Next Door Daddy

by Amy Brent

I started to see James around town. We went to the same gym and I’d see him jogging on the road the same time of morning that I was out. I always looked at his muscled legs and tight ass with hunger in my eyes. I even thought that I drooled sometimes. I never saw him look my way or acknowledge me and it made me want to try harder.

  I knew that Christmas coming. Daddy always threw a huge party at the mansion and invited the team and everyone involved with them as well as several other celebrities on Christmas Eve and I needed to up my game by then. He didn’t notice me right now and there was no other man that I wanted. I was working out a lot more and doing yoga before classes, just to tone up my already athletic body. The closer it got to the holiday, I had some more time off and I hit a salon one day when I was Christmas shopping for my family. I cut off my long hair to a long A line bob and added some caramel lowlights and lighter blonde highlights to the strands. It looked beautiful and I felt like a different person as I stared in the mirror. I left with a smile on my face and felt the eyes on me as I hoped that I could affect James the same way.

  I went home with all of my bags and unloaded them from my Lexus to the door before bringing them upstairs to my room on the second floor. I was the only one on my level and I had a lot of privacy. I unpacked the gifts and also a dress that I’d purchased for the party as I held it up with a smile. It was going to make everyone give me a second and a third look.

  I didn’t anticipate my parents cock blocking me.

  I was in the red dress with the spaghetti straps and tight bodice that ended mid-thigh with a sexy ruffle. I was doing yoga enough to have toned up enough to rock this outfit and I bought some makeup to make my eyes pop with a dark smoky look. My hair was sleek and soft around my shoulders, something that Mom had falteringly accepted after I explained that a friend wanted a salon day and I agreed. Wasn’t it cute?

  My glasses were on the dresser and I had my new contacts in and some stiletto black heels. I turned to leave my room and my father was staring at me with a deer in the headlights look. “Tory, what the hell is that you’re wearing?”

  “You look great too, Dad.” I smirked as I spoke and looked over his crisp suit as my mother walked in wearing something similar to my dress, except that it was silver. “Really? Did you see her dress?”

  “Tory, there’s so little to that. Don’t you want to cover up more?” She fidgeted and I looked between them.

  “Mom, I am turning twenty-one next month. I think it’s time that I start trying out something new. I’ve been a nerd all my life and I want to be a woman,” I told her as my eyes flashed.

  “Is this about a man, sweetie?” Mom asked and I rolled my eyes. They’ll never know the truth.

  “No, it’s about me. I want to have some fun with clothes for a change.” I spun around. “Everything is covered. Nobody is going to see any more than this, because that’s not what I’m looking for. I just want to change my style a little bit.”

  “Fine, just…be careful.” Mom turned and left the room on her own silver stilettos as Dad looked from the doorway to me.

  “Are you sure? You know who’s going to be here tonight and they don’t all have great reputations. I think I prefer the innocent version of my daughter, to be honest,” Dad told me as he came over and hugged me. “Prepare for your brothers to act like guard dogs.”

  “I know,” I replied as I added a layer of clear gloss to my lips and pulled my door closed behind me. They were likely at the bar in the game room and I smiled as I wondered if James would be here.

  We walked downstairs and I started to greet the arriving guests, feeling my parent’s gazes on me as our friends told me how different I looked tonight. They used words such as sexy, gorgeous, stunning and so many others that made me blush and thank them as my hopes rose higher. Would James think the same thing? I’d masturbated to him so many times in my room at this point that I forgot my own name sometimes and tonight was going to be the night I got him. I bought sex toys in the mail to use as I moaned his name night after night. I had to have the real thing.

  I was near the bar in the game room telling my brothers to stop acting like overprotective apes as I saw him enter, dressed in a sexy suit with his hair mussed perfectly. I made eye contact and watched his widen as he took me in with a hungry gaze. I excused myself from my brothers and walked across the room, lifting my head as I met his eyes and passed him with a brush against his body as I felt his erection. I felt my thong dampen as he inhaled my cherry blossom scent and walked up the stairs, offering him a fine view of my ass.

