Her Best Men: A Brother's Best Friends Reverse Harem

by Rye Hart

  “I wouldn’t be your best friend if I didn’t tell you the truth. No matter how hard it is to swallow. I’m worried about you, Katie. Do you want me to take some time off and fly out there?”

  “No, thanks. I don’t need a babysitter.”

  “Katie, don’t be like this.”

  “I gotta go. Talk to you later.”

  I hung up the video call with Whitney and fell back onto the couch. Now I didn’t know what to think. I had one best friend that would want nothing but stories. I had another best friend that wanted nothing more than to make me feel stupid for all this, and I was nowhere close to getting the answers I needed. Wyatt had already walked away from me angry. The other brothers were keeping their distance. And it felt like everything was crumbling before it could get off the ground.

  I peeled myself off the couch and slid out of my work clothes. I left them in a pile on the floor before I slipped into bed. The next day was going to be a long day of in-house counsel work. Their former lawyer was officially gone, and there was a lot of paperwork regarding this Charleston installation waiting for me when I clocked in come eight in the morning.

  And I was going to need sleep if I was going to shove all this aside to be professional.

  CHAPTER 31

  ANDREW

  I hated working Saturdays. My brothers and I had been developing this damn resort and shit for years, and we still couldn’t have our damn weekends to ourselves. I slid from my office and decided to hit the breakroom. I could turn out the lights and lay the fuck down, especially after staring at all the damn paperwork for the build in Charleston. The construction crew was working their asses off in between the bouts of rain the area was having, and I was trying to get a head start on all the bullshit paperwork I’d need to fill out to requisition everything for the damn place.

  “Hey, Andrew,” Katie said.

  “Katie?” I asked as I pushed into the breakroom. “What are you doin’ in here?”

  “Just trying to find a quiet space. Today’s been a pretty rough day,” she said.

  “Tell me ‘bout it. You okay?”

  “Yeah. Just a lot of paperwork.”

  “Sounds like everyone’s havin’ that kinda day. Mind if I sit?”

  “Never. Come on,” she said.

  I sat next to Katie against the wall and leaned my head back. She was sighing in her chair as her body slid lower into her seat. Her legs were stretched out, and she yawned. There wasn’t a movement she was making that didn’t have me wanting to touch her some more.

  Then, she reached out and grabbed my hand.

  “You’ve always been so warm,” Katie said.

  “Comes with all this muscle,” I winked.

  She smiled at me as she looked over at me. Our eyes connected, and for a brief moment, I let myself swim in them. She squeezed my hand, and I moved my foot over to hers. She slipped her leg underneath mine like she was trying to seek shelter for her weary body. I could see the exhaustion in her eyes. I could feel how weak her grip was. I had no idea what was weighing on that mind of hers, but I wanted her to get it off her chest.

  She beat me to the punch.

  “Wyatt told me about the meeting,” Katie said.

  I nodded before I brought her fingers to my lips to kiss.

  “I’m sorry,” I said.

  “Why did you guys do that without me?” she asked. Why did you think you could discuss my life without including me?”

  “We were only tryin’ to get to the bottom of our feelin’s before we brought you into the mix. We figured the four of us bein’ on the same page would make it easier on you when we all sat down and talked shit out,” I said.

  “What does that mean? What feelings?” she asked.

  “You that blind?” I asked with a grin.

  “Treat me as if I am,” she said.

  “We’re all in love with you, Katie. Every single one of us.”

  Katie leaned forward, her body springing to life as the stress seemed to melt from her system. Her hands slid around my neck, drawing me close as our lips collided. I was shocked at the energy that poured from her body. It was like she was waiting for that damn admission to come along.

  I slid my arms around her and pulled her onto my lap. She collapsed into me, her lips swelling underneath my ministrations. I raked my tongue against the roof of her mouth, and she moaned, causing my cock to lurch to life.

  I broke the kiss, afraid I wouldn’t be able to contain myself if it went on any longer.

  “I love you, too, Andrew,” Katie said. “But I love Caleb and Dylan and Wyatt, too.”

  “I figured as much,” I said.

