The Lost Lord of Black Castle (The Lost Lords Book 1)

by Chasity Bowlin

  “Chris—” he broke off, a fit of coughing interrupting his speech. Blood seeped from the corner of his mouth and Graham knew then that the other man’s lungs were filling with the substance. He would not be long for the world.

  “Christopher,” Edmund finally managed to utter. Though the word was barely more than a whisper, it resounded in the small chamber like a pistol shot. The servants gasped in surprise, their shock clearly evident upon their stunned faces.

  “Are you certain that it was Christopher?” Graham pressed. “Is there any doubt?”

  Edmund frowned at him, then admitted in a voice that was growing ever weaker, “He sounded wrong. Thought it was the drink… not—not him… not like him.”

  “Wrong how, Edmund? What did he say to you?” Graham persisted.

  Edmund turned his head slightly and met Graham’s gaze more directly. Graham could see death in the other man’s eyes. It had already sunk its icy claws into him. Edmund’s lips parted, but not in answer. His last labored breath passed them on a sigh and then his chest stilled.

  It wasn’t the first time he’d watched a man die. In truth, of those he’d watched take their last breath, he’d had less feeling for Edmund than most. But the dismayed sound from Beatrice, the tears that gathered in her eyes as she looked at the corpse of a man she’d known since childhood, struck a chord in him. She was hurting, though why he could not fathom given Edmund’s treatment of her. Yet, her pain was evident as was his complete inability to do anything about it.

  He rose and nodded curtly to Warner. To Hammond, he stated, “You’ll see to the preparations.”

  “Yes, my lord… it will be taken care of,” the butler answered gravely. “What of Mr. Christopher, my lord? What is to be done?”

  Graham’s lips firmed. “I will handle that part of it, Hammond. The servants must say nothing to him when they see him. In fact, they should avoid him at all costs for now until I have a firm plan of action in place… if anyone sees him, take note of his direction and come find me immediately. Is that understood?”

  “Certainly, my lord,” the butler answered quickly and with complete conviction. A chorus of agreement followed.

  Graham offered Beatrice his arm. “Come. We must see to Lady Agatha before she hears the news of it elsewhere.” He needed to get her out of that room. He also needed to curb his own ridiculous jealousy of a dead man.

  *

  Beatrice brushed tears from her eyes as they left that small, dismal chamber and made for Lady Agatha’s suite. She did not weep for the man Edmund had become. Her tears were for the boy he’d once been and for the woman they were about to face. Lady Agatha had suffered the agony of a missing child for almost two decades. She’d buried her husband, a kinder man never to be found. Now, with her missing son returned to her, she would have to say her farewells to Edmund who had been like a son to her. It was too much for her to bear and Beatrice feared that it would trigger a setback in the woman’s recovery.

  “Why do you weep for him?” Graham asked softly. “After all that he has done and all that he has threatened… why?”

  “Because when we were children and I was afraid, he would tell me stories. Because when you were gone and Lady Agatha wept enough to fill the ocean itself, he would sit with her,” she answered. “He was different then, before Sir Godfrey’s influence tainted him beyond repair, before his own jealousy and envy, his awareness of the lack of permanence of his position as steward here, nurtured the meanness that Sir Godfrey planted in him.”

  Graham stopped in the corridor and, since he held her arm, she was forced to stop as well. She looked at him then, evenly and without rancor. It was clear from his expression that he disapproved of her tears. Given what he knew of Edmund, she could even understand it. But in a joint history that spanned nearly two and a half decades, it was impossible to condense it down only to those unpleasant moments he had witnessed. “You do not have to mourn for him,” she said softly. “He was little more to you than a rude and ill-tempered stranger… but we’ve been living in one another’s pockets here for decades. The relationships built within these walls are complicated. You do not have to mourn him, but you must not judge me for doing so.”

  They stood there in the corridor, silent for the moment. It stretched between them, fraught and tense, until finally he sighed heavily. “I have no right to dictate what you may feel and who you may feel it for. It is not my place.”

