Love You More

by Lisa Gardner

  “Then we’re all on the same page,” Bobby said. He and D.D. had made it to the front stoop. “We want to find Sophie, bring her home.”

  Lyons’s shoulders came down. He seemed to finally relent. After another moment, he opened the door, gestured them inside.

  They entered into a small mudroom, wood-paneled walls covered in coats, ceramic-tiled floor overrun with boots. House was small, and it only took D.D. a minute to figure out who ran the roost, three young boys, ages five to nine, who rushed into the crowded space to greet the newcomers, talking over one another in their excitement, before their mother, a pretty thirty-something woman with shoulder-length brown curls, tracked them down, looking exasperated.

  “Bedtime!” she informed the boys. “To your rooms. I don’t want to see you again until you’ve brushed your teeth and changed into pajamas!”

  Three boys stared at her, didn’t budge a muscle.

  “Last one to the top of the stairs is a rotten egg!” the oldest boy suddenly yelled, and the three roared off like rockets, piling over one another in their haste to get to the stairs first.

  Their mother sighed.

  Shane shook his head.

  “This is my wife, Tina,” he offered, making the introduction. Tina shook their hands, smiling politely, but D.D. could read tension in the fine lines bracketing the woman’s mouth, the way she looked instinctively at her husband, as if for assurance.

  “Sophie?” she whispered, the name hitching in her throat.

  “No news,” Shane said softly, and he laid his hands on his wife’s shoulders in a gesture D.D. found genuinely touching. “Got some work to do here, okay? I know I said I’d put the boys to bed…”

  “It’s okay,” Tina said automatically.

  “We’ll be in the front room.”

  Tina nodded again. D.D. could feel her eyes on them as they followed Shane from the mudroom into the kitchen. She thought the woman still looked worried.

  Off the kitchen was a small front room. Looked like it had once been a three-season porch that Lyons had finished off with windows, installing a small gas-burning stove for heat. The room was decorated Rugged Male, with a big-screen TV, two oversized brown recliners, and a plethora of sports memorabilia. The Man Cave, D.D. deduced, where the stressed-out state trooper could retreat to recover from his day.

  She wondered if the wife had an equivalent Crafts Room or Day Spa, because personally, she was betting life with three boys topped eight hours on patrol any day of the week.

  Room didn’t really offer seating for three, unless you counted the beanbags piled in the corner, so they stood.

  “Nice home,” Bobby said, once again good cop.

  Lyons shrugged. “We bought it for the location. You can’t see it right now, but the back lawn rolls down into a park, giving us plenty of green space. Great for barbecues. Essential for three boys.”

  “That’s right,” D.D. spoke up. “You’re known for your cookouts. That’s how Tessa and Brian met.”

  Lyons nodded, didn’t say anything. He had his arms crossed over his chest, a defensive stance, D.D. thought. Or maybe an aggressive stance, given how it bulged the muscles of his shoulders and chest.

  “We talked to Lieutenant Colonel Hamilton,” Bobby commented.

  Was it D.D.’s imagination, or did Lyons just tense?

  “He mentioned several of the outings you’ve organized, you know-boys’ night out to Red Sox games, Foxwoods.”

  Lyons nodded.

  “Sounds like Brian Darby often joined.”

  “If he was around,” Lyons said. Another noncommittal shrug.

  “Tell us about Foxwoods,” D.D. said.

  Lyons stared at her, then returned his gaze to Bobby. “Why don’t you just ask me the question.”

  “All right. To your knowledge did Brian Darby have a gambling problem?”

  “To my knowledge…” The trooper suddenly sighed, uncrossed his arms, shook them out. “Goddammit,” he said.

  D.D. took that as a yes.

  “How bad?” she asked.

  “Don’t know. He wouldn’t talk about it with me. He knew I disapproved. But Tessa called me, ’bout six months ago. Brian was on tour, upstairs bathtub had sprung a leak. I gave her the name of a plumber, which she then contacted. Couple of pipes had to be replaced, some drywall patched. When all was said and done, guess it cost a good eight hundred, nine hundred bucks. Except when she went to withdraw it from savings, the money wasn’t there.”

  “It wasn’t there?” D.D. repeated.

