Big Catch

by Cathryn Fox

  Ty stands, positions his cock at her mouth and holds her shoulders as I lift her over my cock. I let her drop an inch, and she squirms, trying to sink my entire length inside her.

  I hold her and control the depth and penetration, as Ty rubs his cock inches from her mouth. She’s so goddamn tight, my cock is aching, and it takes every ounce of restraint I have not to pull her down hard and seat myself high inside. Moving with purpose, I slowly give her inch after inch until she’s squirming, her hair falling over her shoulders as she rocks against me.

  “More,” she cries out, and when I hear the need in her voice, it snaps the last vestige of my control.

  My body breaks out in a sweat, and my heart crashes as I piston upward. I grab her shoulders and push her down. In one quick thrust, I’m all the way inside her, going so far and deep, I’m sure I’ll be lost in her forever. Yeah, losing myself in her forever would be damn sweet.

  Wait, wait, wait. Once again, I’m forced to remind myself Ty is the one looking for forever, not me.

  She rides me, and as pleasure grips my balls, I lose my train of thought. “Fuck, yes,” I cry out as her hot heat singes me. I slam deep and fast as flames surge through me. With her bottom cushioned against my pelvis, I lift her again, pushing her forward slightly, and with each movement she takes Ty’s cock into her mouth.

  “You feel so good, Aly,” I whisper, and Ty and I groan at the same time. “Do you like sucking Ty’s cock while I fuck you with mine?”

  She writhes on top of me, her head bobbing in answer to my question. I exchange a look with Ty, and he holds the back of her head to balance her. I love the way he takes care of her as I drive harder, faster. But despite my depth of penetration, I still can’t seem to get deep enough. Her entire body shudders around my cock, her hot release burning my balls.

  I pinch my eyes and struggle to hang on as Ty gives warning, “Alyssa, I’m there.”

  Her head bobs, and Ty curses as he shoots off into Aly’s mouth, and as he lets go, her sweet cunt tightens even more around my cock. Tension builds, comes to a peak, and a growl I have no control over rumbles from the depths of my throat.

  Tyler drops to his knees, and sweet Aly glances at me over her shoulder, her hot mouth wet from Ty’s release. The desire reflected in her eyes becomes my undoing. I bury myself deep in her hot, silky heat, throw my head back and let go. A tremble racks my body at the onslaught of pleasure.

  As I release high inside her, one of her hands goes to Ty’s head, holding him to her, and the other hand goes behind her to touch my stomach. While the joining is physical, the connection is emotional. Her soft, intimate touch sweeps through me, and I note the strange shift inside me. I glance at Ty. Judging by the way he’s looking at Aly, he feels it, too.

  What the hell just happened?

  Chapter Four

  Alyssa

  As my body and brain come back to earth, I look to the left then to the right to take in the warm bodies brushing against me as they snore softly. I stretch, every muscle from the top of my head to the tips of my toes reminding me of the incredible night with Tyler, and the mind-blowing morning with him and Bray. I’ve always lived life by the straight and narrow, but with these guys, I was anything but. Heck, I was twisted and turned, and put into back-bending positions that gave me pleasure unlike anything I’ve ever felt before.

  I shake my head, incredulous at this turn of events and the way these two men were able to put me at ease. Seriously, though, I can’t freaking believe I just slept with two men—two men who’ve obviously shared women before, judging by the comfort they have with each other and how naturally they fell in time together.

  Honest to God, if that’s not epic, I have no idea what is. As I look at the two men, it’s no wonder I made the mistake of thinking Tyler was Braydon. They have the same haircut, mannerisms, and identical, athletic frames. But when the sunshine had slanted across the wall during our play, I could see that Tyler’s eyes were dark chocolate while Braydon’s were ocean blue.

  Am I upset for going into the wrong room? Honestly, I can’t say that I am, even though this is so not like me. I should be embarrassed on some level, but I’m not. What would the girls back home think—that I’m a dirty girl, or one hell of a lucky one? I’m going with the latter, and if I have it my way, I’ll go with the latter for my entire two-week vacation, providing these men want me again. That thought gives me pause, and a moment of self-doubt.

