Big Bad Neighbor: A Single Dad Next Door Romance

by Tia Siren

  “We could just call it a day right now if you keep up that attitude,” she replied.

  “Okay, okay. Old habits die hard. I think your place is probably cleaner anyway,” he said.

  Together they finished their drinks and sauntered off, back down the road. They continued to talk as though meeting for the first time. A certain level of maturity was exuding from Henry that Kara hadn’t seen before.

  They stopped at a grocery store and gathered a few things they might like for lunch, and Henry promised that she wouldn’t have to lift a finger.

  Once they returned to the tiny apartment, Henry wasted no time getting acquainted with the kitchen. He showed a lot of talent at cooking that Kara didn’t know he had.

  “I cook a lot, actually,” he said, “I just grew up as the head chef of the family since my mom was always working.”

  “And your dad?”

  “He wasn’t in the picture at all. Guess he just figured he had better places to be.”

  Kara felt a little sorry for him, and she made it apparent with her face.

  “It’s nothing to be sorry about,” he said, “I actually never minded taking care of my younger siblings. We’re a close family and always will be.”

  He smiled, but this time, it was honest and heartfelt.

  The food he made was quite good, the two of them sat on her bed in the small studio apartment as there wasn’t much other seating.

  “Do you know why I always shoved you away?” Kara asked.

  Henry shook his head no.

  “You have this air about you, like everything in life is easy. I’ve never had friends like you do, nor have I had such an easy time getting into college. I might have a scholarship too, but I had to spend hours studying to get it. You just had to play a sport.”

  “I spent hours practicing,” he replied, “probably spent more hours on skates than you did with your nose in a book.”

  She really didn’t know what else to say. But, then he leaned in and stole a kiss.

  Kara couldn’t believe it when it happened, but didn’t pull away. When Henry stopped, she felt sad that it was over so soon.

  Kara moved back in for another kiss, and Henry was happy to oblige her. She gracefully put her hands around him, and he hugged her and pulled her in closer.

  A rush of emotion and excitement came to her. She knew she wanted this and Henry surged with passion, laying her down on the bed gingerly.

  Kara stripped off her top, revealing her large buxom chest, exciting her mate even more. He followed suit and tore off his raggedy white shirt.

  She calmed herself momentarily as he unhooked her bra. Kara felt a little embarrassed, not knowing what he would think about her, now that he’d seen her like this.

  Henry looked ravenous, rubbing and pinching her nipples with his hand. Kara caressed down along his tight abs, running her hand along each ridge. Then she found her hand resting on his jeans, wanting to free his manhood.

  She dexterously undid his jeans and tugged them down, along with his underwear. He stopped for a moment to stand up and finish taking off his garments, and while he did, Kara saw the perfect chance to remove what little she had left.

  Henry stood at the end of the bed, surveying his prize. Kara let go of her inhibitions and opened her legs just a little further so he could get a better view.

  Like a wild animal, he collapsed on the bed. She felt warmth in the pit of her stomach and felt her chest get more flush as she lie there with him kissing every inch of her.

  Henry kissed further and further down her stomach until his mouth met her wet sex, and with a flick of his tongue she felt ignited. Tiny sparks shot through every little nerve in her body, making her fingers tingle and her head light up with excitement.

  Every circular lick with his tongue excited her more until she could take no more. She wanted him now.

  Kara grabbed his head and pulled it up to hers. He did as he was told, following along and bringing his mouth up to meet her.

  “I want you inside me,” she said.

  His throbbing member rubbed up and down her dripping womanhood, something she hadn’t felt in a long time. With a slight pop, she could feel him begin to enter. The tingly feeling in her extremities was heightened the further he pressed in.

  Henry was bigger than she thought he’d be. She wondered if she would be able to take all of him, but he fears were quickly forgotten the more he inched inside.

  He continued to suck and pinch on her nipples and only threw her to new planes of pleasure. Only once all of him had entered did he start pumping, in and out.

  Henry’s hips motioned in circles around her as he pushed his manhood inside. She grasped the blankets out of reflex, or possibly in an attempt to keep her from flying away.

  The world disappeared, and all that existed were two celestial bodies, wrapped in ecstasy. She didn’t want it to end, but could already tell it was near. Kara couldn’t last much longer.

  The welling up inside her became completely unbearable until it took over. Her body began to spasm uncontrollably, and she let out a scream of relief as the pleasure took hold.

  Henry could feel her tense around his manhood, as though she were trying to pull him inside more. He released himself inside her, pouring out everything he had.

  The two continued on, cloaked in the pleasure of release and completely spent.

  Tears started to stream down her cheeks without her realizing.

  “What is it?” Henry asked, puzzled and sweaty.

  “I haven’t opened up to someone in a long while. Not since high school. I’m happy that I got the chance with you,” Kara replied.

  “It’s still early in the day, I think we could have that chance again soon,” Henry replied with a coy grin.

  Kara rolled her eyes and fell back in the bed, exhausted.

  6.

  “You need to get your grades up, or you won’t be able to play anymore,” said the coach.