  “I can’t choose just one of you,” she said. “Not when—”

  I rubbed her back as I watched her struggle for her words. She needed time to collect herself. That spark of energy that ignited inside of her was gone, and that tired little girl was slowly starting to emerge again.

  It made me sick to watch her go through all these heavy emotions.

  “What you say ain’t gonna change nothin’,” I said. “Take your time.”

  “I’ve been in love with all of you for so long,” Katie admitted breathlessly.

  I furrowed my brow as she drew in a deep breath.

  “Remember the first time Hunter brought all of you guys home to play at our house?” she asked.

  “Yeah. You were like six or seven, right?” I asked.

  “Six. I fell in love with you guys from that very first moment.”

  “Katie. Ya can’t be in love when you’re six,” I said.

  “I loved you the way a six-year-old knew how to. I wanted to be around you guys. Follow you around and be like you guys. Then, as I got older, it morphed. It went from admiration to wanting your attention. Then it morphed into something sexual. Then it morphed again into a mixture of all those things. Every year I changed, how I felt for you guys changed. But, it never went away. My want to be around you guys and my want to be with you guys never changed.”

  I brushed a curl back behind Katie’s ear as her teary eyes met mine.

  “Don’t cry, pretty lady. I can’t handle that shit with you,” I said.

  “I can’t choose just one of you,” she said. “It has to be all of you or none of you. Having one will only hurt.”

  “I love you, Katie. And I don’t want ya hurtin’. So, if that’s what you want, then I’m behind ya one hundred percent.”

  “What?” she asked, looking genuinely surprised.

  “Yep. I mean, I’m not gonna lie and tell ya that I don’t want ya all to myself because I do. But if this is the only way I get to keep on lovin’ you, then I’m in.”

  Katie threw her arms around my neck like I’d just bought her a fuckin’ mansion or something. She squeezed me tightly as one of her tears dripped onto my neck. I could feel her shaking. All this shit swirling in the air between all of us was weighing down on her something heavy, and I was determined to get this shit off her shoulders.

  “What’s all this?” Caleb asked.

  Katie shot up from my shoulder as she sniffled.

  “Doll, are you cryin’?” Dylan asked from behind Caleb.

  “Could you guys come here?” Katie asked.

  “Yeah. Come on, guys,” I said.

  Caleb and Dylan looked at one another before they came into the breakroom. They sat on either side of me as Katie stayed in my lap. My hands fell to her hips as she turned herself so she could easily see all of us.

  “I know about the meeting,” Katie said.

  Caleb and Dylan looked at one another as nervousness crossed their features.

  “I’m not upset with it or anything, but I do need you guys to understand something. I know what I want. And what I want is all of you. I love you, Dylan. And I love you, Caleb. But I also love Andrew and Wyatt. Dearly. I can’t choose. Choosing would only hurt more than this does now.”

  “We never meant to hurt ya, Katie,” Caleb said.

  “All we wanted to do was make
sure all of us were on the same page before we talked to you,” Dylan said.

  “I know, I know. Andrew’s explained it to me. And I’m not mad. But I need you guys to know that I can’t choose. I’ve been in love with you guys for so long.”

  “And she ain’t jokin’ on that,” I said.

  “It’s always been all of you in my mind. Ever since I was a little girl angry that Hunter wouldn't let me play with you guys. All of you have been in my mind and in my thoughts and in my heart for so long. It feels natural for me to be around all of you. So, if you guys are asking me to choose between you, the answer is I can’t. It’s either all of you or none of you.”

  “Andrew, how do you feel ‘bout this?” Caleb asked.

  “I told her ‘long as she’s happy, I ain’t got a right to tell her otherwise. I support her in her decision. If that’s what she wants, that’s what I’ll give her,” I said.

  “And this is what you want, doll?” Dylan asked.

  “Yes, more than anything. I’m just worried,” Katie said.

  “‘Bout what?” Caleb asked.

  “I don’t think Wyatt’s a fan of the idea,” she said sheepishly.

  “It ain’t gonna be hard to get that lovesick puppy on board with this shit,” Caleb said.

