Next Door Daddy

by Amy Brent

  I awoke to start thinking that I wasn’t alone and then I noticed that Joan had somehow gotten in without my permission. “I rang the doorbell several times. I thought something happened to you. I see that something did, but it’s not exactly what I was thinking.” She raised the stained material of my black dress from the floor on the toe of her very expensive shoes. “I would say that you had a bit more fun than I gave you credit for.” She was in a pair of jeans that molded to her body like a second skin.

  “I don’t need your permission to test my limits. You brought me there locked and loaded. What did you expect to happen?” I was only teasing her and there was no way that I could possibly keep a straight face.

  “Do you want me to guess, or are you going to tell me all the nasty details.” I saw that my window was open in my bedroom and one of my figurines had broken upon her entry. For an older woman, she was quite agile and had kept up a regiment every morning with a personal trainer.

  “I think that it goes without saying that I got lucky. I was left with a smile on my face and a need for a repeat performance. I’m going to be cooking dinner tonight and hopefully, I will be the one that’s in control of what happens after.” I was purposely leaving out the fact that it was three guys instead of one. She could believe what she wanted to. I’m usually more forthright and telling tales out of the school was not uncommon when we got together. Unfortunately, it was usually her tales with me living vicariously through her, but maybe the tables had turned.

  “I think that you are leaving something out. I’m not sure what it is, but I will find out. I’m just glad that you had fun and trust me I wasn’t exactly alone for the evening. College guys really do have the stamina to go all night long. I walked out of his dorm room with my heels in my hand and several guys giving me the eye. I do believe that I’m going to get my paramour to introduce me to some of his brothers.” The very thought of brothers brought to mind what kind of slut I was last night.

  I was tempted to tell her what had happened, but I kinda wanted to keep it to myself. It was the first time that I had a secret that I wasn’t willing to share and I found the idea of letting it all hang out like something that I would never have done under normal circumstances. It could’ve been some kind of nightingale syndrome from them coming to my rescue, but I think it went well beyond that.

  “Michelle, I know how it is to have secrets, but I think that it would make you feel better to get it off your chest.” She was doing her best to weasel information out of me, but I really was in no mood to play this game. “I don’t need the details. If this is something that you wanna keep to yourself, then do it by all means. Don’t let me pressure you. I do think that you have slept long enough and that we should get out there and enjoy this nice sunny day.” I couldn’t have agreed more.

  We went for a jog together and I felt energized, even though I had been fucked like nobody’s business last night. It gave me a sense of self and I found that giving the brothers license to have my body was making me want to do the same thing, but in reverse.

  I had never been one to ogle the merchandise, but today was a different story. Each time that a young man with a nice physique went by me, I would bite my bottom lip and feel my lips quivering. Those boys had awakened something and now that monster wanted to come out and play.

  “I know that look and believe me I was the one that invented the look. Whatever happened last night has opened you up to new possibilities and experiences. I say grab a spoon and dive in. You never know how long that feeling is going to last. For me, it’s every day of my life, but I’m not like normal and everyday girls. I tend to throw caution to the wind and do what feels right. It might make me feel empty afterward, but I always find someone to take away that loss.” I had never heard her talk about herself like this and it was a real eye-opening experience.

  “What I’m hearing you say is that you are ready for a commitment.” She stopped me and put her hand on my chest, which only exasperated my condition. “I didn’t mean to say anything, but do you hear your biological clock ticking? You always said that you wanted a big family, but you never found the right guy to settle down with. Perhaps, you need to be more selective and to get to know a guy before you jump into bed. I know that’s a novel concept, but it’s time to stop acting like you’re still 20 years old.” I had given her a little to think about and the look on her face was of shock.

  “On some small level that is exactly the way I’m feeling. Why is it that any time that I talk to you I always come back with something of a different perspective? You should probably take your own advice, but you’ve been living in the shadows away from the real world for too long. You let what happened with Joseph get the best of you. If this guy makes you happy, then I say don’t hold back and do whatever you can to hold on to that feeling.” Joseph was supposed to be the love of my life, but he ruined that by dying. It wasn’t his fault, but I still blamed him nonetheless for leaving me after only two months of us finding one another.

  “We were made for each other and I don’t think that I will ever find that kind of love. Any other man will pale in comparison. I really don’t want to put him in a position to feel like I’m not entirely invested.” We finally made our way back to my small home. We said our goodbyes and I knew that I wouldn’t be able to keep my so called relationship with the brothers under wraps for long. I had very nosy neighbors and one in particular that had a pair of binoculars that was always using them as if she was part of a neighborhood watch.

  I had a feeling that those boys would be arriving around 6:00 PM. It gave me enough time to shower. There was a moment that I thought I was going to take matters into my own hands. I stopped myself because I had other ideas that were just too delicious to pass up.

  I prepared the ravioli from scratch and it was the way that my grandmother taught me from the moment that I was old enough to pick up a spoon in the kitchen. I had her recipe and it was something that was passed down from one generation to the next.

  The pasta was cooking, the sauce was simmering and I had a medley of fresh vegetables ready to join the rest of the meal. I even made a Caesar salad, but I didn’t take them for the kinds of guys that would be interested in a salad.