  Lyons shrugged. “According to Tessa, they should’ve had thirty grand in savings, except they didn’t. I ended up loaning her the money to pay the contractors. Then, when Brian got back…”

  “What happened?”

  “We confronted him. Both of us. Tessa wanted me there. She said, if it was just her, it would sound like a nagging wife. But if it was both of us, Brian’s wife and best friend, he’d have to pay attention.”

  “You ran a gambling addiction ‘intervention,’ ” Bobby said. “Did it work?”

  Lyons barked hollowly. “Did it work? Hell, not only did Brian refuse to acknowledge he had a problem, he actually accused us of having an affair. We were in cahoots against him. Whole world out to get him.” Lyons shook his head. “I mean… you think you know a guy. We’d been friends for how long? And then one day, he just goes off. It’s easier for him to believe his best friend is fucking his wife than to accept that he has a gambling problem, and that liquidating his life savings to pay off loan sharks isn’t a good way to live.”

  “He took money from loan sharks?” D.D. asked sharply.

  Lyons gave her a look. “Not according to him. He said he’d taken the money to pay off the Denali. So, while we’re all sitting there, Tessa, cool as a cucumber, picks up the phone and dials their bank. It’s all automated systems these days, and sure enough, their vehicle loan still has a $34,000 balance due. Which is when he started yelling that we were obviously sleeping together. Go figure.”

  “What did Tessa do?”

  “Pleaded with him. Begged him to get help before he got in too deep. Which he refused to acknowledge. So finally she said, if he didn’t have a problem, then it should be easy for him to agree not to gamble. At all. He’d stay out of Foxwoods, Mohegan Sun, everywhere. He agreed, after making her promise never to see me again.”

  D.D. raised a brow, looked at him. “Sounds like he really believed you and Tessa were too close.”

  “Addicts blame everyone else for their problems,” Lyons replied evenly. “Ask my wife. I told her all about it, and she can vouch for my time, both when Brian is home and when he’s not home. We don’t have secrets between us.”

  “Really? Then why didn’t you tell us this sooner?” D.D. said. “Instead, I recall this whole little spiel on how you weren’t too involved with Brian and Tessa’s marriage. Now, twenty-four hours later, you’re their personal intervention specialist.”

  Lyons flushed. His fists were clenched at his side. D.D. glanced down, then…

  “Son of a bitch!”

  She grabbed his right hand, yanking it toward the light. Immediately, Lyons raised his left as if to shove her back, and in the next instant he had a loaded Sig Sauer dug into his temple.

  “Touch her and die,” Bobby said.

  Both men were breathing hard, D.D. sandwiched between them.

  The state trooper had a solid fifty pounds on Bobby. He was stronger, and as a patrol officer, more experienced in a street fight. Maybe, if it had been any other officer, he would’ve been tempted to make a move, call the officer’s bluff.

  But Bobby had already earned his battle stripes-one shot, one kill. Other officers didn’t ignore that kind of thing.

  Lyons eased back, standing passively as D.D. jerked his bruised and battered fist under the overhead light. The knuckles on his right hand were purple and swollen, the skin abraded in several areas.

  As Bobby slowly moved his firearm to his side, D.D.’s ga
ze went to the steel-toed boots on Lyons’s feet. The rounded tip of the boot. The bruise on Tessa’s hip her lawyer wouldn’t let them examine.

  “Son of a bitch,” D.D. repeated. “You hit her. You’re the one who beat the shit out of Tessa Leoni.”

  “Had to,” Lyons replied in a clipped tone.

  “Why?”

  “Because she begged me to.”

  In Lyons’s new and improved story, Tessa had phoned him, hysterical, at nine a.m. Sunday morning. Sophie was missing, Brian was dead, some mystery man had done it all. She needed help. She wanted Lyons to come, alone, now, now, now.

  Lyons had literally run to her place, as his cruiser would be too conspicuous.

  When he’d arrived, he’d discovered Brian dead in the kitchen and Tessa, still in her uniform, weeping beside the corpse.

  Tessa had told him some preposterous story. She’d arrived home from patrol, depositing her belt on the kitchen table, then walking upstairs to check on Sophie. Sophie’s room had been empty. Tessa had just started getting nervous, when she heard a sound from the kitchen. She’d raced back down, where she’d discovered a man in a black wool trench coat holding Brian at gunpoint.