  Henry was hoping he wouldn’t hear that for some time. He tried his best to keep his grades up, but he rarely had the time to work on his homework and practice.

  “You might think about getting a tutor. They can be expensive, but I’ve seen many students raise their grades within a few weeks.”

  Henry wanted to do just that, but the thing that was holding him back was something that he had little to no control over.

  “Alright, Coach. I’ll see what I can do.”

  Despite his carefree attitude, Henry was usually under a lot of stress, and most of it had to do with what he might be eating the next day. He didn’t have a job to buy things and was only provided enough money, from his scholarship, for lodging and tuition. He still had to buy all his own books and food, and those were not cheap.

  Still, he thought to himself, maybe Kara would be willing to help out if he were to ask her nicely. She was a tutor after all, and quite a smart one.

  They had been seeing each other almost nightly for the last week. He spent more time at her place than he did at his own, by far. After practice, he would head straight there, and the two would usually end up entwined before the days end.

  Henry thought fondly of their escapades; he liked her more than she probably realized. Although, he still couldn’t figure out exactly why.

  A few hours passed, and he headed to Kara’s tiny apartment.

  He wanted to ask her straight away, but he was easily distracted. Once she answered the door, he greeted her with a kiss. She answered in kind.

  The day wore on, and they found themselves lying in the bed, sweaty and relaxed.

  “Kara,” he said.

  “Yes,” she asked.

  “So, we’ve been spending a lot of time together, and I know that it’s mostly been just us enjoying each other. But, I have a favor I’d like to ask.”

  “Just get out with it, will you?”

  Henry hesitated.

  “Okay, I need a tutor to help me get my grades up, or I won’t be able to keep playing,” he said
.

  Kara sat up, draping the sheets over herself as she did so.

  “You what?” she asked.

  “I need a tutor, and I thought you might be able to help me,” he said again.

  “Okay, I can do it, and I’ll even lower my rate,” she said.

  “That sounds fine,” he said, he wanted to tell her that he couldn’t pay, but he was afraid that she would say no. And, he really needed the help.

  “Can we start tomorrow,” he asked.

  “Sure,” she replied.

  He felt a little relieved that he’d have a tutor, but he still felt stressed about what she’d say after she found out he’d be unable to pay.

  The day passed, and the two met in the library. Kara was a good teacher, and Henry knew that. He worked his hardest to catch up and over the course of the next week, he was actually quite successful.

  “Okay, it’s been a week. Do you think I’ll be able to get paid for my time,” she asked.

  “Would it be alright if I paid you next week,” he asked.

  “Why can’t you pay right now,” she asked in turn.

  “I could pay you through other means,” he said, leaning over for a kiss.

  She pulled away.

  “Wait. Is this why you constantly pursued me for the last while? You needed to get a tutor for free?”

  Henry felt terrible that she thought like this.

  “No, that’s not it in the slightest-”

  “I can’t believe how far you’d go to keep playing your stupid sport. You slept with me so that you could save some money on a tutor. That’s incredibly low, Henry.”

  Kara closed her books, stuffing them inside her bag. A few of the other patrons of the library were starting to take notice, and Henry was getting really nervous; something he rarely felt or allowed himself to feel.

  “It’s over, Henry,” she said.

  Kara stood to leave, and Henry wanted to dart up and grab her. He wanted to do anything to keep her here and tell her the truth, but he was too embarrassed.

  He let her leave and just sat there in shock. The one person he thought he could confide in had just walked out of his life, and there was nothing he could do to stop it.

  7.

  Kara couldn’t remember the last time she’d cried this hard. Of course, it was due to her own stupidity. She finally thought that she’d met a man that she was capable of opening up to and possibly connecting with. Instead, she got stuck with a man that lied to her; and made her feel like some kind of prostitute.

  Her phone rang several times through the night for the last few days. Nearly every call was from Henry, but she didn’t want to talk to him. She nearly threw her phone out the window to make it stop ringing.

  Kara tried her hardest to sleep early, but couldn’t. She started analyzing what she did wrong because she wanted to be sure it wouldn’t happen again.

  George was calling; Kara answered.

  “You’re late, Kara. Where are you?”

  It caught her by surprise; she’d never missed a session before.

  “Just wait there, I’ll be right over.”

  Kara clicked the phone off and dressed quickly, not caring what she put on.

  When she arrived at the library, in her usual spot, George was already there with his books open on the table. He’d been studying on his own, but it didn’t look like he really understood what he was reading.

  “What’s got into you,” George asked.

  She sat her things down on the table and plopped into her seat.

  “It’s a boy thing,” she replied.

  “Yeah, Henry has been pretty broken up, too. He was just sitting in a lounge chair in the backyard all day.”

  Kara forgot that George lived in the same house that Henry did.

  “What, did he finally get kicked off the team,” Kara asked with an annoyed tone.

  “No, but coach pulled him early last game. His head just wasn’t in it.”

  Serves him right, Kara thought, Maybe he’d think twice before he gets that close to someone.

  “Can we just focus on the task at hand,” Kara asked.

  “I only have ten minutes left of this session, so I think I’ll spend them however I want.”