  “Because you are not my husband.” And he never would be, she thought. It seemed she needed to constantly remind herself of the impermanence of their relationship. Failing to do so would only give rise to hopes that, when inevitably dashed, would only bring more pain. Yet she found herself wondering what manner of husband he would be to the woman he wed. Would he be the sort of man who attempted to control even his wife’s thoughts? Because marriage had seemed such an unlikely future for her, she’d grown accustomed to doing as she pleased with little thought to anyone else’s opinions or thoughts. She told herself it was just as well that their relationship would end because she could not imagine ceding control to anyone in that fashion.

  “No,” he replied with another heavy sigh as he scrubbed his hand over his face. “Because it is not my right to tell any man, woman or child what they may feel. I may not understand how you can separate who he was as a boy from the disappointment of him as a man… but I also cannot understand how you can look past all of my many flaws. To exploit your generous nature for my own benefit while castigating you for it when it is applied to others would make me the worst sort of hypocrite.”

  Beatrice hadn’t expected that he would so easily accept it, or that he would so willingly admit to error on his own part. At every turn, his behavior confounded and baffled her. She never knew what to expect from him. Electing to change the subject altogether and to focus on matters that required immediate attention, she pitched her tone low and whispered, “In your chamber, I came to speak to you because I have information that, given what Edmund said, is more imperative than ever… there is another man in this house, one who comes and goes at his leisure through the tunnels and passages, and who looks enough like Christopher to pass for him.”

  He didn’t immediately discount the idea but his skepticism was obvious even as he replied in hushed tones to match her own, “I do not wish to believe that Christopher is responsible for this, Beatrice. I have only just discovered my brother and, while things are certainly tense between us, I had hoped to build a relationship—”

  “I saw him, Graham! Yesterday afternoon when I was going downstairs to greet Dr. Warner and Mr. Eaves! I saw a man I assumed was Christopher at the end of the corridor making for the tower. Then, when I turned to descend the stairs, the real Christopher was walking up them,” Beatrice insisted. “And I’m not the only who has had such experiences here. I spoke with Betsy and she revealed that several servants have had similar experiences. While it seemed unlikely that he could traverse such distances even with the tunnels, that was the most reasonable explanation anyone had.”

  He drew a deep breath, “If that is true… to what end?”

  Beatrice sighed. “I do not fully understand it myself… I’ve only just been able to put together everything. But before you returned, it was almost a certainty that Christopher would eventually take on the role of Lord Blakemore. But he was sent down from school and even then maintained his innocence of the crimes he’d been accused of! What if he truly was innocent? What if his exile home was engineered as part of a greater plot?”

  “This all ridiculously Machiavellian,” he said. “I’m not denying that it’s possible, but the degree of planning and strategy required is prohibitive. Why would someone do this?”

  She was speaking in whispers, but growing more animated as the ideas and theories expanded in her mind. “I told you we are isolated here, our own secluded enclave. As young as Christopher is, his face is still changing, still transitioning from boy to man. In five years’ time, anyone who vaguely resembled him
could return to London, claim to be Lord Blakemore and no one would bat an eye. All the people who would be able to gainsay him have been walking targets. You, Lady Agatha, and me. Now poor Edmund… but not Eloise who was meeting her lover in that tower! She is the key to all of this, Graham. I feel it to my bones.”

  He was silent then, considering. Did he think her ready for Bedlam?

  When at last he spoke, he stunned her yet again. “I cannot think how he would ever encounter someone who looked so much like him, or how such a plot would be hatched, but I cannot reason out any other scenario that fully encompasses everything that is taking place here, either. For now, we will proceed cautiously as if your hypothesis is accurate.”

  “What are you not telling me?” she asked. It was clear to her by his expression that he was concealing something.

  “Lady Agatha confessed to me that Christopher is my half-brother, sired by a lover she took while in France,” he said. “It is possible then that I am not Christopher’s only half-brother?”