  I’d never felt so powerful in my life.

  CHAPTER 5

  James

  That little bitch had the upper hand. Seeing Tory’s body squeezed into that red dress with a hint of her cleavage made my body go rock hard, and I headed to the bar for a whiskey on the rocks to ease the tension in my body.

  I watched her at the gym for over a month now, working her body to perfection. I slipped in my fight to not want her more and more each time but reminded myself of what would happen if I took a taste of her. I jacked off nightly to try and work her out of my system. I fucked more women than I normally would, just to scratch the itch that Tory caused in my body but nothing worked.

  Tonight, I knew that I was damn close to giving in and I finished the drink in one burning gulp as I heard Gary’s voice. “James, good to see you. Thanks for stopping by.”

  There was a part of me that knew it was a bad idea. I’d seen Tory’s new hair and had a feeling that she was changing herself to be the woman that she hid until now. “No problem. I don’t have to be anywhere until tomorrow. How are you?”

  “Doing well,” Gary replied as some of the team came over and we started talking business. The team was heading to the Super Bowl and we were slotted to win. For the life of me, I could not focus on it. The Super Bowl was a dream of every coach and every team and I was thinking more about the girl in the red dress. The girl that was forbidden to me, that could take away all of those dreams. I asked for another drink and excused myself to get some fresh air outside.

  My skin was hot and I felt like my tie was choking me as I stepped out onto the extensive back balcony. It was cold but I needed the reality check and I stepped forward and leaned against the railing. I inhaled the cold air in deep breaths as I closed my eyes, downing the drink before I set it down on a glass table close by. I heard a door open and turned my head to see a woman silhouetted in the doorway in a dim light. It was Tory and she raised her arms over her head as I dragged my eyes over her body. “Hi, James. Having fun?” Her voice, mature over the last time we’d met, traced over my skin and I sucked in my breath.

  “Your dad throws a great party,” I offered as she laughed and stepped forward. I knew that the party was inside, several feet away from us. I think that she knew it as well and was working that in her favor.

  “So do I,” she offered as I shook my head.

  “You’re my fucking boss’s daughter, Tory. I can’t do this with you.” She smelled so good and I inhaled the sweet scent of her skin. Tory was right beside me now and I looked over her shoulders and down to the hint of cleavage that she was giving me. “You’re too young.”

  “I am old enough for you. I want to be dominated by a man that knows what he is doing,” Tory told me, slipping her hand in mine and pulling me over to the room she’d come from.

  “What is this place?” I asked as I looked around the room with a bed and some furniture.

  “One of the pool rooms as well as a guest room. We have many of them so nobody will think about coming out here and looking for us. Everyone loses themselves at these parties and there can be a lot of scandal that goes unnoticed.” Tory closed the door and walked towards me as she locked gazes with me in the light of the room. “My brother fucked an entire group of cheerleaders one year, one by one. I didn’t see them and nor did anyone else, but I heard about it the following month. They all think that I’m the nerdy girl that doesn’t notice anything, but I notice ever
ything.” She slipped her hand between my legs and found my cock hard and throbbing for her.

  “You were beautiful the first time that I saw you,” I groaned as her fingers tightened and stroked me. “Fuck, Tory.” I clenched my fists before I reached out and took her arms and forced her hands away from my body. “This is wrong. So wrong.”

  “It’s just one night, James. Nobody will ever know,” Tory’s eyes were alert as she stared at me

  I wrapped my hands around her body and pulled her close to me before I kissed her, feeling all of my inhibitions disappear as our tongues met in a wild dance. Tory groaned against me and nibbled at my lower lip as I cupped her ass and ground my cock against her. “I want to bend you over and fuck you harder than you’ve ever been fucked before,” I told her before I kissed her senselessly again. “I want that ass slapping against me as you scream my name.”

