Temptation & Trouble: A MFM Romance

by Kelli Callahan

  Hmm, where is everyone? Gabe is usually home by now and Harlan’s car is in the driveway.

  I had been living with Harlan and Gabe for a month. My situation was a lot better than it was when I arrived. I actually liked coming home to spend time with them, even if I got disinterest from one and lust-soaked stares from the other. I didn’t need alcohol to numb the pain, because they could always make me laugh. I felt like I had been put in the friend zone by Harlan, but it didn’t mean I couldn’t enjoy having a conversation with him. Gabe was ridiculously charming, even if he was a bit of an asshole at times.

  The best part about the arrangement was that neither one of them seemed to want me to leave. I thought I would only be staying with them long enough to get back on my feet, but that wasn’t the case. When I suggested getting a second job and looking for an apartment, Gabe countered with an offer to let me enroll in college and stay with them until I graduated—he even offered to pay my tuition. It was quite a commitment from a man that only seemed to be interested in getting my panties off. Harlan immediately backed up Gabe’s offer by telling me I would be foolish to turn him down.

  I guess Harlan is upstairs?

  I was excited to let them both know that I had stopped by the university on the way home and registered for classes. I walked up the stairs and when I got to the top, I noticed that Harlan’s door was closed. I had every intention of knocking, but when I got closer, I saw that it wasn’t closed completely. There was a thin sliver of light and I could hear a noise on the other side that sounded like he was watching a video on his laptop. I put my hand on the door and pushed it gently, which caused it to open wider. I wasn’t prepared for what I saw. Harlan was sitting in his computer chair with his laptop open in front of him. The sound I heard wasn’t just a video—it was porn. He was naked from the waist down and his hand was gently stroking his fully erect cock.

  Oh my god! Fuck, this was a mistake.

  I wanted to look away, but I was mesmerized by what I saw. I had never seen a cock before when it was erect. I had certainly never seen a man masturbate. I had felt Chad’s through his pants when we fooled around, and I even made him cum, but we never went past that point. Watching Harlan’s hand move up and down his shaft as he watched the girl on the screen devour the dick she was sucking made my panties wetter than they had ever been before. My hand slid down my shirt and I unfastened my jeans. What I was doing was dirty and wrong, but I couldn’t control myself. I shifted my jeans down my hips until I could get my hand between my legs and started furiously rubbing my clit through my panties.

  I would love to walk into his room and do exactly what he’s watching—I’d replace his hand with my lips in an instant.

  “What a dirty girl.” A voice startled me from my trance and I nearly jumped out of my tennis shoes when I turned to see Gabe behind me.

  “Shit, fuck!” I yanked my hand out of my jeans and started down the hallway, but Gabe blocked my path.

  “Where do you think you’re going?” Gabe shook his head back and forth with a smile on his face.

  “What the fuck is going on out here?” I heard Harlan’s voice and he pushed his head through the crack in the door.

  “We seem to be living with a spy.” Gabe took a step forward and pushed my shoulder with a playful nudge. “Why don’t you tell Harlan what you were doing, dirty girl? Or maybe the fact that your ass is hanging out of your jeans is enough for him to figure it out.”

  “You were watching me?” Harlan’s tone was a mixture of shock and confusion.

  “She was doing more than watching, man, this dirty girl was rubbing one out along with you.” Gabe chuckled and shook his head.

  “Wow.” Harlan’s voice went flat. “You really are all grown up now.”

  “I don’t know about that.” Gabe continued to chuckle. “If I were you, I’d take this invasion of privacy very seriously—I think she needs a spanking.”

  “What? No!” I shook my head back and forth. “Harlan, I’m sorry—I came up the stairs—I saw you…”

  “It’s fine.” Harlan exhaled sharply. “I guess I should have made sure the door was completely closed. I thought I had plenty of time before anyone got back.”

  “I still think she needs a spanking.” Gabe took another step towards me and I stepped back, standing with my back to the wall so I could see both of them.

  “Well, she has been quite naughty.” Harlan laughed and I saw a half-smile form on the edge of his lips.