  The revelation was not as shocking as it should have been. In some ways, Beatrice realized, she’d always suspected as much. “What shall we do about Christopher and his double? It is clear to us what Edmund must have meant, but perhaps not to everyone else. How will we manage to capture or confront this madman when he slips in and out of the shadows?”

  Graham took her hand again, a much more intimate gesture than simply offering his arm, and one that, if anyone were to see them together, would fully reveal the nature of their relationship. Her protest died on her lips. She had told him she would not renege and if that meant accepting public declarations, she would.

  “If, as you say, Eloise is the key to all of this… then we start with her and let her lover come to us,” he said. “First, let us speak to Lady Agatha and then we will figure out how to best proceed.”

  “You think to use her to get a confession out of him? What if his feelings for her are not so genuine? She may be nothing more than a pawn to him.”

  “Then I will persuade him,” he stated evenly. “By whatever means necessary.”

  Beatrice shivered at the cold and implacable expression that hardened his features. He’d told her he’d been a pirate when it suited his needs to be so and, in that moment, she could see it in him clearly. The gentleness he’d displayed with Lady Agatha, his protectiveness of her, those were only a few of the many layers that comprised the complicated man before her. They could have three lifetimes together, she thought, and she would never know them all.

  “Have I repulsed you, at last?” he asked.

  “Was that your aim? If so, you have failed… I may not like your methods and I may be far too squeamish to be party to them, but I’d be a fool to deny their necessity. This must stop before other lives are lost,” she said firmly. “So do what you will, what you must, and stop expecting me to turn on you at any moment.”

  He stared at her intently for the longest moment, his sharp gaze taking in every detail of her it seemed. At last, he gave a curt nod and said, “Then let us go and take the sad news of Edmund’s passing to Lady Agatha. It is a task that I dread, but postponing it is not an option.”

  Beatrice said nothing further. She simply walked hand in hand with him to Lady Agatha’s suite and waited as he knocked softly. Crenshaw answered, looking, if not rested, then at least less like a walking corpse.

  “My lord, I had to send Mrs. Blakemore away only moments ago… she came here demanding to see my mistress, but I did as you said and would not let her in,” Crenshaw explained, high color blooming on the cheeks of her otherwise pale face.

  “Was she aware of Edmund’s injuries?” Beatrice asked.

  Crenshaw stared at her blankly. “If she was, Miss, she said nothing of it to me. Is he terribly hurt then?”

  “He has died of his wounds,” Graham answered softly. “Is Lady Agatha’s condition well enough for her to hear such news?”

  Crenshaw looked down at the floor, clearly upset by the information. When she looked up again, her eyes gleamed with unshed tears. It was the most outwardly emotional display that Beatrice had ever witnessed from the woman.

  “I daresay no one is ever in a condition to hear such, my lord,” Crenshaw stated, her voice trembling with unshed tears. “But delaying it will not change the truth of it and will not spare her the suffering, only postpone it. I believe it would be best to tell her now and be done with it.”

  “What is it that you are all conspiring about?”

  The question had come from just beyond the bedchamber door. Lady Agatha stood there, her gray hair in a simple braid and a heavy brocade wrapper dwarfing her slender frame.

  “You should sit, or better, lie down,” Graham said.

  “I am ill, not feeble,” she replied evenly. “Tell me what has happened.”

  Beatrice moved deeper into the room to take Lady Agatha’s hand. She led her to a small settee. “It’s terrible news, Lady Agatha… please, sit.”

  “Has something happened to Christopher?” she asked. Fear made her voice tight and sharp.

  “No!” Beatrice denied quickly. “He is well… however, Edmund is not. He was injured in an attack on the road to London—” She stopped, unable to utter the truth knowing how much pain it would inflict. Edmund had been like a son to Lady Agatha, albeit an often disappointing one.

  “How serious is his injury?” Lady Agatha demanded, bracing herself for the news.

  Beatrice looked to Graham imploringly. She could not make herself say it.