  I went through my closet. I picked up the black dress and relived every single moment of last night. I smelled their manly aroma on the fabric and I stuck out my tongue to lick the stained material to bring back the memory of what they tasted like. Remarkably, they all had similar qualities and I had to believe that came from the same kind of diet that they had followed strictly. I still couldn’t believe that they lived together.

  I decided to make them my bitches and the best way to do that was to catch them off guard with something that was going to make them realize just what kind of trouble they were in. 4 inch red high heels accentuated my long legs that had been shaved to a smooth and baby bare texture. The red dress had a plunging neckline and underneath was a black widow outfit that was going to come in handy to make their tongues fall to the floor. I heard the doorbell and I knew that the night was young and things were going to get interesting in a hurry.

  Chapter four

  I wasn’t prepared for what greeted my eyes upon opening the door. They were all dressed impeccably in black suits and the only difference between the three was that Billy was wearing a blue shirt, John was wearing a white shirt and Sean was wearing a red shirt. It was the same color that I was wearing and that was not lost on him, as he took in the sight and gave me an appraising wink to tell me that he approved.

  “As promised, we brought the wine and I do hope that a Red Bordeaux will go with the meal.” It was obvious that John was more sophisticated and worldly. I think that I was going to have to grill him on his past and to find out more about these guys. I didn’t want to treat them like they were a piece of meat, although I’m sure that they wouldn’t mind. “Let me open it for you” Before he could walk past me, I took the initiative and jumped into his arms with my petite frame wra
pped around him like a boa constrictor.

  I left John stunned with my lipstick smeared across his mouth, as I swayed my hips from side to side to show them that tonight was going to be something extraordinary.

  They were ravenous at supper and I was playfully sucking my fingers of the sauce from my plate. All three of them were squirming in their seats. I had definitely started something that I was going to have to finish.

  “I hope that you have all left room for dessert.” Upon those words, I took a deep breath and steeled myself for what I was about to do. Taking a long swallow of the wine, I put it down and then I climbed up onto the table with my knees on either side of my forgotten plate. I slithered towards them with all three of them not able to blink or take their eyes off me for a single second. “I see somebody that didn’t get enough to eat.” I had zeroed my sights on John at the head of the table. I was soon positioned so that he would see that I wasn’t wearing any panties. He took a big breath and he most likely got the aroma of strawberries. I had taken the liberty of using a strawberry scented lube to get me ready for the festivities.

  He tried to move forward and grab my thighs, but I stopped him with my foot up against his chest. The stiletto heel was digging in to make my point. I had placed a black bag on the table and I knew that they were wondering what was inside, but nobody had the guts to ask. Had they even broached the topic, I would have changed the subject and let them believe that it was my business and none of theirs.

  I lifted my leg over the other and I pushed my hips out so that he was face deep in my ass. His tongue snapped forward, but I wasn’t going to allow him to turn me into a pile of jelly. I stood up, put my hand on his face, reached out, and did the same thing to Billy. “You boys are in for quite a treat and I’m feeling particularly nasty tonight.” I produced different colored scarves and neither one of them stopped me, as I tied them to the chair with knots that I had learned from sailing. If they tried to get away, those knots would only get tighter and cut off their circulation.

  Sitting back down on John’s lap, I ripped open his shirt and bit his nipples to hear him cry out with surprise. “You really do know how to make an interesting impression, Michelle.” I slapped him across the face. He looked at me and smiled. “I think I like this side of you.” I placed my finger on his mouth and I made him suck it back and forth to mimic what I had done to other guys in the past.

  “You’ll find that last night was the catalyst to how I’m feeling today. I plan to make the most out of my freedom. You took what you wanted last night and tonight it's my time. Not one of you is going to ruin it.” I made sure to rub up against him through his pants to get him bulging obscenely. He looked completely out of it and I don’t think that he liked that I got up and went to do the exact same thing to Billy. I ran my hands through his short-cropped hair and I kissed his mouth with my hand around his throat to let him know that I meant business.

  I ripped open his shirt and then I moved on to Sean who was trying to be the big man by breaking free of his bonds. He was making that chair bounce up and down in his eagerness to take me by any means necessary. “What’s the matter? Don’t you like being on the receiving end?” I sat on the table in front of him teasing him mercilessly and then producing a silver vibrator. “Don’t you wish that this was your cock?” I moved it back and forth in front of his eyes and then I stuck it in my mouth and let my spirit drool down the sides.

  I spread my legs and raised that dress, until he could see the garters and the painted lips of my pussy. I turned on the mechanism and it came to life with Sean grinding his teeth together in an obvious need to get off. “I’m going to tear you…” I stopped him by stuffing a blue scarf in his mouth and gagging him so that I didn’t hear his inflammatory comments.

  The buzzing of that toy gave me encouragement and I ran it up and down my slit to leave behind a wet trail all the way to my aching hole. “You are a bit of a chauvinist. This first orgasm is going to be by my hand and all of you are going to witness what a girl does in the privacy of her own bedroom.” I didn’t just slam it forward like they did the other night. I took my time and made myself into a private sex show for all of them.

