Town of Chance: Sweet Caroline [The Dare Series 5] (Siren Publishing Ménage Everlasting)

by Dixie Lynn Dwyer

  Hunter was fuming. He had his fists by his side and felt completely jealous.

  “Hunter,” she said his name, and when she touched his shoulder he turned around quickly, still feeling angry, but Caroline covered her face and ducked. It was worse than a sucker punch to his stomach.

  “Fuck,” he said and pulled her into his arms and hugged her tight. She was shaking as he caressed her back and calmed his anger. He scared the hell out of her. She would think he was like that dick who abused her. Damn it to all hell.

  “I’m sorry, baby. I didn’t mean to scare you. I’m angry,” he said to her. She pulled back and he cupped her cheeks and looked down into her glistening eyes.

  “I’m sorry, Hunter. Please don’t be angry with me.”

  “Shh, baby, I’m not angry with you. I’m angry with them. They’re over here being pushy, touching your hair and trying to get you to come to the beach with them. It pisses me off because you’re mine, and my brothers’. We care so much about you, and we’re protective of you, especially because we know what you went through. You deserve better than that. Hell, you deserve better than a man like me. I’m no good at hiding my feelings. I see men talking to you and I’m jealous because I don’t want to lose you and what we have. It’s a first for me, so I’m sorry if I scared you.”

  She smiled at him.

  “I think we both have a lot to learn. Maybe I can help you to not be so jealous and you can help me to not be so scared and afraid that you could strike me in anger because it became almost normal for Cameron to do to me.”

  He tightened his jaw. “We would never hurt you or strike you, not ever. Real men don’t do that. And of course I’ll help you. My brothers and I will help you any way we can.”

  “Okay then, so what’s the plan?” she asked.

  “Hmm, maybe a little make out session and then lunch?” he asked and she giggled as he sniffed and kissed her neck, tickling her before he moved to her lips and kissed her deeply. It upset him that she was so timid around those men, but more so that he scared her and she reacted by covering her face and turning as if ready to receive a strike from him. That just didn’t sit right at all with him. That was something he and his brothers needed to help her with. He knew in that moment that he cared for her even more, and would do everything in his power to protect her and keep her safe. Everything.

  Chapter 7

  C.J. picked Caroline up after work and brought her back to their house. He was feeling concerned, overprotective, and a little uncertain after Hunter explained what happened at the park and her reaction to him. It seemed she really was still living with fear that all men were abusive and could strike at any time. That wasn’t right. It angered him and he thought about the best way to approach this and to build her confidence and take away her fears. As he discussed it with his brothers, they decided to do their best to encourage her, to help her to see that she was no longer a victim, wasn’t weak, or easily overpowered. They needed to do it in a way that wasn’t controlling, commanding, or made to make her feel like they were trying to change her. It was tough, but she was worth it. They already cared so much about Caroline.

  When they arrived at the house, Hunter was cooking dinner and York was working but due home soon. As they gathered in the kitchen talking, C.J. watched Caroline. He took in the sight of her as she stood by Hunter, helping him slice up vegetables. She looked sexy as usual in the knee-length beige skirt that hugged her hips and the pink camisole that showed off her curvy figure. She was well endowed for such a petite woman. Watching her, seeing how tiny she was compared to Hunter made him feel very protective. Especially knowing that other men were trying to hit on her and stake a claim. Hunter also mentioned that one of the guys touched her hair and she didn’t press his hand away but lowered her eyes and her head in retreat and submission. That wasn’t going to happen again.

  He worried about her and although she had come a long way in the last month trusting them, opening up about her fears and what made her nervous or uptight, he wondered if he could help her feel more confident.

  “Hey, Caroline, do you know any self-defense moves?” he asked her.

  “Me? No, why?”

  “Oh I was just thinking that sometimes when people learn some self-defense moves it boosts their confidence and also lessens their own fears. Would you like to learn some?” he asked.

  She looked up at Hunter. “Go ahead. I’ll be in in a minute,” he told her and she smiled.