  Chapter Twenty

  “Edmund is gone,” Graham stated unequivocally. He did not relish relaying such news but he agreed with Crenshaw. To delay and draw it out would be more cruel. “His wounds were too severe and he has succumbed to them.”

  Lady Agatha’s hand tightened on Beatrice’s to the point that her knuckles went white. A sound escaped her, a mournful cry that told him beyond any question how dear Edmund had been to her.

  “Who is responsible for this?” she finally asked through her tears.

  There was no end to the ill tidings he brought, it would seem. “At first glance, and based on what Edmund said, it would appear to be Christopher.”

  She gasped then. “I will not believe that of him! He is sullen and moody, I admit, but Christopher is not violent!”

  “No,” Graham agreed. He prayed that Beatrice’s theory was correct because it might at least spare Lady Agatha some anguish. “I do not think he is… is it possible that your former lover had more than one son?”

  “A half-brother?” Lady Agatha asked. “I do not doubt that it is possible. In retrospect, it is quite easy to see that I was not the only woman to fall prey to his schemes and lies… be truthful, Graham! Do you really believe that might be possible or are you only trying to spare my feelings?”

  “There is a man who comes and goes freely from this house, who looks enough like Christopher for it to be possible. Many of the servants have seen him, albeit at a distance, and even Beatrice, when saw him, assumed he was Christopher,” Graham explained. “Did he know that you were with child before you fled France?”

  Lady Agatha drew a deep breath and then answered with a quavering sigh, “He did. But he denied me and the child, claimed to want no part of either of us as I had fulfilled my only purpose to him.”

  “I know this must be a difficult thing for you to speak of to us, but it is imperative,” he reassured her. “Have you had any contact with Etienne La Chance since you parted?”

  “He wrote to me once,” Lady Agatha admitted. “He asked for money and threatened to expose me… to expose Christopher as his son and see that he would not inherit. At that point, I had almost come to accept your death, Graham, and I knew, whether I was willing to admit it or not, that in all likelihood, Christopher would take the title. It had been Nicholas’ wish. We had discussed it at length. So, I had the money delivered to him by courier… I expected that it would be the first payment of many, but no other demands were forthcoming.” />
  “It seems unlikely that he would have been satisfied with so little when he clearly had the necessary means to extort more,” Beatrice mused. “Why would he stop?”

  “Perhaps it was not by choice,” Graham said. “At this point, we cannot even be certain that he still lives.”

  “But he has a son that might be here within these very walls?” Lady Agatha questioned. “This all sounds ludicrous!”

  “Is it any more ludicrous than your son returning from the dead after eighteen years? Impossibility and implausibility are the order of the day,” Graham chided gently. “The only other option would be that Christopher himself is the villain. It is certainly the more preferable of the two scenarios available to us at this time.”

  Lady Agatha sighed heavily. Her hand trembled as she placed it to her heart. “It is difficult enough to accept that Edmund is gone from us! To think that my dear Christopher might have had a hand in it is more than I can bear!”

  “We must proceed carefully,” he said. “It seems likely, from what we’ve gathered thus far, that Eloise figures heavily within this plot.”

  “Go on then,” Lady Agatha urged. “Tell me what you plan to do.”

  “Eloise will cooperate or she will face prison… I have proof that Edmund was siphoning funds from the estate. It would be easy enough to show that she was complicit in it. She will help us apprehend the killer or face the consequences.”

  “I cannot believe of it her,” Lady Agatha said in dismay. “She is certainly not the most attentive of wives, but surely she had no part in Edmund’s death!”

  Beatrice stepped in then, clarifying for Lady Agatha the source of their suspicions. “Because Graham thought he’d seen Christopher entering the East Tower, I had Betsy lead me there through the passages to investigate it while Graham traveled to York. Eloise entered the chamber while we observed her without her knowledge… she was there for an assignation with a man I initially believed to be Christopher, but I know differently now. She is in the thick of this scheme, Lady Agatha, and now she is a widow. I hardly think it coincidence. As to this man, the likeness is uncanny, unlike anything I have ever seen. It’s quite remarkable.”