The Crossroads Duet

by Rachel Blaufeld

  “But why does he want us?” I asked. “I think you’re on to something,”

  “Eh, I’ve seen these types of pricks. They think they’re going to get a made-for-TV movie or whatever, and wait around for some fancy defense attorney to take their case pro bono. He’s biding his time, fixing his story, making friends and cleaning out his enemies. In other words, glossing shit up, Aly. He thinks he’s going to be a movie star, letting everyone in America hear his gospel.” Barry rolled his eyes and turned back to his newspaper, dismissing both my train of thought and me with a chin lift.

  Walking back to my office, I debated mentioning my concern to Barry, but decided against it. I was competent enough to handle this on my own. As I slid into my desk chair, my foot bumped against the hydrangea. Its scent reminded me of the man who sent it, sending waves of an unfamiliar feeling up and down my spine. Want? Need? Hunger?

  God, Aly. You’re losing it.

  Jake Wrigley was one step above a criminal, and I was a public defender who believed in justice. He drove a fancy car, and spent Christmas in jail for a bar fight. Honest to God, something was messed up there. But what did he mean when he said, “The girl’s not around anymore”?

  And what did that have to do with me? And my legs?

  The way he looked at me that night in jail, I felt like he was a giant mountain lion and I was his prey. A kitten falling for a big cat, and I was pretty sure that didn’t end well. Yet I couldn’t stop myself from Googling “Jake Wrigley and Fizzle Fitness” under the pretense of getting a phone number and leaving a message to thank him for the hydrangea.

  What I didn’t expect was to have several pages of results come up on Fizzle Fitness. Like Alice falling down the rabbit hole, I couldn’t stop from clicking on each and every link. There were two locations plus a third on the way, and review after review about how Fizzle was the “it” place to work out.

  Apparently they had state-of-the-art locker rooms and equipment, the best staff, and the hottest fitness instructors. Is that even a thing? Yelp loved Fizzle, the Pitt students claimed it was the place to be seen, and even out in the suburbs, the stay-at-home moms couldn’t get enough of their superstar trainer, Anthony. Photos of “Toned Tony’s” wicked gleaming smile and bulging biceps littered the page.

  Geez, their Facebook page had some thirty thousand likes. Did everyone in Pittsburgh work out at Fizzle except for me? I’d heard of it years ago, but it was like a cult or something now.

  I scrolled through the ABOUT US page on their website.

  Owner Jake Wrigley, a highly regarded baseball player while studying sports management at the University of Pittsburgh, has always been into fitness.

  That pretty much jibed with what he’d told me. What he didn’t say was that he employed a half dozen trainers at each location, plus a fabulously fit and peppy front desk staff, and a small army of spinning, yoga, and Zumba instructors. Bess Wrigley was listed as the company’s web developer, and I was curious how she was related to the man in question. I felt like I’d heard her name before.

  Then right there smiling at me from the center of one page was a photo of the ever-present bubbly blond cheerleader, Camper Shure, their marketing director. The girl’s photo mocked me, her affluence and perkiness evident in her perfectly straight white smile. Her eyes told me she was a satisfied woman; by her boss, no less. But he claimed she was “no more.”

  My God! I dropped my head into my hands. How could he be ogling my legs when he spent all day around fit, gorgeous women? I ran stairs and jogged around the track. I didn’t do Zumba or even know how to work an elliptical.

  My manners urging me to call and say thank-you warred with my insecurities. There was no way I could compete with the beauties who paraded through his life, day in and day out, and I didn’t even know if I wanted to. I felt myself reaching for my cell phone despite my heart pounding out a staccato beat against my silk blouse, and my head aching from thinking too hard.

  “Fizzle Fitness, city location,” a perky voice said. “Are you ready to get pumped today?”

  I imagined it was the tall, lanky one with shiny, straight brown hair I’d seen in the website photos who answered the phone.

  “Hello, I was hoping to leave a voice mail for Mr. Wrigley.”

  “Um, hold on one sec!” Ms. Pep-in-her-step said.

