Temptation & Trouble: A MFM Romance

by Kelli Callahan

  “Don’t put another load in her throat. I promise this is worth the wait.” Harlan gasped and squeezed my thighs.

  Gabe ignored what Harlan said and started driving his dick into my throat again. Harlan picked up the pace and began to pound my pussy with the full force of his lust. I felt the familiar pressure building up inside me, but it was much stronger than it was before. Every deep thrust from Harlan’s length set my body on fire. I did my best to pleasure Gabe with my tongue, but it was impossible to stay focused on him when I was the thunderous thrusts between my thighs were changing my perspective on life itself. The orgasm built up fast, and I felt Harlan throbbing inside me. He was close. I was over the edge of ecstasy. If I managed to hold out long enough for him to cum, it would be a miracle. Gabe kept his cock furiously thrusting into my mouth, but even that couldn’t distract me from the feeling.

  Oh god! I’m cumming!

  I felt my pussy clench on Harlan’s dick. It was strange to have him inside me when the spasms began. It heightened the pleasure. He drove himself into my g-spot over and over while my body erupted in bliss. Gabe slowed down and pulled his cock out of my throat before I choked to death on it. I gasped for air as my muscles tightened and released. The spasms made Harlan throb harder and then I felt his glans pulsate. He grunted and his head flew back. His mouth opened and a load growl rushed across his lips. I felt cum surging through his shaft and then the condom ballooned inside me. My orgasm kept going, milking his balls until they were totally drained. He kept thrusting until the feeling faded and my whole body relaxed. He slowly pulled himself free, and the instant he was gone, I felt empty—but I knew Gabe was about to change that.

  “Oh my god, that was incredible.” I exhaled sharply and stared at the ceiling.

  “Fucking hell, that was the best pussy I’ve ever fucked.” Harlan crashed on the bed beside me and stretched out.

  “I can’t wait a second longer.” Gabe growled and unrolled a condom on his length. “Get over here and show me how good it is.”

  Gabe didn’t crawl down to take Harlan’s place. He grabbed my leg and yanked me towards him. My legs were folded back towards the mattress in an instant and he drove his cock into my pussy. It was sore, but I was so wet that my tightness was the only thing that resisted him. Harlan caressed my cheek with his hand and then started squeezing my breasts while Gabe forced his dick inside me. He entered me a lot faster than Harlan did, and started thrusting with ferocious lunges. They slammed into me so hard I was sure there would be bruises before he was done, but I didn’t care. My g-spot started to hum as he hammered it, and I felt the pressure building again. It wasn’t going to take me long to orgasm and I could tell Gabe had no intention of taking it slow.

  “You were right.” Gabe grunted and nodded. “This is paradise.”

  “Our own personal paradise—whenever we want it.” Harlan squeezed my nipple. “Isn’t that right, Kacey?”

  “Yes!” I felt a gasp rush from my throat as I tried to speak.

  Gabe was like a beast that had been unleashed on my body. He fucked me so hard that the springs were creating recoil and pushing me back against him. His abdominal muscles flexed against my clit each time he went deep. I could see sweat along his muscular frame, but he didn’t slow down. Every thrust brought me closer to bliss, and I felt the pressure building. My mouth fell open and I squirmed underneath him. Harlan moved his hands along my curves, squeezing and teasing me with every touch. I couldn’t hold back any longer. My pussy clenched and spasmed. Gabe let out a loud gasp and his dick pulsated harder.

  “I’m gonna cum!” I squealed and then I started to scream.

  We were locked in the moment. It felt like my body was floating as my muscles tensed and relaxed. The orgasm sent waves of pleasure through me. Gabe slammed his dick into my spasming pussy and then he began to unload his seed. His volcanic eruption took my second orgasm and pushed it straight into a third. My eyes rolled back in my head and I saw stars before the third one subsided and he was spent. Gabe gave me a few more thrusts and then I felt him start to pull himself free. He put his hand on my stomach and slowly lowered himself down beside me. I looked at him with a smile and then looked back at Harlan. I was no longer a virgin. My body had been ravaged by their lust and I loved every second of it.