  The man had told Tessa that he’d taken Sophie. The only way to get her back was to do as he said. Then he’d shot Brian three times in the chest with Tessa’s gun and left.

  “You believed this story?” D.D. asked Lyons incredulously. They were now sitting in the beanbags. It would almost appear cordial, except Bobby had his Sig Sauer on his lap.

  “Not at first,” Lyons admitted, “which became Tessa’s point. If I didn’t believe her story, then who would?”

  “You think the man in black was an enforcer?” Bobby asked with a frown, “sent by someone Brian owed money to?”

  Lyons sighed, looked at Bobby. “Brian muscled up,” he said abruptly. “You asked about it, yesterday. Why’d Brian bulk up?”

  Bobby nodded.

  “Brian’s gambling started a year ago. Three months into it, he has his first little ‘episode.’ Ran up a bit too much on tab, got roughed up by some casino goons till he worked out a payment plan. Next week, he joined the gym. I think Brian’s bulking up was his own self-protection plan. Let’s just say, after Tessa and I confronted him, he didn’t quit the gym.”

  “He was still gambling,” Bobby said.

  “That’s my guess. Meaning, he could’ve run up more debt. And the gunman came to collect.”

  D.D. frowned at him. “But he killed Brian. Last I knew, killing the mark made it difficult for him to pay up.”

  “I think Brian was past that point. Sounds to me like he pissed off the wrong people. They didn’t want his money, they wanted him dead. But he’s the husband of a state police officer. Those kinds of murders can cause unwanted attention. So they came up with a scenario where Tessa herself became the suspect. Keeps all eyes off them, while getting the job done.”

  “Brian’s a bad boy,” D.D. repeated slowly. “Brian is killed. Sophie is kidnapped, to keep Tessa in line.”

  “Yeah.”

  “This is what Tessa told you.”

  “I already explained-”

  D.D. held up a silencing hand. She’d already heard the story, she just didn’t believe it. And the fact it came from a fellow police officer who’d already lied to them once wasn’t helping.

  “So,” D.D. reviewed, “Tessa is in a panic. Her husband has been shot with her gun, her daughter kidnapped, and her only hope of seeing her daughter alive is to plead guilty to her husband’s murder.”

  “Yes.” Lyons nodded enthusiastically.

  “Tessa hatches a master plan: You’ll beat the shit out of her. Then she’ll claim Brian did it, and she shot him in self-defense. That way she can plead guilty-meeting the terms of her daughter’s kidnappers-while keeping out of prison.” This part actually made some sense to D.D. Given past experience, Tessa Leoni had played to her strengths. Smart woman.

  Bobby, however, had a question for Lyons. “But you really, I mean really beat the shit out of her. Why?”

  The trooper flushed, stared down at his mangled fist. “I couldn’t hit her,” he said in a muffled voice.

  “Then how do you explain the fractured cheek?” D.D. asked.

  “She’s a girl. I don’t hit girls. And she knew it. So she started… At the Academy, we had to pound one another. It was part of the self-defense training. And big guys like me struggled. We’re interested in becoming cops because we have a sense of fair play-we don’t hit women or pick on the little guy.” He eyed Bobby. “Except at the Academy, where all of a sudden you had to.”

  Bobby nodded, as if he understood.

  “So, we trash-talked each other, right? Goaded each other into action, because the big guys had to start seriously hitting, if the little guys were going to seriously learn to defend.”

  Bobby nodded again.

  “Let’s just say, Tessa was really good at goading. It had to be convincing, she said. Spousal abuse is an affirmative defense, meaning the burden of proof would be on her. I had to hit her hard. I had to make her… fear. So she started goading, and kept needling and needling and by the time she was done… Damn…” Lyons looked off at something only he could see. “I had a moment. I really did want her dead.”

  “But you stopped yourself,” Bobby said quietly.

  He drew himself upright. “Yes.”

  “Bully for you,” D.D. said dryly, and the state trooper flushed again.

  “You did this on Sunday morning?” Bobby inquired.

