Zoey (I Dare You Book 2)

by Jennifer Labelle

  “Oh, Nathan.” He looked up just in time to kiss away her tears. “You say the sweetest things, and I’ve never been happier.”

  She reached up to bring her face closer to his. Her tongue traced his bottom lip, coaxing him to open up for her, and there was no asking twice. Their need for each other mounted, spiraling towards bliss. His pace quickened, and she thrust her hips in tune with his, matching his pace.

  Heidi screamed as ripple after ripple of pleasure consumed her, taking Nathan with her shortly after. Completely spent, they fell into slumber in a tangle of limbs and satisfied sighs.

  ****

  Three weeks into her one-on-one relationship with Rafe, Zoey sat across the kitchen table with Heidi again. Rafe and Nathan had hit the gym, while Heidi and Zoey sipped coffee and did their weekly catch up.

  “So I take it things are working out well between you and Rafe?” Heidi smiled, and it made Zoey laugh happily.

  “You know the answer to that already, don’t you?” Zoey was well on her way to falling in love, and thought what the hell, so she decided to share it.

  Rafe had been so sweet and attentive, but most of all patient with her. She had sensed he’d missed Heidi and Nathan, though, and Zoey was finally ready to share his attention again. The first time, that night so long ago between the four of them, had been magical; she was looking forward to their future together the more time they spent hanging out.

  “Have I thanked you yet? Oh, Heidi, it’s been so long since I’ve been this happy, and I’m well on my way to loving him already. It scares the crap out of me, yet he makes me feel so alive and wanted. He’s so attentive and insatiable. I’ve never had someone make me feel so desirable before. Are you sure you’re still okay with all of this?”

  “One hundred percent. I want you both to be happy. When Rafe expressed an interest in settling down, you’re the first person who came to mind. I love Rafe, and I love you too. I also know exactly what you’re talking about because that’s how Nathan makes me feel and so much more. I completely get it.” Heidi reached across the table to squeeze Zoey’s hand. “There’s no need to thank anyone either. I just knew you two would hit it off, and I couldn’t be happier with the turnout.”

  “But I feel bad too.” Zoey blushed and decided to lay it all out there. The more time she spent loving Rafe, the more she wanted to become a foursome again. She had always wanted to spice up her sex life, and what better way to do it? Rafe had a special place in his heart for Nathan and Heidi—Hell, so did she. The three of them had chemistry, shared love, and had been intimate on several occasions, and it made her want to be a part of it again. Heidi was her friend too, after all, it was safe to say Rafe was her boyfriend now, and Nathan seemed like a pretty great guy, so why not?

  “What on earth do you have to feel bad about?”

  “I’m hogging him, aren’t I? Rafe, I mean.”

  “Zoey, it’s okay,” Heidi assured her and scooted her chair closer.

  “No, Heidi. Please just let me finish. I was nervous at first, but now I can’t help but be intrigued. The more I’m with Rafe, and the more I’m around you and Nathan, I can’t help but feel like I’m ready now.” She still felt a little shy, but she also became determined to see it through. It was so much more than their group dare now, and she refused to back down. They were a family, made each other complete while together as well as when they were separate couples. How could she refuse, especially when Heidi had brought the group of them together to begin with? And she was grateful, very much so.

  “Oh, Zoey, I think that’s great. Have you talked to Rafe about this?”

  “Briefly, but I’m sure he’ll be pleased.”

  “Oh yeah, he will.” Heidi chuckled. “Nathan won’t mind a bit either. We’ve had some fun times in the bedroom.”

  “I remember.” She leaned forward and pressed her lips against Heidi’s before she lost her nerve. It was just a quick taste before she continued. “So what do you say we explore some more, just you and me, until the guys get home?”

  “Feel free to explore me all you want. Nathan and Rafe won’t be home for a little while. I know they’d certainly love to walk in on this, of that I’m absolutely sure.” Heidi pulled Zoey back to her mouth to deepen the kiss now that she had the go-ahead.

  It didn’t take long for the kiss to become heated, and it surprised Zoey how fast she became aroused. Suddenly, all she wanted was to feel Heidi’s mouth on her pussy instead of her lips, and she moved as close as she possibly could to the woman she now craved. As if on cue, Heidi cleared the table, and their mugs clattered to the ground. Without parting their lips, Heidi gently lay Zoey on the table and got on top of her. “God, Zoey, please tell me that you’re still comfortable finishing what we’ve started over here?”

  Zoey nodded and fisted the shirt above her head to get it off. She threw it to the floor and stood up to completely undress. Heidi followed suit, until they both were bare, and Zoey pounced.

  Their breasts rubbed against each other as their lips met again. The kiss was mixture of tongue and teeth in their excitement, and they dropped to the floor to continue their mutual pursuit. Damn, Zoey loved the feel of Heidi’s soft, lush curves against her own. Where Rafe was pure, hard masculine muscle, Heidi was soft, silky, and…different.

  She was all woman.