  “Yep. Ya leave that to me, pretty lady,” Andrew said with a wink.

  “And if this is what you want, then I guess it’s what we do,” Dylan said as he took Katie’s hand.

  “Ya got me on board, too,” Caleb said.

  “Since we’re all being honest and everything, could I admit something else?” Katie asked.

  “You can tell us anything. You know you can,” Dylan said.

  “I’ve had this fantasy for a long time about—”

  Katie’s cheeks tinted as a grin crossed my face.

  “I wanna hear ya say it,” I said.

  “I figured you would,” Katie said with a smile. “I’ve always wondered what it would be like for the five of us to be together.”

  My brothers and I sat stock still for a few moments, trying to figure out what to say. Though two days ago, we all swore we’d never share her, here we were, agreeing to do just that. It would be hard enough to know she was with all of us, could we really all sleep with her at the same time?

  Dylan shook his head and heaved a sigh. “I mean, it’s not my first choice, but I guess I’m willin’ to try it if it’ll make you happy,” he said.

  “I agree,” I said. “Caleb?”

  Caleb cleared his throat, “I just don’t want y’all to feel inferior when you see my monster cock,” he said.

  With the ice officially broken on the matter, we all shared a laugh.

  “Alright, I’ll go talk to Wyatt,” I offered.

  I left Katie with my brothers and headed for the stables. My mind reeled as I made my way down the hill. We were really going to do this, we were really going to share Katie. We’d all been so opposed to it, but hearing her admit that she loved us all, and hearing her say it was all or nothing, sealed the deal for me. I couldn’t have none of Katie, so I’d take whatever she’d give me. I didn’t find Wyatt with the horses, but I did find him at the chicken coop, feeding the chickens. He was spreading food around while they were pecking at his boots and the ground he was walking on. He had a bag slung over his massive shoulders and a frown on his face.

  Fuck. The man was torn up from all this shit.

  “Wyatt. Can I talk to ya for a second?” I asked.

  “Yep. Lemme finish up, and I’ll come on out,” he said.

  I watched my brother finish before he stepped out of the coop. He hung up the feed bag and dusted himself off, then brushed the shaggy hair from his face. He sighed heavily as he looked at me, and I questioned where his mind really was. What had he said to Katie that made her think he wasn’t on board for this?

  “Katie’s made a decision,” I said.

  “Wait, what? When? Weren’t we all supposed to meet together?” he asked.

  “Yeah, before ya opened that big-ass mouth of yours and went blabbin’ to her ‘bout it. We’ll talk ‘bout that later, by the way.”

  “She had a right to know,” he said.

  “And she was gonna know. It wasn’t like we were makin’ a decision for her behind her fuckin’ back. Anyway, not the point. The point is, she’s with Dylan and Caleb in the breakroom while I come to inform your sorry ass ‘bout her decision.”

  “How nice of you to keep me in the loop,” he said.

  “You wanna hear her decision or not?” I asked.

  “I take it that it’s not me. Otherwise, she’d be out here.”

  “So, you did give her a reason to doubt you,” I said.

  “The fuck does that mean?”

  “Katie said she wanted all of us or none of us. But she doesn’t think it can happen because of you. The fuck did you say to her?” I asked.

  “Wait. Katie wants all of us?” he asked.

  “Yes, you asshat. She wants all of us. She wants to be shared and loved by all of us. Want to let that sink in a second?”

  I watched him falter as he shook his head, running his massive hand through his hair.

  “I told her I understood,” Wyatt said.

  “What?”

  “When I told her ‘bout the meetin’ we all had together without her, she told me she didn’t think she could choose. She hadn’t made a decision yet or nothin’, so I was hopin’ maybe she still would.”

  “What did ya say to her? ‘Cause she’s under the impression ya don’t approve,” I said.

  “I said I got it, then I left.”

  “Ya left.”

  “Yeah. I left,” he said.

  “What the fuck’s wrong with you? Ya actin’ like you ain’t never been around a woman before!”