  “Are you two going to leave me again?” I put a hand on each one of them.

  “Not this time.” Harlan slid closer. “You’re going to spend the night in our arms.”

  “Don’t think you’re going to get much sleep, though—we’ll be ready to go again before you know it.” Gabe chuckled and cradled my head in his arms.

  This is going to be the longest night of my life—and the best one ever.

  Chapter Twelve

  Harlan

  One month later

  Things changed drastically for all three of us after we spent our first night tangled up in bliss. I let go of my inhibitions and accepted my feelings for Kacey. They simmered below the surface the first night I saw her at the bar, but they didn’t flourish until I took her virginity. It was a different feeling for me—one that I never truly had with my ex-wife. Perhaps I always knew the relationship was poisonous, but I was blinded by my perception of love. It didn’t have to be so fucking complicated. I didn’t have to let it destroy the man I was. It was so much better when I could embrace my passion and let lust consume me. The lust tangled with love, and I knew I felt both for Kacey. Nothing else mattered.

  “Good morning.” Kacey walked into the kitchen and rubbed the sleep from her eyes.

  “You slept late.” I looked up at her and chuckled.

  “We must have worn you out—again.” Gabe stood and poured her a cup of coffee.

  “Yeah, it’s becoming a nightly occurrence, which makes for some long days.” She giggled and yawned when she sat down at the table. “One more day, then the weekend. I can do that.”

  Kacey tried working and going to school in the beginning, but it was a lot of time apart. It also wasn’t necessary since Gabe was being extremely generous. He suggested that she stop working and focus entirely on school—well, school and the relationship growing between us. It was nice to be able to get off work and come home to someone I truly adored. It showed me how different life could be when the relationship was tainted by poison. I was eager and excited every day. When the clock started to wind down the final hour each afternoon, I could hardly sit still in my seat. Gabe seemed to have the same issue, although he didn’t make it home as early as I did. His work sometimes followed him too, but we still had a lot of fun when it was done.

  “So, what are we going to do about the holidays?” Gabe looked around the table. “Kacey, I’d love to have your mom and little sister join us for Thanksgiving.”

  Is Gabe actually planning something that far out?

  “Maybe.” Kacey sighed and nodded. “I’ve talked with her a couple of times on the phone. I told her things were better now and we’re going to get together soon. I’ll bring it up.”

  “If you were already planning something, we don’t want to pull you away from your family.” I raised my eyebrows and tilted my head.

  “No, not at all.” Kacey leaned back and shook her head. “My dad always offers, but I’m just not ready for that yet. My mom hasn’t felt much like celebrating since he left, so she doesn’t normally go all out. I haven’t been much help…”

  “You’re doing a lot better now.” I reached over and patted her hand. “Honestly, I thought it would be harder for you to outrun those demons.”

  “Yeah, there was a time when I wasn’t sure what a day without numbing the pain looked like.” She exhaled sharply. “I guess I needed to move on and find a way to make peace with what happened. It was a lot easier after I finally opened my damn eyes.”

  “So it’s settled then.” Gabe looked around the table and smiled. “We’ll plan a big Thanksgiving dinner and invite the family.”

  “Sounds good.” I nodded and smiled along with him. “
I might even see if my parents want to come.”

  “I know my mother will show up.” Gabe rolled his eyes. “She won’t miss a chance to hit me up for money.”

  “Seriously?” I laughed and reached for my coffee. “You bought her a house, got her a nice car, and she doesn’t have to do anything but spend her allowance as it is.”

  “She always finds a new toy she wants.” Gabe chuckled. “I think she could actually spend all my money if I let her.”

  “I guess we can just put all our families in a room, make some popcorn, and enjoy the show.” Kacey snickered and finished off her last bite of breakfast. “Okay, I’m going to be late for school if I don’t leave now.”

  “Have a good day.” Gabe pushed his chair back and stood.