  “Nine a.m. You’ll find a record of her call on my cell. I ran over, we did our thing… I don’t know. It must’ve been ten-thirty. I returned home. She made the official call in, and the rest is what you already know. Other troopers arriving, the lieutenant colonel. That’s all true. I think Tessa and I were both hoping the Amber Alert might shake things loose. Whole state’s looking for Sophie. Brian’s dead, Tessa’s arrested. So the man can let Sophie go now, right? Just leave her at a bus stop or something. Tessa did what they asked of her. Sophie should be all right.”

  Lyons sounded a little desperate. D.D. didn’t blame him. The story didn’t make much sense, and as hour passed into hour, she was guessing Lyons was also coming to that realization.

  “Hey, Lyons,” she said now. “If you came to Tessa’s house on Sunday morning, how come Brian’s body was frozen before that?”

  “What?”

  “Brian’s body. The ME ruled he was killed prior to Sunday morning, and put on ice.”

  “I heard the DA… some comment…” Lyons’s voice trailed off. He gazed at them dully. “I don’t understand.”

  “She played you.”

  “No…”

  “There wasn’t any mystery man at Tessa’s house Sunday morning, Shane. In fact, Brian was most likely killed Friday night or Saturday morning. And as for Sophie…”

  The burly trooper closed his eyes, didn’t seem to be able to swallow. “But she said… For Sophie. We were doing this… Had to hit her… To save Sophie…”

  “Do you know where Sophie is?” Bobby asked gently. “Have any idea where Tessa might’ve taken her?”

  Lyons shook his head. “No. She wouldn’t harm Sophie. You don’t understand. There’s no way Tessa would harm Sophie. She loves her. It’s just… not possible.”

  D.D. regarded him gravely. “Then you’re an even bigger fool than we thought. Sophie’s gone, and given that you’re now an accomplice to murder, looks to me like Tessa Leoni screwed you over good.”

  25

  Bobby and D.D. didn’t arrest Lyons. Bobby felt it was more appropriate to let internal affairs kick into gear as state investigators could squeeze Lyons more effectively than the Boston police could. Plus internal affairs was in a better position to identify any links between Lyons’s actions and their other major investigation-the missing funds from the troopers’ union.

  Instead, Bobby and D.D. returned to BPD headquarters, for the eleven p.m. debrief with the taskfor
ce.

  The falafel had done D.D. a world of good. She had that gleam in her eye and hitch in her step as they pounded up the stairs to the homicide unit.

  They were closing in now. Bobby could feel the case building momentum, rolling them toward an inevitable conclusion: Tessa Leoni had murdered her husband and child.

  All that remained was putting a few last pieces of the case in place-including locating Sophie’s body.

  The other taskforce officers were already seated by the time D.D. and Bobby walked through the door. Phil looked as jazzed as D.D., and sure enough, he went first.

  “You were right,” he burst out as D.D. strode to the front of the room. “They don’t have fifty grand in savings-the entire sum was withdrawn Saturday morning. The transaction hadn’t been posted when I got the initial report. And get this-the money had also been withdrawn twelve days prior, then returned six days after that. That’s a lot of activity on fifty grand.”

  “How was it finally taken out?” D.D. asked.

  “Bank check, made out to cash.”

  Bobby whistled low. “Couple of pennies, available as hard currency.”

  “Male or female closed the account?” D.D. asked.

  “Tessa Leoni,” Phil supplied. “Teller recognized her. She was still in uniform when she made the transaction.”

  “Setting up her new life,” D.D. said immediately. “If she ends up under investigation for killing her husband, joint assets might be frozen. So she got out the big money first, squirreled it away. Now, how much do you want to bet that if we find that fifty grand, there will be another quarter million sitting with it?”

  Phil was intrigued, so Bobby related the state police’s current investigation into embezzled funds. Best lead-the account had been closed out by a female wearing a red baseball cap and dark sunglasses.

  “They needed the money,” Phil stated. “Did a little more digging, and while Brian Darby and Tessa Leoni look good on paper, you won’t believe the credit card debt six-year-old Sophie has run up.”

  “What?” D.D. asked.

  “Exactly. It would appear Brian Darby opened half a dozen credit cards in Sophie’s name, using a separate PO box. I found over forty-two grand in consumer debt, run up over the past nine months. Some evidence of lump sum payments, but inevitably followed by significant cash advances, most of which were at Foxwoods.”