  Here it comes, she thought.

  “Whatever you did to Henry, he’s broken. Would you, at least, talk to the guy so he can get some closure with all this,” George asked.

  Kara sighed; perhaps some closure was a good idea for both people.

  “Fine, I’ll talk to him.”

  “Good,” George replied. He stood up and started walking away.

  “George?”

  Then Henry took a seat across from her, again. She looked at him with seething hatred before turning away to hide her scowl.

  “I know you’re upset. Would you, at least, hear me out before running off,” Henry asked.

  “I’m listening, but I doubt it’ll help,” Kara replied sternly.

  “Okay, this is something that I’ve been struggling with, and I don’t want anyone else to know. It could ruin my entire life and career if anyone knew.”

  Kara was curious.

  “I’m listening, Henry.”

  He let out a drawn out sigh, focusing his thoughts and trying to loosen up.

  “Kara, I’m incredibly poor,” he said.

  “Is that all,” she asked with scorn.

  “You don’t understand. I’m barely able to afford food. Girls around here see me wearing expensive clothes and spending time with the elite at the school. I take the clothes that my friends would give to charity. I do my own tailoring and cooking so that I can stay trendy.

  “I need help to stay in school; this is my only shot at being something more than a nobody,” he said.

  Kara looked at his eyes. She could see his eyes were already getting clouded with tears. She wanted to jump across the table and hug him, tell him everything would be okay. But, she didn’t.

  “How can I really trust you,” Kara said.

  “The best things in life are free, Kara,” he replied, “but if you want I can show you my bank statement. Or take you to the one bedroom apartment my mother raised three kids in.

  “Or I could cook the same food that I cooked for my younger siblings daily.”

  Kara was beginning to believe him. Perhaps he wasn’t lying to her.

  “You know, you could have told me from the beginning. It wouldn’t have made me any less interested in you. It’s the fact that you took advantage of me before telling me the truth. It’s hard to come back from.”

  He nodded. Tears rolled down his cheeks, and Kara could feel some start to well up behind her eyes.

  “I believe you, Henry,” she said.

  He moved to the chair next to her and leaned over to give her a hug. She accepted it readily. The feeling of warmth didn’t just come from him but also welled up inside her.

  “You know, it’s been a few days,” she said.

  He brushed the tears from his eyes and gave her a puzzled look.

  Kara looked around the library. There weren’t that many people inside, and she felt a little frisky; feelings that felt odd when juxtaposed with her emotional state.

  “I think you owe me this one,” she said.

  Kara reached under her skirt and slid her underwear down to her knees. It seemed that Henry got the hint as he glanced around before ducking under the table.

  The simple but pleasant touch of his hands on her thighs gave her a chill. She wasn’t entirely sure she was ready for what she asked for, but it was too late to back out now.

  His tongue licked along her inner thigh and sent tingles to all her nerves. She opened her legs a little further and relaxed her head back into the seat.

  She could feel herself opening up as he inched closer to her slit. The tip of his tongue met her little clit, and she shivered from the sensation. Kara put her hands on his head and pulled him in closer.

  He obliged her and continued to tease her. Then, a surprising new
twist came when he slipped his finger inside her dripping sex. It felt odd at first, but he rubbed along her g-spot inside, and the new sensation made her arch her back each time he rubbed it.

  The motions of his tongue started to blur together, and she felt the familiar welling inside her stomach. She put a hand over her mouth in an effort to keep herself quiet, but it didn’t help much.

  She moaned with pleasure with each flick of his tongue. He seemed to be enjoying himself as well, making his circles shorter and shorter.

  Then she felt a sudden explosion and her body convulsed. She lost her breath in the moment, not realizing that she was crushing his head with her thighs.

  He pulled himself free and snuck to the other side of the table.

  Through heavy panting, Kara managed to say just one thing.

  “Okay, I believe you.”

  8.

  “They’re not going to like me,” Henry said.

  “I don’t think they’ll care that much,” Kara retorted.

  It had been a couple of weeks since they managed to make up in the library.

  “Do I have to tell them,” Henry asked.

  “You know it’s wrong to keep lying to people that say they’re your friends,” she said.

  “But, what if all the sudden I’m kicked off the team because I’m no longer one of them,” Henry added.

  “You’ll always be a hockey player,” Kara said.

  “Okay, alright, fine. You got me. I’ll do it. And, I’ll live with the consequences,” Henry said.

  They were about to do just that. Kara and Henry walked down the familiar street; from Kara’s house to the house down the street that Henry normally lived.

  Henry walked just a little bit slower, and Kara did her best to keep him on track. He continued to plead the entire way, and it drove her crazy having to constantly reassure him, but it was for the best.

  Once they arrived, they were greeted at the door by George.

  “Hey, you two,” he said, ushering them towards the living room where nearly the entire hockey team had congregated.

  Kara joined a couple of the player’s girlfriends in the back and said her usual greetings. She found herself spending more time with them as of late. They weren’t the smartest people, but they were still good people.

  Henry stood at the front of the assembly. He looked nervous like he would have preferred to be anywhere but there.