  They both moaned, and Heidi took the initiative to push things further. She climbed on top of Zoey and brushed the hair from her eyes. “Will you let me love you with my mouth, Zoey?” She shifted her weight to reach between them. Her fingers slid through the other woman’s wet, needy pussy and lingered. “I’d love for you to do the same to me.”

  “God, yesss…” Zoey hissed, and flexed her hips upward to create better friction against Heidi’s hand as she palmed her. “Lick my pussy, Heidi. Please taste me.”

  “With pleasure.” Heidi smirked.

  Zoey felt like whimpering as Heidi removed her hand and cool air met her sensitive parts briefly. Then she was pleasantly rewarded when Heidi turned around and positioned herself so that Zoey had access to her pussy as well, should she feel the need to reciprocate.

  Zoey admired Heidi’s shimmering cunt as she felt Heidi spread her wider. Heidi pinned her thighs as far as they would go with her hands and lowered her face to take her first lick, and it felt fucking awesome.

  She moaned and thought, fuck it! The thrill of knowing that this woman was doing these things to her made her more excited, and she went for it. She leaned in to taste that pussy again. Zoey Appleby and Heidi Taylor-De Costa were actually tasting each other after a lifetime of friendship, and it felt so incredible and totally liberating. She wanted to savor the special moment between the two of them and squeezed her hands against the firm roundness of Heidi’s ass cheeks while she dove in. Her tongue slipped easily through the slick pink heat, and she reveled in her sweet honey with feather-light caressing strokes to tease her.

  She loved knowing she’d literally brought this woman to her knees. It was a powerful feeling she wanted to revel in again and again, knowing the foursome to come would be even greater. She’d been so caught up in her own thoughts and the task at hand, they both had, that she hadn’t noticed anyone enter the house until they spoke.

  “Holy shit,” Rafe gasped, and both men stopped near the kitchen entrance in a trance.

  “It’s like one hot déjà vu, huh, Rafe?”

  “Hell yeah.” Both men smiled as the ladies looked up at them.

  Zoey’s eyes immediately sought Rafe’s, and her heart nearly beat out of her chest in joy at the pure love and lust that shone through as he stared back. She smiled. Heidi was on top of her, blocking his view of her somewhat. So she spoke.

  “We did talk about this. One thing led to another, and here we are.”

  “And it looks like we got here just in time. This has to be the best show I’ve ever seen. The two women I love the most—what’s not to like?” Rafe chuckled, clearly happy with the situation.

  “Wel
l said,” Nathan agreed. “You took the words right out of my mouth.” Both men sported very obvious hard-ons, and it was Heidi who got everyone focused again.

  “Well, now that we’re all on the same page, I think it’s safe to say that you both will be helping us finish. Why don’t you all get as naked as we are so I can finish eating this very tasty pussy, while she eats mine? Don’t worry, Zoey, Rafe can play with Nathan in the meantime. Now that’s a sight to behold. They’re damn sexy when they play.”

  “I can’t wait.” Zoey smiled as she watched both men scramble to tear off their clothes. It was a beautiful sight indeed, but when Heidi began to lick her again, all rational thought went right out the window. All that mattered was her talented mouth bringing on ecstasy. She tried to mimic what she felt Heidi’s tongue do to her on Heidi. It seemed to be working. Heidi became softer, slicker, and a little more potent as time wore on. Her hips flexed, Zoey’s grip got tighter, and she smiled against Hedi when she heard her scream.

  Oh yeah. Having Heidi come first was thrilling. She knew she had done something right, especially for her first time trying. She slurped, licked, and sucked at her juices to try to capture it all, and it was the taste of her that sent Zoey over. There’d be no turning back now, and she didn’t want to.

  Heidi fingered her while riding out the waves and only got off of Zoey once they subsided. Zoey stood beside her friend and immediately sought Rafe near the kitchen enterance and she gasped.

  A hand closed around hers and squeezed. Heidi.

  “Aren’t they beautiful?” Heidi asked with so much love and pride evident.

  Rafe stood before Nathan, and his hands gripped Nathan’s dark locks as he fucked his mouth while Nathan was stroking his own, demanding release. It was more than beautiful. It was hypnotic and sexy as hell. Two Gods loving each other—they were simply a gorgeous site to behold.

  “They’re amazing,” Zoey answered, and stepped forward to get a closer look. There was no way she was going to miss any of this. She couldn’t take her eyes off of them.

  Just then Rafe looked up, seeking her. Their gazes locked, and it seemed nothing else in the room mattered but them. His hips flexed faster, Nathan’s grip on himself seemed harder while he stroked, and everything erupted. Spurts of cum landed on Nathan’s stomach, and Rafe roared Zoey’s name in his own completion. Nathan pulled back, and she watched Rafe’s seed shoot out onto the floor.

  Then the teasing got started, and everyone laughed.

  “Zoey, huh? Now I realize she’s in the room, but still…” Nathan winked and laughed.

  “Fuck you, man. That’s the same answer you gave me that first night I did the same to you and you called out Heidi’s name.” Rafe laughed too. “So many good memories.”