  I sat there listening to the Katy Perry blaring in my ears while I was on hold, chiding myself for being an idiot, and urging myself to hit END CALL.

  Peppy Girl came back on the line. “Mr. Wrigley doesn’t use his voice mail, and he’s over at the new site. Is this important? Can I help you?”

  “It’s no big deal, perhaps I’ll try again—”

  “Oh, wait!” she blurted, interrupting me, then it sounded as if she put her hand over the phone, but I could still hear her clearly. “Jake! Phone’s for you, wanted to leave you a message. I didn’t tell her you didn’t know how to work your voice mail or even set it up.” She laughed, her voice going all breathy, and even through the phone I could tell she was flirting with her boss.

  In the background, I could hear Jake say, “Cut it out, Chloe. This is a business, not a sorority house.” Then his rumbling voice was in my ear. “Hello?”

  He’d just told poor Chloe off and grabbed her receiver. I pictured him standing at the front desk of Pittsburgh’s Most Popular Gym for the last three years running, waiting for me to respond, and all of a sudden the hilarity of what I was about to do hit me. A tiny giggle bubbled up my chest and I pushed it down, clearing my throat as I reached for some decorum.

  “Hello?” he said again.

  “Hi, Mr. Wrigley. It’s Aly Road.”

  “Excuse me?” The phone receiver rustled as it was moved. “Can you all quiet down? I can’t hear the phone.”

  “It’s Alyson Road . . . from jail.” I whispered the last word, instantly regretting that I chose that as how to describe myself.

  “Hey, it’s Jake. What can I do for you? Did you decide to take me up on my offer for a free membership? It still stands.”

  I gripped my forehead with my palm. Calling him was such a mistake. “I just wanted to say thanks for the plant. It really wasn’t necessary.”

  “Oh, it was. But you don’t need to thank me for a thank-you gift, Aly. Is that okay? For me to call you Aly?”

  “Um, sure. Okay, so thanks,” I said, injecting finality in my tone as I tried to end the stilted conversation.

  “Hey, can you hold on one sec?”

  “Okay . . .” I drawled out the word uncertainly, but what I really wanted was to hang up. What else was there to say?

  I was back on hold, this time forced to listen to some crazy hip-hop that pummeled over the line. I was trying to tune out the constant blaring of what sounded like “pop that pussy” when Jake came back.

  “Hey, I’m back. I’m in my office now. Sorry for all that mix-up. Listen, good thing you called, saves me a trip to the county building. I was going to ask you to dinner. So, what do you say?”

  “Um, Mr. Wrigley—”

  “Jake, remember? I’m not in jail anymore, and you’re no longer an attorney on my case.”

  “Jake, I don’t know. I still don’t think it’s appropriate.” My palms were so sweaty, I ran them one by one along my skirt to dry them, having to shift the phone from hand to hand while I did, but it was futile.

  “It’s just dinner. We started out on the wrong foot and we keep running into each other, so that’s got to mean something, right? Let’s get together on purpose, Legs.”

  “You just like my legs.” Holy shit! Where did that come from? I was flirting with him, egging him on.

  “Well, yes, definitely that too. Why do you think I offered you a membership the first night we met? We need more of those legs in my gym.”

  I felt the blush creep up my pale skin all the way to my forehead. Forget my face, I was seriously burning all the way down to my core. What the hell was I doing? I was supposed to be preparing for the case of m
y career, and instead I was flirting with a guy I met in jail—who did happen to look amazing in ratty jeans and a tight Henley.

  “I’m sorry for bringing that night up again,” I said hesitantly. “That was really inappropriate of me. You weren’t charged with anything, and I shouldn’t hold it against you. Professionally, I mean.”

  “Aly, we’re on the phone. I’m a man and you’re a woman. We’re not discussing business or law, or any of that shit. I’m trying to ask you out on a date. Drop all the professional stuff. So, how’s Thursday?”

  “Well . . . ”

  “No well. Say yes.”

  “Yes. Okay.”