  Most guys see me as a white coat and stethoscope, not a woman—probably because I’m married to my job. Although, I must say I’m tired of the bureaucracy crap at work—management wanting us to move patients through like a Starbucks drive-through. And then there are my folks, who guided me toward a medical degree because my father is a surgeon, my older brother Jacob a specialist with a private practice in Manhattan, and my mother a hospital administrator with a plush corner office. They can’t accept that I want to be in the emergency room trenches.

  When are you going to do something more with your life?

  Oh, but I just did.

  I grin as I glance at my two guys.

  My two guys?

  Well, today they are, anyway.

  What will happen when they awake? Will there be awkwardness between us? Will they want to do this again, or was I just their catch of the day, so to speak? The truth is the men I have been with rarely stayed around long, leading me to believe they see me as a hit it and quit it kind of girl. Nervousness trickles through my veins, and my heart beats a bit faster. Should I leave now before they awake? As I mull that over, I fidget and toy with the bedsheets.

  “What is going through that pretty head of yours?” Braydon asks, and I nearly jump six feet in the air at the sound of his voice. “Hey,” he says, a new tenderness in his tone as he goes up on one elbow and brushes my hair from my face. His hands are so soft and caring that my throat tightens. No one has ever touched me with such care, but Bray and Ty…well, it’s a little insane what their worshipping touch does to me. Shit. Shit. Shit. This is an affair, and I should not be letting myself feel or think there is more going on here. “I didn’t mean to startle you.”

  My racing heart slows. “I’m always jumpy.”

  “Last night and this morning didn’t help?” he asks. At first, I think he’s teasing me, but I don’t see a trace of humor on his handsome face. And why is there such concern in his eyes if this is just about sex? Dammit, there I go overthinking everything again.

  This is sex, Alyssa. Don’t lose your way and think it’s more.

  “It helped. A lot,” I say, my entire body buzzing to life as he continues to touch me.

  “Good.” He runs his knuckles along my chin and down my arm. As my body responds physically to his touch, I try to remain detached, a difficult task considering the attentive way he’s gazing at me and showing such concern.

  “You have the most beautiful body,” he says.

  “So do you.” I slide my hand across the mattress and touch the hot male still asleep—needing the connection with him, too “So does Ty.”

  My nipples tighten painfully, and I can’t believe there isn’t an ounce of awkwardness between us. How can I be so comfortable with this man and his friend? “You need to find a way to relax, Alyssa. Shut that brain off for a while, and don’t think, just feel.”

  “You’re right. I overthink everything.”

  “Believe me, I know where you’re coming from,” he says, and I nod in total understanding. After all, I was the attending physician that day he was rushed to the hospital. “Tell you what—while you’re here, how about no thinking. Just having fun.”

  “Fun is good.”

  A grin full of sensual promise spreads across his handsome face. “Tyler and I will be happy to help with that.”

  “Happy to help with what?” a sleepy Tyler asks from beside me.

  “To show Alyssa how to relax and have some fun. Show her what she’s been missing out on.” Blue eyes full of gentle concern move over my face.
Jeez, when he looks at me like that, it makes my heart trip up. Careful girl, don’t go and do something stupid like fall for one of these guys.

  Lord, that’s two times in as many minutes that I’ve had to lecture myself. I could be in real trouble. “Let us take care of you while you’re here.”

  “And wouldn’t you know it.” Tyler throws his sheets off to expose his erection, a huge grin on his face. I love his playfulness, and get that he’s the joker of the two. “I’m totally equipped to help with that.” He shimmies closer until his erection is pressing against me.

  “Oh,” I say, my body warming all over again.

  Tyler laughs, and in a move I’m growing familiar with, pushes his mussed hair from his forehead. “Oh? That’s all I get?” he asks.

  Braydon and I laugh with him. “That’s all you get,” Braydon says, a crooked smile softening his features. “Time to nourish the sweet doctor.” Braydon looks past my shoulder and zeroes in on Ty. “It’s Becca’s day off and your turn to cook.”