  “This is cruel and unusual punishment, but I have to say that I like it.” John was being very calm, but I couldn’t help to notice that his cock was actually throbbing inside his pants. Having them a captive audience was making it easier to do things that were riskier.

  “Oh yeah…having all of you here and touching myself with this vibrator is driving me insane.” I used one hand to handle the toy and the other hand to manipulate my clit into complete submission. It wasn’t long before I was screaming and pounding my stiletto heels into the chest of Sean. Watching him uncomfortable was like an aphrodisiac that I couldn’t get enough of. “Yes…I’m cumming… I’m coming for all of you.” They could’ve taken that two ways and I meant it in both.

  I gave one final jerk against the toy before I pulled it out and moved the fragrance of my sex under Sean’s nose. I got a giddy thrill when he stuck out his tongue to taste me and to lap off my juices like that of a kitten.

  “I can’t believe that you just made me do that.” I smiled and placed the toy on the table before pushing Sean away from the table with the chair legs scraping across the wood floor. I looked back one time to see that I did draw the blinds. I didn’t want to give the old lady a heart attack. It was kinda fun knowing that nobody had any idea what was going on inside this house.

  “I wouldn’t worry about your masculinity, Sean.” I circled John, grabbing a fistful of his hair and hearing him gasp with his mouth wide open. It gave me more than enough incentive to climb up onto the legs of his chair. I was teetering on the edge and one wrong move could be fatal, but it was that risk of doing something wrong that made it feel right.

  “I know what you want and I don’t see any reason not to give it to you.” John was soon using his tongue once again. He was showing his expertise in this field. I had to hold on to his shoulders and it was a wonder that I didn’t collapse underneath my own impending climax. I stopped him before he could go too far. I landed heavily in his lap. I fished in between us to release him from his prison. He was still my prisoner, but his cock was released for good behavior. I threw my legs over the arms of the chair and then lowered myself very slowly with my hand wrapped around his neck.

  “I want you to beg me for it. I want you to plead and make me believe that this is what you want. If I don’t feel that you’re being truthful, then I will just leave you here with a case of blue balls.” I could see that he was contemplating showing weakness in front of his brothers. I had a feeling that the sexual pleasure was going to win in the end.

  “I want you to sit on my cock. I want you to slip that nice little pussy of yours down over me. I’m begging you for that sweet release that only you can give me. Please…don’t make me wait any longer and you’ve already driven me crazy. I don’t know what I will do if you leave me in this condition.” It was a good start. I wanted to show him that it was not always the girls that had to be submissive.

  I felt his knob begin to kiss my lips. I was already quite excited and I showed him by how easily he penetrated those first couple of inches. The head was bigger than the rest of his shaft, but after it was fully imbedded, it was easier to take that ride all the way down to the bottom. All the breath in my body came out of my lungs at the same time and I was literally on cloud nine. I used his shoulders to lower and rise with my eyes looking into his to see how hard it was for him to hold back.

  “Neither one of you are allowed to cum until I tell you to. If for any reason you do, then you are done for the evening. Trust me; you want to be a part of this.” I left him with the vein pronounced and the rest of his cock looking like it was going to take launch. “I have to wonder which one of you will fall victim first.”

  I did the same thing to Billy. He was a little bigger than his brothers were, but that didn’t stop me from bringing him to the brink and th
en stopping right there on the edge. He looked slightly stunned when I jumped off and left him with his mouth wide open. I was having the time of my life. Sean was going to be the biggest holdout. He didn’t like having a woman tell him what to do and it was about time that he found out what his victims had felt every single time that they found themselves underneath him in whatever position he wanted them.

  I turned my back on him so that he could see my hard ass converging on the object of my desire. I reached back and took out his cock. Without giving him warning, I took every single inch in one long drawn out moan. I stayed buried and moved in a circle so that he was hitting all of those special spots.

  I went back and forth from each one and I had to admit the idea of getting them all off at the same time was quite a thought that I couldn’t get rid of. I just didn’t know how I was going to make it work. They looked like they were beside themselves and especially Sean was giving me this evil glare. It was primarily him that I was trying to teach a lesson, but I think it was lost on him. The sentiment that I was trying to get across was that women should not be treated as objects of sexual desire. I was treating him like he treated every other woman, but I think he liked it.

  “You all have done amazingly well, but I wonder what you would do if I were to pull out all the stops.” I got down on my knees and I moved under the table where they couldn’t see me with the tablecloth obscuring their vision. “I see all of these cocks and I’m not sure which one should have the honor of getting my mouth. Each one of you will cum tonight and in different holes.” I think that my intention got the best of them and their cocks were leaking quite profusely. “That’s right; one of you will fuck my ass and fill it with cream. It’s just a matter of which one. I haven’t decided that yet and I guess only time will tell.”

  I turned my attention towards Sean and I slapped his legs with enough force to hear him grimace in pain. I raked my long clip-on nails down his thighs. I scratched through the material like a tiger after its prey. He was kicking out his legs and then I surrounded his knob with my mouth for a moment before popping clean. I crawled over to John and did the same thing and then Billy got the same treatment.