  I was going to hell. With one quick phone call, all my promises to put my career first and never to get involved with the cool kids went out the window because clearly Mr. Wrigley was already interrupting my work. And according to the Yelpers of Pittsburgh, he was most certainly a cool kid.

  “Great! I’ll pick you up at seven. I already know where you live, so don’t come down. I’ll come up and get you. What unit?”

  “Not going to be that easy, Jake. I’ll wait in the vestibule.” Vestibule? More like an ant-filled hole-in-the-wall.

  “Just wait inside safely then. And here’s my direct number . . . ”

  He rattled off his cell number, and like I did it all the time, I gave him my number. With that, we hung up with a plan all set for Thursday.

  The cool kid and me!

  Poor, dirty, geeky, stuck-in-the-corner Aly Road.

  Jake

  “Dude, get off my site. We’re done, you got me? Fucking done.”

  My biceps flexed under my thermal shirt, ready for a rumble. This ass was testing my patience. He’d defaulted on every item in our deal, and Lane wasn’t here to negotiate or sweet-talk him off the property, so I was handling shit the way I normally did. With brawn and a few threatening dirty looks.

  My soon-to-be ex-contractor glared at me. “That’s bullshit. Fuck you. I’m building your muscle house as fast as I can, dude.”

  “Not fast enough.”

  When I puffed out my chest and got up in his face, he shoved me backward. Good thing that my new foreman, Jax, was standing behind me. He caught my aggressive ass and held me in a lockdown.

  “You’re through,” I told the piece-of-crap contractor, and kicked some dirt up with my foot to emphasize my point.

  “I should call the cops,” he shouted as a little spittle ran down the side of his mouth.

  “But you won’t,” I tossed back. “You got a record a mile long, so get the hell out.”

  Lucky guess. Took one tough guy to know another. I watched the loser kick the door of his truck before climbing in, and then he tore out of the parking lot, kicking up gravel as he did.

  Jax and I had visited the site the night before and he was up-to-date with what I needed, so I headed out and left him to it. I had another project to attend to; I was a regular businessman now.

  The thought made me laugh to myself as I rumbled down the highway in my Hummer. The Bimmer was gone, and I was now the proud owner of a new venture. Another step toward ridding myself of the heavy burden on my back that I was chipping away at bit by bit. I didn’t deserve full forgiveness, but at least I could salvage a small piece of my heart.

  My phone rang, interrupting my pride fest.

  “Yo, Bess, what’s up? All good?”

  Without even a hello, she went right for the jugular. “I told you not to get involved with her, didn’t I?”

  I was an idiot. Rather than punching the dash and veering my car into oncoming traffic, I slapped my hand against the steering wheel. I should have known Camper would go to Bess and play the poor victim. I was so damn angry with myself for ever starting with the bitch, and of course my sister-in-law was right to say I told you so.

  “Bess, babe, she’s cray—the crazy kind of cray—and she knew what she was getting into. I’m not a commitment man like my brother.”

  She laughed. “He wasn’t a commitment man either, if I recall. All it takes is the right girl. But Camper wants it all on a silver platter, and I told both of you to let it be.”

  “Well, it’s not within Camper to listen. That girl can be so freaking fake. You don’t even know the half of it. She’s pissed at you now too, by the way.”

  “I know. She called me with her pity-party-for-one, wanting to know how I ended up happy and she didn’t.”

  “Because she’s always trying to trade up, looking for an edge. You need to cool it with her. She’s not a good friend, Bess.” I flicked on my turn signal and took the next exit, veering right toward my destination.

  “I hear you, Jake. But you didn’t listen either. I’ve got your best interests at heart, not because you’re my brother-in-law but because I love ya. Who rescued me when everything went south with AJ? And who got Lane and me to see clearly? You.”

  “Bess, don’t get all mushy on me,” I said while sitting at a stoplight.

  “Seriously, what about you? You doing okay? Lane said you’re still in therapy. Are you feeling any better?”

  “I’m good. Better than ever. Honestly. In fact, I gotta go because I got something new going on.”

  “Come visit soon?”

  “Yeah,” I said before ending the call.