  “I’m on it,” Tyler says and kicks the blankets to his feet. I stare at his gorgeous body as he rises and moves about the room without a hint of modesty. He tugs on a pair of jeans and foregoes the shirt.

  I let my gaze roam over him, appreciating him like he’s a fine piece of art, and with his body and finely tuned muscles, he’s so much better than any sculpture I’ve ever seen. My fingers tingle as I take him in, and when he turns and catches me admiring his frame, he gives me a big smile and sinks to the bed beside me.

  He touches my face softly, and my heart misses a beat. “What do you like for breakfast?”

  “I…anything is fine.”

  “How about pancakes?”

  “Sure.”

  “Try not to burn them this time,” Braydon says.

  “Don’t listen to him.” Tyler shoots me a cocky grin. “He’s just jealous because I can do everything better than he can.”

  “Fuck off,” Braydon shoots back.

  Loving the teasing camaraderie between these two, I poke Tyler’s chest and say, “I wouldn’t say you’re better at everything.” Braydon laughs, and when Tyler feigns hurt, I add, “I’d say you’re equally as good.” It’s true—they were completely on par in the bedroom, and both had given me the best, hottest sex of my life.

  “Okay, I’ll take it,” Tyler says, and catching me by surprise, kisses me deeply. “You’re incredible, Alyssa,” he says, his voice so goddamn soft and tender, my heart trips up.

  When he jumps from the bed and leaves, I turn and catch the way Braydon is watching me, those blue eyes of his moving over my face like he can see deep into my soul.

  “So, it was me you wanted to fuck last night, huh?” I look down as a wave of embarrassment moves through me. He slides a finger under my chin and nudges it up until my eyes are locked on his. “Hey, don’t be embarrassed. Not with me, or Ty. Here on this island, you can let go, be whoever you want, and do whatever you want. I love that you own your sexuality, and you should never be ashamed of your needs.”

  I nod, and as I let his words sink in, I say, “I was waiting for you to put the fire out last night. I watched you, or rather Tyler, slip into this room.” I stare into his eyes. What is it about this man—these men—that makes me feel so at ease that I’m able to tell them anything? Must be their laid back, easy going vibe. Moving here was obviously the best thing for them. Going for full disclosure, I add, “I wanted to go out with you last year when you asked. I was just so busy.”

  “I thought you weren’t interested.”

  “I was. My job, you know. It eats up all my time. Plus, you were my patient.”

  “I’m not anymore,” he says with a grin.

  “I know.”

  His smile fades. “If you don’t like something, you should change it.”

  “That’s just it. I do like what I do. Just pressures from administration, family.”

  “Ah, I know all about pressure from the job.”

  I think about his trip to the ER. “Yeah, I know you do.”

  “What about your family?” he asks.

  I let loose a sigh, not wanting to ruin the moment by digging into that can of worms. “Can we talk about something else?”

  “Sure, how about we discuss how much you wanted me,” he says, and I sense that he’s trying to lighten my mood.

  “Want, not wanted,” I tease in return.

  “And Ty?”

  “Want,” I say again. He grins. “Can I tell you something?”

  He brushes his hand over my chin. “Anything.”

  “I think I might have been sent here to your villa on purpose.”

  His brow pulls together. “Really?” He looks down like he’s deep in thought. “Does it have something to do with that pact you didn’t want to talk about?”

  “Yeah. You see, my friends and I all put our names in a hat on New Year’s Eve two years ago. We drew, keeping it a secret, and on the month of our twenty-fifth birthday, we receive a dossier with all the things needed for an epic adventure.”

  “Explain ‘epic.’”

  Leave it to Braydon to pick up on that. The guy is astute, that much is for sure.

  “Sex,” I say. “We’re not supposed to come home until we’ve have epic sex.”

  He gives a low slow whistle, his head going from side to side. “Talk about pressure.”

  I run the bedding through my fingers. “Yeah, I know. I never even thought I—”

  He cuts me off. “Not for you, sweetness. For Ty and me.”

  I laugh, loving how he calls me sweetness and Ty calls me sweet thing. “Ah, I think we’ve already achieved epic, Bray.”

  He frowns. “When is your birthday?”

  “Tomorrow, actually.”