  C.J. headed into the living room. He took off his shoes and Caroline followed by slipping off her heels.

  “Okay, so what do you do if someone comes charging at you like this?” he asked and stepped toward her. She covered her face, turned sideways, and went stiff.

  He caressed her arms. “Not exactly. You should react with a countermove or stance to show that you’re not intimidated.”

  “But I probably would be.”

  “No, don’t have that attitude. Be assertive and strong. Believe in yourself.”

  She nodded. “Okay,” she said and he did it again. Each time he came at her, she did something different but ultimately it was a defensive move.

  But as they went over a few more, he couldn’t resist teasing her, slapping her ass, brushing his thumb along her nipple and finally tackling her to the rug.

  “C.J.,” she scolded when he had her on her back, her legs straddling him and her wrists above her head. By using one hand to keep her arms in place, he used the other one to tickle her. She screamed and laughed and wiggled so he lowered down over her and suckled her neck, tickling her even more.

  “What is going on in here?” Hunter asked and York joined him. He was pulling off his tie and undoing the uniform shirt.

  “Help me, Hunter. He isn’t playing fair.”

  “Oh really,” C.J. said and then suckled her neck and trailed his mouth deeper to her cleavage. He swirled his tongue into her bra and she gasped. Suddenly they locked gazes. “Feel good?” he whispered, feeling his cock harden. Caroline had to feel it to in this position.

  “Yes.”

  He slowly released her arms, letting his hands slide down from her palms, over her arms that she kept above her head, and to her breasts. He leaned down and kissed her lips and she ran her fingers through his hair. They explored one another’s mouths. They moaned and rocked their hips and then he ran his hand under her skirt along her thigh. He squeezed her ass cheek and shifted over her one thigh before maneuvering his fingers between her legs.

  “Open for me, Caroline,” he said against her lips. She was breathing rapidly, her lips full and wet, her eyes holding his. Slowly she opened and he wanted to scream for joy. He pressed fingers under her panties and against her mound.

  “C.J.,” she moaned and tilted her head back.

  He found her clit and played with it, stroking over it as York joined them on the rug.

  “I missed you, baby,” he said to her.

  She smiled at him. “I missed you, too,” she said. Her eyes welled up with tears. She looked so beautiful.

  “I love coming home to you like this, in my brother’s arms, him exploring your body. Do you like it?” he asked.

  “Yes.”

  “Good,” Hunter said and kissed her lips.

  C.J. lifted up and pressed her skirt up higher. He slowly pressed a finger to her cunt and she gasped.

  “Easy, baby, nice and slow. I bet you’re really wet. Is she really wet, C.J.?” Hunter asked and York bent down next to her on the other side.

  “Oh yeah, very wet.”

  “I wonder if her cream is just as sweet as she is?” Hunter asked.

  “Oh God, Hunter, please,” she begged and he cupped her cheek and chin and held her gaze.

  “Let us love you, baby. Let us take all the fear and the pain away forever.”

  A tear rolled from her eye. “I want to. I really want to try.”

  “Let go, sweetie. We’ll catch you,” C.J. told her and then he pulled down her panties before he lowered to h
is belly and explored her pussy with fingers and mouth.

  * * * *

  Caroline cried out her first release. She was panting and shaking her head side to side as all three men were feasting on her body. Hunter and York removed her shirt and her bra was open and hanging by her side. They used their mouths and teeth to stimulate her breasts which somehow made her cunt react, too.

  “I want to see you completely naked and spread out on my bed so I can explore every inch of you. Make love to us, baby. Stay with us tonight,” Hunter said.

  “Yes. I want to. I want to be with the three of you.”

  C.J. thrust his fingers faster and faster into her cunt. He alternated tongue and fingers and she kept coming and coming. She cried out again and he smiled at her softly.

  “You’re perfect and so responsive to my touch. You know that we care about you and want to protect you and keep you safe and well loved, don’t you?” he asked her as she held his gaze. He slid a finger from her pussy to her anus and pressed over it.

