhle really thinks somebody killed her? He thinks this was a murder?"

  Gina nodded. "I got the very strong impression he's leaning that way."

  This gave Stuart a moment of pause. His eyes scanned the corners of the ceiling, then came back to Gina. "I'm starting to be pretty glad they talked me into you," he said.

  7

  Juhle got Gina Roake's message that she was representing Stuart Gorman, but couldn't do anything about it in the near term. He was only a few blocks away from the Travelodge, but he was on his way to Russian Hill to try to talk with some of the neighbors.

  He got lucky on his first try. Juhle was sitting in a breakfast nook, talking to Stuart’s next-door neighbor, Leesa Moore. Their conversation was competing with the low drone of a television set that sat on the kitchen counter next to the microwave, tuned to some talk show with a male host. Juhle had no idea who the host was or why anyone would want to listen to him talk to his similarly unfamiliar female guest about the details of the two months she'd apparently spent, from what Juhle could gather by half-listening, confined in a basement as a sex slave for three teenage boys in upstate New York.

  Leesa Moore was a well-preserved sixty-three-year-old who had lived in this house for twenty-six years, the last five of them alone after her husband had died. She was a retired schoolteacher who volunteered five mornings a week at a library branch in the Marina.

  "Especially this past summer," she was saying, "it seemed the fighting was just about constant."

  "Between Stuart and Caryn?" “Oh, yes.