  “Tell me about it,” Zoey heard herself say, and both men finally turned to them again. Nathan reached out for Heidi, and she gladly went to him while Rafe did the same with Zoey.

  “I’m not sure if she’s mentioned it, but my first encounter with Heidi and Nathan was when Heidi approached me for a threesome. It seems she wanted to surprise Nathan, and boy, did she ever.” He chuckled, and Nathan spoke up to help him out.

  “Rafe was our neighbor, and Heidi thought it would be nice to tie him to my bed with silk scarves. Only I went and ruined the surprise and almost lost Heidi for good. The truth was I loved her so much it hurt, and it scared the shit out of me. Anyway, the first time I was with Rafe like this, I screamed out Heidi’s name in bliss instead of his that night. I couldn’t get her out of my head, and she’s been my world ever since.” He smiled, and Heidi snuggled closer.

  “Rafe is the one who actually brought us together again.” Heidi shrugged. “And the rest is history.”

  “So…” Zoey pressed herself tight against Rafe, got on her toes, and kissed him. “Since you just screamed out my name as you came, does that mean I’m your world too?”

  “It appears so, honey.” Rafe spun her towards the table and pressed her against its surface. He lifted her and stepped between her legs. “Because I can’t stop thinking about you. Damn, but you’re sexy.” And then he entered her, home at last.

  Nathan proceeded to do the same to Heidi on the other side. Zoey smirked, and Heidi winked as she turned her head to look at the other couple. She moaned as Rafe pumped into her, his mouth on her chest, and it was heaven.

  Heidi reached over and threaded her fingers in Zoey’s long blonde locks. She saw that Nathan feasted as Rafe did with his mouth on Heidi’s breasts. Both men pulled in and out at a leisurely tempo with their cocks. It was too good to rush, and she did the next natural thing she could think of to join the foursome further—her mouth sought Heidi’s again. She could still taste herself on her, the mixture of both of them merging together into one erotic encounter, and it was better than she had imagined it to be.

  This was the best she could ever hope it to be, and she knew then what type of bond they all shared, and it now included her.

  She was one of them and hoped to keep it that way. The dare was now complete, and it was a dream come true.

  ****

  “Who’s the band? They’re pretty good,” Heidi said to Zoey as she settled into their booth with a round of drinks for them all. They were at The Rendezvous on half-price Tuesday, the bar Zoey frequented to unwind now and again.

  “They’re a local band called Lyric. They play here a few times a week, actually.”

  “Well, they’re no Purple Nurple,” Rafe teased, causing Nathan and Heidi to laugh while he explained. “They were this horrid band that played at Drink Nights. I’m glad you’ve got talent up in this place.” He chuckled.

  “I agree.” Zoey smiled and snuggled closer into his embrace.

  “Speaking of all things good…” Heidi gave Rafe a knowing glance and cleared her throat as he motioned for her to continue. “Rafe, Nathan, and I got to talking, and you clearly know that we like having you around. So, what would you say to making it a little more permanent?”

  “I’d say it sounds wonderful. What do you have in mind?”

  “Well—”

  “Move in with me,” Rafe blurted out, and removed his arm from around her shoulder so he could turn in his seat to face her. He gripped her hands between his and looked slightly nervous this time. It was awesome, and she couldn’t help but smile seeing the usually confident man fumble through his words. “We’d like you to move in with us. Heidi and Nathan have redecorated the upstairs to be big enough for the four of us, and when we want our privacy, we’ve got the spare room we christened on our very first night together. You can decorate it however you like. What do you say?”

  “Yes. I say yes.” She snuggled closer yet again and wrapped her arms around him. “How can a girl refuse? I could seriously get used to this.” She looked up to meet his gaze and smiled wide. “I love being with you, in your arms, and when we make love. You’re in my head too, Rafe, and I don’t want this to go away with any of you.”

  He leaned down to kiss her and looked touched by her words. “You’re everything I could have ever dreamed of in a woman,” he whispered. “We have an ancient word in Greek, Zoi, like your name but spelled differently. It means life, and I want you to know you’re an important part of mine.”

  “Oh, Rafe, thank you. I feel the same way.” She swallowed to try to hold off the tears threatening to fall. She was so happy.

  “Well, Rafe it looks like you followed in my footsteps after all. We’ve both found our something spicy, and I wouldn’t change a thing,” Nathan announced proudly while looking down at Heidi with so much love. “It looks like your match making worked perfectly, Heidi.”

  “Well said, Nathan, and thank you, Heidi. I couldn’t have asked for anything better.”

  “To all things spicy.” Heidi cheered, holding her beer bottle high, while Zoey and the others joined in to toast with her.

  And in the end, the trio became a foursome.

  Now it was Meagan’s turn.

  The End


  www.jenniferlabelle.com

  If you enjoyed this book, you may also like:

  Wicked Man by Beth D. Carter

  Beauty in the Beast by Elyzabeth M. VaLey

  Bedding the Babysitter by Sam Crescent

  Evernight Publishing ®

  www.evernightpublishing.com