  “Yes, C.J. Yes, I know you do. Oh God, please. What are you doing?” she rambled as he slid his finger into her ass and used his thumb to stimulate her pussy lips.

  “Getting you ready, sweetness,” he whispered, holding her gaze. Hunter caressed up her thigh on one side and York was on the other. They both looked down to see what he was doing to her as they held her thighs open. She was so incredibly aroused, she was shaking with a mix of emotions. She was gripping their arms and tilting her head back panting.

  “Sweet, sweet Caroline, you are a gorgeous sight. How does it feel, sweetness? Tell us if you like the three of us touching you together?” York asked her.

  She looked at him and could see his desire, and the way he looked her body over in such a possessive manner but also as if he liked what he saw, like he couldn’t peel his eyes from her thighs and pussy. It did something to her. This was different, calmer, raw, unscathed by violence or power.

  “Help me, York. Help me to let go,” she begged. He and C.J. grunted, and when she looked at him she could tell he was biting his cheek and he seemed upset by her fear. Something told her that these three brothers could help her and had the ability to make things right.

  York lowered down and kissed her lips. “The three of us will. Trust us, Caroline, and I promise you’ll never feel alone again.”

  He covered her mouth and kissed her deeply as he slid his hand along her groin, touching her pussy on one side, while Hunter did the same on the other side, and C.J. stroked her ass and cunt two more times before pulling out his fingers. It was so wild, and she never felt as special as right now, or as desirable.

  “Come to me, baby.” C.J. said to her and opened his arms as he knelt in front of her. How could she resist? He was so handsome, so sexy and strong. Even though he was a law enforcement officer like Cameron, he was different, just like York was. They were good law enforcement. Loyal, patriotic, kind, caring and compassionate. They weren’t evil, manipulative or violent. She knew from their muscles and their confident personalities, that they were indeed resourceful and capable when pushed to the limit. It was a side saved for bad guys, and more than likely a side she hoped to never see.

  Hunter and York guided her up. When she went to C.J., he pulled her into his arms and hugged her tight. “I promise this will be perfect, but if you get scared, if you need more time, just stop us and we’ll wait until you’re ready.”

  She kissed his neck and loved him for the sacrifice he was willing to make. She licked his neck and nibbled his earlobe then whispered into his ear, “I want you now. Make love to me, C.J., I need you.”

  He lifted her up and carried her through the living room and up the stairs. Hunter and York followed. When they got to a large bedroom, they began to undress and C.J. helped her out of her bra. He stared at her body and licked his lips. “You have an incredible body, Caroline. You’re perfect,” he said and then wrapped his arms around her and kissed her deeply. He pressed her back until the back of her legs hit the mattress and she fell backward. He slid his hands up her thighs, spreading her.

  “Now where was I?” he asked before he lowered his mouth to her pussy and suckled her cream. When she looked at Hunter and York, both men were naked and both were sporting some hefty cocks. She felt a bit intimidated and Hunter crawled up onto the bed and held her gaze.

  “You can handle us because we’re meant to be together.” He leaned down and kissed her. He stroked his tongue into her mouth as C.J. lowered between her legs and feasted on her cunt.

  She felt the second mouth on her other breast and moaned into Hunter’s mouth. York sucked and tugged on her nipple, sending tiny spasms through her body. She rocked her hips and felt her cream release from her pussy. She wanted them. One after the next, claiming her, loving her, becoming a complete part of her. It was so scary how deep the emotions felt. A flash of concern that she may never be the same after today crossed her mind. What if she became possessive of them? What if she got so needy for them to be near her, inside of her, by her all the time that she turned them off? She couldn’t be clingy.

  Hunter released her lips and held her gaze.

  “Are you okay?” he asked her.

  She swallowed hard. “I feel so much, Hunter. I want so much and it scares me.”

  “Don’t feel scared. We feel the exact same way. Like if we aren’t right by your side, touching you, loving you, that we’ll feel lost and alone.”

  Her eyes widened. “You feel it, too?” she asked, hearing the shock in her voice.