  “You’re the first person, James. I’m giving you my virginity tonight. I want it to be you that makes me come for the first time,” Tory said against my lips as I froze for a moment. “Think how tight I’ll feel around you.”

  I hadn’t had a virgin since high school and I swear that I hardened more as I plowed her mouth with my tongue. I pushed Tory back to the bed as I asked her if she locked the door and she cried out that as I found the zipper in the back of her dress. I pulled it down and the material pooled around her ankles as she shimmied her hips to force it to drop. Her full breasts were bare and small nipples hard for me as she slid her hands over her body to cup them.

  I stripped off my tie as I watched her and unbuttoned my shirt. Her eyes took me in hungrily and I slipped it off and loosened my pants before I stepped towards her.

  Our lips met as she wrapped her arms around my neck and fell back onto the bed. My pants were halfway down my legs and my cock pressed against her thigh as she rocked against me. Her pussy was hot and wet and I dragged my lips down her jaw and dragged my hardness against her needy folds. I sucked on her neck as she arched her back and pressed her hot nipples against my wife beater that I wore under my shirt.

  My desire for Tory released into an uncontrollable urge, leaving behind all sense and logic. I forgot that she was forbidden as I kissed my way down her body and dragged her skin between my teeth as she jerked against me. Her tits were pressed against me as I found her nipples and sucked hard as I pressed my cock between our bodies and fucked the lace of her thing. “James, oh God. I want you to fuck me so hard,” Tory begged me, sounding every bit the young woman that she was as I pulled up and looked at her.

  “Are you on anything?” I asked her in a hoarse voice as she nodded.

  “Bad periods. I’ve been on the pill since I was sixteen,” Tory told me as I slid my hands between her thighs and pulled off her underwear. She moaned as she spread her legs and I fingered her before sliding a finger into her tight entrance. “Make me come.” I stared at her as my thumb found her hard clit and stroked it as she dropped her head back.

  CHAPTER 5

  Tory

  The feeling of his hand stroking me and inside me was almost too much to bear as I closed my eyes. This was what I’d dreamed of as my own hand stroked my clit and slipped inside of me in the darkness of my room. I knew that I was close and I begged him to make me come as he increased the pressure against me. I hadn’t lied about the pill but I wouldn’t mind a mistake. I wouldn’t mind a future with James and give him a baby. I would just focus on this right now, this night. It was going to be perfect and memorable.

  James moved over me and kissed my neck as he whispered that he would move slow for me. I knew that he would take care of me and that was in part why I chose him, though I preferred older men to begin with. He lowered himself between my legs and spread me open as I cried out and tried to lift myself to him. He pressed against my entrance and I slid my legs around him and pulled him down to me for a long kiss. That was when he slipped inside, little by little, kissing me sweetly as our tongues slid together slowly.

  Oh God, the pressure. He filled me and I grabbed his head and strung my hands through his hair. “Are you okay, baby?” James asked me as I nodded and begged him to keep going. He just had to move a little further and the pain would be over and I could enjoy this. I could have my dream.

  There was a sharp pinch of pain as me moved forward and I cried out as he stilled and looked down at me before he kissed me again. “I’ll stay here for a minute. You feel so good around me and I know you will love this in a couple of minutes. Just bear with me.”

  “I know I will. Just keep going,” I urged him and sighed as he slipped further inside. Pain blended into pleasure and I was soon wrapping my legs around him and rocking against him to feel him deeper and harder. Oh God, it felt so good and I never wanted him to stop. I felt something snap inside of my body and I was crying out his name as I came long and hard. I didn’t want him to wait but he swore that I was going to come around him so he could feel me.

  I did.

  James kept moving until he stilled and I felt his heat filling me. He murmured that this was the best Christmas ever and that I was a great gift as he held me tight in his arms.

  James kissed my body as I stared at him and smiled. I knew that this wasn’t the last time that I would have him. I would make sure of that.