  “What about it, dirty girl? Are you going to let Daddy Harlan give you the spanking you deserve?” Gabe bit down on his lip and grinned.

  Oh my god, is this really happening?

  “Do you… want to give me a spanking?” I turned towards him completely and felt my heart beating hard in my chest.

  “Right now, I’m thinking about doing a lot more than that.” Harlan exhaled sharply and his eyes traced my body.

  “He’s going to make you scream.” Gabe’s closed the distance between us and I felt his breath on my neck. “But he’s not the only one. I’ve wanted you since the second I laid eyes on you, and I’m not waiting anymore.”

  “Hold on…” I felt my legs shaking when Gabe gave me a gentle push towards Harlan’s room. “I’ve never done this before.”

  “That’s okay, you’ll learn that two is a lot better than one.” Gabe’s lips were so close to my neck that I could feel his words against my skin.

  “No—I mean—I’m still a virgin.” I looked at Harlan and saw his eyes open wide with surprise.

  “Huh? How?” Harlan face twisted into a confused stare. “You were engaged to that dumbass who cheated on you for two years!”

  “What kind of idiot doesn’t pop this cherry the first chance he gets?” Gabe’s tone had as much confusion as what I saw on Harlan’s face.

  “I don’t know…” I looked down at the floor.

  “Well, that’s about to change.” Gabe pressed his lips to my neck and moved up to my ear. “You can kiss that cherry goodbye because I’m going to devour it.”

  “Oh god!” I moaned when I felt his lips—they sent shivers through my whole body.

  “But first I’m going to teach you a lesson about spying on people.” Harlan pulled his door open and grabbed my wrist.

  I couldn’t believe what was happening. Harlan pulled me into the bedroom and Gabe followed. The door closed and I felt Gabe’s hands on my waist. He slid his fingers into my panties and pushed them down until they were even with my jeans. A second later, they were both around my knees and Harlan was pulling me towards the bed. He sat down and I tumbled across his knee with my ass in the air. I had never been spanked before. I wasn’t sure if I should be scared or excited. I got so turned on pleasuring myself while I was watching Harlan that the latter was definitely winning. Harlan shifted me on his knee and then I felt a stinging smack. It was immediately followed by a second one on the opposite side of my ass.

  “Ow!” I squirmed on his knee and threw my hand back to block him before he could land another one.

  “Uh oh.” Gabe chuckled. “She doesn’t know what happens to naughty girls that don’t know how take their punishment.”

  “Apparently not—now she’s going to get spanked even harder.” Harlan laughed and pushed my hand away. “Why don’t you grab her arms.”

  I felt Gabe’s fingertips graze the back of my thighs. They slid along the inside and brushed against my pussy before he traced the crevice of my ass. He took a seat beside Harlan and pulled my hands into his lap. His cock was tight against his pants and he was as hard as Harlan. Harlan lifted his hand overhead and landed another hard smack on my ass, but he didn’t pull away. He let his finger slide along my inner thigh and teased my pussy with a quick touch. I arched my back and moaned as he pulled his hand away and gave me my next stinging smack. I gasped and bit down on my lip when his hand found my pussy again, and he slid it along my labia until it was against my clit. After two quick rotations, he pulled away and spanked my ass with
a smack that was hard enough to make me tense up.

  “Why are you torturing me?” I groaned and looked over my shoulder.

  “We’re not torturing you.” Gabe wrapped one hand around both my wrists and leaned forward to squeeze my breasts, rubbing the nub that formed against my bra. “We just like to play with our food before we eat it.”

  “And we’re definitely going to eat this cherry.” Harlan pushed his finger against the entrance of my pussy. “We’re going to make you cum, and then we’re going to make your first time one you never forget.”

  “What happened to you?” I moaned louder and looked back at Harlan. “You wouldn’t even look at me—I’ve tried to show you I was interested since I moved in.”

  “I saw it. I’m not blind.” Harland lifted his hand and brought it down on my ass. “I just kept trying to convince myself you were the same little girl I used to know—even if you were being a tease.”

  “She’s definitely not a little girl anymore.” Gabe pushed his cock against my hand. “She’s a dirty, filthy girl that wants to have her cherry popped.”