  As far as sisters-in-law went, Bess could be nosy, but her heart was in the right place. At the very least, it wasn’t covered in muck like mine.

  At a few minutes before seven, I pulled my Hummer up to the curb in front of Alyson’s building and hopped out. Running my hands through my wet hair, I ran up the steps and threw open the door to find my date leaning against the banister at the back of the hallway.

  “Hey, Aly,” I called out, feeling like Rocky Balboa when he yelled, “Hey, Adrian!” He was a stupid jock, his only asset his strength, and she was a gorgeous, classy specimen of a woman.

  I loved the way Alyson’s nickname rolled off my tongue like an ultra-smooth Scotch after a long day at work. It coursed through my body with the satisfaction of sliding deep inside a woman splayed out on silk sheets.

  The girl was too good for me, but Jesus Christ, I couldn’t help but want her anyway. I had brute strength and power, but I didn’t have a heart worthy of giving to a girl like her. I’d have to settle for doing something worthwhile for the lady, and if we ended up with a little time between the sheets, who was I to say no?

  I took a glance around and said, “Let’s blow this joint.” Her apartment building was even seedier on the inside than on the outside. I needed to get the hell out of there quickly because if we stayed there one more second, I was going to throw the chick over my shoulder and never bring her back.

  “Okay,” she said softly. The tough lawyer from jail was gone, leaving behind a woman who looked extremely nervous. If I had to guess, this lady was married to her career. Dating took a backseat—the way-back row—to the initials after her name.

  I held the door open and Legs walked through, her dewy scent tickling my nose as I took in her curves, and just like that my cock joined the party. Down, boy, I instructed, but it seemed as though my dick had a mind of his own. Before joining Aly outside, I turned back toward the building and adjusted myself, pretending to be careful not to slam the door closed.

  “How do you feel about sushi?” I asked, my words tumbling out faster than I wanted as I ran past her down the steps to open the truck door for her. My grandmother taught me that move.

  “I like it,” she said with a small smile. “I’m not as adventurous as most, but I can make my way through a few rolls.” She slid her legs into the Hummer, barely needing any help to hop inside, and I leaned over to buckle her in. “I can do it myself,” she said as she batted my hand away, and her feistiness made me smile.

  I walked around the front of the vehicle and hopped inside, threw the transmission into DRIVE, and asked, “All set?”

  My heart was beating faster than during any workout. After all, I’d never been much of a “dater.” I was more into f
riends with benefits and one-night stands, but Alyson wasn’t that type, and I didn’t want her to be.

  “All good. New vehicle?” she asked, stroking a finger along the leather interior.

  “Nah, this is my regular ride. In fact, I unloaded the other one this week.”

  I pulled away from the curb and headed back toward town, thinking the sushi bar at one of the local luxury hotels would be both romantic and fun. What the fuck did I know about dating?

  “Oh,” she said, then looked out the window without saying anything more.

  There was a brief silence, and I needed a filler. It was too soon to toss out what I planned to say later in the evening, so I went for plan B.

  “I got a little surprise for you.” I hit the touchscreen for the radio and hit CD. The disc dropped into place and skipped to track three. The drumbeat kicked in and the lyrics followed behind.

  “I’ve lost my mind on what I’d find, and all the pressure left behind on Allison Road,” blared through the interior of the truck.

  I caught Alyson pursing her lips out of the corner of my eye, and at first I felt as if I’d fucked up, but then she burst out giggling.

  “I thought you hated this song?” she said, mocking me with a raised eyebrow.

  “It’s my new favorite,” I teased back, and soon there was no more awkward silence.

  “Turn it off,” she said with a dramatic, yet good-natured grimace. “What do you normally listen to?”

  “Rock, some hip-hop, and Miley Cyrus.”

  “Stop!” She let out a belly laugh, clutching her stomach.

  Her smile was wide, and her glossy lips tempted me. If her laughter didn’t sound so fucking great, I would have shut her up with my own lips. It had been a long time since I’d heard honest-to-God real laughter.

  “Go ahead,” I told her. “Put on whatever you like.”