  We made love again, this time with me on my knees as he took me from behind. It felt so good and I gripped the sheet as he pounded into me. He was thick and I knew that I’d never want anyone different, at least until I got what I wanted.

  James realized the time after we rested together and stood to dress. He fixed himself as best as he could and hit the restroom that was closest to the entrance while I sat on the bed and played back my night. I had sex, sex with a real man that knew what he was doing. All of the changes that I made were worth it and I could feel that my life was about to change.

  I dressed and crept through the door that led to my locked room as I washed my face and took off my dress. The party was over for me and I got what I wanted. I smiled as I closed my eyes and snuggled under the covers, completely oblivious to the noise of the party. I looked forward to future times with James and the path that my life was headed as I drifted off to sleep with the cool air blowing in the cracked window.

  Our chef Mary was cooking breakfast when I woke up and made my way downstairs. The house was empty and messy and I looked around as she laughed. “I think there’s a few stragglers in the basement, though I’m not sure. If so, I’m making enough food.” I wondered if James was still here, what he’d done after our time in the guest room. Was he still thinking about me?

  I decided that there was no way that he couldn’t be after the way that he looked into my eyes as he was giving me my first experience with sex. James was so concerned with me and my feelings throughout the experience, so caring and good. It was perfect.

  I made plans for our future as I ate and looked over the pool before my parents stumbled downstairs. As always, they’d been drunk the night before and didn’t remember the small fight over my dress or the fact that I’d disappeared for the night. Nobody really remembered anything from our infamous parties and I’d planned my night based on that.

  It was easy to go with Dad to the stadium on my break for business that he had to attend to and I even agreed to work on some of his accounting since his normal accountant was on a month’s leave for the holidays. It was easy to me and I could come alone there when I needed to, or at least pretend to need to. Dad would never know.

  I also went to the gym a lot and waited to see James there so I could casually say hello. It took a week but finally, I saw him on the treadmill watching something on the television screen in front of him. I was just finished with my yoga class and I approached him as I forced a flirtatious smile on my face. “James, hello.”

  “Tory. Hi. How are you doing?” He looked me over in my tight pants and cropped tank top and I felt my body heat up inside.

  “Good. I just finished class.” I glanced at the clock and got an
idea. “Want to grab something to eat when you’re finished? I was busy today and never really got around to it.”

  His want was all over his face and James swallowed after a moment. “I don’t know if that’s a good idea, Tory.” He glanced around but we were alone and he licked his lips. “I don’t know if anything should ever happen with us again.”

  “Didn’t you like it?” I asked as his face flushed pink.

  “Of course, I did. I’m honored that you wanted me that way but your father would kill me if he ever knew.” James gave me a long look and licked his lips.

  “He’ll never know, James. Dad’s busy with the team and the investments that he’s always involved with. I get out on my own all of the time and I’d never tell him.” I looked around carefully. “I don’t want you to lose your job.” My words were low and he glanced around as he seemed to consider my words.

  “Give me your number,” James suggested as he handed me his phone. I sent myself a text so I’d know his number and he looked at me for a long moment. “I’ll send you my address and you can meet me there in half an hour? I’ll order in.”

  I grinned and nodded. “That sounds perfect. I’ll see you soon.” I made my way to the locker room and showered quickly before I changed into some skinny jeans and a long sleeved shirt before I pulled on my gray fleece jacket.

  By the time I was in my car, I had his address and I entered it into Google maps as I let the car warm up.

  CHAPTER 6

  James

  I must be out of my fucking mind. I should have told Tory no and that this could not happen again. My job was on the line if anybody found out and possibly my life, but the way she looked at me made me weak. I remembered how she felt, so tight and hot as I claimed her for the first time. I hadn’t had a woman for the first time in years and she addicting to me. I thought that once more wouldn’t hurt before she worked me out of her system and I could just go back to my casual flings.