  “Oh yeah, so very much. Hell, I could feast on these breasts for hours, doll,” York added and suckled her nipple then tugged.

  “Oh God, York.”

  Hunter caressed his thumb along her lower lip and she moaned softly from C.J.’s ministrations as well as from York’s tugs on her nipple. It was overwhelming.

  “Are you okay? We’re not going too fast? You’re not scared?”

  She took a deep breath and C.J. looked up at her as well as York and Hunter.

  “It’s perfect. I feel safer than I have ever felt before because of the three of you. Make love to me. Please make me all yours.”

  Hunter smiled.

  “With pleasure, baby,” C.J. said.

  “Condoms?” York asked.

  “I’m on birth control,” she told them.

  “Great, no barriers. We’re going to make you all ours,” York said and then lowered his mouth to her breast. Hunter lowered to her other breast and C.J. spread her thighs and aligned his cock with her pussy.

  “You’re ours, baby. It’s becoming official tonight.” C.J. held her gaze as he slid into her cunt, clenching his teeth, trying to go slow. She felt how big, thick, and hard he was as he stretched her inner muscles and they tried making room for him. When both Hunter and York tugged on her nipples hard she cried out and C.J. sunk the rest of the way in.

  “God damn, you’re so tight, baby. Holy shit,” he said as he gripped her hips and began to stroke into her. Hunter and York raised her arms above her head and kissed along her arms to her inner elbow to give their brother more room. She closed her eyes and cried out another release as C.J. gripped her hips and began to thrust into her over and over again. He felt so heavy, so big and sexy. She was completely aroused by him, by them and how they worked together, made love to her together. She was amazed by the connection she felt.

  “Look at me, Caroline. Look at me and come with me,” he said to her. She stared up at him, and Hunter and York released her arms and moved back. She reached up and caressed his chest, holding onto his shoulders as he lowered and thrust into her faster and faster. She widened her thighs, pressed her knees to his sides, needing, wanting all of him and she screamed out his name as she came. C.J. grunted and moaned then she felt his body shake as he came inside of her then hugged her close.

  * * * *

  C.J. kissed her everywhere he could. Her shoulder, her neck then to her lips then back over her chest and to her breasts. He suckled the ni
pple and she squirmed beneath him. The feel of her fingers running through his hair aroused him and gave him goose bumps along his skin. He lifted up, realizing how petite she was beneath him and how more protective and possessive he felt of her.

  “This is only the beginning. You’re mine and I’m yours. Always.” He pressed his lips to hers and when he released them she smiled as she let him get up and Hunter and York prepared to take his place.

  * * * *

  York slid between Caroline’s legs and hugged her to him. She wrapped her legs around his waist as he lowered over her and cupped her head and neck between his forearms. He used his thumbs to slide over her skin and cheekbone as he held her gaze. “You’re so strong and beautiful. I know it’s been rough, but I think you realize we could never hurt you,” he said to her.

  “I know you won’t. You make me feel so much. Everything but scared. It’s like the three of you are a protective barrier around me and nothing can get in. It’s amazing,” she said to him.

  “It’s special and we won’t ever take it for granted. Can you handle me, or do you need some time?”

  She shook her head. “I want to make love to you and then Hunter. One after the next so we’re one at the same time.”

  “Honey, you do know that one day we’re going to take you together?”

  He saw her cheeks blush and she nibbled her bottom lip. “I know, York. I want to. I want all of it.” He pressed his lips to hers and kissed her with all the emotion and desire he had inside. Then he slowly slid his cock into her cunt and she took him thrusting, moaning and relaxing her muscles so he could penetrate her fully.

  He eased up, releasing her lips and began a set of slow, deep thrusts. He locked gazes with her gorgeous sage-green eyes and cupped her breasts. “You’re so sexy and beautiful. I’ll never get enough of you, baby. I want to share so much with you.”

  “I want that, too,” she said and he stroked a little faster. He tugged on her nipples and then he just couldn’t take the sensations. He needed to find his release and to claim his woman fully. “Fuck I can’t take it. You feel so good.”