  Once Kacey left for school, Gabe and I finished getting ready and headed to work. I was already thinking about Kacey before I pulled into the parking lot. If Gabe was planning for the holidays, he was definitely getting attached. It brought a smile to my face, thinking about the man who seemed to despise love finally falling for someone. I hoped it would happen after college, but I could tell he wasn’t ready. He held onto his bachelor card as long as he could, but it was definitely time for him to retire it. There was a time when I wouldn’t have dreamed of sharing someone I cared about with another man, but it was different with Gabe. I trusted him more than I trusted anyone else in the world. We had someone special and I would do anything in my power to make sure we never lost it.

  “I’m home.” I pushed the door open and slammed it. “Kacey, are you here?”

  “Yep!” I heard her voice from the downstairs office. “Just working on one of my stupid assignments.”

  “Stupid?” I walked into the office and chuckled. “You’re just getting started with college—freshman year is the easy part.”

  “Tell that to my Creative Writing professor.” She leaned back in the chair and sighed. “He wants me to write an essay about anything. He didn’t even give me a freaking topic!”

  “That’s pretty common.” I sat down across from her. “What kind of ideas have you come up with?”

  “Nothing. I’m staring at a blank screen.” She looked over the top of her laptop. “I’m supposed to be learning shit, not making it up on my own.”

  “Try to come up with something original. Make it something that the professor probably doesn’t know much about.” I tilted my head and shrugged. “That always worked for me.”

  “I’m not sure he wants to hear about the best place to buy a fake ID.” She laughed and shook her head. “What else? Underage drinking? How to become an alcoholic before you’re twenty-one? Oh, I got it—how to carry on a scandalous relationship with two older men.”

  “You think it’s scandalous?” I raised an eyebrow and grinned. “I thought we were just having fun.”

  “It’s very scandalous.” She stood up and walked around the desk. “Not that I’m complaining.”

  “Get over here—I’ll show you how scandalous this can be.” I grabbed the front of her jeans and pulled her close.

  “Good, I need a distraction from the screen anyway.” She wrapped her arms around the back of my head and straddled the chair I was sitting in.

  I pulled Kacey into my arms and squeezed her tits as she sank down into my lap. Our lips met in an instant and I started to ravage her mouth with my tongue. I never got tired of crushing her pouty lips with mine. My dick started to swell in my pants, ready for action as soon as she was against me. I pulled her shirt off and tossed it to the side as my lips drifted down to her bra. It joined her shirt on the floor and I started to let my tongue swirl around her nipples. Her tits were ravishing and turned me on so much my cock started to throb. I fumbled with the front of her jeans and unbuttoned them, pushing my hand into the denim until I felt her wetness. She moaned against my ear and dug her fingernails into the back of my scalp.

  “I don’t care if Gabe isn’t home yet.” She brushed my ear with her lips. “I want to feel you inside me.”

  “He’ll have his turn.” I gasped as her hand went down to my cock. “Besides, it might be a late night for him.”

  “I need you now.” She unfastened my pants and squeezed my dick.

  I loved sharing Kacey with Gabe, but I definitely wasn’t going to complain about having her all to myself. I lifted her off my lap and walked to the couch. We tore at our clothes until we were both naked and she straddled me again. Her pussy pressed against my glans and then she started to descend on my shaft. I wrapped my hands around her shoulders and drove my dick into her before she was all the way down. She sank against my body and started to ride me, bouncing on my cock. Her beautiful tits were directly in front of me and I sucked on them as she started to pick up the pace. I normally liked being on top, but she looked like an angel ascending to heaven and crashing to earth each time she bounced. Her tight pussy squeezed every inch of my shaft and I felt the pressure in my balls immediately.

  “I should write a report on how much I’ve come to love this feeling.” She moaned and ran her hand along my muscled chest, tracing one of my tattoos.

  “I’m pretty sure your professor would ask if he could join in.” I grunted and wrapped my hands around her ass. “I’m not sharing you with anyone else.”