  “Is that what you are?” Harlan gave me another hard smack. “Are you a dirty, filthy girl that wants her pussy filled with cock until both of us explode inside you?”

  “Yes!” I moaned and pushed back against his finger.

  There was no way I was the first girl they had shared. It was too comfortable for them. I wondered if that had been my downfall from the beginning. I chased Harlan while pushing Gabe away. Perhaps if I had given into Gabe earlier, I wouldn’t have had to wait so long to get Harlan’s attention. I didn’t just want Harlan anymore, though. I wanted them both. They were going to claim me and take my virginity. It might have been confusing at first, but once I processed what they planned to do to me, my body was on fire with the flames of my desire. Harlan made my ass sting as his hand continued to come down, but every time I felt him rub my clit, I wanted more.

  “Why don’t you do something useful with that mouth while Harlan makes you squirm. You liked watching Harlan stroke his cock, how about you try sucking one?” Gabe started unbuckling his belt and grinding his dick into my hand a little harder.

  Gabe’s cock started to grow even more once it was free from the fabric prison that barely contained his length. He let go of my wrists, tangled one hand in my hair, and guided his dick towards my lips with the other. I opened wide when the glans smeared my lipstick and felt him sliding against my tongue. He had a fat cock that forced me to stretch my jaw just to accommodate his girth. Gabe lifted me by the hair and then forced me to take more of his length. I could feel the glans forcing its way into my throat. I gagged for a moment and he lifted my head so I could draw a breath, but then shoved himself deep into my throat again.

  “We’ll teach you how to suck cock—you’ll learn to beg for it.” Gabe lifted me and let my lips drag slowly along his shaft before jamming his glans into my throat again.

  “It’s making her so fucking wet. She already loves it.” Harlan stopped spanking me and started rubbing my clit with his calloused finger.

  The spanking had left my ass sore, but I couldn’t even focus on the fire burning there because the fire inside me was so much hotter. Harlan’s finger might as well have been a magic wand designed for my pleasure. It was way more intense than anything I had ever felt when I touched myself. Gabe kept working his dick deeper into my throat and then I felt my lips collide with his flesh. He left it there, holding my head until I gagged and then he started to bounce me like a rag doll on his dick. It felt like my lips were being crushed and bruised as they slammed into his pelvis. I kept my mouth wide open, feeling the saliva drip down my chin as I used my tongue to massage him. He grunted and growled each time he plunged himself deep into my throat.

  “She’s about to cum.” Harlan moved his finger to the entrance of my pussy and tried to push it inside me. “Her pussy’s already trying to spasm—god damn, she’s fucking tight.”

  “Don’t cum yet.” Gabe let out a growl and started moving my lips faster on his shaft. “I want to feel you cum while you swallow my load.”

  “You heard what he said.” Harlan pulled his finger away and slapped my ass—hard. “You don’t get to cum until he does.”

  The pressure inside me was so tight that even Harlan’s stinging smack wasn’t enough to quell my impending orgasm. The impact of his hand vibrated down to my pussy and made me tingle. Gabe started to lift his hips up to drive his dick even deeper when he slammed my lips against his flesh. I felt his thick shaft throbbing against my tongue and his glans started to pulsate. His breathing got faster and I heard a throaty-growl erupt from within him. He was about to explode. I tasted salty pre-cum on my tongue and then I felt Harlan’s finger on my clit. He rubbed it furiously and the pressure inside me started to release. My throat vibrated as Gabe’s cock silenced the scream that tried to rise up.

  “Fuck yeah, that feels amazing.” Gabe forced his dick deep into my throat and held me there as he started to cum. “Swallow every drop, you dirty girl.”

  I orgasmed so hard I saw stars. Gabe’s dick throbbed and pulsated even harder when he started to erupt in my throat. I swallowed as fast as I could, but it was hard to concentrate with Harlan’s finger forcing the orgasm to last longer by continuing to rub my clit. My body quivered and shook against him. When Gage was done dumping thick ropes of cum into my throat, I felt him release the grip on my hair. Harlan’s finger stopped moving and he dragged it along my labia before he finally pulled it away. My body was weak, but I had never felt bliss like that before. I was already exhausted and I hadn’t even lost my virginity.