  “What was I supposed to do? I want her to choose me! I don’t wanna share her beauty and her spirit with my older brothers, man!”

  “That ain’t your choice,” I said. “And besides, ya love her, right? That’s been your shtick this entire time. You’ve loved her longer than any of us have?”

  “Well, yeah,” he said.

  “So, if ya really love her, and this is what she wants, why you out here throwin’ some toddler tantrum ‘bout it? Buck up. Be a man. Give her what she wants. Try it out, for her. Because ya love her, and it’s what she wants from ya.”

  “That’s really her decision?” he asked.

  “Yep. She even admitted up there she was in love with ya. For what reason, I ain’t gotta clue. But she’s crazy about ya and worried ‘bout what you’ll think of her now.”

  “I don’t think any less of her.”

  “You sure as hell got a weird way of showin’ it. You ready for the other part of this?”

  “There’s more?” he asked.

  “Yep. She admitted to wantin’ to be with all of us. At once.”

  I watched Wyatt’s eyes darken just like my brothers had, and I knew I had him. None of us wanted to admit it, but those were our favorite fuckin’ encounters. The ones with women who wanted all of us at once. Who wanted us to stuff her full and watch her squirm as we took what we wanted from her.

  And now we all had the opportunity to do that with the greatest woman in the fuckin’ world.

  “All right,” Wyatt said. “I’ll give it a shot.”

  CHAPTER 32

  KATIE

  I stumbled into one of the empty resort suites Dylan had opened for us as Wyatt plunged his tongue into my mouth. When he had walked into that break room and smiled at me, tears of happiness welled in my eyes. I was so excited that he was on board, and all I knew to do was kiss him. My entire body wanted him at that moment. That moment when I knew he wasn’t angry with me any longer.

  I could hear furniture being pushed off to the side as the plush carpet revealed itself underneath. Wyatt began stripping me down as I reached for Caleb, crashing our lips together. I kissed each one of them, tasting their unique textures as their hands rid me of my clothes
. I tugged at Dylan’s tie and reached for Andrew’s belt buckle. I pulled Caleb’s shirt over his head and tugged at Wyatt’s boots.

  Then, I dropped to the floor and grabbed the first pair of hips I felt.

  I could feel my arousal pooling underneath the folds of my pussy. I was shaking with want as my mind spun a thousand miles a second. It was happening. It was finally happening. I was going to be able to enjoy the Lee brothers all at once. I was going to know what it sounded like for my name to drip from all their lips at the same time.

  Tears of happiness crested my eyes again as I pulled Wyatt’s cock between my lips.

  His hands reached down and cupped my cheeks as he slid to the back of my throat. I looked up at him as a tear trailed down my cheek. I caught his bright green eyes as he smiled down at me, his thumb wiping away the wetness as the brothers formed a circle around my naked body.

  “So beautiful,” Wyatt said breathlessly. “You look so beautiful like this, Katie.”

  One by one, I sucked them all off. I moved to Caleb, feeling him fist my hair as he slammed back into my throat. He guided my motions as his cock grew against my teeth, pulsing and threatening to spill down my throat already.

  Then he moved my head from his cock to Dylan’s.

  “Hiya, doll. Ya look spectacular down there,” he said.

  I hummed as I took his cock, feeling his precum drip down the back of my throat. Caleb’s hand was guiding my head up and down Dylan’s cock. I reached my hands out for Andrew and Wyatt, feeling their fingers interlock with mine. Dylan’s long cock slid down the curvature of my throat, forcing more tears to my eyes as I synced my breathing with his thrusting.

  Then, I pulled myself away and moved to Andrew.

  I licked at his cock as he drew in a sharp hiss of air. I felt someone kneel behind me, spreading my legs with his. The moment his hands grabbed my hips I knew it was Dylan.

  He plunged two fingers into my tight pussy as he worked his other hand around my asshole. I could feel him slicking his fingers with my arousal, and I moaned when he inserted one slowly into my puckered hole. I shivered with delight as Andrew pulled away from me with Wyatt quickly coming into view. He took my face and guided it back toward his cock as Dylan slowly worked a second finger into my ass.