  “The two of you keep me too busy anyway.” She threw her head back and I felt her pussy clench.

  Kacey guided my cock into her g-spot each time she went down and I felt her getting wetter. The pressure in my balls got more intense as her body reacted to our passion. She had become my addiction. I couldn’t even go a single day without having her in my arms. Kacey’s movements got faster and I started to move against her with the same perfect rhythm. If her moans were any indication, she was close to an orgasm. It certainly wasn’t going to be a marathon. She rode me hard, bouncing on my dick until the pressure in my balls couldn’t hold back any longer. My head went back against the couch and cum surged through my shaft. The instant it splattered inside her pussy, she started to shake. Her mouth opened wide and a loud gasp echoed from her throat as she started to cum.

  “Oh god!” She fell forward against me and her body quivered while she orgasmed.

  “Just a little more.” I held her ass and lifted her up a few times, bringing her down against my flesh as the last drops of cum drained into her pussy.

  “Wow, you two got started without me.” I heard Gabe’s voice and turned to see him standing in the doorway.

  “He was just getting me warmed up.” Kacey turned towards Gabe with a grin. “Welcome home.”

  “And what a nice welcome it is.” Gabe nodded and started to remove his suit jacket.

  Chapter Thirteen

  Gabe

  One week later

  I pursued Kacey just like I would have pursued any woman that caught my eye. Kacey held out longer than most, but she was worth it. My feelings were deeper than the lust I felt for her body. Lust might have drawn me to her, but it wasn’t what captivated me. I took advantage of every opportunity I could, just to make sure she stayed one more day. I was tangled in a web and willing to do anything for her—and that was before we shared our first night together. Once I had a taste, I knew I was in trouble. The temptation I felt for other women faded. The only one I wanted was Kacey. It was such a powerful feeling and it made me feel alive for the first time in my life. Was it love? Could it happen that fast? I really had nothing to compare it to. It was certainly more intense than anything I had ever felt before. I knew that with absolute certainty.

  The nights we spent together were explosive. Kacey had finally started to come into her own. She knew from the beginning that she wanted Harlan. She didn’t expect her desires for me to grow as quickly as they did. She definitely never considered a situation where she would be shared by the both of us. I was fearful that it wouldn’t last in the beginning since Harlan was the one she really wanted, but as the days passed, it was clear that she needed both of us. She had been mistreated by the boy she fell in love with
. She needed something better. She needed to feel the fury of a man, ravaging her body and showing her how much she could be craved. We certainly did that—every chance we got. She didn’t just have one man devoted entirely to her needs, she had two.

  “She’s incredible, isn’t she?” Harlan poured a second cup of coffee and sat down across from me.

  “You’re thinking about her too?” I chuckled and lifted my head. “Yes, she definitely is.”

  “Are you going to admit at some point that this isn’t just another random fuck?” Harlan tilted his head inquisitively.

  “Do I have to say that out loud? I thought it was clear.” I scoffed and picked up my coffee. “Of course, she’s not like the girls we’ve hooked up with in the past. She’s special.”

  “You’re the one that doesn’t believe in love.” Harlan chuckled and sipped his coffee. “I did that dance once—right down the altar.”

  “You mean, straight to hell.” I chuckled alongside him and drained my coffee cup. “I’ve been really hesitant. You know why and you’re the only one I’ve ever told about what I went through growing up.”

  “I get it, but I’ve always said you just needed to find the right girl. I made a mistake when I married Maria, and that left me as fucked up inside as you are, but now we have something a lot better.” Harlan nodded and put down his coffee.

  “Yes, we do.” I looked towards the stairs. “Maybe this is what I always needed. The two of us—we’re closer than brothers. It doesn’t take blood to make us family. We went our separate ways, but Kacey has made us closer than ever. At least, I hope you feel that way.”

  “I do.” Harlan nodded quickly. “I’ve seen how fucked up a bad relationship can be. I lived the horror of heartache. The three of us together creates a different dynamic and it finally gave me the courage to think about the future again—you know, further than the day in front of me.”