  His head comes back with a start. “Yeah?”

  I nod. “Yup.”

  He goes quiet again, and I poke his chest. “What’s going through that pretty head of yours?” I ask, shooting his words back at him.

  “You’ll see,” he says, a wicked, mischievous grin on his face.

  “Um, should I be scared?”

  The blue of his eyes deepens. “Never of me,” he says quietly, and my heart misses a beat. “Or Tyler.”

  “Okay,” I say. While I might not have known the men long, this morning’s shared intimacies, and the way they both took such great care with my body, created a trusting bond between us. And that’s a bit terrifying for me because it’s going to make walking away a whole lot harder.

  “Come on. Let’s get a shower then head down to eat. Tyler should have the pancakes done by then.”

  He captures my hand and leads me to the shower. We both climb in like being naked under the hot spray together is something we do all the time, like it’s the most natural thing in the world. It might not be, but it’s damn nice, and I plan to enjoy every second of it. Broken heart be damned.

  Bray positions me under the spray and grabs the soap. He lathers his hands and places them on my body. “Sore?” he asked.

  “Yeah, a bit.”

  He cringes. “Were we too rough?”

  “Nope. It was perfect, Bray.” My heart thuds, the closeness, the connection I feel to him in such a short time, a little hard to comprehend. Bewildering or not, it’s still there, tugging at me. Lacking any sort of inhibition, I go up on my toes and place a soft kiss on his mouth. His breath seems to stall as his eyes meet mine.

  “What was that for?” he asks softly as he spins me around, securing my back to his stomach as one soapy hands goes to my stomach.

  “For—”

  “Never mind,” he says, his other hand going to my shoulder to pull my hair back. He presses his mouth to the sensitive spot on my neck. “You don’t need a reason to kiss me. Let’s make that a rule. Kissing whenever we want.”

  “I like that rule.” His hands slide slower, and one glides between my legs. “How about touching when and where we like, too?”

  The vision of Braydon and Ty touching me in public for all to
see races through my mind. Why the hell does that idea excite me so much? I used to be straight-laced, but in only a few short hours I’ve gone and done a complete about-face. Damned if I don’t like it. But what on earth would my family think if they knew I was here sleeping with two guys? But it’s so sexy. So forbidden. I feel a moment of panic, and my body stiffens.

  Stop letting them control your life.

  “You’re overthinking again aren’t you, Aly?” he asks.

  I nod then shake my head to clear it. “I know.”

  “Let’s get your mind on something else.” His fingers part my sex, and he lightly strokes my clit. “Too sore for this?”

  “No,” I whisper and let my head fall back on his shoulder. “Never.”

  He strokes gently, petting me softly, a feathery light brush over my clit. My breathing changes as I give myself over to the sensations he’s arousing in me.

  “So nice,” I murmur.

  He bends and puts his mouth near my ear. “Good,” he whispers, his warm breath racing over the shell of my lobe and eliciting a shiver from deep within.

  He gently slides a finger inside me, and I close my eyes against the flood of pleasure. From behind, his cock grows against my back, and I wiggle my ass, wanting to tease him.

  “Go ahead. Poke the bear, Aly, and see what it gets you.”

  I grin at the way I get to him. There’s a heady power in knowing I can arouse this strong man, bring him to his breaking point.

  Bray adjusts my feet, widens them, and pushes another thick finger inside me.

  “Oh, yes, just like that,” I say without thinking.

  “This is how you like it?”

  “Yes,” I moan.

  “Good, because for the next two weeks, this is how you’re going to get it. Every day, all day, whenever we want, wherever we want.”

  His fingers stroke deep, and my legs weaken. Bray slides an arm around my waist and practically holds me up as he drives his fingers in and out of me. I sway slightly and he holds me tighter.

  “That’s it, Aly. Just feel.”

  As he stirs desires deep inside me, I move against his hand, the hot spray running over my breasts and stimulating my nipples. My eyes slip shut as his fingers slide in and out of me, his movements slow, deliberate, taking me higher and higher. My breasts grow swollen, hot, and I exhale a raspy breath as pleasure pools between my legs.