  Maybe I like being a dirty girl.

  “Okay.” Harlan started lifting me off his knee. “Time for us to devour that cherry.”

  “Already?” I looked over my shoulder at him. “I just had the most powerful orgasm of my life!”

  “We’ve barely gotten started.” Gabe brushed the hair away from my eyes. “We’re going to make you cum so many times that you won’t even be able to walk tomorrow.”

  Chapter Eight

  Kacey

  My emotions were in turmoil. Harland made me cum harder than I ever thought was possible. Part of what made it so powerful was having Gabe’s cock buried in my throat while the pleasure seized my whole body. My blood was pumping hard in my veins, my heart was thumping against my chest, and it felt like I was on fire from head to toe. If that was their version of punishment, then I was glad I spied on Harlan. It wasn’t what I imagined when I thought about us tangled in a lover’s embrace as he took my virginity. It was better. I wasn’t just going to lose my virginity to one man—I was going to have my innocence taken by two amazing men with bodies like Greek gods. They were on fully display as they removed the rest of their clothes, stripped me naked, and stretched me out on the bed.

  “I can’t wait to taste your cherry.” Gabe sank between my thighs and I felt his tongue glide along my labia.

  “Every curve on your body is perfect.” Harlan squeezed one of my breasts with his hand and leaned forward to kiss the nipple on the other one.

  Feeling two sets of lips teasing my flesh made my skin sizzle with anticipation. Harlan circled my nipple until it was a hard nub and then moved his lips over to my other breast. I never realized how sensitive they could be. Gage moved his tongue along my labia and plunged it inside me until my hymen was stretched. He tightened his tongue and gave me several quick thrusts before kissing his way up to my clit. I moaned when he pushed the hood away and flicked his tongue against the sensitive bundle of nerves. It felt even better than Harlan’s finger. Gabe made his tongue dance around it and the sensation of pleasure made my skin sizzle even more.

  “I can’t wait to fuck you.” Harlan let his lips move up to my neck and then he teased my earlobe with his tongue. “I wanted you the first night I saw you at the bar, but I thought you were so innocent—now I know how dirty you really are.”

  “Yes.” I moaned and arched my back.
/>
  “Gabe made you love sucking cock, didn’t he?” Harlan lifted me up until our eyes were locked together.

  “He did.” I nodded and bit down on my lip.

  “You want your lips around mine now—tell me you do.” He leaned forward until our lips were almost touching.

  “I want it.” I nodded again and stared into his eyes.

  Harlan crushed my lips beneath his. They were still sore from what Gabe did to me, but I didn’t care. The combination of Harlan’s tongue ravaging my mouth while Gabe kept his busy circling my clit almost made me erupt into another orgasm on the spot. As much as I wanted to feel that explosion of bliss again, I was also eager to make Harlan cum. He kissed me for almost a full minute before he pulled away from my lips and wrapped his hand around the back of my head. He pulled my head off the mattress and mounted me with his hard cock ready to enter my mouth. I opened as he approached and took it as he forced it into my throat. He kept my head in position and started to fuck my mouth, each thrust driving his dick deeper into my throat.

  “She’s got a nice hot mouth, doesn’t she?” Gabe pulled his tongue away from my clit and chuckled.

  “It’s fucking amazing.” Harlan grunted and continued to thrust.

  “Just wait until you taste this pussy.” Gabe flicked his tongue against my clit.

  “I don’t want to wait.” Harlan looked down at me and growled with a primal lust in his eyes.

  Harlan released his grip on the back of my neck and pulled his cock out of my mouth. I looked at him in confusion for a moment until he started to turn over. He positioned his cock directly above my mouth and started to descend into it once he was facing the opposite direction. He leaned forward and suddenly I felt two tongues massaging my pussy. Gabe moved down to the entrance while Harlan circled my clit. The combination of pleasure sent even more urges through me. Harlan left his cock halfway in my mouth and I started to shift myself forward so I could glide along his shaft. His hips moved slowly, grinding his glans against my tongue as I took him deeper into my throat.